29 Aug 2024獨媒#3972
【立場案】檢控涉案文章作者?李桂華:視乎是否具煽動意圖
Stand News was alleged to have published seditious articles. Former editor-in-chief Chung Pui-kuen and acting editor-in-chief Lam Siu-tong were found guilty today at the District Court of conspiracy to publish seditious publications. Asked whether police would investigate and take further action against the journalists and bloggers who wrote the articles, after the court found that the articles in question had seditious intent, National Security Department Chief Superintendent Li Guihua said it would depend on whether the articles had seditious intent: “As for the authors and those responsible for writing them, we will look at one thing: whether they had seditious intent in doing so. If they did, we will discuss with the Department of Justice whether prosecution is ultimately appropriate.”
《立場新聞》涉嫌發布煽動性文章,前總編輯鍾沛權及署任總編輯林紹桐今日在區域法院,被裁定串謀發布煽動刊物罪名成立。對於法庭已就涉案文章裁定具煽動意圖,警方會否就撰寫文章的記者、博客作調查及進一步行動。國安處總警司李桂華表示,會視乎文章是否有煽動意圖:「就作者,同埋嗰啲負責寫嘅人士,我哋會睇睇一樣嘢,佢哋有無煽動意圖做呢一樣嘢,如果有嘅話,我哋會同律政處商量,究極適唔適合檢控嘅情況。」
29 Aug 2024獨媒#3973
【立場案】記協:判決證香港新聞自由嚴重倒退
The two former chief editors of Stand News, Chung Pui-kuen and Lam Siu-tong, were found guilty today of conspiracy to publish seditious publications. In a statement, the Hong Kong Journalists Association said the case clearly reflected the decline of press freedom in Hong Kong. It said the Stand News case had already caused irreversible harm to Hong Kong’s journalism industry before the verdict.
《立場新聞》兩位前總編輯鍾沛權和林紹桐,今日被判串謀發布煽動刊物罪名成立。記協發聲明,指案件明確反映香港新聞自由衰落。在裁決前,立場案亦已對香港新聞業界造成不可逆轉的傷害。
29 Aug 2024星島#3976
屠龍案|陪審團無需交代裁決理由 3名已認罪被告擔任污點證人 未必有基礎申請推翻認罪答辯
The “Dragon Slaying Brigade Squad” was alleged to have planned to plant bombs during a procession and shoot police officers. After the trial of the seven male and female defendants, only one male defendant, Lai Chun-pong, was convicted of conspiracy to cause an explosion likely to endanger life or seriously damage property; the other six were acquitted. There were also several defendants who pleaded guilty in the case. Three of them—Victor Chun Keung Wong, Eddie Pang Kwan-ho and So Wai-hin—testified in court as tainted witnesses. Barrister Lau Wai-hung told Sing Tao that a jury is not required to give reasons when finding a defendant not guilty, and that the only thing known is the jury’s verdict of acquittal. He said defendants who had pleaded guilty might not have grounds to apply to overturn their guilty pleas, stressing: “The fact that someone else was acquitted does not mean you can be acquitted too.”
「屠龍小隊」涉計劃在遊行中設置炸彈並槍殺警員,涉案7男女經審訊後,僅有1名男被告賴振邦串謀導致相當可能會危害生命或對財產造成嚴重損害的爆炸罪罪成,其餘6人全部罪脫。本案另有數名認罪被告,當中3名已認罪被告為本案擔任污點證人出庭作證,包括黃振強、彭軍壕及蘇緯軒。大律師陸偉雄接受《星島》訪問時表示,陪審團裁定被告無罪時毋須交代裁決理由,大家只知陪審團裁定被告罪脫結果,認為已認罪被告未必有基礎申請推翻認罪答辯,強調「人哋脫罪唔代表你都可以脫罪」。
28 Aug 2024法庭線#3961
47人案求情.新西梁國雄柯耀林|10人全部完成陳詞 吳敏兒一方指日後脫離政治
In the case involving 47 democrats charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power”, eight New Territories West candidates who pleaded guilty, together with Leung Kwok-hung and Ricky Yiu Lam Or, who took part in the New Territories East primary election and were convicted after trial, completed mitigation submissions for seven defendants on Tuesday (see separate report). The remaining defendants, Ng Man-yee, Roy Hoi Pong Tam and Ricky Yiu Lam Or (on the 28th), also completed their mitigation submissions on Wednesday morning (key points are set out in the table in the main text).
Ng Man-yee’s counsel said she only learned that she was suspected of breaking the law when she was arrested, and was shocked. She would leave politics in future. Her barrister said that if the starting point for sentencing in this case was set too high, there would be little room to impose sentences in more serious cases in future. Roy Hoi Pong Tam’s counsel said former Observatory director Lam Chiu-ying had written a mitigation letter for Tam, praising Tam’s efforts on environmental protection. Counsel also said Tam had no intention of engaging in politics in future, and might even stop advocating environmental issues.
The barrister representing Ricky Yiu Lam Or said Ko belonged to the category of “other participants”; even if classified as an “active participant”, Ko would be at the lower end of that category. However, the judge questioned the defence’s claim that Ko’s level of participation was lower than that of the others.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,參選新西的認罪 8 人偕同參與新東初選、經審訊後定罪的梁國雄、柯耀林,周二完成 7 人求情(見另稿),餘下的吳敏兒、譚凱邦及柯耀林(28 日)周三早上亦完成求情(重點見內文表)。
吳敏兒一方指,吳至被捕才知自己涉違法,對此感震驚,而她日後會脫離政治;其大狀指若本案量刑起點過高,他日嚴重案件難有判刑空間。譚凱邦一方稱,前天文台台長林超英為譚撰求情信,表揚譚為環保出力;又指譚未來無意接觸政治,甚至不再提倡環保議題。
柯耀林的代表大狀稱,認為柯屬於「其他參加」,即使被歸類成「積極參加者」,亦屬當中較低一方。不過法官質疑辯方指柯的參與程度比其他人低的說法。
28 Aug 2024法庭線#3962
47人案求情.新西.梁國雄柯耀林|尹兆堅前家傭:他出獄前,我會一直留在這裡
In the case involving 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power”, the eight defendants who pleaded guilty after taking part in the New Territories West primary election, together with Leung Kwok-hung and Ricky Yiu Lam Or, who took part in the New Territories East primary election and were convicted after trial, continued making mitigation submissions on Wednesday (28th). The hearing dealt with the mitigation submissions of Ng Man-yee, Roy Hoi Pong Tam and Ricky Yiu Lam Or.
The domestic helper who cared for Yin Siu-kin’s family for nearly 16 years also attended the hearing on Wednesday. She said Yin was a good employer who would help resolve her problems, and that after Yin was arrested, she attended the hearings and visited him. She said that when she missed Yin and his family, she would look at their photos on her phone: “I will stay here until he is released.”
Joe Wong, former chairperson of the Hong Kong Confederation of Trade Unions, described Ng Man-yee as brave and resilient: “To be able to maintain one’s beliefs while in adversity is a very rare thing. I consider myself far behind her.” A “student” of Ricky Yiu Lam Or said that when visiting last week, they felt he was “not as active and a little more depressed”, and also believed that Ko’s profile was relatively low: “It seems that fewer people pay attention to him. I hope he also knows that people are supporting him.”
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,參與新西初選的認罪 8 人,偕同參與新東初選、經審訊後定罪的梁國雄、柯耀林,周三(28 日)續求情,處理吳敏兒、譚凱邦及柯耀林求情。
照顧尹兆堅一家近 16 年的家傭,周三亦到場旁聽,她表示尹是好僱主,會為她解決問題,又指尹被捕後,自己有旁聽案件及探望對方。她指,當想念尹一家人時,會翻看電話內的合照,「直到他出獄前,我會一直留在這裡。」
前職工盟主席黃迺元形容,吳敏兒勇敢、堅韌,「喺逆境入面仍然能夠保持信念,係好難得嘅事,我自問望塵莫及」。柯耀林的「學員」則提及,上周探望時感到他「冇咁積極、憂鬱咗少少」,又認為柯的知名度比較低,「好似少啲人會留意佢,希望佢都知道有人撐住佢。」
28 Aug 2024法庭線#3963
反恐首案|陪審團第二日退庭商議 詢問反恐罪與交替罪之分別、無有效裁決應如何處理
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 82nd day at the High Court on Wednesday (28th). The jury deliberated for about eight hours on Tuesday without reaching a verdict and put three questions to the court, including the difference between the charges under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance and the alternative charges, and what should be done if no valid verdict could be reached.
Judge Cheung Wai-ling said the Anti-terrorism Ordinance charge required proof that the defendants intended to place a bomb in a public place, causing others to die or suffer serious injury. The alternative charge did not require the location to be considered, but only proof of an intention that would be highly likely to endanger life. The judge also said the jurors should learn from one another and consider each other’s views, as some might be persuaded to change their positions, provided they remained faithful to their oaths and reached a verdict in accordance with the facts. If they still could not reach a consensus after deliberating, they could seek the judge’s guidance.
At 7:30 p.m., after deliberating for more than 19 hours, the jury had still failed to reach a consensus. The judge adjourned the case until Thursday.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周三(28 日)在高等法院踏入第 82 天審訊。陪審團周二退庭商議約 8 小時尚未有裁決,並向法庭提出 3 個問題,包括《反恐條例》控罪與交替控罪之分別、無法達成有效裁決時應如何處理等。
法官張慧玲回答指,《反恐》控罪須證明被告有意圖在公共場所放置炸彈,令他人死亡或嚴重受傷;交替控罪則毋須理會地點,只須證明有意圖相當可能會危害生命。官另指,陪審團應互相借鑒及考慮他人意見,有人或會被說服而改變立場,前提是忠於宣誓時的誓言,作出合乎事實的裁決。若商討後仍未有共識,可尋求法官指引。
至晚上 7 時半,陪審團退庭商議逾 19 小時後仍未能達成共識,法官押後至周四續。
28 Aug 2024法庭線#3964
元朗721白衣人暴動案上訴 蔡立基上訴得直撤罪 罪脫王志榮發還重新考慮
In the first case involving white-clad men in the Yuen Long 7.21 attack, seven people were convicted and one was acquitted. Four of those convicted appealed. On Wednesday (the 28th), Court of Appeal judges Pang Wai-cheong, Poon Man-ki and Pang Po-kam handed down their decision, allowing Alex Lap Kee Choi’s appeal and quashing the convictions for rioting and assault with intent to injure. Leave to appeal for the other three was refused, and their convictions and sentences were upheld.
The Department of Justice also appealed by way of case stated against the acquittal of Zhirong Wang. The Court of Appeal allowed the Department’s appeal and remitted the decision to the trial District Court judge, Eddie Chor Man Yip, for reconsideration. Zhirong Wang is due to appear in the District Court on 15 October and was allowed bail on the existing conditions in the meantime.
The Court of Appeal said the trial court had overstepped the boundaries by asking Alex Lap Kee Choi to perform actions and bare his teeth in court, thereby requiring him to assist the prosecution in establishing its case. After excluding the courtroom actions, there was “considerable difficulty” in determining whether police photographs and footage of the incident could establish that Alex Lap Kee Choi was the offender. Although the Court of Appeal was certain, after comparing them, that the two images showed the same person, it said that “identification of a person is ultimately subjective” and that no inevitable conclusion could be reached. It therefore found Alex Lap Kee Choi not guilty.
It is understood that Ng Wai-nam, Tang Ying-pan and Alex Lap Kee Choi, who were convicted at trial, have been released and did not attend court. Tang Wai-sam, who is still serving his sentence, is expected to be released as early as February 2026. Zhirong Wang did not respond to reporters’ questions, made a waving gesture and left the High Court.
元朗 7.21 襲擊首宗白衣人案,7 人罪成,1 人罪脫。罪成其中 4 人提出上訴,上訴庭法官彭偉昌、潘敏琦、彭寶琴周三(28 日)頒下裁決,裁定被告蔡立基上訴得直,撤銷暴動及有意圖傷人的定罪。其餘 3 人上訴許可則遭駁回,維持定罪及刑期。
律政司另就脫罪被告王志榮,以案件呈述方式上訴。上訴庭裁定律政司得直,發還原審區院法官葉佐文重新考慮裁決,10 月 15 日將於區院提訊,期間王准以原有條件保釋。
上訴庭指出,原審要求蔡立基在庭上做動作及露齒笑,屬越界要求他協助控方舉證;剔除庭上動作後,對於是否可憑警方照片及事發影像肯定蔡是犯案人「不無糾結」,雖然上訴庭比對兩者肯定是同一人,但指「人物辨認始終是主觀」,無法論斷必然結論,裁定蔡立基罪脫。
據了解,原審罪成的吳偉南、鄧英斌、蔡立基已獲釋,他們未有到庭。至於仍在服刑的鄧懷琛,料最早在 2026 年 2 月獲釋。王志榮則沒有回應記者問題,作擺手手勢後離開高院。
28 Aug 2024法庭線#3965
支聯會被指煽動顛覆案|2025.5.6開審、預留75天 鄒幸彤要求釐清顛覆「非法手段」
The case in which the Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China and its former chairpersons Lee Cheuk-yan, Albert Ho Chun-yan and Chow Hang-tung are charged with “incitement to subversion of state power” was heard at the High Court on Wednesday (28th) for its third case management hearing. The trial was scheduled to begin on 6 May next year, with 75 days set aside for the hearing.
A pre-trial review will take place on 20 February next year. Chow Hang-tung has applied for overseas witnesses to testify by video link, and the application will be dealt with in court on 28 October this year. It concerns a dispute over Section 79I of the Criminal Procedure Ordinance, which took effect with the Article 23 legislation. The provision states that overseas witnesses may not be called in national security cases.
The court heard that Chow Hang-tung had asked the prosecution to clarify the details of the charge, including what “illegal means” the Hong Kong Alliance was alleged to have used to subvert the state. The prosecution previously replied that this covered “any act intended to subvert the state by illegal means, and any act of subverting the state is illegal”, and said that the offence did not have to involve force. The judge directed the prosecution to clarify within two weeks what types of offences “illegal means” referred to.
支聯會及其前正副主席李卓人、何俊仁、鄒幸彤被控「煽動顛覆國家政權」一案,周三(28 日)於高等法院進行第三次案件管理會議,並定於明年 5 月 6 日開審,預留 75 天審期。
明年 2 月 20 日進行審前覆核。鄒幸彤申請海外證人以視像作供,將於今年 10 月 28 日開庭處理,涉及廿三條立法生效的《刑事訴訟程序條例》第 79I 條爭議,條例列明,國安案不得傳召海外證人。
庭上透露,鄒幸彤要求控方釐清控罪詳情,指明支聯會煽動以何「非法手段」顛覆國家,控方早前回覆指,涵蓋「任何以非法手段旨在顛覆國家嘅行為,而任何顛覆國家行為都係非法」,指毋須涉及武力。法官則指示控方,在兩周內釐清「非法手段」即甚麼類型的罪行。
27 Aug 2024法庭線#3953
47人案求情.新西梁國雄柯耀林|7人完成陳詞 伍健偉答官確認無悔意
In the case involving 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power”, eight who pleaded guilty after standing in the New Territories West primary, together with Leung Kwok-hung and Ho Sum Cheung, who participated in the New Territories East primary and were convicted after trial, began mitigation submissions on Tuesday (the 27th). Leung Kwok-hung, Chu Hoi-dick, Ho Sum Cheung, Prince Wong Ji-yuet, Ng Kin-wai, Au Nok-hin and Kwok Ka-ki have completed their submissions. The mitigation submissions of Ng Man-yee, Roy Hoi Pong Tam and Ricky Yiu Lam Or will be dealt with on Wednesday.
Ng Kin-wai made his own submission, saying the “35+” primary was conducted “in broad daylight and was well known to all”, while the “five demands” were reasonable and had not been ruled unlawful. He considered that the government “did not do so” despite being able to. In response to the judge, he confirmed that he had no remorse, saying that as a politician he expected himself to shoulder responsibility and did not regret his actions. He said choosing to remain in Hong Kong was to fulfil his promise to “stand and fall together with Hong Kong people”.
Ho Sum Cheung wrote a mitigation letter personally, saying he had deeply reflected and should not have endangered national security through the scrutiny of the budget, and hoping to care for his elderly parents, wife and children in the future. In his letter of representation, Leung Kwok-hung said legislators’ exercise of their veto twice reflected the will of the people, and that he had “no complaint” about becoming a prisoner. Prince Wong Ji-yuet wrote that he had run for election in the hope of bringing change to those who had lost hope, and expressed guilt towards his parents and family.
Kwok Ka-ki received mitigation letters from former senior officials and Legislative Council members, saying that he was peaceful and non-violent and would defend the rights of the underprivileged. Au Nok-hin said he hoped to work for the international NGO World Central Kitchen in the future; he also received mitigation letters from three former senior officials. The case continues on Wednesday.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,參選新西的認罪 8 人,偕同參與新東初選、經審訊後定罪的梁國雄、柯耀林,周二(27 日)起進行求情,梁國雄、朱凱廸、張可森、黃子悅、伍健偉、尹兆堅、郭家麒已完成陳詞;周三將處理吳敏兒、譚凱邦及柯耀林求情。
伍健偉自行陳詞指「35+」初選是「陽光底下進行、眾所周知」,而「五大訴求」是合情合理、沒被裁定違法,認為政府「是不為也」。他回答法官時確認自己沒悔意,指作為政治人物,期許自己有承擔,他不後悔,選擇留港是兌現承諾,「同香港人齊上齊落」。
張可森親撰求情信指有深刻反省,不應藉審議預算案危害國安,望未來照顧高堂、愛妻育兒。梁國雄在陳情書指,議員兩次行使否決權是民意依歸,對成為階下囚「毋怨」。黃子悅撰信指參選是望為失去盼望者帶來改變,對父母家人感愧疚。
郭家麒獲前高官、立法會議員撰寫求情信,指他和平、非暴力,會捍衛弱勢權利;尹兆堅則指日後望到國際 NGO 世界中央廚房工作,他亦獲 3 名前高官撰求情信。案件周三續。
27 Aug 2024法庭線#3954
反恐首案|法官完成引導 陪審團退庭商議
In the first case under the anti-terrorism legislation, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 81st day at the High Court on Tuesday (27th). After the judge, Cheung Wai-ling, completed eight days of summing up and directing the jury, the three-man, six-woman jury began deliberations at about 11am and had yet to reach a verdict by 7pm. The jury also put questions to the court. The judge said she needed time to consider them and adjourned the matter until Wednesday.
The judge summarised the elements of the offences charged in the case in the morning, saying the prosecution had to prove that the defendants intended to kill police officers and intended to cause the death of, or serious injury to, others. She said the jury had to be sure that there was an agreement for an unlawful purpose before considering whether each defendant intended to reach the agreement and put it into effect. She also said that if the jury considered that the account given by a defendant who testified might be true, that would be sufficient to find the defendant not guilty. The defendants had no previous convictions at the time of the incident, indicating a low propensity to commit offences.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周二(27 日)在高等法院踏入第 81 天審訊,法官張慧玲完成共 8 天總結供詞及引導陪審團,3 男 6 女陪審團早上約 11 時開始退庭商議,至晚上 7 時尚未有裁決。陪審團另向法庭提出問題,法官指需時考慮,押後至周三再處理。
法官早上總結涉案控罪的罪行元素,指控方須證明各被告有意殺死警察、以及有意令他人死亡或嚴重傷害。官指,陪審團須肯定本案有協議作非法目的,再考慮各被告是否有意達成協議及付諸實行。官又指,若陪審團認為作供被告說法可能是真,就足以裁定無罪,而各被告案發時無案底,代表犯罪傾向性低。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.