4 Sept 2022獨媒#2409
InMediaHK Compares Liberal Studies Textbooks from 2014 to 2020 with Some of the First Civics Textbooks Published in 2022
在新的課程框架下,公民抗命、三權分立、法治四層次、多元身分等概念被刪去,換上國家安全、國民身分、國家成就等課題;法治不再包括「以法限權」,「保障人權」之餘亦不能影響他人權利、社會秩序和國家安全;補充資料以官方說法為主,例如政府新聞處和司長網誌,學習問題不再要求學生討論爭議點,只需回答「為何人大釋法不會影響司法獨立?」
Under the new curriculum framework, concepts such as civil disobedience, separation of powers, the four levels of the rule of law and multiple identities have been removed and replaced with topics including national security, national identity and national achievements. The rule of law no longer includes “using the law to limit power”; while human rights are protected, this must not affect the rights of others, social order or national security. Supplementary materials mainly present official views, such as those from the Information Services Department and blogs by bureau secretaries. Learning questions no longer require students to discuss controversial points, asking only questions such as, “Why would an interpretation by the National People’s Congress not affect judicial independence?”
26 Nov 2020聞庫(立場)#961
【Castrating Liberal Studies】Education Bureau Ignores Task Force Recommendations, Scraps Existing Grading System; Subject to Be Renamed After 11 Years
政府劍指通識教育科,教育局今日(26 日)正式公布「改革」高中通識科,雖然學校課程檢討專責小組今年 9 月提交的報告,明確建議維持現行 1 至 5** 考試評級,惟教育局拒絕採納,教育局局長楊潤雄宣布,高中通識科評級將改為「合格」及「不合格」,並透過重整、刪減,減走一半課程內容。改動後的通識科將改名,但名稱未定,楊解釋科目已被「污名化」,希望科目有新開始,避免社會人士有錯誤理解或不好觀念。
The government is targeting Liberal Studies. The Education Bureau today (26th) formally announced its “reform” of senior secondary Liberal Studies. Although the report submitted by the Task Force on School Curriculum Review in September this year clearly recommended retaining the existing 1 to 5** examination grading system, the Education Bureau refused to adopt the recommendation. Secretary for Education Kevin Yeung announced that senior secondary Liberal Studies would instead be graded as “Pass” or “Fail”, while half of the curriculum content would be removed through restructuring and cuts. The subject will be renamed after the changes, but its new name has not yet been decided. Yeung explained that the subject had been “stigmatised” and said he hoped a new name would give it a fresh start and prevent members of the public from having misunderstandings or bad perceptions of it.
18 Aug 2020聞庫(立場)#771
Liberal Studies Textbooks Delete Content on Civil Disobedience, Rule of Law and Human Rights after De Facto Education Bureau Censorship
通識科近年受建制派狙擊。教育局去年推出通識教科書「專業諮詢服務」,被批評變相強制將課本送審。各出版社首按當局「諮詢」意見後首次作出的修訂版本昨日(17日)推出。《立場新聞》發現,通識科六大單元之一「今日香港」的各款教科書作出多處修訂,其中曾被《文匯報》大篇幅報道抨擊的《雅集新高中通識教育系列(第四版)》,將一整頁有關「公民抗命」的資料練習題刪走,當局要求刪除原因僅稱是「教學需要」。
Liberal Studies has come under attack from the pro-establishment camp in recent years. Last year, the Education Bureau introduced a “Professional Consultation Service” for Liberal Studies textbooks, which was criticised as effectively making it compulsory for textbooks to be submitted for vetting. The revised editions produced by publishers for the first time after following the authorities’ “consultation”意见 were released yesterday (17th). Stand News found that various Liberal Studies textbooks had made multiple revisions to the “Hong Kong Today” unit, one of the subject’s six major units. In the Ya Ji New Senior Secondary Liberal Studies Series (Fourth Edition), which had been extensively criticised in Wen Wei Po, an entire page of materials and exercises on “civil disobedience” was removed. The authorities’ stated reason for requiring its deletion was simply “teaching needs”.
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.