5 Sept 2025法庭線#7264
32-year-old defendant in first anti-terror case jailed for nine years; extra five months for possessing flick knife and other offences, sentence appeal dismissed
2019 年 12 月 8 日「國際人權日大遊行」前夕,警方搜出大批武器,包括手槍、子彈等,事後多人被捕,被指串謀殺警,政府首引《反恐條例》下的控罪起訴。當中 32 歲男子陳玉龍在高院承認無牌管有槍械及彈藥,判囚 9 年。陳另涉管有彈簧刀及沒展示有效車牌等,在裁判法院承認各一項「管有違禁武器」及「偽造文件」罪,加監 5 個月。
陳不服裁判法院的刑期上訴,指量刑起點過高,加上源於警方就「反恐案」拘捕他時發生,刑期應全數同期執行。上訴案周五(5 日)在高院原訟庭審理。暫委法官姚勳智認為,量刑起點非明顯過重,而兩案的性質、背景不同,上訴方稱若在高院一併判刑,可以全數同期執行是「純屬臆測」。官又稱,裁判官已將部分刑期同期執行,量刑恰當,即日駁回上訴。
On the eve of the 8 December 2019 International Human Rights Day march, police uncovered a large quantity of weapons, including pistols and ammunition. Several people were subsequently arrested and accused of conspiring to kill police officers, and the government brought charges under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance for the first time. Among them, 32-year-old Chan Yuk-lung pleaded guilty in the High Court to possessing firearms and ammunition without a licence and was sentenced to nine years in prison. Chan was also charged with possessing a flick knife and failing to display a valid vehicle registration plate. He pleaded guilty in the Magistrates’ Court to one count each of possession of a prohibited weapon and forgery, and was sentenced to an additional five months in prison.
Chan appealed against the sentence imposed by the Magistrates’ Court, arguing that the starting point for sentencing was too high and that, as the offences arose from his arrest by police in connection with the “anti-terrorism case”, the sentences should have been served entirely concurrently. The appeal was heard in the High Court’s Court of First Instance on Friday (the 5th). Acting Judge Yiu Fan-chi found that the sentencing starting point was not manifestly excessive and that the two cases differed in nature and background. The appeal argument that the sentences could have been served entirely concurrently if he had been sentenced together in the High Court was “purely speculative”. The judge also said that the magistrate had already ordered part of the sentence to run concurrently and that the sentence was appropriate. The appeal was dismissed the same day.
5 Sept 2025法庭線#7265
Hong Kong Independence Party case defendant jailed for five years after admitting conspiracy to incite secession; sentence appeal dismissed and certificate application for CFA appeal rejected again
被指為「香港獨立黨」主席的 41 歲葡籍男子黃煡聰,2022 年入境時被捕,他承認《國安法》下「串謀煽動他人實施分裂國家」罪,被判囚 5 年。因《國安法》刑期下限,他未獲全數認罪扣減,就此申請刑期上訴許可,今年 4 月被上訴庭駁回。黃煡聰之後再向上訴庭申證明書,以申請終院的上訴許可,上訴庭周五(5 日)頒下判詞,駁回申請。
黃爭議《國安法》中刑罰下限的規定,是否適用於串謀罪。上訴庭認為,《國安法》的立法用意,是其刑罰機制同樣適用於串謀罪,上訴人的理據毫無合理爭辯之處,拒絕發出證明書。
另據終審法院網頁顯示,黃亦已直接向終院申上訴許可,據司法機構網頁,案件暫未排期聆訊。
The 41-year-old Portuguese man Wong Kin Chung, who was identified as the chairman of the Hong Kong Independence Party, was arrested when he entered Hong Kong in 2022. He admitted the offence of “conspiracy to incite others to commit secession” under the National Security Law and was sentenced to five years’ imprisonment. As the National Security Law provides for a minimum sentence, he was not granted the full reduction for his guilty plea. He subsequently applied for leave to appeal against his sentence, but the Court of Appeal dismissed the application in April this year. Wong Kin Chung then applied to the Court of Appeal for a certificate to seek leave to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal. In a judgment handed down on Friday (the 5th), the Court of Appeal dismissed the application.
The defendant disputed whether the National Security Law’s minimum-penalty provision applies to the conspiracy offence. The Court of Appeal held that the legislative intent of the National Security Law was for its sentencing mechanism to apply equally to conspiracy offences. It found that the appellant’s grounds had no reasonable prospect of argument and refused to issue a certificate.
The Court of Final Appeal’s website also shows that the defendant has directly applied to that court for leave to appeal. According to the Judiciary’s website, the case has not yet been scheduled for hearing.
5 Sept 2025集誌社#7266
Swire Beverages strike | Union committee member sacked after crash; over 100 workers strike for a day as dismissal is withdrawn and suspension imposed
一名香港太古可口可樂的貨車司機,上月在將軍澳倒車時,發生交通意外,撞倒一名行人。香港太古可口可樂昨(4日)以公司安全指引「倒車時未有穿戴安全帶」為由,即時解僱該車手。太古飲料(香港)職工總會指,公司過往甚少解僱發生交通意外的員工,涉事車長同為工會理事會成員,工會今( 5 日) 早上在公司門外發起無限期罷工,約百多員工支持,工會要求公司取消解僱涉事車長、承諾對外勤同事工作上遇到檢控,作出法律支援及承擔等。 警方指現場為非法集會。
勞資雙方舉行會議後,公司讓步,撤回解僱安排,以停職等候判決,期間會支付底薪。公司同意不會處分罷工同事,只作無薪處理,並表示會檢討「安全條款」,加強培訓,日後也會設立「法律顧問」,給同事諮詢,日後如有罷工,會在五日前通知。工人結束罷工,明日(6日)復工。
A truck driver for Swire Coca-Cola Hong Kong was involved in a traffic accident in Tseung Kwan O last month while reversing, knocking down a pedestrian. Swire Coca-Cola Hong Kong dismissed the driver yesterday (4th), citing the company’s safety guideline that he had not worn a seatbelt while reversing. The Swire Beverages (Hong Kong) Employees’ Union said the company had rarely dismissed employees involved in traffic accidents in the past, and that the driver was also a union committee member. The union launched an indefinite strike outside the company this morning (5th), with more than 100 employees supporting it. It demanded that the company cancel the driver’s dismissal and commit to providing legal support and assuming responsibility when field staff faced prosecution in the course of their work. Police said the gathering at the scene was an unlawful assembly.
After the two sides held a meeting, the company conceded and withdrew the dismissal, placing the driver on suspension pending the judgment while continuing to pay his basic salary. The company agreed not to discipline the striking employees, but to treat the time as unpaid, and said it would review the “safety clause”, strengthen training, and establish a “legal adviser” service to provide consultations for employees. It also said that five days’ notice would be given in future if there was a strike. The workers ended the strike and will return to work tomorrow (6th).
5 Sept 2025集誌社#7267
Blacklisting Candace Chong|Performing arts academy meets students; senior officials take a detour to avoid media
資深編劇莊梅岩早前公開批評,演藝學院抽起其訪問、又勸阻她在音樂劇演出後謝幕,批評校董會「拿著放大鏡」找「軟對抗」,校方則一直未有正式回應是否「封殺」莊梅岩;校方昨向學生發短訊,稱因「特殊情況」,學校高層將與學生「會面溝通」。校董會主席、校長等人今午與學生閉門會面,職員多次表示不會回應傳媒,會面結束後,高層未有從正門離開、「兜路走」拒見記者。
綜合與會學生,校方在會上多次重申事件「溝通有問題」,變相承認莊梅岩指控屬實,又引述校方指下指示的人已離開學校,形容「成件事嘅發生係一個好蠢嘅藉口」,又肯定日後學生能演出莊的劇本。演藝學院傍晚以電郵回覆傳媒,指「有關部門在內部溝通及處理流程確有未盡完善之處」,會汲取經驗、檢討機制。
Veteran playwright Candace Chong earlier criticised the Hong Kong Academy for Performing Arts for pulling an interview with her and discouraging her from taking a curtain call after a musical performance. She accused the school’s governing council of “holding a magnifying glass” to look for “soft resistance”. The academy has not formally responded to whether it was “blacklisting” Chong. The school sent students a text message yesterday saying that, due to “special circumstances”, senior school officials would “meet and communicate” with them. The governing council chair, the president and others held a closed-door meeting with students this afternoon. Staff repeatedly said they would not respond to the media, and after the meeting the senior officials did not leave through the main entrance, instead taking a “detour” to avoid reporters.
According to students who attended, the school repeatedly said at the meeting that there had been “problems with communication”, effectively acknowledging that Chong’s allegations were true. They also quoted the school as saying that the person who gave the instructions had left the school, describing the whole incident as “a very stupid excuse”, and assuring them that students would be able to perform Chong’s scripts in future. The Hong Kong Academy for Performing Arts replied to the media by email in the evening, saying that “the relevant departments’ internal communication and handling procedures were indeed not fully完善”, and that it would learn from the experience and review its mechanisms.
4 Sept 2025HK01#7254
Police to Conduct Territory-wide Traffic Enforcement at Irregular Times and Locations from Next Week; Drones to Be Trialled on Two Road Sections
警方將首次使用無人機在非市區路段作試點進行交通錄影執法,加強對違例司機的阻嚇性,包括石澳道及荃錦公路,在兩路段的上落斜急彎,以不定時形式,對橫越雙白線等違例行為,進行高空定點蒐證,警方會紀錄車牌,確認違例行為及司機身份後,發出定額罰款通知書或傳票。警方強調,無人機執法以透明及公開原則進行,無人機會在公眾地點執法,執法地點附近會設置告示通知公眾,機身會有反光貼及紅藍閃燈,無人機在錄影搜證上會遵守《個人資料(私隱)條例》。
Police will for the first time trial the use of drones for traffic video enforcement on non-urban road sections to enhance deterrence against offending drivers. The trial will cover Shek O Road and Route Twisk, focusing on sharp bends on uphill and downhill sections. At irregular times, aerial fixed-point evidence will be gathered on offences including crossing double white lines. Police will record vehicle registration numbers and, after confirming the offence and the driver’s identity, issue fixed penalty notices or summonses. Police stressed that drone enforcement would be conducted according to the principles of transparency and openness. The drones will operate in public places, notices will be placed near enforcement locations to inform the public, and the aircraft will carry reflective strips and red and blue flashing lights. The drones will comply with the Personal Data (Privacy) Ordinance when recording video and gathering evidence.
4 Sept 2025獨媒#7255
As One Moves to Tai Nan Street Shop; Founder Kong Wai Chu: “We’ll Keep Going for as Long as We Can”
前區議員朱江瑋創辦網購平台「如一」,開業四年曾多次「搬舖」,目前旺角店位於旺角好望角大廈,惟6月中旬獲業主通知不獲續租,原址全層租出作補習社,需於8月31日出遷出。「如一」決定首次離開商場,在太子大南街設地舖,昨日起(9月3日)試業。
「如一」門市曾多次獲不同部門關注,朱江瑋表示,曾向原業主爭取租用好望角其他單位,惟並不成功,引述稱業主「驚警察上門」。最終「如一」新店選址大南街,新舖位花費約20萬,「做啲自己覺得啱嘅嘢,做得幾耐得幾耐」。
Former district councillor Kong Wai Chu founded the online shopping platform “As One”. In its four years of operation, it has moved premises several times. Its current Mong Kok shop is in Ho Wang Kok Building, but the landlord notified it in mid-June that the lease would not be renewed. The entire floor at the original site was rented to a tutorial centre, and the shop had to vacate by 31 August. “As One” decided to leave a shopping centre for the first time and open a ground-floor shop on Tai Nan Street in Prince Edward. It began a trial opening yesterday, 3 September.
The “As One” shop had attracted attention from various departments on several occasions. Kong Wai Chu said it had sought to rent another unit in Ho Wang Kok Building from the original landlord, but was unsuccessful, quoting the landlord as saying they were “afraid the police would come to the door”. The new “As One” shop was ultimately located on Tai Nan Street, at a cost of about $200,000. Kong Wai Chu said: “We’ll do what we feel is right and keep going for as long as we can.”
4 Sept 2025明報#7256
Schools respond to live-streamed military parade; students say a strong military ensures national security
教育局上月向全港中小學發通函,鼓勵學校昨日舉行升國旗儀式及唱國歌,以及收看閱兵儀式直播,昨日有不同學校響應。署理教育局長施俊輝表示,閱兵儀式是最好的國安教育,冀學生可傳承愛國情懷。有參與的學生認為國強才能國安,將來會投身紀律部隊貢獻國家。
施俊輝:歷史是最好教科書
昨日多間學校舉行升旗禮,並安排學生觀看閱兵直播,包括中華基督教會協和小學(長沙灣)及香港教育工作者聯會黃楚標中學等。香港專業進修學校更邀請同學及老師為直播旁述,向200名師生講解中國軍備。負責旁述的學生帥斌華表示,歷史不能遺忘及重演,認為只有中國的影響力日漸強大,對未來戰爭規則才有改寫的能力,世界和平才有保障,「強軍才能國安」。
施俊輝昨到愛國教育支援中心出席抗戰勝利紀念日儀式,席上他感謝學界積極響應局方號召,認為閱兵儀式是最好的國家安全及愛國主義教育,「歷史是最好的教科書」,又稱香港在抗戰期間擔當重要角色,展現出不屈不撓的愛國精神。
他又說,國家能走上繁榮昌盛的道路使人民安居樂業,並在國際舞台上舉足輕重,這些成果均得來不易,冀學生珍惜並傳承先烈的愛國之情,好好裝備自己,為國家未來發展作貢獻。
Last month, the Education Bureau issued a circular to all primary and secondary schools in Hong Kong encouraging them to hold flag-raising ceremonies, sing the national anthem and watch a live broadcast of the military parade yesterday. Various schools responded. Acting Secretary for Education Jeff Chun Fai Sze said the parade was the best national security education and hoped students would carry on the patriotic spirit. Participating students said that a strong country and military were necessary for national security, and some said they would join the disciplined services in future to contribute to the country.
Several schools held flag-raising ceremonies and arranged for students to watch the live broadcast, including CCC Heep Woh Primary School (Cheung Sha Wan) and HKFEW Wong Cho Bau Secondary School. Hong Kong College of Technology also invited students and teachers to provide commentary on the broadcast, explaining China’s military equipment to 200 teachers and students. Student commentator Shuai Binhua said history must not be forgotten or repeated, and that only if China’s influence continued to grow would it be able to reshape the rules of future wars and safeguard world peace. He said, “A strong military ensures national security.”
Jeff Chun Fai Sze attended a Victory Day of the War of Resistance commemorative ceremony at the Patriotic Education Support Centre yesterday. He thanked the education sector for actively responding to the bureau’s appeal, saying the parade was the best national security and patriotic education and that “history is the best textbook”. He also said Hong Kong had played an important role during the War of Resistance, demonstrating an unyielding patriotic spirit.
He added that the country’s progress towards prosperity had enabled its people to live and work in peace and contentment and had given it considerable weight on the international stage. These achievements had not come easily, and he hoped students would cherish and carry on the patriotic feelings of those who came before them, equip themselves well and contribute to the country’s future development.
4 Sept 2025法庭線#7257
“6436” and Candle Designs Spray-Painted in Black in Sha Tin on June 4; Tsang Kin-fung Pleads Guilty, Told He Could Face Jail
前公民黨成員、人稱「霸氣哥」的曾建峯,被指於今年六四在火炭馬路及告示欄,以黑色噴漆噴上「6436」、蠟燭圖案,被控刑事損壞。案件原定周四(4 日)在沙田裁判法院開審,被告開審前改為認罪。
辯方求情指,被告因母親健康變差、小說創作不順利,喝酒後干犯本案,行為實屬不智,惟他之前一直奉公守法。暫委裁判官江美儀押至 9 月 18 日判刑,候索取社會服務令及感化報告,強調仍有機會判監。被告准保釋候判。
Former Civic Party member Tsang Kin-fung, known as “the domineering brother”, was accused of spray-painting “6436” and candle designs in black on Fo Tan Road and notice boards on June 4 this year. He was charged with criminal damage. The case was originally scheduled for trial at Sha Tin Magistrates’ Courts on Thursday (the 4th), but the defendant changed his plea to guilty before the trial began.
The defence said in mitigation that the defendant committed the offence after drinking because his mother’s health had deteriorated and he was experiencing difficulties with his novel writing. It said his conduct had been unwise, but that he had previously obeyed the law. Acting Magistrate Kong Mei-yee adjourned the case to September 18 for sentencing, pending social service order and probation reports, and stressed that imprisonment remained possible. The defendant was granted bail pending sentencing.
4 Sept 2025法庭線#7258
Second terrorism case | Jury convicts 3 and acquits 5 after 3½ days of deliberation; mitigation hearings set for October
反恐條例第二案 9 人陪審團由周一開始退庭,經過約 28 小時退庭商議後,周四(4 日)下午一致裁定首 7 名被告《反恐條例》主控罪全部不成立,其中 3 人的「串謀導致相當可能危害生命的爆炸罪」交替控罪成立。第八被告的企圖製造炸藥亦不成立。
罪成的 3 人,何卓為聞判時點頭,李嘉濱微笑、表現平靜,張家俊亦見平靜;獲裁無罪的 5 人,吳子樂緊張、望天,楊怡斯低頭,張琸淇及何培欣眼泛淚光,張並向律師點頭、掩面飲泣。周皓文則平靜、點頭。有旁聽親友用紙巾拭淚。散庭時有律師團隊相擁。
法官陳仲衡押後至 10 月 10 日處理求情及判刑,並為 3 名罪成被告索取臨床心理學家報告,另為第四被告索取精神科醫生報告。兩名無罪被告有訟費申請,下次提訊將一併處理。
本案圍繞 2020 年明愛醫院急症室廁所、羅湖站爆炸案,控方亦指控被告策劃在將軍澳尚德邨停車場引爆炸彈,不過警方在事發前拘捕各人(個人案情見內文)。據《法庭線》計算,獲裁無罪的 5 人已還押逾 40 至逾 2000 天,即日獲釋。罪成 3 人皆已還押逾 2000 天,他們的罪名最高可判囚 20 年。
In the second case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, a nine-member jury began deliberating on Monday and, after about 28 hours, unanimously found all seven principal charges under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance against the first seven defendants unproven on Thursday afternoon (the 4th). However, three defendants were convicted on the alternative charge of conspiring to cause an explosion likely to endanger life. The eighth defendant was acquitted of attempting to manufacture explosives.
Of the three convicted defendants, Ho Cheuk Wai nodded when the verdict was delivered, Lee Ka-ban smiled and appeared calm, and Christopher Ka Tsun Cheung also appeared calm. Of the five acquitted defendants, Tsz Lok Ng appeared nervous and looked up at the ceiling, Yeung Yee-sze lowered their head, while Cheung Cheuk-ki and Ho Pui-yan had tears in their eyes. Cheung nodded to the lawyers, covered their face and sobbed. Chow Ho-man remained calm and nodded. Some friends and relatives in the public gallery wiped away tears with tissues. Lawyers from the teams embraced one another when the court adjourned.
Judge Chan Chung-hang adjourned the case until 10 October for mitigation and sentencing. Clinical psychologist reports were ordered for the three convicted defendants, while a psychiatric report was ordered for the fourth defendant. Two acquitted defendants applied for costs, which will be dealt with at the next mention.
The case concerned the 2020 explosion incidents in a toilet at the accident and emergency department of Caritas Medical Centre and at Lo Wu Station. The prosecution also alleged that the defendants had planned to detonate a bomb in the car park of Sheung Tak Estate in Tseung Kwan O, but police arrested them before the incidents took place (see the main text for the individual case details). According to calculations by The Witness, the five acquitted defendants had been remanded for more than 40 to more than 2,000 days and were released the same day. The three convicted defendants had each been remanded for more than 2,000 days, and their offences carry a maximum sentence of 20 years' imprisonment.
4 Sept 2025法庭線#7259
Terrorism second case | Jury finds charges against seven under Terrorism Ordinance not proven; police to actively invoke National Security Law and other offences
反恐條例第二案 9 人陪審團,經過約 28 小時退庭商議後,周四(4 日)一致裁定首 7 名被告《反恐條例》主控罪全部不成立,其中 3 人的「串謀導致爆炸」交替控罪成立。第八被告的企圖製造炸藥亦不成立(見另稿)。
就 5 人獲判無罪,警方國安處警司張伯傑指,會與律政司就所涉的法律議題進行研究。至於案中有 7 人被控《反恐條例》,均被陪審團裁定不成立,張回應指,法庭早前裁定本案所有被告「表證成立」,反映法庭認為控方舉證充足,足以要求被告答辯,又指警方未來會積極引用《國安法》和已完善的《維護國家安全條例》檢控。
至於有被告指控被捕後,遭警方「打、嚇、氹」逼供,張強調,本案證據於正式審訊前,已在另一程序經法庭評核,法官裁定證據在合法框架下獲取、口供是被告自願作出,「所以呢個係得到法庭認證咗嘅一部分」。
After about 28 hours of deliberation, the nine-member jury in the second case under the Terrorism Ordinance unanimously found on Thursday (4th) that all the principal charges under the Terrorism Ordinance against the first seven defendants were not proven. The alternative charge of conspiracy to cause an explosion was proven against three of them. The eighth defendant was also found not guilty of attempting to manufacture explosives (see separate report).
Regarding the five people who were acquitted, Cheung Pak-kit, a senior superintendent of the Police National Security Department, said the police would study the legal issues involved with the Department of Justice. Asked about all seven defendants charged under the Terrorism Ordinance being found not guilty by the jury, Cheung said the court had earlier ruled that a prima facie case had been established against all defendants, reflecting the court’s view that the prosecution had presented sufficient evidence to require the defendants to enter their defence. He also said the police would actively invoke the National Security Law and the improved Safeguarding National Security Ordinance in future prosecutions.
Regarding allegations by some defendants that they had been “beaten, threatened and coaxed” by police into making confessions after their arrests, Cheung stressed that the evidence had already been assessed by the court in another proceeding before the formal trial. The judge had ruled that the evidence was obtained within a lawful framework and that the statements were made voluntarily, “so this is part of what has been certified by the court.”
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.