26 Aug 2025法庭線#7213
19-year-old woman charged with incitement over alleged calls to vote to establish “Hong Kong Parliament”; remanded until Oct 31
19 歲女子被指於今年 3 月至 5 月期間拍攝宣傳短片等,被控一項煽動罪,指她煽惑和鼓勵香港居民參與投票以成立「香港議會」。案件周二(26 日)在西九龍裁判法院首度提堂。
被告穿黑色短袖上衣,家人到庭旁聽。控方指辯方需要閱讀案件文件、索取法律意見,再決定答辯意向,同意押後案件。
被告有保釋申請。《國安法》指定法官、總裁判官蘇惠德聽罷控辯陳詞後,拒絕保釋申請,並押後至 10 月 31 再訊,被告須還押。官亦要求辯方在 10 月 24 日,提前向法院表達答辯意向。
A 19-year-old woman was charged with one count of incitement over allegations that she filmed promotional short videos and other materials between March and May this year, inciting and encouraging Hong Kong residents to vote to establish the “Hong Kong Parliament”. The case was first brought before the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Tuesday (the 26th).
The defendant wore a black short-sleeved top, and family members attended the hearing. The prosecution said the defence needed to review the case documents and seek legal advice before deciding on the defendant’s plea, and agreed to an adjournment.
The defendant applied for bail. After hearing submissions from both sides, designated National Security Law judge and Chief Magistrate So Wai-tak refused the bail application and adjourned the case until Oct 31 for a further hearing. The defendant was remanded in custody. The magistrate also directed the defence to inform the court of the defendant’s plea indication in advance on Oct 24.
26 Aug 2025法庭線#7214
Jimmy Lai case | Defence says government pushed extradition bill despite opposition, and articles merely pointed out its mistakes; judge questions claim
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」等罪,案件周二(26 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)展開第 154 日審訊,辯方第五日結案陳詞。
辯方指,涉案 161 篇刊物在煽動罪下均有合理辯解,舉例指政府於社會出現嚴重憂慮、諮詢不足下,仍強推《逃犯條例》修訂,文章可指出政府犯錯。法官屢質疑,可能是公眾被媒體誤導,而非政府出錯。辯方回應,因此更需要媒體提供資訊,促進公眾討論,強調社會不應只得一個立場。
針對涉及重光團隊(SWHK)的勾結罪,辯方指沒證據顯示黎與李宇軒、陳梓華等人串謀,要求外國實施制裁,陳及李於《國安法》後的行為,僅出於個人意願等原因。至於黎在《國安法》生效前,曾向陳梓華發訊指「準備戰鬥到最後」,辯方指可解作「合法地戰鬥到最後」,不一定涉及違法行為。審訊周三續。
The trial of Apple Daily founder Jimmy Lai, who is charged with offences including conspiracy to collude with foreign forces, entered its 154th day on Tuesday (26th) at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, sitting as the High Court. It was the fifth day of the defence’s closing submissions.
The defence said all 161 publications in question had a reasonable defence to the sedition charges. It cited the government’s pushing ahead with amendments to the Fugitive Offenders Ordinance despite serious concern in society and insufficient consultation, saying the articles were entitled to point out the government’s mistakes. The judge repeatedly questioned whether the public might instead have been misled by the media, rather than the government having made mistakes. The defence replied that this made it even more necessary for the media to provide information and promote public discussion, stressing that society should not have only one viewpoint.
Regarding the collusion charge involving Stand with Hong Kong (SWHK), the defence said there was no evidence that Lai had conspired with Andy Li and Chan Tsz-wah, among others, to ask foreign countries to impose sanctions. It said Chan’s and Li’s actions after the National Security Law took effect were attributable to their personal wishes and other reasons. As for a message Lai sent Chan Tsz-wah before the National Security Law took effect, saying “prepare to fight to the end”, the defence said this could be understood as “fight to the end lawfully” and did not necessarily involve unlawful conduct. The trial will continue on Wednesday.
26 Aug 2025集誌社#7215
Lingnan University Students’ Union | Members say police searched them and security confiscated orientation publications; university says activity was unauthorised
嶺南大學昨(25日)舉行開學禮,有學生會成員稱在大學門外派發迎新刊物期間被警員截查,校園保安亦沒收同學手持刊物、提醒新生「內容不盡正確」。嶺大臨時編委署理總編輯表示對事件感到憤怒和不解,質疑校方是否有權力收走編委出版刊物,擔心事件會造成寒蟬效應,令其他學生組織噤聲。另外,嶺大學生會晚上宣布原定於 8 月尾舉行的迎新營,因場地方「不可抗力因素」無法按計劃舉行。
嶺大回覆時未有回應校方是否報警、為何要沒收刊物等,僅重複上月發出的聲明,指學生會為外部註冊社團,未獲授權於校內進行任何活動。《集誌社》向警方查詢是否接獲校方報案、基於甚麼理由行動等,仍候回覆。
Lingnan University held its opening ceremony yesterday (25th). A Students’ Union member said that members were stopped and searched by police while distributing orientation publications outside the university, and that campus security confiscated publications held by students and reminded freshmen that the “content was not entirely accurate”. The acting editor-in-chief of the interim editorial board said they were angry and puzzled by the incident, questioned whether the university had the authority to take away publications issued by editorial board, and feared the incident would create a chilling effect, silencing other student organisations. Separately, the Lingnan University Students’ Union announced last night that its orientation camp, originally scheduled for the end of August, could not be held as planned because of “force majeure factors” at the venue.
In its response, Lingnan University did not address whether the university had reported the matter to police or why the publications had been confiscated. It merely repeated a statement issued last month, saying that the Students’ Union was an externally registered society and had not been authorised to conduct any activities on campus. The Collective向警方查詢 whether the university had reported the matter to police and the reasons for the action, and was still awaiting a response.
25 Aug 2025法庭線#7206
Radiographer Jailed 13 Months for Inciting Assault on Police in LIHKG Comment Saying “Kill the Dogs”; Leave to Appeal Refused, Judge Says Intent Was Plain
案發時 29 歲放射師,於 2019 年 12 月在「連登」帖文留言提及「殺狗」等字眼,被指煽惑他人襲警,事隔近 3 年被起訴一項「煽惑他人有意圖傷人而致有人身體受嚴重傷害」,2024 年 9 月被判監 13 個月。他不服定罪提上訴許可申請,今年 6 月被上訴庭法官潘敏琦即日駁回。官周一(25 日)頒判詞,稱上訴理據不具合理爭拗之處。
法官批評,申請方把留言斬件式,或分拆式考慮,「對其他整體情況置若罔聞的做法,根本不切實際」,又指申請人沒作供,法庭毋須憑空為其想像答辯理由。官並同意原審裁斷,申請人案發前後其他帖文,曾多番以相同侮辱字眼稱呼警員,反映涉案留言並非因一時意氣或情緒失控,心態和意圖「無所遁形,昭然若揭」。
法官另向他發出「減時命令」,即他有權再提上訴許可申請,惟若被駁回,上訴庭有權把他聽候上訴裁定的扣押期,不計算在他刑期之內。
The radiographer, aged 29 at the time of the offence, commented on a LIHKG post in December 2019 using words including “kill the dogs”. He was accused of inciting others to assault police and, nearly three years later, was charged with one count of “inciting another with intent to cause grievous bodily harm to a person”. He was sentenced to 13 months’ imprisonment in September 2024. He applied for leave to appeal against his conviction, but the application was dismissed on the same day in June by Court of Appeal judge Justice Pang Min-ki. In reasons handed down on Monday (25th), the judge said the grounds of appeal had no reasonable prospect of argument.
The judge criticised the applicant’s approach of considering the comment in fragments or separately, saying that “the practice of turning a blind eye to the other overall circumstances is simply unrealistic”. As the applicant had not given evidence, the court was not required to invent a defence for him. The judge also agreed with the trial court’s finding that the applicant had repeatedly used the same insulting terms to refer to police officers in other posts before and after the offence. This showed that the comment in question was not made in a moment of anger or emotional loss of control, and that his state of mind and intent were “inescapable and plain”.
The judge also issued a “time deduction order”, meaning that he may renew his application for leave to appeal. However, if the application is refused, the Court of Appeal may order that the period for which he is detained pending the appeal decision not be counted towards his sentence.
25 Aug 2025法庭線#7207
Man jailed 24 months for inciting wounding after posting “stab the small-intestine area”; leave to appeal sentence refused, judge says remarks were inciting
2021 年銅鑼灣七一刺警案當晚,23 歲男子被指在「連登」發布「下次應該插身體中間小腸嘅部位」等留言,經審訊後被裁定「煽惑他人有意圖而傷人」罪成,判監 24 個月。他不服判期提上訴許可申請,今年 7 月聆訊後,被上訴庭法官潘敏琦即日駁回,至本周一(25 日)頒判詞。
判詞指,申請方提出的唯一上訴理據,是指原審法官以判監 24 個月為量刑起點,忽略上訴庭就「張敬生案」的判詞及情節,判刑明顯過重。官於判詞反駁,指比較兩案嚴重性沒實質意義,又提到申請人在警員被刺後 12 分鐘,已發首個留言「乘勢狙擊」,且理直氣壯回應他人「教人點插都唔得呀」等,認為其留言並非開玩笑,而是「目標為本」、血腥兇殘、極具教唆性。
判詞稱上訴理據不具合理爭拗之處,另下達「減時命令」,即他有權再向上訴法庭提出上訴許可申請,但假如申請最終被駁回,上訴法庭有權命令他在聽候上訴裁定時間的扣押期,不計算在他所受刑罰的刑期之內。
On the night of the 2021 July 1 police stabbing in Causeway Bay, a 23-year-old man was alleged to have posted comments on LIHKG including, “Next time, the part in the middle of the body where the small intestine is should be stabbed.” After trial, he was convicted of inciting another to wound with intent and sentenced to 24 months’ imprisonment. He applied for leave to appeal against the sentence. After a hearing in July this year, Court of Appeal judge Poon Man-ki dismissed the application on the same day, with the judgment handed down this Monday (25th). The judgment stated that the applicant’s sole ground of appeal was that, by adopting 24 months’ imprisonment as the sentencing starting point, the trial judge had failed to take proper account of the Court of Appeal’s judgment and the circumstances in the Cheung King-sang case, resulting in a sentence that was manifestly excessive. The judge rejected that argument, saying that comparing the relative seriousness of the two cases served little substantive purpose. She also noted that, just 12 minutes after the police officer was stabbed, the applicant had already posted his first comment, effectively “seizing the opportunity to encourage further attacks”, and had defiantly responded to others with remarks such as, “So you can’t even teach people where to stab?” The judge found that his comments were not made in jest, but were purpose-driven, graphic and brutal, and highly inciting in nature.
The judgment held that the proposed ground of appeal was not reasonably arguable. The court also made a loss-of-time order. This means that the applicant may still renew his application for leave to appeal before the Court of Appeal, but if that application is ultimately refused, the Court of Appeal may order that some or all of the time he spends in custody pending determination of the appeal not count towards his sentence.
25 Aug 2025BBC#7208
Bloomberg Hong Kong Correspondent Denied Visa Renewal; Foreign Correspondents’ Club Says Concerns Over Press Freedom Are Worsening
香港入境部門再次拒絕為外國記者發放工作簽證。
最新的一位涉事人為彭博新聞(Bloomberg)記者鍾碧琪(Rebecca Choong Wilkins),她已駐港6年,目前正放產假。
上周五,香港外國記者會(FCC)率先於(8月22日)發聲明公佈消息,指當局並未就其拒絕簽證續簽提供任何理由,加劇對香港新聞自由受侵蝕的擔憂。
彭博新聞發言人向BBC中文表示,不能評論個別情況,但指會全力支持鍾碧琪,並繼續透過適當渠道解決事件。
Hong Kong’s immigration authorities have again refused to issue a work visa to a foreign journalist.
The latest journalist involved is Bloomberg News reporter Rebecca Choong Wilkins, who has been based in Hong Kong for six years and is currently on maternity leave.
The Foreign Correspondents’ Club, Hong Kong, issued a statement last Friday (22 August) announcing the matter. It said the authorities had provided no reason for refusing to renew her visa, exacerbating concerns over the erosion of press freedom in Hong Kong.
A Bloomberg News spokesperson told BBC Chinese that the company could not comment on individual cases, but said it would fully support Choong Wilkins and continue to address the matter through appropriate channels.
25 Aug 2025法庭線#7209
Jimmy Lai case | Defence: Media have a duty to scrutinise those in power and should enjoy greater freedom of expression than the public
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」等罪,案件周一(25 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)展開第 153 日審訊,辯方第四日結案陳詞。
辯方指,《蘋果》是傳統報紙媒體,而記者有責任向公眾提供資訊,應較公眾享有更大言論自由,若有文章提到制裁,法庭須考慮該文章是否新聞報道。
辯方另質疑「從犯證人」、前壹傳媒行政總裁張劍虹供詞矛盾不可信,舉例指張在誓章提到,沒參與制定《蘋果》編採政策,但他在庭上則指會審閱文章,確保員工遵從編採指示。辯方又指,張確認曾在獄中與警員傾談數小時,質疑他被游說轉任控方證人。案件周二續審。
Next Digital founder Jimmy Lai is charged with “conspiracy to collude with foreign forces” and other offences. The case entered its 153rd day of trial at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, sitting temporarily as the High Court, on Monday (25th), with the defence making closing submissions for a fourth day.
The defence said Apple Daily was a traditional newspaper and that journalists had a duty to provide information to the public, and should therefore enjoy greater freedom of expression than the public. It said that if an article mentioned sanctions, the court must consider whether the article constituted news reporting.
The defence also questioned the credibility of “accomplice witness” and former Next Digital chief executive Cheung Kim-hung, citing contradictions in his testimony. For example, Cheung said in an affidavit that he had not participated in formulating Apple Daily’s editorial policy, but told the court that he reviewed articles to ensure staff complied with editorial instructions. The defence also said Cheung confirmed that he had spoken with police officers for several hours while in prison, and questioned whether he had been persuaded to become a prosecution witness. The trial will continue on Tuesday.
25 Aug 2025法庭線#7210
Anti-terrorism case: Prosecution cites suspected protest items found at fifth defendant’s home; jury told not to use them to support case
2020 年初,明愛醫院、羅湖港鐵車廂被發現有爆炸品,Telegram 頻道「九十二籤」事後承認責任。7 人被控《反恐條例》罪名,餘下 1 人被控以「企圖製造炸藥」罪。8 人不認罪,周一(25 日)於高院踏入第 156 天審訊,法官續引導陪審團。
法官陳仲衡完成解釋警員供詞的部分。官提及,第五被告楊怡斯家中被搜出有勞工手套、護髀、黑色手袖等物品,提醒陪審員「可能認為同示威有關物品,大家唔好有太多考慮,新聞成日見到示威、成日睇到物品,大家唔好(就物品)對第五被告案情作考慮」,指示不要用楊家中被檢取的該些物品,支持控方對楊的指控。
另外官開始就專家證人的部分開始引導,官提及警方刑事部技術支援組時任署理總督察盧永楷曾指,他以第四被告張家俊被檢取的手機,測試張手機中的 Telegram 機械人程式,而該程式出現與羅湖案爆炸裝置一樣的憑證(token)。案件周二(26 日)續審。
In early 2020, explosives were found at Caritas Medical Centre and in a Lo Wu MTR train compartment. The Telegram channel “九十二籤” subsequently claimed responsibility. Seven people were charged with offences under the Terrorism Ordinance, while the remaining person was charged with “attempting to manufacture explosives”. All eight pleaded not guilty. On Monday (25th), the trial at the High Court entered its 156th day, with the judge continuing to direct the jury.
Judge Chan Chung-hang completed the part concerning explanations of police officers’ evidence. The prosecution referred to items including work gloves, thigh guards and black arm sleeves found at the home of the fifth defendant Yeung Yee-sze. The judge reminded the jurors that they might regard the items as related to protests, but told them not to attach too much significance to them, noting that protests and such items were frequently seen in the news. He directed them not to use the items seized from Yeung’s home in considering the prosecution’s case against Yeung.
The judge also began directing the jury on the expert evidence. He referred to evidence from Lo Wing-kai, then acting chief inspector of the Police Criminal Investigation Department’s Technical Support Unit, that he used a mobile phone seized from the fourth defendant Christopher Ka Tsun Cheung to test the Telegram bot program on Cheung’s phone, and that the program contained the same token as the explosive device in the Lo Wu case. The trial will continue on Tuesday (26th).
24 Aug 2025法庭線#7205
Chan Fai-wong inquest jury recommends cameras in police vehicles; family urges serious consideration: “If there had been one then, could the truth have emerged?”
死因庭今年 7 月裁定的士司機陳輝旺「非法被殺」,陪審團向警方建議在警車安裝可收音的錄像鏡頭,保障被捕人的安全。陳輝旺的女兒回覆《法庭線》指,建議「非常具體及明確」,促請當局認真回應及考慮。
女兒提及,爸爸因警員箍頸致全身癱瘓,幸好西隧的錄影鏡頭拍攝了當刻情況,否則箍頸致癱的原因只會石沉大海,但爸爸身上亦有 20 多處非致命的瘀傷,他生前指遭警員用警棍毆打,但可惜警車上沒有錄影鏡頭,「我爸滿身瘀傷的原因依然成謎」。
女兒續問,「到底我爸雙手被反鎖、被箍上警車後,在那狹小空間的 20 分鐘裡,發生甚麼事?若果當年警車有錄影鏡頭,這 20 分鐘所發生的事情可否水落石出?」
她又指,作為市民亦非常關注錄影鏡頭衍生的私隱問題,爸爸曾申請西隧片段被拒絕,最後經由死因庭申請才能查看當晚片段,反映只要設立嚴謹程序就能保障私隱,同時有助社會維護公義與揭露真相。
The Coroner’s Court ruled in July this year that taxi driver Chan Fai-wong was unlawfully killed. The jury recommended that police vehicles be fitted with video cameras capable of recording sound to safeguard the safety of arrested people. Chan Fai-wong’s daughter told The Witness that the recommendation was “very specific and clear”, and urged the authorities to respond to and consider it seriously.
The daughter said her father became paralysed from the neck down after a police officer restrained his neck. Fortunately, cameras at the Western Harbour Crossing recorded what happened at the time; otherwise, the cause of his paralysis would have remained unknown. However, he also had more than 20 non-fatal bruises. He said before his death that police officers had beaten him with batons, but there were no cameras in the police vehicle. “The reason my father was covered in bruises remains a mystery.”
She continued: “What exactly happened during those 20 minutes in that confined space after my father’s hands had been handcuffed behind his back and he had been put into the police vehicle? If there had been a camera in the police vehicle then, could what happened during those 20 minutes have come to light?”
She also said members of the public were very concerned about privacy issues arising from the use of cameras. Her father had been refused access to the Western Harbour Crossing footage and was ultimately able to view the footage from that night only after applying through the Coroner’s Court. This showed that, as long as rigorous procedures were established, privacy could be protected while helping society uphold justice and uncover the truth.
23 Aug 2025明報#7204
Cyber Patrols and Digital Forensics Help Immigration Department Conduct Undercover Operations Against Illegal Workers
入境處2021年成立網絡罪案及法證調查小組,透過網絡巡邏為前線提供情報,又以數碼法證技術,包括修復及分析智能電話、手提電腦等電子裝置的電子數據,協助蒐證及舉證,加強打擊假結婚、買賣假證件、安排非法勞工等網上入境罪行。就近日引起關注的非法勞工問題,小組過去一年協助特遣隊作6次「放蛇」行動,拘捕21名來港從事清潔、代購、攝影、導遊等不同行業的內地非法勞工。
一年6放蛇拘21人
入境處助理首席入境事務主任(反恐及情報科)吳海量稱,近年犯罪分子利用不同電子裝置溝通,在網上平台試圖組織非法活動,包括誤導或誘使市民聘用非法勞工、假結婚、買賣假證等,故該處成立網絡罪案及法證調查小組,加強打擊相關網上入境罪行。
The Immigration Department established a Cybercrime and Forensic Investigation Group in 2021. Through cyber patrols, the group provides intelligence to frontline officers and uses digital forensic techniques—including the recovery and analysis of electronic data from devices such as smartphones and laptops—to assist in gathering and presenting evidence, strengthening efforts against online immigration-related offences including sham marriages, the sale and purchase of forged documents, and arrangements involving illegal workers. In response to the illegal-worker issue that has attracted attention recently, the group assisted a task force in carrying out six undercover operations over the past year, resulting in the arrest of 21 mainland illegal workers who had come to Hong Kong to work in various sectors, including cleaning, purchasing-agent services, photography and tour guiding.
Six undercover operations in one year result in 21 arrests
Wu Hoi-leung, Assistant Principal Immigration Officer (Counter-Terrorism and Intelligence Division) of the Immigration Department, said criminals in recent years had used different electronic devices to communicate and attempted to organise illegal activities on online platforms, including misleading or inducing members of the public to hire illegal workers, arranging sham marriages and trading forged documents. The department therefore established the Cybercrime and Forensic Investigation Group to strengthen efforts against related online immigration offences.
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.