15 Jan 2025法庭線#4430
Jimmy Lai Fraud Case: Lai and Former Senior Executive Wong Wai-keung Appeal; Prosecution Says Any Company Occupying Tenant’s Premises Must Be Licensed, Judgment Reserved
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英與集團行政總監黃偉強,被指向科技園公司隱瞞違反將軍澳工業邨租契,2022 年分別被判監禁 5 年 9 個月及 1 年 9 個月。兩人不服定罪提上訴,周三(15 日)在高等法院續審。
律政司代表、刑事檢控專員楊美琪指,承租人的任何公司佔用處所都須要申請牌照,被告有披露責任,卻隱瞞「力高」存在。她又指,承租人獲科技園公司批准以優惠地價租地,因此屬「特殊租契」。惟法官指承租人投資金額巨大,計劃同時促進香港經濟發展,質疑非僅對承租人有利。
楊美琪又指,黎是「作出指示及決定的人」,利用「蘋果印刷」犯案。法官關注,按律政司此說法,黎與「蘋果印刷」應屬「共同犯罪」,但後者沒被控。楊指,黎幕後控制涉案公司,舉例在洗黑錢案,涉事公司也不會被起訴。上訴庭聽畢雙方陳詞,將於 6 個月內頒布書面判詞。
Next Digital founder Jimmy Lai and group executive Wong Wai-keung were accused of concealing from the Hong Kong Science and Technology Parks Corporation that they had breached the lease for the Tseung Kwan O Industrial Estate. They were sentenced in 2022 to 5 years and 9 months’ imprisonment and 1 year and 9 months’ imprisonment respectively. Both appealed against their convictions, with the hearing continuing at the High Court on Wednesday (15th).
The prosecution’s representative, Director of Public Prosecutions Mi Ki Yeung, said that any company occupying the premises as a tenant must apply for a licence. The defendants had a duty to disclose this but concealed the existence of “Dico Consultants”. She also said the tenant had been allowed by the Hong Kong Science and Technology Parks Corporation to lease the land at a concessionary rent, making it a “special lease”. The judge, however, noted that the tenant had invested a substantial amount and that the project also promoted Hong Kong’s economic development, questioning whether it benefited only the tenant.
Mi Ki Yeung also said Lai was “the person who gave instructions and made decisions” and had used Apple Daily Printing to commit the offence. The judge questioned whether, under the prosecution’s argument, Lai and Apple Daily Printing should be regarded as “joint offenders”, even though the latter had not been charged. Yang said Lai controlled the company behind the scenes, citing the money-laundering case in which the company involved would likewise not be prosecuted. After hearing submissions from both sides, the Court of Appeal will deliver its written judgment within six months.
15 Jan 2025法庭線#4431
Second Terrorism Case | First Defendant Says in Video Interview: Caritas Explosives Case “Had Nothing to Do with Me”; Alleges “Shan Gai” Was Involved
2020 年初,明愛醫院、羅湖港鐵車廂被發現有爆炸品,Telegram 頻道「九十二籤」事後承認責任。7 人被控《反恐條例》罪名,餘下 1 人被控以「企圖製造炸藥」罪。8 人不認罪,案件本周一因陪審員不適押後,周三(15 日)於高等法院續審,踏入第 35 天審訊。
控方繼續播放首被告何卓為的錄影會面片段,何供稱借用單位給「山雞」(被指為次被告)使用,警員詢問有沒有目睹山雞在單位製造粉末,何答稱「冇」,後來補充見過山雞與他人混合化學物時使用黃色粉末,估計對方製作爆炸品。
何卓為在錄影中強調,透過新聞才得知明愛醫院發生爆炸案,指沒有參與製作炸彈、「唔關我事嘅」。他並稱,看到「山雞」事後在 Telegram 群組說「我搞掂咗」、「個煙彈成功咗」,因此相信對方有份製作及放置在明愛的炸彈。
In early 2020, explosives were found at Caritas Medical Centre and in an MTR train compartment at Lo Wu. The Telegram channel “92 Lots” subsequently claimed responsibility. Seven people were charged with offences under the Terrorism Ordinance, while one remaining defendant was charged with “attempting to manufacture explosives”. All eight pleaded not guilty. The trial was adjourned on Monday this week because a juror was unwell, and resumed at the High Court on Wednesday (15th), entering its 35th day.
The prosecution continued playing excerpts from a video-recorded interview with first defendant Ho Cheuk Wai. Ho said he had lent a flat to “Shan Gai” (alleged to be the second defendant). When a police officer asked whether he had seen Shan Gai making powder at the flat, Ho said “no”. He later added that he had seen Shan Gai and others using yellow powder while mixing chemicals, and assumed they were making explosives.
In the recording, Ho Cheuk Wai stressed that he only learned from the news that an explosion case had occurred at Caritas Medical Centre, saying he had not participated in making bombs and that it “had nothing to do with me”. He also said that he saw “Shan Gai” say in a Telegram group afterwards, “I’ve finished it” and “the smoke bomb was successful”, and therefore believed that the other man had been involved in making and placing the bomb at Caritas.
14 Jan 2025集誌社#4427
National security police conduct two-day operation, invite Chung Kim-wah’s wife and son to assist investigation
國安警去年底懸紅各100萬元,通緝香港民研前副行政總裁鍾劍劍華等六人,近日開始針對個別被通緝人士的親友,展開調查行動。繼香港香港民研主席兼行政總裁鍾庭耀昨 ( 13 日)被國安警帶走後,據了解,國安警今早邀請鍾劍華的太太及兒子,到警署助查。下午 12 時許,鍾劍華的兒子,離開旺角警署。鍾劍華太太於下午1時30分步出天水圍警署,她急步離開後,一度被傳媒追訪拍攝。
At the end of last year, national security police offered rewards of $1 million each for information leading to the arrest of six wanted people, including former deputy chief executive of the Hong Kong Public Opinion Research Institute Chung Kim-wah. In recent days, they have begun investigative operations targeting the relatives and friends of individual wanted people. After HKPORI chairperson and chief executive Chung Ting-yiu was taken away by national security police yesterday (13th), national security police are understood to have invited Chung Kim-wah’s wife and son to assist with an investigation this morning. Chung Kim-wah’s son left Mong Kok Police Station at around noon. Chung Kim-wah’s wife left Tin Shui Wai Police Station at 1:30 pm; after walking away quickly, she was briefly pursued, interviewed and filmed by the media.
14 Jan 2025法庭線#4428
Lai Chee-ying fraud case | Lai and former executive Wong Wai-keung appeal, say Dico Consultants shared premises related to newspaper business and did not require a licence
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英與集團行政總監黃偉強,被指向科技園公司隱瞞違反將軍澳工業邨租契,2022 年分別被判監禁 5 年 9 個月及 1 年 9 個月。兩人不服定罪和判刑提上訴,周二(14 日)在高等法院審理。
上訴方指,涉案「力高」公司與報紙業務相關,並非「佔用」處所,而是「共用」處所,因此毋須領取牌照,黎智英、黃偉強亦沒有披露責任,又指租契並不要求整個土地用於出版、印刷報紙等指明用途。另外,上訴方指黃偉強已服刑完畢,故放棄判刑上訴。
律政司一方則指,「蘋果印刷」多次為不同公司申請牌照和續牌,但不包括「力高」,又指不論是佔用或共用處所,都應該申請牌照,而「力高」沒有牌照,就屬違反租契,重申承租人有披露責任。案件周三(15 日)續審。
Next Digital founder Lai Chee-ying and the group’s chief administrative officer, Wong Wai-keung, were accused of concealing from the Hong Kong Science and Technology Parks Corporation a breach of the lease for the Tseung Kwan O Industrial Estate. They were sentenced in 2022 to 5 years and 9 months’ imprisonment and 1 year and 9 months’ imprisonment respectively. Both appealed against their convictions and sentences, with the appeals heard at the High Court on Tuesday (the 14th). The appellants argued that the company involved, Dico Consultants Limited, was related to the newspaper business and did not “occupy” the premises, but merely “shared” them. They therefore argued that no licence was required and that neither Lai nor Wong was under a duty to disclose the arrangement. The appellants also submitted that the lease did not require the entire site to be used for specified purposes such as publishing and printing newspapers.
The appellants further said that Wong had already completed his sentence and was therefore abandoning his appeal against sentence.
The Department of Justice argued that Apple Daily Printing Limited had applied for and renewed licences on multiple occasions for various companies, but not for Dico Consultants. It submitted that a licence was required regardless of whether the premises were occupied or shared. Since Dico Consultants did not have a licence, this amounted to a breach of the lease. The prosecution also reiterated that the lessee had a duty to disclose the arrangement.
The hearing will continue on Wednesday (15th).
13 Jan 2025集誌社#4421
National Security Wanted Case | Chung Ting-yiu and Two Others Taken Away by National Security Police; Six Boxes of Items Seized from Polling Institute Office over Alleged Assistance to Fugitive
據了解,香港民研主席及行政總裁鍾庭耀今早在住所(13日)被警方國安處上門帶走,被指涉協助被通緝在逃人士;據悉相關人士為香港民研前副行政總裁鍾劍華,他於去年平安夜被國安警懸紅 100 萬通緝。一批警員今早約九時多,到民研位於黃竹坑南滙廣場的會址戒備,有傳媒拍攝到上午約 10 時,鍾庭耀被帶到南滙廣場。現場所見,警員在業勤街、業興街兩個大廈出入口戒備,惟未有特別截查出入人士。晚上六時許,警方將鍾庭耀及另外兩人帶走,及檢走約六個膠箱的物品。
It is understood that Chung Ting-yiu, chairperson and chief executive of the Hong Kong Public Opinion Research Institute, was taken away from his residence by officers from the police National Security Department this morning, the 13th, over alleged assistance to a wanted fugitive. The person concerned is reportedly Chung Kim-wah, the institute’s former deputy chief executive, who was placed on a HK$1 million wanted reward by national security police on Christmas Eve last year. A group of police officers took up positions at the institute’s office in South Horizons, Wong Chuk Hang, at about 9 a.m. this morning. Media footage showed Chung Ting-yiu being taken to South Horizons at around 10 a.m. Officers were seen stationed at two building entrances on Yip Hing Street and Yip Kan Street, but did not conduct special checks on people entering or leaving. At around 6 p.m., police took Chung Ting-yiu and two other people away and seized approximately six plastic boxes of items.
13 Jan 2025法庭線#4422
Jimmy Lai case | Cheung Kim-hong testifies Lai promoted “Support Small Shops” advertising campaign; Lai says he did not attend meeting and proposal came from employees
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」等罪,周一(13 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)展開第 118 日審訊,黎第 26 日作供。
就「從犯證人」前壹傳媒行政總裁張劍虹供稱,黎於 2019 年曾推「撐小店」廣告活動,辯方展示《蘋果》工作平台 Slack 紀錄,顯示黎當時不在港,會議由張劍虹主持。黎又指,建議由員工提出,否認在其他渠道向張表示支持提議。案件周四(16 日)續審。
Next Digital founder Jimmy Lai is charged with “conspiracy to collude with foreign forces” and other offences. The trial entered its 118th day on Monday (13th) at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, sitting as the High Court, with Lai giving evidence for the 26th day.
Former Next Digital chief executive Cheung Kim-hong, described as an “accomplice witness”, testified that Lai promoted a “Support Small Shops” advertising campaign in 2019. The defence displayed Slack records from Apple Daily’s work platform showing that Lai was not in Hong Kong at the time and that the meeting was chaired by Cheung. Lai also said the proposal had been put forward by employees, denying that he had indicated his support for it to Cheung through other channels. The trial will continue on Thursday (16th).
13 Jan 2025法庭線#4423
721 White-Clad Men Case | 3 Men Plead Guilty to Rioting and Other Offences, Involving Punching and Throwing Objects; One Says He Wanted to Mediate; 12 White-Clad Men Convicted to Date
元朗 7.21 襲擊,事隔 4 年後再多 4 名白衣人被落案起訴暴動等罪,其中一人早前認罪已判囚,餘下 3 人周一(13 日)在區院認罪,還押至 1 月 23 日判刑。至今共 12 名白衣人罪成。案情指,3 名被告分別被指曾揮拳襲擊、在月台聚集、擲物、手持藤條進出車廂及揮向閘內人等。
控方在 3 人被裁定罪成後透露,他們均報稱沒三合會背景,但涉及 3 至 9 項定罪紀錄,包括管有危險藥物、刑事恐嚇、刑事毀壞等。辯方求情時提及,被告在月台是想分隔兩班人,欲調停雙方、平息衝突;強調被告的角色為「追隨者」,並非主導者、指揮者。
法官謝沈智慧一度關注,稱「如果我話呢件案嚴重之處係早有預謀,會咁啱著晒白衫,咁啱攞藤條,其他人又攞藤條,咁啱佢又戴手套去?」辯方回應稱明白,沒有陳詞。
Four more white-clad men were charged with rioting and other offences in connection with the Yuen Long 7.21 attack four years after the incident. One had earlier pleaded guilty and been sentenced to imprisonment, while the remaining three pleaded guilty at the District Court on Monday (13th). They were remanded until 23 January for sentencing. A total of 12 white-clad men have now been convicted. The case alleged that the three defendants had punched people, gathered on a platform, thrown objects, and carried rattan sticks into and out of train carriages and swung them at people inside the gates, among other acts.
After the three men were convicted, the prosecution disclosed that they had all reported having no triad background, but had between three and nine previous conviction records, including possession of dangerous drugs, criminal intimidation and criminal damage. In mitigation, the defence said the defendants had been trying to separate two groups on the platform and mediate between the two sides to calm the conflict. It stressed that the defendants were followers, rather than leaders or organisers.
Judge Adriana Noelle Tse Ching at one point raised concerns, saying: “If I say the seriousness of this case is that it was premeditated—how else would they all happen to be wearing white, happen to have rattan sticks, while other people also happened to have rattan sticks, and he happened to be wearing gloves?” The defence replied that it understood and made no further submissions.
10 Jan 2025法庭線#4418
Second terrorism case | First defendant says he only provided premises and received thousands as a storage fee, denies links to bombings
2020 年初,明愛醫院、羅湖港鐵車廂被發現有爆炸品,Telegram 頻道「九十二籤」事後承認責任。7 人被控《反恐條例》罪名,餘下 1 人被控以「企圖製造炸藥」罪。8 人不認罪,周五(10 日)於高等法院踏入第 33 天審訊。
拘捕首被告何卓為的偵緝警員供稱,何在警誡下一度稱「啲炸彈係家俊整嘅」,其後改稱不知道是否對方製作,又指「呢 3 單嘢真係唔關我事,我剩係借咗大角咀個地方畀佢哋用咋嘛」。
控方另播放何卓為首個錄影會面,顯示何稱猜測「山雞」、「夠鐘改名」(均被指為同案被告)在其宏創方單位內製造炸彈,又指與「山雞」於「一間好黃嘅酒吧」認識,當時知道對方需找地方,故向他們提供單位,並有收取數千元「當存倉費、 當交租」,否認與爆炸案有關。案件下周一(13 日)續,繼續播放錄影會面。
In early 2020, explosives were found at Caritas Medical Centre and in a Lo Wu MTR train carriage. The Telegram channel “92 Signs” subsequently claimed responsibility. Seven people have been charged with offences under the Terrorism Ordinance, while the remaining defendant faces a charge of “attempting to manufacture explosives”. All eight have pleaded not guilty. The trial at the High Court entered its 33rd day on Friday (10th). A detective police officer who arrested the first defendant, Ho Cheuk-wai, testified that, under caution, Ho initially said, “The bombs were made by Ka-chun”, but later said he did not know whether Ka-chun had made them. Ho also said, “Those three incidents really had nothing to do with me. I only lent them the place in Tai Kok Tsui to use.”
The prosecution also played Ho’s first video-recorded interview in court. In the interview, Ho said he suspected that “Shan Gai” and “Time to Change Name” — both alleged to be defendants in the same case — had made bombs in his unit at The Galaxy in Tai Kok Tsui. He said he had met “Shan Gai” at “a very pro-yellow bar” and learned at the time that the other party needed a place to use, so he made the unit available to them.
Ho said he received several thousand dollars from them “as a storage fee, or as rent”, and denied any involvement in the bombing incidents.
The trial will continue next Monday (13th), when the court will continue viewing the video-recorded interview.
10 Jan 2025法庭線#4420
Final Appeal in Tam Tak-chi’s Sedition Case: Defence Cites Gandhi, Says Freedom to Express Dissatisfaction Should Apply Where There Is No Incitement to Violence
人民力量前副主席「快必」譚得志,被指 2020 年擺街站時,發表「黑警死全家」、「光時」等言論,被裁定「發表煽動文字」等 11 罪成,判囚 40 個月,他就本案已完成服刑。譚不服定罪及刑罰提終極上訴,終院 5 位法官於周五(10 日)聽畢雙方陳詞,押後裁決。
本案爭議之一,是煽動罪須否證煽暴意圖。代表譚的資深大律師戴啟思,引印度聖雄甘地在 1922 年大審判中的自述指,感情無法被製造或以法律去規範,若一個人對某人或制度沒有感情,只要不涉煽動暴力,他應該有自由充分表達不滿。律政司則重申,終院已裁定煽動罪合憲,沒侵犯言論自由,控方毋須證明具煽暴或擾亂公共秩序意圖。
針對上訴方指煽動罪屬「可公訴罪行」,須在高院原訟庭由陪審團審理,法官質疑,舊煽動罪最高刑罰僅判囚 2 年,由原訟庭及陪審團處理是否「小題大做」,又指「可公訴罪行」由原訟庭審訊的規定非「約束衣」。
Former People Power vice-chairman “Fast Beat” Tam Tak-chi was convicted of 11 offences, including “uttering seditious words”, over remarks allegedly made at a street booth in 2020, including “black cops should die with their entire families” and “Liberate Hong Kong, revolution of our times”. He was sentenced to 40 months in prison and has completed his sentence in the case. Tam, dissatisfied with his conviction and sentence, brought a final appeal. Five Court of Final Appeal judges finished hearing submissions from both sides on Friday (the 10th) and reserved judgment.
One issue in the case is whether a sedition charge requires proof of an intention to incite violence. Senior Counsel for Tam, Philip John Dykes, cited Mahatma Gandhi’s account of his 1922 trial, saying that feelings cannot be manufactured or regulated by law. If a person has no feeling towards someone or an institution, he should have the freedom to fully express his dissatisfaction so long as it does not involve inciting violence. The Department of Justice reiterated that the Court of Final Appeal had ruled that the sedition offence was constitutional and did not infringe freedom of speech, and that the prosecution was not required to prove an intention to incite violence or disrupt public order.
In response to the appellant’s argument that sedition is an “indictable offence” that must be tried by a jury in the Court of First Instance, the judges questioned whether having the Court of First Instance and a jury handle the matter was “making a mountain out of a molehill”, given that the maximum sentence for the old sedition offence was only two years’ imprisonment. They also said that the requirement for indictable offences to be tried in the Court of First Instance was not a “straitjacket”.
9 Jan 2025法庭線#4406
Anti-terrorism trial: Surveillance officer says first defendant resisted interception in train carriage and was carried to platform after being subdued
2020 年初,明愛醫院、羅湖港鐵車廂被發現有爆炸品,Telegram 頻道「九十二籤」事後承認責任。7人被控《反恐條例》罪名,餘下 1 人被控以「企圖製造炸藥」罪。8 人不認罪,周四(9 日)於高院踏入第 32 天審訊。
第四被告一方盤問負責檢視 CCTV 的 O 記警員,指他憑片中人的外套、褲、背囊等辨認,質疑衣物人人都可以買到。警員稱,「一件衫係可以周圍買嘅,但一件衫、一對鞋、一個背囊拍埋一齊,係絕無僅有嘅」,又稱被告的「揈頭」步姿亦是絕無僅有。
制服首被告何卓為的監視警員供稱,當晚尾隨何並登上往東涌的港鐵列車,收到指示要截查,故與同袍走到何身邊,並從腰間持委任證向何展示,而何推開警員,「之後有起身同反抗嘅行為」,兩警制服何並將他抬離車廂到月台。案件周五續。
In early 2020, explosives were found at Caritas Medical Centre and in an MTR train carriage at Lo Wu. The Telegram channel “Ninety-Two Lots” later claimed responsibility. Seven people were charged with offences under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, while the remaining person was charged with “attempting to manufacture explosives”. All eight pleaded not guilty, and the trial at the High Court entered its 32nd day on Thursday (9th).
Counsel for the fourth defendant cross-examined an O Division police officer responsible for reviewing CCTV, saying that he identified the person in the footage by the jacket, trousers and backpack, and questioning whether such clothing could be bought by anyone. The officer said, “A shirt can be bought anywhere, but a shirt, a pair of shoes and a backpack put together are absolutely unique.” He also said the defendant’s “head-swaying” walking style was unique.
The surveillance officer who subdued the first defendantHo Cheuk Wai testified that he followed Ho that night and boarded an MTR train bound for Tung Chung. After receiving instructions to intercept and search him, he and a colleague approached Ho, and he took his warrant card from his waist and showed it to Ho. Ho pushed the officer away, “then got up and resisted”. The two officers subdued Ho and carried him out of the carriage onto the platform. The case continues on Friday.
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.