5 Aug 2024法庭線#3881
First Anti-terrorism Case | Prosecution Completes Closing Submissions, Says Two Ng Chi-hung Team Defendants Made Bombs and Scouted Before Test-firing Guns
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周一(5 日)在高等法院踏入第 65 天審訊。控方完成結案陳詞,提到吳智鴻團隊的行動不斷升級,最終演變成「12.8 計劃」。兩名被指為吳團隊的被告,控方指賴振邦必然知悉計劃涉炸彈,指他曾爆竊大學實驗室,並協助製造炸彈。另一被告許湛榮則在試槍前探路,曾參與軍訓。
至於被控串謀眾籌作恐怖主義行為的女被告,控方指此罪毋須與「12.8 計劃」有必然關係,指「屠龍」對外宣揚五大訴求、「一齊殺狗」等,「並唔係出嚟遊行咁簡單」,其中使用汽油彈已屬針對他人的嚴重暴力。
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 65th day at the High Court on Monday (the 5th). The prosecution completed its closing submissions, saying the actions of the Ng Chi-hung team had continually escalated, eventually developing into the “12.8 Plan”. Regarding the two defendants alleged to belong to Wu’s team, the prosecution said Lai Chun-pong must have known that the plan involved bombs. It said he had burgled a university laboratory and assisted in making bombs. The other defendant, Hui Cham-wing, had scouted the area before test-firing guns and had previously taken part in military training.
As for the female defendant charged with conspiracy to crowd-fund terrorist acts, the prosecution said the offence did not necessarily have to be related to the “12.8 Plan”. It said “Dragon Slaying Brigade” had promoted the five demands and slogans including “Kill the dogs together” to the public, and that this “was not simply going out to march”. The use of petrol bombs, it said, already constituted serious violence directed at other people.
2 Aug 2024法庭線#3875
First terrorism case | Prosecution: Conspirators need no clear division of roles, only a common purpose to attack police with guns and bombs in public places
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周五(2 日)在高等法院踏入第 64 天審訊。控方第四日結案陳詞,指本案串謀由吳智鴻團隊開始,「屠龍小隊」後來加入,此後兩方「成咗一個組合」,計劃亦演變成「12.8 計劃」。
控方指,吳團隊在「屠龍」加入前,曾談及製作炸彈、試槍等,顯示已串謀襲擊警察。控方重申,串謀者各有角色、毋須有明確分工,只要他們有共同目的在公眾地方,以槍和炸彈攻擊警方,「咁佢嘅參與已經夠。」
In the first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial at the High Court entered its 64th day on Friday (the 2nd). On the fourth day of the prosecution’s closing submissions, the prosecution said the conspiracy began with the Ng Chi-hung team, and that the “Dragon Slaying Brigade squad” joined later. The two sides thereafter “became one combination”, and the plan evolved into the “12.8 plan”.
The prosecution said Ng’s team had discussed making bombs and test-firing guns before the “Dragon Slaying Brigade” joined, showing that they had already conspired to attack police officers. The prosecution reiterated that conspirators each had their own roles and did not need a clear division of labour; as long as they shared the common purpose of attacking police with guns and bombs in public places, “then their participation was already sufficient.”
2 Aug 2024法庭線#3876
Hong Kong Alliance Information Disclosure Case: Court of Final Appeal Grants Leave for Final Appeal; Judgment Reveals Chow Hang-tung Described Court’s “Creative Interpretation” of Offence
已被剔除公司註冊的支聯會,前副主席鄒幸彤與兩名前常委鄧岳君、徐漢光,被裁定拒交資料罪成。3 人本周三( 7 月 31 日)獲得終審法院批出終極上訴許可,定於 2025 年 1 月 8 日進行聆訊。
終院周五(2 日)頒下判詞,除了重申就 4 項議題批出上訴許可,亦完整列出上訴方理據,當中提到鄒幸彤指出,本案是《國安法》實施細則首案,當她按照字面真誠解讀法例行事,沒料到法庭對條例具「創意解讀」(creative interpretation),並判處接近最高判罰的刑期,對她構成實質及嚴重不公。
The Hong Kong Alliance, which has been struck off the Companies Register, was convicted of failing to provide information, along with its former vice-chair Chow Hang-tung and two former standing committee members Tang Ngok Kwan and Hon Kwong Tsui. The three were granted leave for a final appeal by the Court of Final Appeal on Wednesday (July 31), with the hearing scheduled for January 8, 2025.
In a judgment handed down by the Court of Final Appeal on Friday (the 2nd), the court not only reaffirmed that leave to appeal had been granted on four issues, but also set out the appellants’ grounds in full. It stated that Chow Hang-tung had said this was the first case under the implementation rules of the National Security Law. She had acted in good faith based on a literal reading of the law and had not expected the court to adopt a “creative interpretation” of the provision, resulting in a sentence close to the maximum penalty. She said this constituted substantive and serious injustice to her.
2 Aug 2024法庭線#3877
San Tin Technopole | Environmental Protection Department conditionally approves EIA report; Tse Sai-kit seeks judicial review, alleging breach of EIA Ordinance
2024 年 5 月,環保署署長有條件批准新田/落馬洲發展樞紐環評報告,守護大嶼聯盟召集人謝世傑以個人身分,周四(1 日)入稟高等法院提司法覆核,指違反《環評條例》,又指政府擴充發展範圍無再諮詢,涉程序不公,要求推翻環保署長的決定。
環保署周一晚發稿指,將詳細研究申請書內容,並按照法定程序處理相關司法覆核申請,現階段不宜作出進一步評論。
In May 2024, the Director of Environmental Protection conditionally approved the environmental impact assessment report for the San Tin/Lok Ma Chau Development Node. Tse Sai-kit, convener of the Alliance for a Beautiful Environment, filed an application for judicial review at the High Court in a personal capacity on Thursday (1), alleging that the decision breached the Environmental Impact Assessment Ordinance. Tse Sai-kit also alleged that the Government had expanded the development area without further consultation, making the process procedurally unfair, and sought to overturn the Director of Environmental Protection’s decision.
The Environmental Protection Department said in a statement on Monday evening that it would study the contents of the application in detail and handle the judicial review application in accordance with statutory procedures. It said it was not appropriate to make further comment at this stage.
1 Aug 2024法庭線#3869
First Terrorism Case | Prosecution Says Dragon Slaying Brigade Defendant Asked “Do We Need to Lie Low?” and Must Have Known Plan Involved Attacking Police with Guns and Bombs
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周四(8 月 1 日)在高等法院踏入第 63 天審訊。控方繼續結案陳詞,指「屠龍小隊」有共識,不會親自用槍及炸彈,在計劃中負責「引戰」,藉破壞引誘警員到場。而 4 名被指為「屠龍」成員的被告,分別曾參與試槍、飯局和開會,商討「12.8 計劃」。
針對個別被告,控方指張俊富有份商討炸彈擺放位置;張銘裕則與同謀者吳智鴻有聯繫,曾轉發測試炸彈引爆器的影片至「屠龍」群組。
另一被告嚴文謙事前問「8 號之後我哋使唔使避一避?」,控方指反映他必然知悉計劃將用槍和炸彈攻擊警方,「用時代背景去睇,個串謀根本係呼之欲出。」至於被告李家田稱僅在旁觀察,控方指隊員對他關心密切,「得到嘅對待,係咪一個乜都唔做嘅隊員嘅態度?」
In the first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial at the High Court entered its 63rd day on Thursday (August 1), with the prosecution continuing its closing submissions. The prosecution said the “Dragon Slaying Brigade unit” had agreed that its members would not personally use guns and bombs, but would be responsible for “provoking conflict” in the plan by causing destruction to lure police officers to the scene. Four defendants identified as members of “Dragon Slaying Brigade” had separately taken part in test-firing guns, a meal gathering and meetings to discuss the “12.8 plan”.
Regarding individual defendants, the prosecution said CHEUNG Chun-fu had taken part in discussing where to place the bombs. Cheung Ming-yu had been in contact with co-conspirator Ng Chi-hung and had forwarded a video testing a bomb detonator to the “Dragon Slaying Brigade” group.
Another defendant, Yim Man-Him, had asked beforehand, “After the 8th, do we need to lie low?” The prosecution said this showed he must have known that the plan involved attacking police with guns and bombs, adding, “Viewed in the context of the times, the conspiracy was plainly apparent.” As for defendant Lee Ka Tin, Christian, who said he had merely observed from the sidelines, the prosecution said the team members had shown him close concern: “Is the treatment he received the attitude towards a team member who did nothing?”
1 Aug 2024法庭線#3873
August 31 Prince Edward Station case|5 men convicted of assaulting police and obstructing police; magistrate says imprisonment inevitable, defence cites nearly 5 years since incident and seeks reduced sentences
2019 年 8 月 31 日,旺角及太子港鐵站內發生衝突,防暴警進站以警棍等制服和拘捕多人。16 人事隔逾 3 年 8 個月被起訴襲警等罪,其中一宗涉 11 人案件,5 男不認罪受審,周四(8 月 1 日)在九龍城裁判法院被裁定罪成,還押至 8 月 15 日判刑,以待索取背景報告。
辯方求情時提及,本案至今近 5 年,對被告人生規劃有影響,望酌情減刑。辯方另提及有被告學歷不高但努力工作,積極參加調酒比賽,指他一時衝動犯案;有被告為家中的經濟支柱,且需要供養年邁父母,並指因本案喪失晉升機會。
裁判官陳志輝聽畢求情稱,「法庭可以講,一定係監禁㗎啦,純粹長短」,並著控方呈交本案的時序表。
On August 31, 2019, clashes occurred inside Mong Kok and Prince Edward MTR stations. Riot police entered the stations and subdued and arrested a number of people using batons and other means. Sixteen people were charged with assaulting police and other offences more than three years and eight months later. In one case involving 11 people, five men pleaded not guilty and stood trial. They were convicted at Kowloon City Magistrates’ Courts on Thursday (August 1) and remanded until August 15 for sentencing pending the preparation of background reports.
In mitigation, the defence said that nearly five years had passed since the case began, affecting the defendants’ life planning, and asked the court to exercise discretion in reducing their sentences. The defence also said that one defendant had limited educational qualifications but worked hard and actively participated in bartending competitions, and that he had committed the offence on impulse. Another defendant was the family’s financial pillar and needed to support his elderly parents; the defence said he had lost promotion opportunities because of the case.
After hearing the mitigation submissions, Magistrate Brian Chi Fai Chan said, “The court can say that imprisonment is definitely the sentence; it is purely a matter of length,” and directed the prosecution to submit a timeline of the case.
31 Jul 2024法庭線#3862
Four books including Szeto Wah memoir rejected; Chow Hang-tung seeks judicial review, saying decision unconstitutional
正就支聯會案還押的前支聯會副主席鄒幸彤,指其母親今年初嘗試送入記協出版的《人民不會忘記:八九民運實錄》、作者陳慧所著小說《弟弟》、已故民主黨元老司徒華回憶錄《大江東去》及佔中發起人朱耀明回憶錄《敲鐘者言》,惟 4 本書遭懲教署以「對社會事件存在偏頗描述」、引起在囚者「萌生對抗管治嘅意識」等理由扣起。
鄒幸彤向懲教署提出上訴亦遭駁回。她周二(30 日)入稟高等法院提出司法覆核,挑戰懲教署的決定不合憲、不合理,侵害她受《基本法》保障的表達自由,令她蒙受與外界資訊「完全隔絕」的風險,要求法庭推翻署方決定,批准她在收押所收取該 4 本書。
入稟狀強調,相關書籍僅描述當代政治事件、歷史等,在香港亦非「禁書」,即使有部分內容挑戰政治秩序,「在一個民主社會,應給予機會表達,以和平方式挑戰現行政治秩序的政治理念」。
Chow Hang-tung, the former vice-chairwoman of the Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China who is currently remanded in custody over the Alliance case, said her mother tried earlier this year to send her four books published by the Hong Kong Journalists Association, including *People Will Not Forget: A Record of the 1989 Democracy Movement*, the novel *Younger Brother* by Chan Wai, the memoir *The Great River Flows East* by the late Democratic Party veteran Szeto Wah, and the memoir *Words of a Bell Ringer* by Occupy Central initiator Chu Yiu-ming. The Correctional Services Department withheld all four books on grounds including that they contained “biased descriptions of social events” and could cause prisoners to “develop an awareness of opposing governance.”
Chow’s appeal to the Correctional Services Department was also rejected. On Tuesday (the 30th), she filed for judicial review in the High Court, challenging the department’s decision as unconstitutional and unreasonable, and as infringing her freedom of expression protected under the Basic Law. She said the decision placed her at risk of being “completely cut off” from information outside prison, and asked the court to overturn it and allow her to receive the four books at the remand centre.
The application said the books merely described contemporary political events, history and other matters, and were not “banned books” in Hong Kong. Even if some of their content challenged the political order, it said that “in a democratic society, political ideas that challenge the existing political order in a peaceful manner should be given the opportunity to be expressed.”
31 Jul 2024法庭線#3863
Happy Valley Police Station Petrol Bomb Case: Four Men Jailed for 41 to 63 Months for Arson; Mother and Son Jailed for Six Months over Evidence Destruction
4 男於 2020 年涉向跑馬地警署投擲 3 枚汽油彈,波及附近停泊的私家車,其中一人的胞弟及母親涉協助銷毀證據。一男認縱火罪,另 5 人被裁定縱火、妨礙司法公正罪成。法官王詩麗周三(31 日)在區域法院判 4 名縱火被告監禁 41 至 63 個月,另兩人涉串謀銷毀證據,判囚 6 個月。
法官批評 4 名縱火被告行為興風作浪,唯恐天下不亂,目無法紀,公然挑戰權威,亦不顧當值警員會否受傷。若其行為令油站起火,火勢隨時蔓延,一發不可收拾,可見他們漠視生命財產,藐視法律。至於銷毀證據的兩母子,法官指他們一心為協助及保護家人犯案,並非早有預謀,其行為沒有重大影響提控,或影響證據份量。
Four men allegedly threw three petrol bombs at Happy Valley Police Station in 2020, affecting nearby parked private cars. The younger brother and mother of one of the men were allegedly involved in helping to destroy evidence. One man pleaded guilty to arson, while the other five were convicted of arson or perverting the course of justice. On Wednesday (the 31st), District Court judge Wan Sze-lei sentenced the four arson defendants to between 41 and 63 months in prison. The other two, a mother and son who were involved in conspiring to destroy evidence, were sentenced to six months’ imprisonment.
The judge criticised the four arson defendants for stirring up trouble, seeking chaos, disregarding the law, openly challenging authority and failing to consider whether on-duty police officers might be injured. Had their actions caused a petrol station to catch fire, the blaze could have spread at any time and become uncontrollable. This showed that they had disregarded lives and property and held the law in contempt. Regarding the mother and son who destroyed evidence, the judge said they acted solely to assist and protect family members who had committed offences, and had not planned it in advance. Their actions had no substantial impact on the prosecution or might have affected the weight of the evidence.
31 Jul 2024法庭線#3864
Terrorism first case | Prosecution closes: After “hiking” to test-fire a gun, “Dragon Slaying Brigade” member knew of and joined conspiracy to kill police
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周三(31 日)在高等法院踏入第 62 天審訊。控方續作結案陳詞,指涉及「屠龍小隊」的被告,最遲於 2019 年 11 月到西貢「行山」試槍後,知悉及加入串謀殺警計劃。
控方指,試槍後有「屠龍」被告拿取手槍,而按照原定計劃,「屠龍」會使用槍械;但「屠龍」隊長黃振強與同謀者吳智鴻見面後,黃向成員稱有新計劃,「唔使行眼鏡 plan 」。控方指由此可見,當時「殺警計劃」已成形。
控方另引述「屠龍」TG 通訊,指當中曾出現「20KG」字眼,除沒參與會議的一成員外,其他人未曾問及有何意思,反映「屠龍」已與吳智鴻一方達成協議,將使用炸彈和槍械。
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 62nd day at the High Court on Wednesday (31st), with the prosecution continuing its closing submissions. It said the defendants involved in the “Dragon Slaying Brigade squad” knew of and joined a conspiracy to kill police officers no later than November 2019, after going “hiking” in Sai Kung to test-fire guns.
The prosecution said that after the test-firing, a “Dragon Slaying Brigade” defendant took a handgun, and under the original plan, “Dragon Slaying Brigade” would use firearms. However, after the “Dragon Slaying Brigade” captain Victor Chun Keung Wong met co-conspirator Ng Chi-hung, Victor Chun Keung Wong told members that there was a new plan and that there was “no need to carry out the Glasses plan”. The prosecution said this showed that the “plan to kill police” had already taken shape at that time.
The prosecution also cited “Dragon Slaying Brigade” Telegram messages, saying that the term “20KG” had appeared. Apart from one member who did not attend the meeting, no one else had asked what it meant, indicating that “Dragon Slaying Brigade” had reached an agreement with Ng Chi-hung’s side to use bombs and firearms.
31 Jul 2024法庭線#3865
Hong Kong Alliance refusal-to-provide-information case|Chow Hang-tung and two others granted leave for final appeal on four issues; hearing on 8 January next year
已被剔除公司註冊的支聯會,前副主席鄒幸彤與兩名前常委鄧岳君、徐漢光,被裁定拒交資料罪成。3 人向終審法院申請終極上訴許可,獲得批准,定於 2025 年 1 月 8 日進行聆訊。
署理首席法官李義、常任法官霍兆剛、林文瀚就申請方 3 項法律爭議批出許可,包括《國安法》實施細則下的未提交資料罪,控罪元素是否包括必須證明被告事實上屬外國或台灣代理人,以及警方發出的「遞交資料通知書」,可否要求被告提交《國安法》前的資料等。
另外,終院亦批准申請方以部分證物因「公眾利益豁免權」被遮蓋,有機會造成重大審訊不公為由,批准上訴許可。聆訊時,代表申請方的資深大律師彭耀鴻舉起原審文件證物的副本,向法官展示大量內容遭塗黑遮蓋的情況。
The Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China, which has been struck off the Companies Register, was found guilty of failing to provide information. Its former vice-chairwoman Chow Hang-tung and two former standing committee members Tang Ngok Kwan and Hon Kwong Tsui applied to the Court of Final Appeal for leave to appeal, which was granted. The hearing is scheduled for 8 January 2025.
Acting Chief Justice Li Yee and Permanent Judges Fok Chiu-kong and Lam Man-hon granted leave on three legal issues raised by the applicants. These included whether, under the implementation rules of the National Security Law, the elements of the offence of failing to submit information require proof that the defendants were in fact agents of a foreign country or Taiwan, and whether a police-issued notice to submit information could require defendants to provide information from before the National Security Law came into effect.
The Court of Final Appeal also granted leave on the ground that the redaction of some exhibits under public interest immunity might have caused substantial unfairness at trial. At the hearing, senior counsel representing the applicants Robert Yiu Hung Pang held up copies of the exhibits from the original trial to show the judges that large portions of the contents had been blacked out.
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.