15 Jul 2024法庭線#3814
First terrorism case | Prosecution cites messages saying “There’s a fight to be had in positional warfare” and “I’ll personally teach archery”; Lee Ka Tin, Christian says they were “just idle chatter”
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周一(15 日)在高等法院踏入第 53 天審訊。被告李家田第六日作供,控方引述「屠龍」群組內訊息提問,包括中大衝突期間,李提及「陣地戰有得打喇,我最多親自教咁多位射箭好冇」、「大殺傷力武器佢哋收起晒唔撚畀用」,又形容中大示威者如「童子軍」。李於庭上分別以「搵話題」、「齋講吹水」、評論情況等原因解釋。
控方另質疑,李聲稱不會使用暴力,但其理念與「屠龍」相近?李指,當時「屠龍」示威是為了反對警方使用暴力,及爭取「五大訴求」,但否認這些屬他個人訴求,亦對其他人有否使用暴力沒有評價。
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven people have pleaded not guilty, and the trial entered its 53rd day at the High Court on Monday (15th). On the sixth day of testimony by defendant Lee Ka Tin, Christian, the prosecution cited messages in the “Dragon Slaying Brigade” group and questioned him about them. During the clashes at Chinese University, Lee had written: “There’s a fight to be had in positional warfare. At most, I can personally teach all of you archery, okay?” and “They’ve put away all the highly destructive weapons and fucking won’t let them be used.” He also described the CUHK protesters as “Boy Scouts”. In court, Lee explained the messages by saying he was looking for topics, just making idle chatter, or commenting on the situation.
The prosecution also questioned whether Lee claimed he would not use violence while holding beliefs similar to those of “Dragon Slaying Brigade”. Lee said the “Dragon Slaying Brigade” protests at the time were aimed at opposing police violence and pursuing the “five demands”, but denied that these were his personal demands and declined to comment on whether other people had used violence.
13 Jul 2024集誌社#3812
Previously embroiled in national security case, Elizabeth Yin Ngor Tang has passport returned and travels to Japan; police: action will be taken according to law
去年被指涉違《港區國安法》被捕的鄧燕娥,最近終獲發還護照,六月去了日本旅行「充電」,今年內亦準備到外地參加女兒婚禮。面對生活,鄧燕娥總輕鬆面對,她說問心無愧。警方指,採取任何行動,會按實際情況,依法處理。
Elizabeth Yin Ngor Tang, who was arrested last year for allegedly violating the Hong Kong National Security Law, has recently had her passport returned and travelled to Japan in June to “recharge”. She is also preparing to travel abroad this year to attend her daughter’s wedding. Facing life, Elizabeth Yin Ngor Tang remains relaxed and says she has a clear conscience. Police said any action would be handled according to the law based on the actual circumstances.
12 Jul 2024法庭線#3810
Anti-terrorism Ordinance first case|Earlier claimed police assault, Lee Ka Tin, Christian says he fears retaliation: “But even if I’m scared, I still have to speak out and let people know what the police do”
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周五(12 日)在高等法院踏入第 52 天審訊。被告李家田第五日作供,就他早前稱被捕時遭警員施襲、擔心母親遭同等對待,李周五供稱「直到而家我都好驚」,擔心日後獲釋會遭警方報復。
控方質疑,李母親在其被捕後隨即離港、並於 2022 年過身,還有甚麼擔心。法官亦關注,李感害怕為何仍在庭上講述遭警員施襲。李略加重語氣稱:「我驚,但我都仲要講…因為我要畀所有人知道,警察係會點做嘢。同埋我相信,法庭係會畀到一個公義我。」
李另解釋其 TG 帳戶名稱,指喜愛動畫《V 高達》,認同其反戰概念;亦認同「Beatles」成員「John Lennon 」追求和平的理念,故改名為「I am reinforce jr. 」、「John Lemon 」。
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, all seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial at the High Court entered its 52nd day on Friday (the 12th). Defendant Lee Ka Tin, Christian gave evidence for a fifth day. Li, who earlier claimed that police officers assaulted him during his arrest and said he feared his mother would be treated likewise, testified on Friday: “I’m still very scared even now,” expressing concern that he might face police retaliation after being released.
The prosecution questioned what there was left to fear, given that Li’s mother left Hong Kong immediately after his arrest and died in 2022. The judge also asked why Li continued to describe the alleged assault in court if he was afraid. Li, placing slightly more emphasis on his words, said: “I’m scared, but I still have to speak out … because I want everyone to know what the police will do. And I believe the court will give me justice.”
Li also explained the name of his Telegram account, saying that he liked the animation 《V Gundam》 and identified with its anti-war concept. He also agreed with the Beatles member John Lennon’s pursuit of peace, and therefore changed his name to “I am reinforce jr.” and “John Lemon”.
12 Jul 2024獨媒#3811
Female Student Acquitted of 8.31 Wan Chai Riot Charge: Department of Justice Wins Appeal; Court of Appeal Says Verdict Was Irrational
2019年8月31日灣仔的衝突中,一名法律系女學生獲裁定暴動及管有攻擊性武器罪不成立,並獲批出訟費,律政司就無罪裁決上訴。上訴庭在上月的聆訊中就暴動罪批准律政司上訴,撤銷無罪裁決及訟費命令,並發還原審法官重新考慮裁決;至於管有攻擊性武器罪,上訴庭則駁回上訴,維持無罪裁決和訟費命令。上訴庭今(12日)頒布書面判決理由,指女生管有行山杖和長雨傘與和平示威不符,其背囊中也被搜出護膝、護臂、頭盔、護目鏡等物品,上述環境證供的「疊加效應」是壓倒性的,惟原審法官沒有正確考慮和充份分析環境證供,因此就暴動罪的無罪裁決是「有悖常理」。
A law student was acquitted of riot and possession of an offensive weapon charges arising from the clashes in Wan Chai on 31 August 2019, and was awarded costs. The Department of Justice appealed against the acquittal. At a hearing last month, the Court of Appeal granted the Department’s appeal in respect of the riot charge, quashed the acquittal and costs order, and remitted the matter to the trial judge for reconsideration of the verdict. As for the possession of an offensive weapon charge, the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and upheld the acquittal and costs order. In written reasons for judgment handed down today (12th), the Court of Appeal said that the student’s possession of a hiking pole and a long umbrella was inconsistent with peaceful demonstrations. Knee pads, arm guards, a helmet, goggles and other items were also found in her backpack. The cumulative effect of the circumstantial evidence was overwhelming, but the trial judge had failed to properly consider and sufficiently analyse the circumstantial evidence; therefore, the acquittal on the riot charge was “irrational”.
11 Jul 2024法庭線#3805
47-person case: Yu Wai-ming may face disciplinary hearing in addition to sentence; Au Nok-hin writes mitigation letter for Sham Tsz-kit
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,參選九西、超區及衞服 9 人,當中 6 人昨完成求情陳詞,餘下的王百羽、岑子杰和余慧明於周四(11 日)亦完成(陳詞重點見內文表)。案件押後至 7 月 30 日再續,屆時將處理新西 8 人的求情,料需時 3 天。
余慧明一方陳詞時,提到她任職深切治療部護士,參政因 2019 年爆發新冠疫情,因當權者無視醫護關注,遂參選立會爭話語權;而在本案的刑期後,余或要接受護士管理局的紀律聆訊。庭上亦讀出余親撰的求情信(見另稿),不過期間法官打斷指是政治論述。
岑子杰一方提及,控方證人區諾軒為他撰寫求情信,指岑是在九龍西協調會議上,主要反對無差別否決預算案主張的人,對該區沒就否決達成共識「起了決定性作用」。
In the case involving 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power”, nine people who stood in Kowloon West, the Super District Council and Health Services constituencies were involved. Six completed their mitigation submissions yesterday, while the remaining three—Wong Pak-yu, Sham Tsz-kit and Yu Wai-ming—also completed theirs on Thursday (11 July). The case was adjourned to 30 July, when mitigation submissions for eight people from New Territories West will be heard; the process is expected to take three days. The key points of the submissions are set out in the table in the article.
During Yu Wai-ming’s submissions, it was said that she worked as an intensive care unit nurse and entered politics after the COVID-19 outbreak in 2019, because those in power ignored healthcare workers’ concerns, leading her to stand for election to the Legislative Council to have a voice. After serving her sentence in this case, Yu may also have to face a disciplinary hearing by the Nursing Council. The court also read out a mitigation letter written by Yu herself (see separate report), but the judge interrupted, saying it constituted political rhetoric.
Sham Tsz-kit’s side said that prosecution witness Au Nok-hin had written him a mitigation letter. It said Sham was the person who, at Kowloon West coordination meetings, mainly opposed proposals to indiscriminately veto the budget, and had played a “decisive role” in the constituency not reaching a consensus on the veto.
11 Jul 2024法庭線#3808
47-Democrats Case Mitigation|Yu Wai-ming: Still Believe There Was Nothing Wrong with Changing the Order Through Voting; Perhaps My Only Mistake Was Loving Hong Kong Too Much
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,參與九西初選及功能界別的被告周四(11 日)續求情,余慧明的代表大狀石書銘,庭上讀出她親自撰寫的求情信。
余在信中表示,由於政府未能及時採取措施預防新冠疫情爆發,因此希望進入政治體制、參選立法會,增加對政府議價的能力,「但被指控為顛覆國家政權,這在其他民主國家中聞所未聞」。
她指,法庭的裁決「指五大訴求是空中樓閣,但其中的一項訴求,是實現《基本法》所承諾的雙普選」,反問若政府認為落實「23 條」是它的憲制責任,「那麼實現雙普選難道就不是?」
她續指,至今仍認為,通過在立法會投票以改變現有秩序「並沒有甚麼不對」,又稱「也許我犯下的唯一錯誤,就是我太愛香港」。法官陳慶偉此時打斷石書銘,指這並非求情信,而是政治論述。
In the case involving 47 democrats charged with conspiracy to subvert state power, defendants who took part in the Kowloon West primary election and functional constituencies continued mitigation submissions on Thursday (11th). Counsel for Yu Wai-ming, Randy Shu Ming Shek, read out a mitigation letter she had written herself in court.
In the letter, Yu said that, because the government had failed to take timely measures to prevent the outbreak of COVID-19, she had hoped to enter the political system and stand for election to the Legislative Council in order to increase her bargaining power with the government. “But I was accused of subverting state power. This is unheard of in other democratic countries.”
She said the court’s judgment “described the five demands as a castle in the air, but one of the demands was to achieve the universal suffrage promised by the Basic Law”. She asked: if the government believed that implementing “Article 23” was its constitutional responsibility, “then is achieving universal suffrage not [a constitutional responsibility]?”
She continued to say that she still believed there was “nothing wrong” with changing the existing order through voting in the Legislative Council, adding, “Perhaps the only mistake I made was that I loved Hong Kong too much.” Judge Andrew Hing Wai Chan interrupted Randy Shu Ming Shek at that point, saying that this was not a mitigation letter but a political argument.
11 Jul 2024法庭線#3809
First anti-terrorism case | Lee Ka Tin, Christian says he did not take part in destruction, only observed to make a documentary; prosecution asks, “What were you watching? Where did the story come from?”
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周四(11 日)在高等法院踏入第 51 天審訊。被告李家田第四日作供,接受控方盤問。李供稱,當時「屠龍」不會以汽油彈傷害他人,他亦沒有參與破壞及使用汽油彈等行為,只是在現場「睇示威者情況」,搜集資料製作紀錄片。控方質疑,「睇咩」、「個故事從天嚟?」李指,「透過畫面睇佢哋行為動作,就攞到個故事」。
至於李稱曾遭警以「水刑」及拳打腳踢方式襲擊。控方質疑,當時李坐著,涉事警員較「大肚腩」,要「烏低身」、「屈住肚腩」施襲?李確認。李又指,事後沒有向值日官投訴,因擔心對他及母親不利。
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 51st day at the High Court on Thursday (the 11th). Defendant Lee Ka Tin, Christian was giving evidence for the fourth day and was cross-examined by the prosecution. Li said Dragon Slaying Brigade would not use petrol bombs to injure others at the time, and that he had not taken part in acts including destruction or the use of petrol bombs. He said he was at the scene only to “observe the protesters’ situation” and collect information for a documentary. The prosecution asked, “What were you watching?” and “Where did the story come from?” Li said, “By watching their behaviour and movements through the footage, I obtained the story.”
Li also said he had been assaulted by police using “water torture” and by punching and kicking. The prosecution questioned whether, as Li was seated, the officer involved—who had a relatively “large belly”—would have had to “bend down” and “bend around his belly” to assault him. Li confirmed this. Li said he did not complain to the duty officer afterwards because he feared this would be detrimental to him and his mother.
10 Jul 2024獨媒#3798
Quick Bui jailed for 40 months for publishing seditious words; High Court appeal dismissed, leave granted to appeal to Court of Final Appeal
人民力量前副主席譚得志「快必」,被指2020年1至7月期間在不同街站叫喊「光時」、「黑警死全家」等口號,被裁定「發表煽動文字」等11項罪成,共判囚3年4個月。譚就定罪及刑期提出上訴,今年3月遭高等法院駁回。譚再申請上訴至終審法院,今(10日)獲上訴庭批出許可。法官同意申請方提出的議題屬重要的法律觀點,亦接受本案之外還有其他同類案件,故判決結果不僅影響本案。
Tam Tak-chi, also known as “Quick Bui” and former vice-chairman of People Power, was convicted of 11 charges, including publishing seditious words, over slogans such as “Liberate Hong Kong, revolution of our times” and “black cops, may your whole families die”, which he was accused of shouting at various street stations between January and July 2020. He was sentenced to three years and four months in prison. Tam appealed against his convictions and sentence, but the appeal was dismissed by the High Court in March this year. He then applied for leave to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal and was granted leave by the appellate court today (the 10th). The judges agreed that the issues raised by the applicant involved important points of law and accepted that there were other similar cases, meaning the outcome would affect more than just this case.
10 Jul 2024法庭線#3799
11.18 Yau Ma Tei | Man convicted of rioting jailed 52 months; conviction appeal dismissed — judge: those who did not want to take part would not have been there
2019 年 11 月 18 日,警方圍封理工大學,大批民眾於油尖旺區聚集,213 人涉在油麻地「圍魏救趙」被控暴動。其中 11 名被告不認罪受審,1 人被裁定罪名不成立,10 人罪成判囚 50 月至 52 月。
當中兩人不服定罪提出上訴,上訴庭周三(10 日)開庭審理,1 人撤回上訴申請,另 1 人繼續上訴。上訴庭聽罷申請方陳詞,請律政司毋須陳詞,即時駁回上訴,將在 6 個月內頒判詞解釋理由。
申請方爭議警方未能肯定在何處截停申請人,加上他並非身穿黑衣、身上無裝備,質疑法庭何以肯定他參與暴動;法官則指案發前理大騷亂已持續一周,當晚油麻地暴動開始 1 小時,警方才開始包圍示威者拘捕,質疑申請人「咁你去做乜?正常唔想參與唔會走埋去」。
On 18 November 2019, police cordoned off the Polytechnic University, while large numbers of people gathered in the Yau Tsim Mong District. A total of 213 people were charged with rioting in connection with the “besieging Wei to rescue Zhao” action in Yau Ma Tei. Eleven defendants pleaded not guilty and stood trial; one was acquitted and 10 were convicted and sentenced to between 50 and 52 months in prison.
Two of them challenged their convictions on appeal. The Court of Appeal heard the applications on Wednesday (10th). One withdrew his application, while the other continued with his appeal. After hearing submissions from the applicant, the court said the Department of Justice did not need to make submissions and immediately dismissed the appeal. It will deliver its reasons in a judgment within six months.
The applicant disputed that the police had been unable to establish where they had stopped him. He was not wearing black and had no equipment on him, and questioned how the court could be satisfied that he had taken part in the riot. The judge said the unrest at the Polytechnic University had continued for a week before the incident, and that on the night in question the police only began surrounding and arresting protesters one hour after the rioting in Yau Ma Tei had started. The judge asked: “Then what were you doing there? A normal person who did not want to take part would not have gone there.”
10 Jul 2024法庭線#3800
Joe Chen Bites Off Chiu Ka-yin’s Left Ear in “Street Justice”; Law Firm Clerk Acquitted of Rioting and Wounding with Intent
中年無業漢陳真涉於 2019 年 11 月 3 日,於太古城中心外,咬甩前東區區議員趙家賢左耳及持刀傷人,其後遭「私了」。6 名男子被控暴動、有意圖而傷人等罪,其中 61 歲律師樓文員,周三(10 日)在區域法院被裁定暴動及意圖傷人罪名不成立,當庭釋放;36 歲無業男則兩罪罪成,還押至本月 20 日求情。
法官高偉雄表示,陳真沒預警下襲擊途人及咬掉趙家賢耳朵,行為兇殘。考慮報稱文員被告,當時腳踢陳真背部,非身體要害,當一名被陳真拉扯的男子掙脫後,被告亦無再踢陳真,認為他當時是使用了合理武力,不能排除他真誠為保護他人。
針對暴動罪,控方指被告在商場內高呼「斬人」,是為了召集更多人襲擊陳真。法官則指,事發後曾向警員提供資料,又在陳真襲擊途人案任控方證人,行為與控方指控完全不相符。至於另一被告,法官認為他毫無疑問在暴動發生後逗留現場,曾用伸縮雨傘襲擊陳真頭部,除了構成有意圖而傷人罪,亦因此直接參與了暴動。
A middle-aged unemployed man, Joe Chen, allegedly bit off former Eastern District councillor Chiu Ka-yin’s left ear and wounded people with a knife outside Cityplaza on November 3, 2019, and was subsequently subjected to “street justice”. Six men were charged with rioting, wounding with intent and other offences. A 61-year-old law firm clerk was found not guilty of rioting and wounding with intent at the District Court on Wednesday (10th) and was released in court. A 36-year-old unemployed man was convicted of both charges and remanded until the 20th of this month for mitigation.
Judge Ko Wai-yung said Joe Chen had attacked passers-by without warning and bitten off Chiu Ka-yin’s ear, describing the conduct as brutal. In considering the clerk’s case, the judge noted that he had kicked Joe Chen in the back rather than a vital part of the body, and that after a man pulled by Joe Chen had broken free, the defendant did not kick Joe Chen again. The judge considered that he had used reasonable force at the time and could not rule out that he had acted genuinely to protect another person.
On the rioting charge, the prosecution said the defendant had shouted “slash people” inside the shopping centre in order to rally more people to attack Joe Chen. The judge noted that the defendant had provided information to police after the incident and had served as a prosecution witness in the case concerning Joe Chen’s attack on passers-by, conduct that was completely inconsistent with the prosecution’s allegations. As for the other defendant, the judge found beyond doubt that he had remained at the scene after the riot broke out and had attacked Joe Chen on the head with a telescopic umbrella. This constituted wounding with intent and also meant that he had directly participated in the riot.
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.