5 Jul 2024法庭線#3783
PolyU escape case: 19 convicted of perverting the course of justice, riot and other offences; eight with longest sentences appeal
2019 年 11 月,理工大學內大批示威者被警方包圍,19 人被指協助他人逃出,包括駕車接載示威者離開等,被控意圖妨礙司法公正、暴動等罪。當中 5 人承認暴動罪,餘下 14 人經審訊後被裁定罪成;他們被判囚 20 至 70 個月,以及教導所。
司法機構資料顯示,刑期最重即判囚 60 至 70 個月的 8 名被告,上周五(28 日)不服定罪及判刑提出上訴。案件暫待排期處理。
In November 2019, large numbers of protesters inside the Hong Kong Polytechnic University were surrounded by police. Nineteen people were accused of helping others escape, including by driving protesters away, and were charged with attempting to pervert the course of justice, riot and other offences. Five pleaded guilty to riot, while the remaining 14 were convicted after trial. They were sentenced to between 20 and 70 months’ imprisonment, as well as training centre orders.
Judiciary records show that the eight defendants who received the longest sentences—between 60 and 70 months’ imprisonment—appealed against their convictions and sentences last Friday (the 28th). The cases are awaiting listing.
5 Jul 2024法庭線#3784
First Terrorism Case | Prosecution Completes 47 Days of Evidence; Defence Expected to Decide Next Week Whether Defendants Will Testify
《反恐條例》首案,不認罪 7 人周五(5 日)在高等法院踏入第 47 天審訊,控方傳畢證人及播放閉路電視片段後,表示已完成舉證。案件押後至下周一(8 日)續審,料屆時辯方將決定各名被告會否作供。
In the first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, the seven defendants who pleaded not guilty entered the 47th day of the trial at the High Court on Friday (the 5th). After calling all its witnesses and playing CCTV footage, the prosecution said it had completed presenting its evidence. The case was adjourned until next Monday (the 8th), when the defence is expected to decide whether each defendant will testify.
5 Jul 2024法庭線#3785
Lai Chee-ying alleges National Security Commission acted beyond powers over Tim Owen visa; Court of Appeal refuses certificate for final appeal
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」,2022 年 10 月獲高等法院批准,聘用英國御用大狀 Tim Owen 來港抗辯。律政司上訴失敗後,全國人大常委會就《國安法》釋法,指法院在國安案批准聘任海外律師前,應先取得特首發出的證明書。
黎智英 2023 年入稟司法覆核,挑戰國安委建議入境處拒絕向 Tim Owen 批出簽證,指國安委越權,被高院駁回許可申請,黎再申請上訴許可亦被駁回。黎早前申請上訴至終審法院,上訴庭周五(5 日)頒判詞拒絕申請﹐重申國安委決定不受司法覆核挑戰。
根據法例,擬上訴人可向上訴庭申請上訴至終院的證明書,而假若上訴庭拒發,仍可直接向終院上訴委員會,一併申請證明書及上訴許可。
Next Digital founder Jimmy Lai Chee-ying was charged with “conspiracy to collude with foreign forces”. In October 2022, the High Court approved his hiring of British King’s Counsel Tim Owen to come to Hong Kong to defend him. After the Department of Justice lost its appeal, the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress interpreted the National Security Law, stating that before a court approved the hiring of an overseas lawyer in a national security case, it should first obtain a certificate issued by the Chief Executive.
In 2023, Lai filed for judicial review, challenging the National Security Commission’s recommendation that the Immigration Department refuse to grant Tim Owen a visa, and alleging that the commission had acted beyond its powers. The High Court rejected his application for leave, and Lai’s subsequent application for leave to appeal was also rejected. Lai earlier applied to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal. On Friday (the 5th), the Court of Appeal issued its judgment refusing the application and reaffirming that decisions of the National Security Commission are not open to challenge by judicial review.
Under the law, a proposed appellant may apply to the Court of Appeal for a certificate to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal. If the Court of Appeal refuses to issue one, the applicant may still apply directly to the Court of Final Appeal’s Appeal Committee for both a certificate and leave to appeal.
5 Jul 2024法庭線#3786
Chow Hang-tung’s Recusal Application in Hong Kong Alliance Subversion Case Rejected; 3 Judges ‘Fully Confident’ Fair Trial Possible
支聯會及其前正副主席李卓人、何俊仁、鄒幸彤被控「煽動顛覆國家政權」一案,鄒幸彤指審理支聯會拒交資料上訴案的法官黎婉姬,曾閱讀不向辯方披露的控方「公眾利益豁免權」(PII)文件,申請「換官」。高院原訟庭周五(5 日)駁回鄒的申請。
判詞反駁鄒幸彤,指法官曾參與涉及某方的案件、作出不利於某方的裁決,「並不足以成為尋求(法官)迴避的充分理由」;又指兩案控罪不同,「看不到前案的證據,事實裁斷或定罪與本案有什麼關聯」,而黎在該案的裁斷,亦不涉及鄒的可信性或可靠性。
判詞又指,若然黎官參與本案審訊,自然會提醒自己在審案時謹慎,將 PII 材料拋諸腦後,不被影響。3 官最後指,「都對於申請人及同案其他被告人能夠獲得公平審訊有十足的信心」。
Chow Hang-tung, former vice-chairwoman of the Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China, applied for the recusal of Judge Anna Yuen Kee Lai, who had read the prosecution’s “public interest immunity” (PII) documents that were not disclosed to the defence while hearing the Alliance’s appeal against its refusal to provide information. The High Court’s Court of First Instance rejected Chow’s application on Friday (the 5th). The case concerns charges of “incitement to subversion of state power” against the Alliance and its former chairmen and vice-chairmen Lee Cheuk-yan, Albert Ho and Chow Hang-tung.
4 Jul 2024法庭線#3775
First anti-terrorism case | Telegram expert says it is impossible to verify whether a user read messages if they did not participate in group chat
《反恐條例》首案,不認罪 7 人周四(4 日)在高等法院踏入第 46 天審訊。庭上早前提及,警方以程式 Cellebrite 破解涉案手機資料。Cellebrite 專家在盤問下確認,未必能復原全部訊息,亦可能會有不明符號。
控方之後再傳召 Telegram 專家,講解 Telegram 運作。專家確認,假如群組成員沒有參與對話,沒有資料可證實,該名用戶是否曾閱覽相關訊息,亦表示沒有逐一檢查涉案 Telegram 群組的設定。
The trial of seven people who have pleaded not guilty in the first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance entered its 46th day at the High Court on Thursday (the 4th). The court had earlier heard that police used Cellebrite software to crack data from the phones involved in the case. A Cellebrite expert confirmed under cross-examination that not all messages could necessarily be recovered and that unidentified symbols might also appear.
The prosecution then recalled a Telegram expert to explain how Telegram operates. The expert confirmed that if a group member did not participate in a conversation, there was no data that could establish whether the user had read the relevant messages. The expert also said they had not checked the settings of the Telegram groups involved one by one.
4 Jul 2024法庭線#3776
47-Defendant Case | Six East Kowloon defendants to make mitigation submissions on Friday; Joshua Wong proposed countering CCP, Wu Chi-wai said to have committed to the plot
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,第三批罪成被告、初選時參選九東區的 6 人,將於周五(5 日)處理求情,料需時 2 天。《法庭線》翻查裁決理據判詞、庭上證供及承認案情,整理他們被指控的罪責與角色。
據案情,6 名被告提交初選表格時,均附上「共同綱領」,提及「會積極運用基本法賦予立法會的權力,包括否決財政預算案」;而只有胡志偉沒有簽署〈墨落無悔〉,但案情指他受訪時指民主黨會受共識約束,是「對謀劃作出承諾」。
黃之鋒曾發文章,提及連結選舉戰線和國際戰線反制中共;譚文豪曾公開稱若特首不回應「五大訴求」,公民黨將「否決晒所有法案、所有嘅撥款」。譚得志曾稱兩次否決預算案,「癱瘓個政府」。李嘉達則曾將抗爭帶入立法會。
至於經審訊被裁定罪成的施德來,曾公開承諾兩度否決預算案,法官指他脫離民協過往的價值。
In the case involving 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power, six defendants in the third group to be convicted, who ran in the East Kowloon primary election, will make mitigation submissions on Friday (the 5th). The process is expected to take two days. The Witness reviewed the judgments setting out the reasons for the verdicts, evidence given in court and the agreed facts, and compiled the alleged culpability and roles of the defendants.
According to the case facts, all six defendants attached a “joint manifesto” when submitting their primary-election forms. It referred to “actively using the powers conferred on the Legislative Council by the Basic Law, including vetoing the budget”. Wu Chi-wai was the only one who did not sign “No Regrets After Casting the Ballot”, but the case facts said that in an interview he stated that the Democratic Party would be bound by consensus, which constituted “a commitment to the plot”.
Joshua Wong had published an article referring to linking the electoral front with the international front to counter the Chinese Communist Party. Jeremy Tam had publicly said that if the Chief Executive did not respond to the “five demands”, the Civic Party would “veto all bills and all funding”. Tam Tak-chi had said that vetoing the budget twice would “paralyse the government”. Lee Ka-wai had brought the protests into the Legislative Council.
Sze Tak-loy, who was convicted after trial, had publicly pledged to veto the budget twice. The judge said that he had departed from the Association for Democracy and People's Livelihood's past values.
4 Jul 2024法庭線#3777
PolyU clashes | ENT doctor appeals after bid to call Chris Tang and two other officers to testify in tear-gas compensation case is rejected
2019 年 11 月,理大衝突期間,在理大附近開設診所的耳鼻喉科醫生,稱遭警方誤射催淚彈入診所,致起火受損,於 2021 年入稟向警方索償逾 672 萬港元。原告醫生早前要求傳召警務處長蕭澤頤及另兩名警員作供,遭高院聆案官拒絕,他不服決定提出上訴。
案件周四(4 日)在高院處理,法官歐陽桂如聽罷雙方陳詞,押後 7 月底前頒下裁決。原告質疑警方是發射催淚彈的一方,不可能經過 3 年調查,總結不知道是那名警員發射催淚彈,要求蕭澤頤身為警隊之首,親自解釋調查結果;警務處一方則重申警方「根本不可能找出」發射涉案催淚彈的人,亦可能是其他人趁亂撿起催淚彈投擲,認為蕭的證供與案無關。
In November 2019, during the clashes at the Polytechnic University, an ear, nose and throat doctor who operated a clinic near the university said police mistakenly fired a tear-gas round into the clinic, causing a fire and damage. The doctor filed a claim against the police in 2021 seeking more than HK$6.72 million in compensation. The plaintiff had earlier sought to call Commissioner of Police Chris Tang and two other police officers to testify, but the application was rejected by a High Court master. He has appealed the decision.
The case was heard in the High Court on Thursday (4th). After hearing submissions from both sides, Judge Ouyang Kwei-yu adjourned the decision until before the end of July. The plaintiff questioned how the police, whom he said were the party that fired the tear-gas round, could conclude after three years of investigation that they did not know which officer had fired it. He asked Tang, as head of the police force, to personally explain the investigation’s findings. The Police Commissioner’s side reiterated that it was “simply impossible to find out” who had fired the tear-gas round in question, and that someone else might have picked it up and thrown it amid the disorder. It argued that Tang’s evidence was irrelevant to the case.
3 Jul 2024法庭線#3768
47-case mitigation · Hong Kong Island | Dozens queue to attend; Leung Wong-wai’s friend: When I want to give up, I think of him
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪,初選時參選港島區的 6 人,袁嘉蔚、梁晃維、徐子見、鄭達鴻及楊雪盈完成求情陳詞,周三(3 日)將由彭卓棋一方陳詞。早上旁聽人龍較昨日減少,有人用排隊時間寫信。
有梁晃維的朋友稱,雖然得知他已完成求情,但仍想「搏一搏」在法庭內望見他,更一度哽咽稱,「佢講嘅嘢真係好打動到我,我覺得佢喺咁困難嘅環境,都會想鼓勵香港人」。
他又稱,「可能呢幾年身邊有好多人一路抽離,變到好唔理時事」,而自己想放棄的時候,「我會諗起佢…然後我唔可以耷落去啦,同埋真係好 proud of 佢」。
Of the 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power, five of the six people who stood in the Hong Kong Island constituency in the primary—Yuen Ka-wai, Leung Wong-wai, Tsui Tsz-kin, Cheng Tat-hung and Yeung Suet-ying—have completed their mitigation submissions. On Wednesday (the 3rd), the Michael Cheuk Kei Pang side will make submissions. The queue to attend the hearing was shorter this morning than yesterday, and some people used their time in the queue to write letters.
A friend of Leung Wong-wai said that although he knew Leung had completed his mitigation submissions, he still wanted to “try his luck” and catch a glimpse of him in court. He became choked up at one point and said, “What he says really moves me. I think that even in such a difficult environment, he still wants to encourage Hong Kong people.”
He also said, “Maybe over the past few years, many people around us have gradually withdrawn and become very unconcerned about current affairs.” When he himself wanted to give up, he said, “I think of him… and then I can’t let myself sink, and I’m really so proud of him.”
3 Jul 2024法庭線#3769
11.12 CUHK No. 2 Bridge | One acquitted of rioting; Department of Justice appeal allowed and case remitted to District Court for reconsideration
2019 年 11 月 12 日,中大「二號橋」有示威者響應「黎明行動」聚集,防暴警員發射逾千枚催淚彈驅散。當場被捕的其中兩人經審訊後,獲裁定暴動罪名不成立。律政司以「案件呈述」方式提出上訴。上訴庭周三(3 日)處理其中一人的上訴案。
上訴庭聽罷陳詞,裁定律政司上訴得直,撤銷無罪裁決,將在 6 個月內頒判決理由。案件發還原審法官李慶年重新考慮裁決,將在 9 月 5 日於區域法院提訊,期間被告須繼續遵守一系列保釋條件,包括不得離港;另一名無罪被告據悉已離港,律政司沒繼續提上訴。
律政司一方質疑,原審法官過分顧及無證據顯示被告何時到達暴動核心和逗留多久,亦沒有考慮其他壓倒性證據,裁決有違常理;答辯方則強調,原審已考慮所有證據,而被告身處現場,存在參與暴動以外的其他可能性。
On 12 November 2019, protesters gathered at CUHK’s “No. 2 Bridge” in response to the “Dawn Operation”. Riot police fired more than 1,000 rounds of tear gas to disperse them. Two of those arrested at the scene were later acquitted of rioting after trial. The Department of Justice appealed by way of case stated. The Court of Appeal heard one of the appeals on Wednesday (the 3rd).
After hearing submissions, the Court of Appeal allowed the Department of Justice’s appeal, set aside the acquittal and said it would hand down its reasons for judgment within six months. The case was remitted to the trial judge, Clement Lee, for reconsideration of the verdict. The case will be mentioned at the District Court on 5 September. In the meantime, the defendant must continue to comply with a series of bail conditions, including a ban on leaving Hong Kong. The other acquitted defendant is understood to have left Hong Kong, and the Department of Justice did not continue with its appeal.
The Department of Justice argued that the trial judge had placed undue weight on the absence of evidence showing when the defendant arrived at the core of the riot and how long he remained there, while failing to consider other overwhelming evidence, making the verdict contrary to common sense. The defence stressed that the trial judge had considered all the evidence and that, although the defendant was at the scene, there were other possibilities apart from his participation in the riot.
3 Jul 2024法庭線#3770
First anti-terrorism case | Police used Cellebrite to extract phone data; officer agrees some deleted messages can be recovered but software is not foolproof
《反恐條例》首案,不認罪 7 人周三(3 日)在高等法院踏入第 45 天審訊。庭上早前提及,警方以程式 Cellebrite 擷取涉案手提電話的資料。控方傳召負責應用 Cellebrite 的警長以專家身分作供。警長指,Cellebrite 可以復原部分被刪除的訊息,但同意程式「唔係萬能」,並不一定能復原全部資料。
The seven defendants who have pleaded not guilty in the first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance entered the 45th day of their trial at the High Court on Wednesday (the 3rd). It was previously mentioned in court that police had used Cellebrite software to extract data from the mobile phones involved in the case. The prosecution called the police sergeant responsible for using Cellebrite to testify as an expert witness. The sergeant said Cellebrite could recover some deleted messages, but agreed that the software was “not foolproof” and could not necessarily recover all the data.
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.