18 May 2024法庭線#3548
Jimmy Lai case | Andy Li’s 15 days of testimony: How was SWHK formed, and how did it shift from newspaper ads to international lobbying?
黎智英國安案於 2023 年底開審,控方先後傳召 3 名《蘋果》前高層「從犯證人」作供,內容主要針對《蘋果》的運作及黎智英的角色。審訊隨後進入另一範疇,控方傳召「12 港人」之一的李宇軒作供,李主要講述於 2019 年下半年進行的 3 次眾籌登報計劃,及「SWHK (重光團隊)」的成立及運作,以至其個人國際遊說行動,對《國安法》的想法等。
李宇軒於 2024 年 3 月 13 日首日出庭,於 4 月 11 日完成 15 日作供。《法庭線》整合連日內容,讓讀者更易理解供詞重點。
The trial of Jimmy Lai under the National Security Law began at the end of 2023. The prosecution subsequently called three former Apple Daily executives as “accomplice witnesses”, whose evidence mainly concerned the operation of Apple Daily and Lai’s role. The trial then moved to another area, with the prosecution calling Andy Li, one of the “Hong Kong 12”, to testify. Li mainly described three crowdfunding campaigns to place newspaper advertisements in the second half of 2019, as well as the formation and operation of SWHK (Stand with Hong Kong), his personal international lobbying efforts and his views on the National Security Law.
Li first appeared in court on 13 March 2024 and completed 15 days of testimony on 11 April. The Court Line compiled the evidence given over those days to make the key points of his testimony easier for readers to understand.
17 May 2024集誌社#3544
British Spy Case Follow-up | HK$100m Cross-Border Debt Collection Triggers Suspected Espionage Case; Creditor Is Mainland Investment Company
英國政府日前(13日)以《國家安全法》起訴三名男子,其中一人為香港駐倫敦經貿辦行政經理袁松彪。根據案情透露,「協助海外情報機構」罪涉及三人被指監控遭懸紅通緝的社運人士羅冠聰、蒙兆達、劉祖廸等人;「境外干預罪」則指被告涉強行闖入一英國住址,背後原來涉及一宗逾億港元的「跨境追債」,行動導致三人被捕。
懷疑諜案由一宗追債行動所「引爆」,債主是誰?《集誌社》綜合控方案情、香港和內地公司註冊資料,追查到追債背後人物,疑為 Tina Zou 鄒田甜(又名田甜、田靜),持香港身分證,聲稱為澳洲跨國投資集團 TWT Property Group 創辦人,其母王玉珠在內地持有多間投資公司。記者到訪其在港註冊公司地址查詢,辦公室座落灣仔乙級商廈、無人應門,另一慈善基金會註冊地址則為秘書公司。
The British Government charged three men under the National Security Act on the 13th, including Yuen Chung-piu, an administrative manager at the Hong Kong Economic and Trade Office in London. According to details of the case, the charge of assisting an overseas intelligence agency concerns allegations that the three men monitored wanted social activists including Nathan Law, Mok Siu-tat and Lau Cho-dik. The foreign interference offence alleges that the defendants forcibly broke into a UK address; the incident was reportedly linked to a cross-border debt collection involving more than HK$100 million and led to the arrest of the three men.
The suspected espionage case was triggered by a debt collection operation. Who was the creditor? The Collective reviewed the prosecution's case and company registration records in Hong Kong and the mainland, tracing the person believed to be behind the debt collection to Tina Zou (also known as Tin-tin and Tin Ching). She holds a Hong Kong identity card and claims to be the founder of the Australian multinational investment group TWT Property Group. Her mother, Wong Yuk-chu, owns several investment companies in the mainland. When reporters visited the registered address of her Hong Kong company to make enquiries, the office was located in a Grade B commercial building in Wan Chai and no one answered the door. The registered address of another charitable foundation was a company secretarial firm.
17 May 2024法庭線#3546
First terrorism case|Victor Chun Keung Wong said in videotaped interview that accomplice had over $1 million in funds, so he played along by claiming he wanted guns to “placate and deceive him first”
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周五(17 日)在高等法院踏入第 18 天審訊。認罪被告、自稱「屠龍小隊」隊長黃振強續接受盤問。
庭上播放黃被捕後的錄影會面,黃在片中稱毋須律師陪同,並向警方提供手機密碼,又提到知悉同謀者吳智鴻有過百萬資金,所以投其所好訛稱想用槍、「氹住、呃住佢先」,以獲取資金,強調計劃一直由吳主導,自己不涉製作炸彈等。
辯方另引述投訴警察課報告,指黃投訴遭警武力對待和威嚇時,有警員向他稱「你信唔信 8.31 有死人 … 掟埋你 … 可以送你返大陸」。黃聞言輕聲啜泣,同意曾遭武力對待,並指其中一名涉事警員,有份為他錄取錄影會面。
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 18th day at the High Court on Friday (17th), with the defendant who pleaded guilty, Victor Chun Keung Wong, continuing to be cross-examined. The court played a videotaped interview conducted after Wong’s arrest. Wong said in the recording that he did not need a lawyer present and provided police with his phone password. He also said he knew that his accomplice, Ng Chi-hung, had funds exceeding one million, so he falsely claimed that he wanted to use guns in order to play to Ng’s interests and “placate and deceive him first” to obtain funding. He stressed that the plan had always been led by Ng, and that he was not involved in making bombs or other such activities. The defence also cited a Complaints Against Police Office report, saying that when Wong complained of being subjected to police violence and threats, an officer told him: “Do you believe that there will be deaths on 8.31 … throw you in too … we can send you back to the mainland.” Wong softly sobbed after hearing this, agreed that he had been subjected to violence, and said that one of the officers involved had also taken his videotaped interview.
17 May 2024法庭線#3547
Day 78 of Jimmy Lai trial|National security officer recounts taking Chan Tsz-wah’s statement; order bans disclosure of witness protection details
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英與《蘋果日報》3 間相關公司,被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」等罪,案件周五(17 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)展開第 78 日審訊,國安警在辯方盤問下,講述到羈押中心替陳梓華錄取口供的過程。
另外,法庭頒下命令,指任何人包括媒體及公眾,不得以任何方式披露證人保護計劃下的證人身分、身處位置,或危害此人安全的資料,以免損害司法公義;違反命令可被控藐視法庭。案件押後至下周一(20 日)續審。
Next Digital founder Jimmy Lai and three companies related to Apple Daily have been charged with “conspiracy to collude with a foreign country or with external elements” and other offences. The case entered its 78th day of trial on Friday (17th) at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, temporarily exercising the jurisdiction of the High Court. Under questioning by the defence, a national security police officer described the process of taking Chan Tsz-wah’s statement at a detention centre.
The court also issued an order prohibiting anyone, including the media and the public, from disclosing by any means the identity or whereabouts of a witness under the witness protection programme, or any information that could endanger the person’s safety, to avoid compromising the administration of justice. Breach of the order may constitute contempt of court. The case was adjourned until next Monday (20th).
16 May 2024法庭線#3538
Lai Chee-ying case: Day 77 hearing | Police officer spoke with Cheung Kim-hung in prison for over three hours, denies lobbying him to become prosecution witness
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英與《蘋果日報》3 間相關公司,被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」等罪,案件周四(16 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)展開第 77 日審訊。辯方早前申請重召「從犯證人」前壹傳媒行政總裁張劍虹,就 Slack 平台提問,法官周四拒絕辯方申請,指不論這個遲來的申請動機是甚麼,重召張劍虹明顯不符司法公正。
另外,控方應辯方要求傳召國安警黎國勇,黎供稱 2021 年 11 月 11 日往荔枝角收押所,向張劍虹派發有關其申請保釋的判詞,兩人傾談獄中日常逾 3 小時,張提議對方翌日再探訪。張翌日表示任控方證人,黎供稱對此感驚訝,並否認首次探訪與對方聊天,是想遊說張成為控方證人。案件周五(17 日)續審。
Media tycoon and Apple Daily founder Lai Chee-ying and three companies associated with Apple Daily are charged with offences including conspiracy to collude with a foreign power. The case entered its 77th day of hearing at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, sitting as the High Court, on Thursday (16th). The defence had earlier applied to recall former Next Digital chief executive Cheung Kim-hung, an “accomplice witness”, to question him about the Slack platform. The judge rejected the application on Thursday, saying that regardless of the motivation behind the late application, recalling Cheung was plainly contrary to the interests of justice.
At the defence’s request, the prosecution also called national security police officer Lai Kwok-wing. Lai testified that he went to Lai Chi Kok Reception Centre on 11 November 2021 to give Cheung a judgment concerning his bail application. The two spoke for more than three hours about daily life in prison, and Cheung suggested that Lai visit again the next day. Cheung said the following day that he would act as a prosecution witness. Lai testified that he was surprised and denied that his conversation with Cheung during the first visit was intended to persuade him to become a prosecution witness. The hearing will continue on Friday (17th).
16 May 2024法庭線#3540
First terrorism case|Defence says Victor Chun Keung Wong fabricated claim that co-defendant knew of plan to kill police officers to facilitate guilty plea; Wong denies it
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周四(16 日)在高等法院踏入第 17 天審訊。認罪被告、自稱「屠龍小隊」隊長黃振強續接受盤問。辯方續關注黃的承認案情,與其庭上供詞有出入。黃確認部分承認案情與事實不符,稱「呢啲係控方攞出嚟,佢話幾多就幾多㗎啦。」
黃另指,曾致電涉協助籌款的被告劉佩凝,講述將有人使用槍和炸彈,著努力協助眾籌。辯方質疑,黃事隔近 4 年才透露通話內容,形容是「無從對證」,質疑黃為配合認罪,「作出嚟去誣衊」被告;黃不同意。
黃另被問及,除了「殺警計劃」外,有否作出其他行為涉恐怖主義,黃稱「用汽油彈我都覺得算係嘅」,指曾蓄意將汽油彈擲向警員身上。
In the first case under the anti-terrorism law, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 17th day at the High Court on Thursday (16th). Victor Chun Keung Wong, the defendant who pleaded guilty and described himself as captain of the “Dragon Slaying Brigade squad”, continued to be cross-examined. The defence continued to focus on discrepancies between Wong’s admitted facts and his testimony in court. Wong confirmed that parts of the admitted facts did not accord with the facts, saying: “The prosecution brought these out; whatever it said, that was it.”
Wong also said he had called defendant Lau Pui-ying, who was involved in helping with fundraising, and told the defendant that someone would use guns and bombs, urging the defendant to make efforts to assist the crowdfunding. The defence questioned why Wong had waited nearly four years to disclose the content of the call, describing it as “impossible to corroborate”, and accused Wong of making it up to smear the defendant in order to facilitate his guilty plea. Wong disagreed.
Wong was also asked whether, apart from the “plan to kill police officers”, he had committed any other acts involving terrorism. Wong said, “I also think using petrol bombs counts,” and said he had deliberately thrown petrol bombs at police officers.
15 May 2024獨媒#3537
‘Glory to Hong Kong’ injunction: YouTube blocks access in Hong Kong to 32 videos
上周(5月8日),上訴庭裁定律政司就要求頒令禁止傳播反修例歌曲《願榮光歸香港》上訴得直,禁止市民具意圖煽動分裂國家和侮辱國歌而散播歌曲。YouTube 向《路透社》表示,將禁止從香港地區瀏覽禁制令提及的32條涉不同版本《願榮光歸香港》的影片。
列於律政司入稟狀、32條在 YouTube 的不同版本《願榮光》,部分的影片名稱列明「香港國歌」,亦包括韓文、英文、日文、德文、荷蘭文、手語、純樂器、中樂合奏版本。禁制例子包括《願榮光》的二次創作,例如《願榮光歸香港X肥媽有話兒》大戲版;以及何韻詩在中環一次集會演唱的版本。
Last week (May 8), the Court of Appeal allowed the Department of Justice’s appeal against the refusal to grant an injunction prohibiting the dissemination of the anti-extradition bill song “Glory to Hong Kong”. The injunction prohibits people from disseminating the song with the intention of inciting secession or insulting the national anthem. YouTube told Reuters that it would block access from Hong Kong to the 32 videos involving different versions of “Glory to Hong Kong” mentioned in the injunction.
14 May 2024獨媒#3527
UK charges Hong Kong Economic and Trade Office manager over alleged direction of surveillance of pro-democracy figures in UK; China expresses strong dissatisfaction, calls charges fabricated
中國駐英大使館及外交部駐港公署批評昨日發聲明,反指英方「羅織罪名」,對港府進行「無中生有的污衊抹黑」,對此表示強烈不滿和堅決反對。公署又稱英方濫用國安名義,「無視基本人權保障,任意逮捕羈押」,並批評是「政治操弄、干預香港事務」,以及「包庇勾連反中亂港分子」。公署要求英方停止「打著國安旗號炮製案件」,並警告「立即懸崖勒馬、糾正錯誤」,停止干預香港事務和中國內政,否則會遭中方「堅決有力反擊」。
港府聲明無用「戰狼」語調
港府在接近晚上11時發出的聲明,沒有採用如公署的強烈字眼,表示已要求英國政府提供聲稱事件的相關資料詳情,正等待回覆。又指嚴正要求英方公正處理事件,切實保障聲稱涉事的經貿辦行政經理的合法權益,並必須確保經貿辦的正常工作不受影響。全篇聲明未有表達任何不滿或反對。
The Chinese Embassy in the UK and the Office of the Commissioner of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Hong Kong criticised the UK in statements issued yesterday, accusing it of “fabricating charges” and making “baseless smears and vilification” of the Hong Kong Government. They expressed strong dissatisfaction and firm opposition. The commissioner’s office also said the UK had abused the name of national security, “disregarded basic human rights protections and arbitrarily arrested and detained” people, and criticised the move as “political manipulation and interference in Hong Kong affairs”, as well as “sheltering and colluding with anti-China and anti-Hong Kong elements”. It demanded that the UK stop “fabricating cases under the banner of national security” and warned it to “immediately pull back from the brink and correct its mistakes”, cease interfering in Hong Kong affairs and China’s internal affairs, or face “firm and forceful countermeasures” from China.
Hong Kong Government statement did not use a “wolf warrior” tone
In a statement issued at around 11pm, the Hong Kong Government did not use the strong wording adopted by the commissioner’s office. It said it had asked the British Government to provide details of the information relating to the alleged incident and was awaiting a response. It also said it had made a serious demand that the UK handle the incident fairly, effectively safeguard the lawful rights and interests of the administrative manager of the Hong Kong Economic and Trade Office allegedly involved, and ensure that the office’s normal work was not affected. The statement expressed no dissatisfaction or opposition.
14 May 2024獨媒#3528
Former Master’s Classmate of Defendant, John Lee: “My Impression of This Person Is This Photograph”
英國倫敦警察廳昨日(13日)表示,已落案起訴三名男子違反當地的《國家安全法》,指他們涉嫌協助香港情報機構,以及觸犯外國干涉罪,其中63歲男子袁松彪為退休警司,現為香港駐倫敦經貿辦行政經理。政府昨延至晚上10時許才發出聲明,稱已要求英國政府提供事件的相關資料詳情。行政長官李家超今日被記者問及時稱,指中國駐英國大使館已發出聲明,並表示強烈反對及提出嚴正交涉,特區政府亦已要求駐港英國總領事館提供事件詳情。
The Metropolitan Police in London said yesterday (13th) that it had charged three men under the UK’s National Security Act, alleging that they had assisted a Hong Kong intelligence agency and committed a foreign interference offence. The 63-year-old Yuen Chung-piu, a retired superintendent, is currently an administrative manager at the Hong Kong Economic and Trade Office in London. The Hong Kong Government issued a statement only after 10pm yesterday, saying it had asked the UK Government to provide details of the incident. Asked by reporters today, Chief Executive John Lee said the Chinese Embassy in the UK had issued a statement expressing strong opposition and making solemn representations, and that the HKSAR Government had also asked the British Consulate-General in Hong Kong to provide details of the incident.
14 May 2024集誌社#3529
UK Spy Case | HKETO Account Reportedly Paid Nearly HK$1 Million, Including Surveillance of Nathan Law and Others
英國政府昨(13日)以《國家安全法》「協助海外情報機構」及「境外干預罪」起訴三名男子,其中一人為香港駐倫敦經貿辦行政經理袁松彪。據了解,案情涉及經貿辦直接付款約 9.55 萬鎊( 約 93 萬港元),用途包括監控遭香港國安警懸紅百萬元通緝的社運人士羅冠聰、蒙兆達、劉祖廸等人。
特首李家超今( 14日)早出席行政會議前,被問及經貿辦有否向其中兩被捕人過數等問題時,他表示,任何對特區政府無理指控,都不能接受。被問及袁松彪是否他同學?他回應說:「我對呢一個人嘅印象,就係呢一張照片」。
The British government yesterday (13th) charged three men under the National Security Act with assisting a foreign intelligence service and the offence of foreign interference. One of them is Yuen Chung-piu, an administrative manager at the Hong Kong Economic and Trade Office in London. It is understood that the case involved direct payments of about £95,500 (approximately HK$930,000) by the office, including for the surveillance of activists such as Nathan Law, Mung Siu-tat and Lau Cho-dik, who are wanted by Hong Kong national security police with a HK$1 million bounty on each of them.
Before attending an Executive Council meeting this morning (14th), Chief Executive John Lee Ka-chiu was asked whether the Economic and Trade Office had transferred money to two of those arrested. He said that any unfounded accusations against the HKSAR Government were unacceptable. Asked whether Yuen Chung-piu had been his classmate, he replied: “My impression of this person is just this photo.”
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.