11 Jul 2025法庭線#7029
Doctor Wong Ping-leung admits issuing over 6,000 vaccine exemption certificates; jailed for 9 months as judge condemns greed
2022 年新冠疫情期間,醫生王秉亮被指濫發 6,000 張「免針紙」,被控 6 項「不誠實地意圖欺騙而取用電腦」罪。他承認其中 4 罪,其餘 2 罪存檔法庭。王周五(11 日)在區域法院被判囚 9 個月,為首宗濫用免針紙定罪判刑案件。
法官郭偉健批評,被告「財迷心竅、利慾薰心」,在 4 個半月內謀取逾 460 萬元診金,吸引想逃避接種疫苗人士應診「同流合污」。法官又指,被告濫用職權,對要求免針紙求診者來者不拒,破壞政府對私家醫生的信任,減慢社會復原,嚴重影響公共健康。
法官指,被告涉及 4 項控罪,每罪量刑起點為 6 個月,部分刑期同期執行,被告認罪減刑三分一,再考慮被告被捕後參與義工活動,額外減刑一個月,判處被告監禁 9 個月。
During the COVID-19 pandemic in 2022, doctor Wong Ping-leung was accused of issuing more than 6,000 vaccine exemption certificates and was charged with six counts of accessing a computer with a dishonest intent to deceive. He pleaded guilty to four charges, while the remaining two were filed on the court record. On Friday (11th), he was sentenced to nine months’ imprisonment in the District Court, in the first conviction and sentencing case involving the abuse of vaccine exemption certificates. Judge Kwok Wai-kin criticised the defendant as having been blinded by money and consumed by greed. The judge said Wong had sought to earn more than HK$4.6 million in consultation fees over four and a half months, attracting people seeking to evade vaccination to attend his clinic and going along with them. The judge said Wong had abused his authority, accepted without exception people seeking exemption certificates, undermined the government’s trust in private doctors, slowed the recovery of society and seriously affected public health. The judge said the defendant faced four charges, each with a starting point of six months’ imprisonment. Some of the sentences were to run concurrently. After a one-third reduction for his guilty pleas and a further one-month reduction for taking part in volunteer work after his arrest, he was sentenced to nine months’ imprisonment.
26 Jan 2024獨媒#2888
Youth admits spraying “People have the right not to be vaccinated” and other slogans, jailed for five months; judge says wording could incite undesirable elements and lead to violence
一名22歲男子涉前年於觀塘工廈及旺角大廈外牆,噴上「人類有權不打疫苗」、「斷頭台清算黑警」等字句,被國安處拘捕。他早前承認3項刑事毀壞罪,今(26日)在觀塘裁判法院被判囚5個月。署理主任裁判官劉綺雲指,涉案字句挑戰法律、挑戰作為重要執法機關的警方,以及挑戰政府為保障市民健康而實行的政策。劉官認為字句會激發不良份子並令其有機可乘,相當可能導致有人使用暴力,並嚴重危害公眾秩序及安全。
A 22-year-old man was arrested by the National Security Department after allegedly spray-painting the words “People have the right not to be vaccinated” and “Guillotine to settle accounts with black cops” on an industrial building in Kwun Tong and the exterior wall of a building in Mong Kok the year before last. He earlier admitted three counts of criminal damage and was sentenced to five months’ imprisonment at Kwun Tong Magistrates’ Courts today (26th). Acting Principal Magistrate Liu Kei-wan said the wording challenged the law, the police as an important law-enforcement agency, and government policies implemented to protect public health. Liu said the wording could incite undesirable elements and give them an opportunity to exploit the situation, and was quite likely to lead to people using violence, seriously endangering public order and safety.
28 Oct 2022明報#5635
Three arrested over suspected brokering of vaccine exemption certificates for HK$300 commission each
警方早前就有醫生懷疑濫發「免針紙」拘捕39人。警方昨再拘捕3名女子,涉嫌為其中一名被捕西醫戴港盛充當中介,透過WhatsApp介紹500多名客人,每張免針紙抽佣300元。
Police earlier arrested 39 people over a doctor’s suspected excessive issuing of vaccine exemption certificates. Yesterday, police arrested three more women who were suspected of acting as intermediaries for one of the arrested Western doctors, Tai Kong-sing, introducing more than 500 clients via WhatsApp and receiving a HK$300 commission for each certificate.
27 Oct 2022法庭線#5626
Kwok Cheuk-kin files another judicial review, saying government’s amendment abolishing vaccine exemption certificates has no appeal mechanism; seeks to overturn it
「長洲覆核王」郭卓堅上周司法覆核勝訴,高等法院裁定醫衞局長無權廢除免針紙。政府本周刊憲修例,醫衞局長有合理理由懷疑下可廢除免針紙。郭在周四(27 日)再入稟高院申請司法覆核,指政府修例後,受影響人士無上訴機制,要求法院推翻新例。
Kwok Cheuk-kin, known as the “Cheung Chau judicial review king”, won a judicial review last week after the High Court ruled that the Secretary for Health had no power to abolish vaccine exemption certificates. The government gazetted amendments this week allowing the Secretary for Health to abolish a vaccine exemption certificate where there are reasonable grounds for suspicion. Kwok filed another application for judicial review at the High Court on Thursday (27th), saying that those affected have no appeal mechanism after the government’s amendment, and asking the court to overturn the new law.
25 Oct 2022法庭線#5597
Government amendment empowering health secretary to invalidate vaccine exemption certificates takes effect tomorrow, says it is in Hong Kong’s “best interests”
政府早前宣布廢除7名被捕西醫所發出的逾兩萬張「免針紙」,被市民提出司法覆核挑戰成功,廢除的決定被推翻。不過特首會同行政會議今早通過修改第599L章,重新賦權予醫務衞生局局長,當有「合理理由懷疑」某註冊醫生發出免針紙前未有進行臨床評估,或以「公眾利益」為考量,可以宣告某註冊醫生發出免針紙無效。政府表明基於「急切性」,不會就司法覆核上訴,但會以「先訂立後審議」立法,條例明日生效,但立法會明日才有機會討論。
The government earlier announced the cancellation of more than 20,000 vaccine exemption certificates issued by seven arrested Western medicine doctors, but members of the public successfully challenged the decision in a judicial review, and the cancellation was overturned. However, the Chief Executive in Council approved amendments to Cap. 599L this morning, once again empowering the Secretary for Health to declare vaccine exemption certificates issued by a registered doctor invalid where there are “reasonable grounds to suspect” that the doctor did not conduct a clinical assessment before issuing them, or where this is considered to be in the “public interest”. The government said that, because of the “urgency”, it would not appeal the judicial review, but would enact the legislation first and have it considered later. The amendments will take effect tomorrow, although the Legislative Council will only have the opportunity to discuss them tomorrow.
25 Oct 2022法庭線#5600
Education Bureau abruptly changes full-day class requirements; 90% three-dose threshold for secondary schools deferred to February, 70% two-dose threshold for primary schools
教育局原本要求,11月起中學若要安排全日面授課堂,須有九成或以上學生已打三針。惟在實施前一星期,當局突然宣布暫緩有關要求,指考慮校方或需更多時間增加接種率,將實施日子改為明年2月起。另外由12月起,小學的兩針接種率如達七成或以上,亦可申請回復全日面授。
The Education Bureau had originally required that, from November, at least 90% of students at a secondary school must have received three doses before the school could arrange full-day in-person classes. However, one week before implementation, the authorities suddenly announced that the requirement would be deferred, saying schools might need more time to raise the vaccination rate. It will instead take effect from February next year. From December, primary schools with a two-dose vaccination rate of at least 70% may also apply to resume full-day in-person classes.
25 Oct 2022法庭線#5603
Advertising Worker Fined $2,000 After Admitting Use of Family Member’s Vaccination Card to Enter Restaurant
1 名 26 歲廣告職員涉以他人針卡進入食肆,被控一項「企圖誤導警務人員而提供虛假資料」罪,周二(25 日)在九龍城裁判法院認罪,裁判官考慮到案發於疫情不算最嚴重之時,判被告罰款 2000 元。
A 26-year-old advertising worker who allegedly used another person’s vaccination card to enter a restaurant pleaded guilty on Tuesday (25th) at Kowloon City Magistrates’ Courts to one count of providing false information with intent to mislead police officers. The magistrate fined the defendant $2,000, taking into account that the offence occurred when the pandemic was not at its most serious.
21 Oct 2022法庭線#5589
Kwok Cheuk-kin wins judicial review over vaccine exemption certificates; more than 20,000 remain valid
7 名私家醫生被指濫發「免針紙」被警方調查,「長洲覆核王」郭卓堅提司法覆核,挑戰政府不承認 7 人所發出、逾兩萬張「免針紙」的決定,被高院法官高浩文裁定勝訴,下令撤銷局長決定,政府一方須付訟費。
Seven private doctors were investigated by police over alleged improper issuance of “vaccine exemption certificates”. Kwok Cheuk-kin, known as the “Cheung Chau judicial review king”, brought a judicial review challenging the government’s decision not to recognise more than 20,000 certificates issued by the seven doctors. High Court Judge Godfrey Lam ruled in his favour, ordered the Secretary’s decision to be quashed, and ordered the government to pay the costs.
18 Oct 2022法庭線#2620
Judicial review over vaccine exemption certificates: Kwok Cheuk-kin wins appeal against legal-aid refusal
政府指 7 名私家醫生涉嫌濫發「免針紙」,原定他們所發出的逾兩萬張「免針紙」周三(12 日)起失效。「長洲覆核王」郭卓堅上周一獲高等法院批出司法覆核許可,挑戰政府的決定或屬違法。法援署其後指,郭卓堅沒有「法定地位」提覆核,拒批法援。郭卓堅不服提出上訴,案件周二(18 日)於高等法院進行閉門聆訊,裁定郭上訴得直。
The Government said seven private doctors were suspected of improperly issuing “vaccine exemption certificates”, and that the more than 20,000 certificates they had issued were originally scheduled to become invalid from Wednesday (12th). Kwok Cheuk-kin, known as the “Cheung Chau Judicial Review King”, was granted leave by the High Court last Monday to seek a judicial review challenging whether the Government’s decision was unlawful. The Legal Aid Department subsequently said Kwok did not have “legal standing” to bring the review and refused his legal-aid application. Kwok appealed against the decision. The case was heard in camera at the High Court on Tuesday (18th), which ruled in his favour.
18 Oct 2022法庭線#2622
Alleged Vaccine Exemption Certificate Case | Doctor Choi Suk Mui, Annie Charged with Conspiracy to Defraud Granted Bail, Barred from Contacting Prosecution Witnesses Including Three Clinic Nurses
主任裁判官蘇文隆應控方要求,押後本案至 12 月 13 日,作進一步調查,期間批准蔡以現金 10 萬元等條件保釋,不可干擾控方證人,包括診所 3 名護士。辯方透露,涉事診所仍有運作,蔡亦有上班。控辯雙方均確認,蔡已無權限登入醫健通發「免針紙」。
At the prosecution’s request, Chief Magistrate Don Man Lung So adjourned the case to 13 December for further investigation. Choi was granted bail on conditions including a cash sum of HK$100,000 and was barred from contacting prosecution witnesses, including three nurses from the clinic. The defence said the clinic involved remained in operation and that Choi was still reporting to work. Both sides confirmed that Choi no longer had access to eHealth to issue vaccine exemption certificates.
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.