11 Mar 2025法庭線#4622
At least 12 defendants in anti-extradition bill riot cases were social workers or trainees; four including Chan Hung-sau said they attended in the course of their duties, only one acquitted
社工陳虹秀被控 2019 年 8 月 31 日在灣仔暴動一案,陳經重審,周二(11 日)在區院被裁定罪成,即日還押。
《法庭線》統計,至少 12 名反修例暴動案的被告為社工,或正修讀社工系的準社工;其中陳虹秀等 4 人的辯解是憑藉社工身分緩和警方情緒、到場「執仔」、情緒支援,僅一人獲裁無罪,其上司作供確認會指派社工到場工作,要掛社工證、不可穿黑衫,與被告被捕時衣著符合。
其餘 3 人包括陳虹秀則被裁定罪成。翻查判詞,區院法官據穿黑衣、在場徘徊等行為,推論 3 人有意圖參與暴動,協助及鼓勵示威者作出破壞社會安寧行為,其中一人被指充當「哨兵」。
Social worker Chan Hung-sau was charged with rioting in Wan Chai on 31 August 2019. Following a retrial, she was found guilty at the District Court on Tuesday (11th) and remanded in custody the same day.
Courtline’s tally found that at least 12 defendants in anti-extradition bill riot cases were social workers or people studying social work to become social workers. Four of them, including Chan Hung-sau, argued that they had attended in their capacity as social workers to defuse police tensions, “pick up children” and provide emotional support. Only one was acquitted. The person’s supervisor testified that social workers would be assigned to work at the scene, were required to wear their social worker identity cards and could not wear black clothing, which was consistent with the defendant’s clothing when arrested.
The other three, including Chan Hung-sau, were found guilty. A review of the judgments showed that District Court judges inferred from conduct including wearing black clothing and loitering at the scene that the three intended to take part in the riot and assist and encourage protesters to commit acts that breached the peace. One of them was alleged to have acted as a “lookout”.
16 Dec 2020HKFP#1076
Hong Kong social worker cleared of obstructing police during 2019 demonstration
Social worker Hui Lai-ming is acquitted of deliberately obstructing police on 29 Sep 2019, with the magistrate ruling the police witness "unreliable".
Social worker Hui Lai-ming was acquitted of deliberately obstructing police on 29 September 2019, with the magistrate ruling that the police witness was “unreliable”.
10 Dec 2020立場新聞#1044
Social Workers’ General Union secretary-general Lai Ming (1968) Hui’s assault charge changed to obstructing police before trial; defence says video shows no assault and prosecution is stopping at nothing
去年 9 月 29 日「全球反極權大遊行」引發衝突,社工總工會總幹事許麗明,原本被指在當日金鐘太古廣場外襲擊警員 A ,案件今日(10日)在西九龍裁判法院開審。惟甫開庭,控方申請修改控罪,改控許阻差辦公。辯方直斥控方「無所不用其極」,並透露早前向控方提交影片,清楚顯示許無襲警,但控方選擇修改控罪而非撤控,批評其「檢控的心態同方法唔恰當」。裁判官聽取陳詞後,批准修改控罪。
Clashes broke out during the “Global Anti-Totalitarianism Rally” on 29 September last year. The secretary-general of the Social Workers’ General Union, Lai Ming (1968) Hui, was originally accused of assaulting Police Constable A outside Pacific Place in Admiralty that day. The case opened today (the 10th) at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts. However, at the start of the hearing, the prosecution applied to amend the charge to obstructing a police officer in the execution of duty. The defence said the prosecution was “stopping at nothing” and disclosed that it had earlier submitted video footage clearly showing that the defendant had not assaulted the officer. It criticised the prosecution for choosing to amend the charge rather than withdraw it, saying that its “prosecutorial mindset and method are inappropriate”. After hearing submissions, the magistrate approved the amendment.
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.