23 Sept 2025法庭線#7351
Challenge to Secondary School Hair Rules | School Board Granted Approval to Submit CUHK Professor’s Report on School Uniform and Grooming Norms
兩名中學畢業生入稟區院,指自己有性別不安及特殊學習需要,但校方完全沒處理,更因他們拒絕剪短頭髮,被要求在校內示眾或改上網課,令他們承受沉重精神壓力,要求法庭宣告校方違反性別和殘疾歧視條例、作賠償及道歉。
雙方各自申請呈交專家報告。區院首席法官高勁修周二(23 日)頒判詞,批准校方的申請,讓其呈交中大教授的專家報告,以證明香港在校服和儀容上有常規;學生一方則質疑專家的研究方法如何證明常規,而就算有,亦涉性別刻板印象。
官認為,校方的專家有專業資格提供證據,而其研究方法可在審訊中挑戰,故現階段批准加入報告。
Two secondary school graduates filed a claim in the District Court, saying they had gender dysphoria and special educational needs but that the schools had failed to address them. They said that, after they refused to cut their hair short, they were required either to be publicly singled out at school or to switch to online classes, causing them severe emotional distress. They asked the court to declare that the schools had breached the Sex Discrimination Ordinance and Disability Discrimination Ordinance, and sought compensation and an apology.
Both sides separately applied to submit expert reports. District Court Chief Judge Ko King-shiu handed down a judgment on Tuesday (23rd), approving the schools’ application to submit an expert report by a professor at the Chinese University of Hong Kong to demonstrate that there are conventions in Hong Kong regarding school uniforms and grooming. The students questioned how the expert’s research methods could establish such conventions, and argued that, even if they existed, they involved gender stereotypes.
The judge held that the schools’ expert was professionally qualified to give evidence and that the research methods could be challenged at trial. The judge therefore approved the inclusion of the report at this stage.
16 Nov 2023集誌社#8652
Hair-Length Ban|Two Former Students Sue Alma Maters, Say Rule Banning Boys from Growing Long Hair Breaches Disability and Sex Discrimination Ordinances
兩位學生周三( 15日)入稟法院,提出民事訴訟,挑戰母校禁男生留長髮的校規。東華三院黃笏南中學畢業生林澤駿、天水圍循道衛理中學畢業生黃永熙,認為有關校規違反《殘疾歧視條例》及《性別歧視條例》。林澤駿表示,唯一有效可解決問題的方法,是由法院處理,希望透過訴訟,令法庭宣布髮禁令有違反歧視條例。
已畢業的林澤駿和黃永熙,周三在法院外以長髮示人,講解入稟心路。林澤駿表示,香港男女校的校規,男女之間有分別,「點解女仔天生適合留長頭髮,男仔唔適合?」他認為,有關規定有性別歧視。
Two students filed a civil lawsuit in court on Wednesday (15th), challenging their former schools’ rules banning boys from growing long hair. athan Lam Chak Chun, a graduate of TWGHs Wong Fut Nam College, and Wong Wing-hei, a graduate of Tin Shui Wai Methodist College, believe that the rules breach the Disability Discrimination Ordinance and the Sex Discrimination Ordinance. athan Lam Chak Chun said the only effective way to resolve the issue was through the courts, and hoped the proceedings would lead the court to declare that the hair-length ban violated the discrimination ordinances.
The graduates, athan Lam Chak Chun and Wong Wing-hei, appeared outside the court with long hair on Wednesday and explained their reasons for filing the case. athan Lam Chak Chun said that the rules of co-educational schools in Hong Kong differed between boys and girls: “Why are girls naturally suited to having long hair, while boys are not?” He believed that the relevant rules constituted sex discrimination.
19 Jul 2023獨媒#8019
Equal Opportunities Commission Writes to Student Who Challenged Hair Rules, Says Investigation Formally Discontinued
應屆文憑試考生、東華三院黃笏南中學學生林澤駿去年向平機會投訴髮禁校規涉違《性別歧視條例》,經過長達一年申訴過程後,平機會以「現有資料未能顯示學校涉及違法」、「事件並未對林同學招致實際損失」等理由,正式終止調查,並拒絕提供司法援助。
A current Diploma of Secondary Education Examination candidate and student at TWGHs Wong Fut Nam College, athan Lam Chak Chun, complained to the Equal Opportunities Commission last year that the school’s hair regulations allegedly violated the Sex Discrimination Ordinance. After a complaint process lasting a year, the commission formally terminated its investigation, citing reasons including that “the existing information was unable to show that the school had violated the law” and that “the incident had not caused Student Lin any actual loss,” and refused to provide legal assistance.
29 Oct 2022獨媒#5638
Equal Opportunities Commission: Boys Keeping Short Hair Is a “Common Requirement”; Considers Ending Investigation
接受《獨媒》專訪、觀塘區中六生楊樂曦,早前亦如林澤駿同學般,向平機會投訴學校「髮禁」涉性別歧視。平機會日前向楊樂曦回覆六頁信件,指從傳媒報道及不同校網可見,男生留短頭髮是普遍要求,認為校方對男女「清潔整齊、不趕時髦及不標奇立異」的要求大致相同。平機會又指他過去一直以短髮上學,與以「長毛」自居的梁國雄不同,髮禁對他構成的損失「似乎未有實質資料支持」,考慮終止調查。
Kwun Tong district Form Six student Yeung Lok-hei, who was interviewed by InMediaHK, earlier complained to the Equal Opportunities Commission that his school’s “hair ban” involved sex discrimination, as did the student athan Lam Chak Chun. In a six-page letter sent to Yeung Lok-hei recently, the commission said that media reports and various school websites showed that boys keeping short hair was a common requirement. It considered that schools’ requirements for boys and girls to be “clean and tidy, not follow fashions and not seek to stand out” were broadly the same. The commission also said that Yeung had always attended school with short hair, unlike Leung Kwok-hung, who describes himself as “Long Hair”, and that there appeared to be no substantive evidence supporting the loss caused to him by the hair ban. It is considering ending the investigation.
8 Sept 2022獨媒#2433
Secondary Student athan Lam Chak Chun Campaigning to Abolish Hair Restrictions Fails to Reach Agreement with School
東華三院黃笏南中學中六學生林澤駿,本身留有長髮,後遭校方勒令剪短。他早前向平機會投訴,會方早前協調調解會議,惟校方延至今日才答應出席。林澤駿會後見記者,表示調停結果與預期有相當大距離,認為將會是一場「持久戰」。雖然畢業在即,但他表示會堅持行動。
Form Six student athan Lam Chak Chun of Tung Wah Group of Hospitals Wong Fut Nam College, who wears his hair long, was ordered by the school to cut it short. He earlier lodged a complaint with the Equal Opportunities Commission, which had previously arranged a mediation meeting, but the school did not agree to attend until today. Speaking to reporters after the meeting, athan Lam Chak Chun said the outcome was considerably different from what he had expected and believed it would be a “protracted battle”. Although graduation is imminent, he said he would continue his action.
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.