29 Oct 2025集誌社#7459
47-person case | Accomplice witness Chiu Ka-yin reportedly released early; first defendant in case also freed early; Correctional Services: No comment on individual cases
47 人案罪成被告、從犯證人趙家賢,據報周二(28日)提早獲釋。趙家賢在 47 人案被判囚 84 個月,刑期在 2028 年 2 月屆滿,他現服刑 56 個月獲釋,早了兩年四個月重獲自由,相信是同一國安案件中,首位獲扣減刑期的被告。《集誌社》向懲教署及警方查詢。懲教署回覆指,不評論個別個案。
Chiu Ka-yin, a convicted defendant and accomplice witness in the 47-person case, was reportedly released early on Tuesday (28th). Chiu was sentenced to 84 months’ imprisonment in the case, with his sentence due to expire in February 2028. He was released after serving 56 months, regaining his freedom two years and four months early. He is believed to be the first defendant in the same national security case to have his sentence reduced. The Collective Media contacted the Correctional Services Department and the police for inquiries. The Correctional Services Department replied that it did not comment on individual cases.
27 Oct 2025集誌社#7454
47-person case: Tsui Tsz-kit completes sentence and is released; reportedly stayed in hospital overnight
47 人案被告、前區議員徐子見今(27日)刑滿。清晨時份,有警車駛到赤柱監獄外,約 5 時 50 分,一輛拉下車窗窗簾的私家車,駛出赤柱監獄。據了解,徐子見昨晚留院,他獲釋的手續已辦妥,已是「自由人」,早上仍在醫院,中午已出院回家。
Tsui Tsz-kit, a defendant in the 47-person case and a former district councillor, completed his sentence today (27th). In the early morning, a police vehicle arrived outside Stanley Prison. At about 5:50am, a private car with its window curtains drawn drove out of the prison. It is understood that Tsui stayed in hospital last night, and the procedures for his release had been completed, making him a “free man”. He was still in hospital in the morning and was discharged and returned home at noon.
14 Oct 2025法庭線#7421
Assistant Solicitor Convicted of Helping Owen Chow Send Complaint Letter Without Authorisation; High Court Refuses Certificate for Appeal to Final Court
2023 年 5 月,因「47 人案」還押的鄒家成,被指未經授權下,透過律師寄出予申訴專員公署的投訴信,投訴懲教署損毀及拒絕其親友送入的兩本佛學書籍。鄒與一名女律師被裁定「將未經授權的物品攜離監獄」罪成,鄒判囚 3 日,律師罰款 1,800 元。
兩人不服提定罪上訴被駁回,鄒則獲改判罰款 1,800 元。涉案律師申請上訴至終院許可證明書,周二(14 日)在高等法院即日被駁回。司法機構網頁顯示,涉案律師已直接向終院再申請上訴許可,暫未排期聆訊。
In May 2023, Owen Chow Ka-shing, who was remanded in custody over the “47-person case”, was accused of sending, through a lawyer and without authorisation, a complaint letter to The Ombudsman alleging that the Correctional Services Department had damaged two Buddhist books and refused to accept them when they were sent in by his friends and relatives. Chow and a female lawyer were convicted of “taking unauthorised articles out of a prison”. Chow was sentenced to three days’ imprisonment, while the lawyer was fined HK$1,800.
Their appeals against conviction were dismissed, while Chow’s sentence was varied to an HK$1,800 fine. The lawyer involved applied for a certificate granting leave to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal, but the application was dismissed immediately at the High Court on Tuesday (14th). The Judiciary’s website shows that the lawyer has directly applied to the Court of Final Appeal again for leave to appeal; no hearing date has yet been set.
17 Sept 2025獨媒#7325
[47-person Primary Election Case] No Sentence Reduction Confirmed Last Week; Fast Beat Says, “Expected That”
47涉組織及參與民主派初選,被控「串謀顛覆國家政權罪」,45名罪成被告去年11月判刑人民力量前副主席譚得志(快必)被判囚4年5個月。快必的社交媒站昨日發文,指早前經評估後,在上周收到「成績表」獲確認未獲扣減刑期。快必對結果表示「預咗㗎啦」,又稱「唔緊要」,因在獄中有很多書未看。快必最後稱,仍希望盡快出獄與朋友相聚。
譚得志目前在石壁監獄服刑,刑期尚餘20個月。他的社交媒站昨日發文,指數名中學同學在上周末前往探望,其中二人已近一年沒有見過快必,在見到他後感覺其瘦了不少,而且面色紅潤。快必就笑言,因為剛剛做完運動,所以面色紅紅地,並揭高上衣向中同展示肌肉,獲中同拍手讚好。
Forty-seven people were charged with conspiracy to subvert state power over organising and participating in the pro-democracy primary election. Forty-five convicted defendants were sentenced last November, including People Power former vice-chairman Tam Tak-chi (Fast Beat), who was sentenced to four years and five months in prison. In a post on his social media account yesterday, Fast Beat said that after an earlier assessment, he received a “report card” last week confirming that he would not receive a sentence reduction. He said of the result, “Expected that,” and added, “It doesn’t matter,” because he had many books in prison that he had not yet read. Fast Beat said he still hoped to be released as soon as possible to meet his friends.
Tam is currently serving his sentence at Shek Pik Prison, with 20 months remaining. In a post yesterday, his social media account said several of his secondary-school classmates visited him before the end of last weekend. Two of them had not seen Fast Beat for nearly a year and felt that he had become considerably thinner, while his complexion looked ruddy. Fast Beat joked that his face was red because he had just finished exercising, then lifted his shirt to show his muscles to his classmates, who applauded him.
19 Aug 2025法庭線#7174
47-person case|Gwyneth Ho released from prison; review of case and mitigation submissions; Au Nok-hin also expected to be released this year
民主派初選 47 人案,共 45 人「串謀顛覆」罪成被判監。選擇認罪、被判囚 4 年 3 個月的袁嘉蔚,周二(19 日)在羅湖懲教所出獄。袁因另案 2020 年六四晚會參與未經批准集結罪成被判囚 4 個月,總刑期較長,故延至現時出獄。
在 2020 年舉行的民主派初選,袁嘉蔚參選港島區,以第二名出線。控方引用她曾簽〈墨落無悔〉聲明、出席抗爭派記者會等,指控她支持顛覆謀劃。
袁為前南區田灣區議員,代表大狀求情指她在獄中結婚,望盡早出獄與丈夫共度時光、建立家庭,形容她正處於更生的路上。連同袁嘉蔚,至今已有 12 名被告出獄,按刑期推算年內尚有徐子見將會出獄(見內文圖)。據悉袁已回家,與親友團聚。
In the democratic camp primary election 47-person case, 45 people were convicted of “conspiracy to subvert” and sentenced to imprisonment. Gwyneth Ho, who pleaded guilty and was sentenced to four years and three months, was released from Lo Wu Correctional Institution on Tuesday (19th). Ho was also convicted in a separate case of participating in an unauthorised assembly at a June 4 event in 2020 and sentenced to four months in prison. As a result, her total sentence was longer and she was not released until now.
In the democratic camp primary election held in 2020, Ho ran in Hong Kong Island and came through in second place. The prosecution cited her signing the “With Ink, No Regrets” declaration and attending press conferences held by the protest camp, among other matters, and accused her of supporting the subversion plan.
Ho is a former Southern District councillor for the Tin Wan constituency. Her counsel said in mitigation that she had married in prison and hoped she could be released as soon as possible to spend time with her husband and build a family, describing her as being on the path to rehabilitation. Including Ho, 12 defendants have now been released. Based on the length of the sentences, Au Nok-hin is expected to be released later this year (see graphic in the article). Ho is understood to have returned home and reunited with family and friends.
19 Aug 2025集誌社#7180
47-person case · Released from prison | Tiffany Yuen: Thank you all for your hard work; married co-defendant Fung Tat Chun Frankie in prison, with the two uploading photos together | Fung: Previously, only my wife was behind bars—No…
民主派 47 人案、前南區區議員袁嘉蔚今日( 19日)刑滿出獄。清晨五時許,國安警的車輛已來到羅湖懲教所,其後駛出。據了解,袁嘉蔚已返到家中,與家人團聚。她被裁定屬積極參加者,判囚 4 年 3 個月。在獄中曾因與囚友擁抱而被單獨囚禁「水飯房」的袁嘉蔚,曾在書信中表示想和田灣街坊、南區居民好好相擁。代表律師去年求情時稱,九月將滿 31 歲的袁嘉蔚,由 26 歲起還押,現已在獄中與同案另一被告結婚,希望出獄後建立家庭、與丈夫共度時光。
Tiffany Yuen, a former Southern District councillor convicted in the 47-person pro-democracy case, completed her sentence and was released from prison today (19th). At around 5 a.m., National Security Police vehicles arrived at Lo Wu Correctional Institution and later drove away. Yuen is understood to have returned home and reunited with her family. She was found to be an active participant and sentenced to four years and three months in prison. Yuen, who was placed in solitary confinement in the “water-and-rice room” after hugging a fellow prisoner, had written that she wanted to embrace the residents of Tai Wan and people in the Southern District. During mitigation submissions last year, her counsel said that Yuen, who would turn 31 in September, had been remanded since the age of 26 and had married another defendant in the case while in prison. She hoped to build a family after her release and spend time with her husband.
28 Jul 2025法庭線#7100
47 Defendants Case | Third Batch Released from Prison; Nathan Lau Chak Fung Wears Long-Sleeved Shirt, Fung Tat Chun Frankie Goes Straight into Building; Ng Man-yee Reportedly Home
47 人案第三批 3 名被告吳敏兒、馮達浚、劉澤鋒周一(28 日)出獄。他們清晨由車接載離開,6 輛車全部拉上窗簾,監獄外的警力與之前相若,而被告住所附近同樣有警員戒備。
傳媒拍到劉澤鋒、馮達浚回家的畫面。劉在住所大廈外的路邊下車,拿着「包頭」步行回大門廈,他穿長袖衫及長褲,向記者稱「唔該晒,Bye bye。」馮則在屋苑大閘內下車,直接進入大廈,記者隔閘大聲問他感受,馮未有回應。據悉吳敏兒亦已出獄,回到家中。
The third batch of three defendants in the 47 Defendants Case—Ng Man-yee, Fung Tat Chun Frankie and Nathan Lau Chak Fung—were released from prison on Monday (28th). They were driven away in the early morning. All six vehicles had their curtains drawn. The police presence outside the prison was similar to before, while officers were likewise stationed near the defendants’ homes.
The media captured footage of Nathan Lau Chak Fung and Fung Tat Chun Frankie returning home. Lau got out by the roadside outside his residential building and walked to the entrance carrying a “包頭”. He was wearing a long-sleeved shirt and long trousers, and told reporters, “Thank you very much. Bye bye.” Fung got out inside the gates of his housing estate and went straight into the building. When reporters shouted through the gates asking how he felt, Fung did not respond. Ng Man-yee was also reportedly released and returned home.
28 Jul 2025法庭線#7102
47-person case | Ng Man-yee, Fung Tat Chun Frankie and Nathan Lau Chak Fung released from prison; review of case facts and mitigation submissions; two more expected to be released this year
民主派初選 47 人案,共 45 人「串謀顛覆」罪成被判監。選擇認罪、被判囚 4 年 5 個月的吳敏兒、馮達浚、劉澤鋒,周一(28 日)分別從羅湖及赤柱監獄獲釋。
案件圍繞 2020 年舉行的民主派初選,吳敏兒參選新西,馮達浚及劉澤鋒參選九西,3 人均告落敗。控方引用他們在初選論壇等表述,指控他們支持顛覆謀劃。
吳敏兒為前職工盟主席,求情指至被捕才知違國安,未來會脫離政治。馮達浚為本土抗爭派,曾創辦網媒「加山傳播」,他在求情信向泛民真誠道歉。劉澤鋒為樹仁大學學生會前會長、「學聯抗爭者基金」前主席,案情指他是本土抗爭派,求情時稱誤信初選合法。
預料今年尚有 2 名被告袁嘉蔚及徐子見將出獄,預計出獄時間見內文圖。
In the pan-democrat primary election case involving 47 people, 45 were convicted of “conspiracy to subvert” and sentenced to imprisonment. Ng Man-yee, Fung Tat Chun Frankie and Nathan Lau Chak Fung, who pleaded guilty and were sentenced to four years and five months in prison, were released from Lo Wu and Stanley prisons respectively on Monday (28th).
26 Jul 2025法庭線#7099
47-Person Case Appeals: Defendants and Department of Justice Dispute Verdicts and Grounds for Excessive Sentences
民主派初選案,上訴庭 7 月中一連四天處理罪成的 12 人就定罪及或刑罰提出上訴,以及律政司就劉偉聰無罪裁決提上訴的聆訊,法官指將在 9 個月內,即不遲於 2026 年 4 月中頒布判決。
《法庭線》以列點形式整理各被告案情相關的口頭陳詞,讓讀者容易理解上訴方指出原審法官判決錯誤的理據,以及答辯方的回應。部分議題因依賴書面陳詞,庭上未有讀出,故未有涵蓋。
除了個人案情,被告方與律政司亦分別就法律爭議陳詞,例如提出「顛覆罪」條文的「非法手段」應如何詮釋,以及法庭應在何種情況下才介入立法機關行使權力的事宜等,詳見聆訊第一日、第二日的報道。
In the democratic primary election case, the Court of Appeal heard, over four consecutive days in mid-July, appeals by 12 convicted defendants against their convictions and/or sentences, as well as the Department of Justice’s appeal against the acquittal of Lawrence Wai Chung Lau. The judges said they would hand down their judgment within nine months, no later than mid-April 2026.
The Witness has summarised in bullet points the oral submissions concerning each defendant’s case, to make it easier for readers to understand the grounds on which the appellants argued that the trial judges had erred in their judgments, as well as the respondents’ replies. Some issues relied on written submissions and were not read out in court, and are therefore not covered.
In addition to the circumstances of the individual cases, the defendants and the Department of Justice also made submissions on legal disputes, including how “unlawful means” in the provisions on the offence of subversion should be interpreted, and the circumstances in which the court should intervene in the exercise of powers by the legislature. See the reports on the first and second days of the hearing for details.
17 Jul 2025法庭線#7054
47 Democrats Case Appeal | Defence Challenges Sentencing Tiers, Excessive Starting Points and Devastating Overall Terms; Judgment to Be Handed Down Within 9 Months
民主派初選案周四(17 日)展開第四日上訴聆訊,雙方完成刑罰上訴陳詞。高院首席法官潘兆初稱將在 9 個月內頒下判決。早前出獄的岑子杰到庭旁聽;散庭時,梁國雄、林卓廷向旁聽揮手,楊雪盈則露齒笑。
被告方爭議刑罰分級、量刑起點過高,指梁國雄、林卓廷、黃碧雲不應被裁定為「積極參加者」,其中,大狀沈士文力陳,林、黃沒有公開支持謀劃、「幾乎保持沉默」,兩人面對的 7 年量刑起點,有如指他們的角色等同同案更激進的被告,原審實屬錯誤。
被告方又爭議減刑因素,如陳志全、何啟明任公職多年,應獲更多減刑;鄭達鴻一方指,其量刑起點應與同屬公民黨的譚文豪有別;鄒家成、黃子悅另涉暴動案,代表大狀指原審分期執行判刑,對兩人是沉重打擊、毀滅性。
The fourth day of the appeal hearing in the democrats’ primary election case began on Thursday (the 17th), with both sides completing their submissions on the sentencing appeals. Chief High Court Judge Poon Siu-chu said the judgment would be handed down within nine months. Chan Tsz-kit, who was released from prison earlier, attended the hearing. At the end of the hearing, Leung Kwok-hung and Lam Cheuk-ting waved to those in the public gallery, while Yeung Suet-ying smiled broadly.
The defence challenged the sentencing tiers and the starting points, which it said were too high, arguing that Leung Kwok-hung, Lam Cheuk-ting and Wong Pik-wan should not have been classified as “active participants”. In particular, counsel Erik Ignatius Sze Man Shum argued forcefully that Lam and Wong had not publicly supported the plotting and had “remained almost silent”. The seven-year starting points imposed on them effectively treated their roles as equivalent to those of more radical defendants in the same case, which was an error by the trial court.
The defence also challenged the mitigating factors, arguing that Chan Chi-chuen and Ho Kai-ming, who had held public office for many years, should have received greater reductions. Cheng Tat-hung’s side said his starting point should differ from that of fellow Civic Party member Jeremy Tam Man-ho. Chow Ka-shing and Prince Wong Ji-yuet were also involved in a separate riot case; their counsel said that the trial court’s ordering of the sentences to be served consecutively was a heavy blow and devastating for the two men.
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.