4 Dec 2025法庭線#7636
612 Fund Societies Ordinance case: Appeal side says broad interpretation harms freedom of association; ruling due within 9 months
「612 人道支援基金」被指沒註冊為社團案,5 名信託人不服定罪提上訴,周四(4 日)展開第二天聆訊,上訴方和律政司完成陳詞,法官押後於 9 個月內,即明年 9 月或之前頒判決。
上訴方資深大狀李志喜稱,法庭愈循廣義詮釋條例,對結社自由就構成愈大損害,又引「香港民族黨」與近日兩組織被禁在港運作為例,指很多事現已可循國安法規處理,反問仍要求註冊社團有何用處。大狀林國輝則指,何韻詩真誠相信是出於人道支援而成立基金,而非社團。
律政司一方則認為「612基金」屬於信託,亦是條例定義下的社團,指上訴人為着共同目的聚在一起開會,亦有涉足公開籌款等活動。
In the case alleging that the 612 Humanitarian Relief Fund was not registered as a society, its five trustees, dissatisfied with their convictions, lodged an appeal. The second day of the hearing took place on Thursday (4th), with the appeal side and the Department of Justice completing their submissions. The judge adjourned the case and will deliver a ruling within nine months, by September next year at the latest.
Senior Counsel Gladys Veronica Chi Hei Li for the appeal side said that the more broadly the court interpreted the Ordinance, the greater the damage to freedom of association. Citing the Hong Kong National Party and the recent bans on two organisations operating in Hong Kong as examples, counsel said that many matters could now be dealt with under the National Security Law, and questioned the purpose of continuing to require societies to register. Counsel Harry Kwok Fai Lam said that Denise Ho genuinely believed the fund had been established for humanitarian support, rather than as a society.
The Department of Justice argued that the “612 Fund” was a trust and also a society as defined by the Ordinance. It said the appellants had gathered to hold meetings for a common purpose and had also engaged in activities including public fundraising.
3 Dec 2025法庭線#7627
612 Fund Societies Ordinance Case: Judge Focuses on Organisation’s Nature; Appeal Says It Was Neither a Trust nor a Society
「612 人道支援基金」被指沒註冊為社團案,5 名信託人不服定罪提上訴,周三(3 日)展開首天聆訊。天主教香港教區榮休主教陳日君樞機、前立法會議員何秀蘭、大律師吳靄儀的法律代表完成陳詞。高院首席法官潘兆初關注,組織在性質上是否信託。
上訴方否認,又指單憑有共同目的不足夠認定它是社團,而它亦沒有階級架構、不設會員。上訴方又指,律政司錯誤依賴七十年代判例,而原審裁斷吳靄儀是基金負責人等,與實況「格格不入」。案件周四續。
The appeal hearing opened on Wednesday (3 July) after five trustees of the 612 Humanitarian Relief Fund, which was accused of failing to register as a society, challenged their convictions. Legal representatives for Cardinal Joseph Zen Ze-kiun, the emeritus bishop of the Catholic Diocese of Hong Kong, former Legislative Council member Margaret Ng, and barrister Audrey Eu Yuet-mee completed their submissions. Poon Siu-tung, Chief Judge of the High Court, focused on whether the organisation was, by nature, a trust. The appellants denied this, arguing that a common purpose alone was insufficient to establish that it was a society, and that it had neither a hierarchical structure nor members. They also argued that the Department of Justice had wrongly relied on case law from the 1970s, and that the trial court’s finding that Audrey Eu was a person in charge of the fund was “at odds with reality”. The case continues on Thursday.
25 Apr 2025法庭線#6727
Cardinal Joseph Zen, Arrested in 612 Fund National Security Case and Ordered to Surrender Passport, Allowed to Leave Hong Kong for Pope Francis’s Funeral
教宗方濟各(Pope Francis)周一在梵蒂岡逝世。天主教香港教區榮休主教陳日君樞機的秘書,周五(25 日)向《法庭線》確認,陳經法庭批准暫時取回護照,並已啟程前往梵蒂岡,暫未有返港日期。
陳日君與「612基金」另 5 人於 2022 年被捕,警方國安處指他們涉違「勾結」罪,引用實施細則附表二,要求眾人交出護照。陳曾經於 2023 年初獲法庭批准暫時取回護照,他當時赴梵蒂岡出席教宗本篤十六世的喪禮。
Pope Francis died at the Vatican on Monday. The secretary to Cardinal Joseph Zen Ze-kiun, emeritus bishop of the Catholic Diocese of Hong Kong, confirmed to The Witness on Friday (25th) that Zen had been granted court approval to temporarily retrieve his passport and had departed for the Vatican. He does not yet have a date for his return to Hong Kong.
Zen and five others linked to the 612 Fund were arrested in 2022. The Police National Security Department said they were suspected of violating a “collusion” offence and cited Schedule 2 of the Implementation Rules, requiring them to surrender their passports. Zen was granted court approval to temporarily retrieve his passport in early 2023, when he travelled to the Vatican to attend the funeral of Pope Benedict XVI.
4 Nov 2024明報#4199
612 Fund case: Lawyer receives written warning after Law Society rules conduct breached practice rules; no indication yet of referral to disciplinary tribunal
警方國安處2022年5月調查「612人道支援基金」案時,指控有大律師及律師涉專業失當並向兩個律師會投訴。繼大律師公會今年初指無證據38名涉事大律師專業失當後,據本報了解,陸續有涉案事務律師收到調查結果,指裁定涉事行為違反《律師執業規則》,並可能有損個人或法律專業名譽,但據在本報初步掌握的這批個案,只收到律師會書面警告,暫未見這批個案轉交可撤銷執業資格的律師紀律審裁團處理。
明報記者 林勵
投訴調查是否已完成 待回覆
律師會今年1月回應時透露共收到16宗投訴,當時其中10宗已完成調查並正覆核,最嚴重的個案可能需轉交律師紀律審裁團處理。本報昨午向律師會查詢是否已完成調查所有投訴,有待回覆。至於有沒有個案要由律師紀律審裁團審理,則有待查證。
律師會前會長、立法會法律界議員林新強相信,律師會是按機制研究後作出決定,雖然發信做法相對輕微,都是一種處分。另一前會長兼議員何君堯說,2019年引發社會事件性質嚴重,「無理由發信遺憾就算」。
When the police National Security Department investigated the 612 Humanitarian Relief Fund case in May 2022, it accused barristers and solicitors of professional misconduct and lodged complaints with the two legal professional bodies. After the Bar Association said early this year that there was no evidence of professional misconduct by the 38 barristers involved, Ming Pao understands that solicitors implicated in the case have successively received the investigation findings. They state that the conduct in question was found to have breached the Solicitors’ Practice Rules and might adversely affect the reputation of the individuals or the legal profession. However, based on the cases initially obtained by this newspaper, the solicitors have only received written warnings from the Law Society, and there is so far no indication that these cases have been referred to the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal, which can revoke practising qualifications.
Ming Pao reporter Lam Lai
Whether complaint investigations have been completed awaits a response
In its response in January this year, the Law Society disclosed that it had received a total of 16 complaints. At that time, 10 had completed investigation and were under review, while the most serious cases might need to be referred to the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal. This newspaper asked the Law Society yesterday afternoon whether investigations into all the complaints had been completed, but a response was pending. Whether any cases need to be heard by the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal also remains to be ascertained.
Former Law Society president and Legislative Council legal-sector lawmaker Ambrose San Keung Lam believes that the Law Society made its decision after studying the matter in accordance with established procedures. Although sending a letter is a relatively minor measure, it is still a form of disciplinary action. Another former president and lawmaker, Junius Ho Kwan-yiu, said that the social incident triggered in 2019 was serious in nature: “There is no reason for it to be considered settled merely by sending a letter of regret.”
19 Jan 2024獨媒#2842
38 barristers complained against over receiving 612 Fund payments for alleged professional misconduct; Bar says all complaints unfounded
警方國安處2022年拘捕612人道支援基金信託人時,指多名大律師及律師涉嫌專業失當,分別向大律師公會及律師會作出投訴。大律師公會今日宣布經調查後,沒有證據顯示38名被投訴的大律師違反誠信或作出專業失當行為,亦不涉及刑事成份,決定終止有關調查。至於4名未有妥善保存紀錄的大律師,技術上違反守則,公會主席杜淦堃已向4名人士發信敦促日後須保存紀錄。被問事件會否影響大律師將來代表反修例事件的被告,杜淦堃指只要會員「守法守規,睇唔到點解要擔心」。
When the Police National Security Department arrested the trustees of the 612 Humanitarian Relief Fund in 2022, it alleged that several barristers and solicitors had committed professional misconduct and lodged complaints with the Hong Kong Bar Association and the Law Society. The Bar Association announced today that, following an investigation, there was no evidence that the 38 barristers complained against had breached their integrity or committed professional misconduct, and that the matter did not involve any criminal element. It therefore decided to terminate the investigations. Four barristers who had not properly kept records had technically breached the relevant rules. The association’s chair, Victor (1977) Dawes, has written to the four people urging them to keep records in future. Asked whether the matter would affect barristers’ future representation of defendants in cases arising from the anti-extradition bill movement, Victor (1977) Dawes said that as long as members "obey the law and rules, I can't see why there should be any concern."
5 Jul 2022明報#2176
Around 35 barristers who received 612 Fund cheques sent letters by Bar Association seeking explanations; chairman Victor (1977) Dawes reportedly handling matter personally
大律師公會向部分曾涉612基金資助案件的大律師發信,要求解釋直接收取612基金支票的理由,以及有否聲稱以義務形式代表被告等。
The Bar Association has written to some barristers who were involved in cases funded by the 612 Fund, asking them to explain why they directly received cheques from the 612 Fund and whether they had claimed to represent the defendants on a pro bono basis.
24 May 2022獨媒#2021
612 Fund trustees and secretary summonsed over unregistered society; appear in court this morning
已停止運作的「612人道支援基金」5名信託人,包括天主教香港教區榮休主教陳日君樞機、大律師吳靄儀、前嶺南大學文化研究系客席副教授許寶強、歌手何韻詩及因另案正在服刑的前立法會議員何秀蘭,早前遭國安處拘捕,指他們涉嫌干犯「串謀勾結外國勢力或者境外勢力危害國家安全」罪,獲准保釋候查。
他們與前基金秘書施城威另被指沒有遵循《社團條例》要求,為基金作出註冊,另遭票控「沒有在指明時限內申請註冊或豁免註冊社團」,今早(23日)於西九龍裁判法院提堂。
The five trustees of the now-defunct 612 Humanitarian Relief Fund—Cardinal Joseph Zen Ze-kiun, emeritus bishop of the Catholic Diocese of Hong Kong; barrister Margaret Ng; Hui Po-keung, a former adjunct associate professor in the Department of Cultural Studies at Lingnan University; singer Denise Ho; and former Legislative Council member Cyd Ho, who is serving a prison sentence in another case—were earlier arrested by the National Security Department on suspicion of committing the offence of conspiracy to collude with a foreign country or external elements to endanger national security. They were granted bail pending investigation.
They and the fund’s former secretary Sze Ching-wee were also accused of failing to comply with the Societies Ordinance by registering the fund, and were summonsed for the offence of failing to apply for registration or exemption from registration of a society within the specified period. They appeared at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts this morning (23rd).
23 May 2022獨媒#2018
Law Society Receives One Complaint Related to 612 Fund from National Security Department
警方國家安全處早前拘捕已停止運作的612人道支援基金5名信託人,並指發現有律師和大律師在提供服務時涉嫌作出專業失當行爲,已向律師會和大律師公會作出投訴。香港律師會今日召開記者會,會長陳澤銘確認收到1宗投訴,並以專業操守調查須保密為由,拒絕透露涉及的律師、律師行數目及涉嫌專業失當的行為等其他資料,並表示不會與大律師公會交換資料或合作,兩會將各自進行調查。
The National Security Department of the police earlier arrested five trustees of the now-defunct 612 Humanitarian Relief Fund and said it had found that lawyers and barristers had allegedly committed professional misconduct while providing services. It lodged complaints with the Law Society of Hong Kong and the Hong Kong Bar Association. The Law Society held a press conference today, at which its president, Chan Chak-ming, confirmed that it had received one complaint. Citing the confidentiality of professional-conduct investigations, he declined to disclose the number of lawyers or law firms involved, or other information about the alleged professional misconduct. He said the Law Society would not exchange information or cooperate with the Bar Association, and that the two bodies would conduct their investigations separately.
19 May 2022明報#2006
Audrey Eu Files for Return of Documents in 612 Fund Case Covered by Legal Professional Privilege
支援反修例運動被捕者及傷者的「612人道支援基金」去年停運,包括大律師吳靄儀的5名基金信託人早前被警方國安處拘捕,除正服刑的前立法會議員何秀蘭,其餘4人獲准保釋。吳靄儀昨(18日)入稟高等法院,要求警方歸還涉及法律專業保密權或不屬手令權限的文件,並禁止警方存取、檢視和取用有關文件,以及向警方索償。
The 612 Humanitarian Relief Fund, which supported people arrested or injured during the anti-extradition bill movement, ceased operations last year. Five of the fund’s trustees, including barrister Audrey Eu, were earlier arrested by the Police National Security Department. Former Legislative Council member Cyd Ho Sau-lan is serving a prison sentence, while the other four were granted bail. Eu filed an application with the High Court yesterday (18th), seeking the return of documents covered by legal professional privilege or outside the scope of the warrant, an order prohibiting the police from accessing, inspecting or using the documents, and damages from the police.
13 Sept 2021立場新聞#1563
Chris Tang: Hopes to complete Article 23 legislation in next LegCo term; response received to request for information from 612 Fund
保安局長鄧炳強接受《東方日報》專訪,表示會著手推動基本法 23 條立法,期望在下個立法會期內完成,會諮詢公眾,形容立法會是「盡快處理,愈早愈好」。
Secretary for Security Chris Tang said in an interview with Oriental Daily that he would begin promoting legislation under Article 23 of the Basic Law, hoping to complete it in the next Legislative Council term. He said the public would be consulted and described the Legislative Council’s approach as “dealing with it as soon as possible—the earlier the better.”
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.