9 May 2023法庭線#6420
47人案|證人X否認秘密攝錄 另稱戴耀廷曾提「推翻政府」 辯方指口供沒提
The 55th day of the trial in which 47 democrats are charged with conspiracy to subvert state power began on Tuesday (9th). Anonymous prosecution witness X testified that he filmed and recorded a New Territories West primary election coordination meeting for “research”. He said the recording was conducted “openly”, adding: “I don’t know whether everyone knew about it; I just put [the recorder] in my bag.”
Regarding the unsteady footage, X said: “I’m not a professional videographer.” He admitted that he had not asked those present for permission, but said: “Nobody at the scene said filming was not allowed.” In response to the defence’s challenge, he added: “I wasn’t recording secretly; I took it out and filmed in full view.”
X also testified that, before the New Territories West meeting, Benny Tai had said that promoting the “35+” plan was intended to “overthrow the government”. The defence pointed out that he had not mentioned this in his statement to police. X replied that Tai had referred to “forcing the Chief Executive to step down”, and said: “In my understanding, that is, I feel, forcing the Chief Executive to step down means overthrowing the government.” X completed his testimony that day.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周二(9 日)展開第 55 天審訊。控方匿名證人 X 供稱,在初選新界西協調會議拍片及錄音,用作「研究」,又指是「公開進行」攝錄,稱「我就唔知道係咪大家都知道,我就咁擺(錄音筆)喺袋到」。
對於片段鏡頭晃動,X 稱「我唔係一個專業嘅攝錄人士」,他承認沒問過在場人士的准許,「但係現場都無人話唔可以影」,又在回應辯方質疑時稱「我唔係秘密(攝錄),我係好光明正大咁攞出嚟影。」
X 另供稱,戴耀廷在新西會議前曾提及推動「35+」計劃是想「推翻政府」。辯方質疑他未有在向警方錄取的口供提及。X 答稱戴提及「逼特首落台」,故「以我嘅理解,即係我覺得,逼特首落台,就係要推翻政府」。X 是日完成作供。
8 May 2023法庭線#6415
47人案|辯方問及無差別否決預算案 鍾錦麟指為爭五大訴求而否決「較貼近實況」
The trial of 47 pro-democracy defendants charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 54th day on Monday (the 8th). Defence counsel Trevor Beel asked whether Tai Yiu-ting’s plan was to “indiscriminately” veto budget bills across the board. Chung Kam-lun replied: “I rather think that your original formulation—that the budget bills were to be vetoed in order to fight for the five demands—is closer to the actual circumstances.”
Chung also completed three days of testimony. Ten defendants did not conduct cross-examination, and the prosecution did not re-examine him. In addition, the judge approved the prosecution’s application for an anonymity order for a witness, who will testify behind a screen. The prosecution also read out two sets of amended admitted facts involving Wong Pik-wan, Lam Cheuk-ting and Ho Kai-lai; Ho’s version added details of her being DQ’d in 2020.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周一(8 日)展開第 54 天審訊。辯方大狀 Trevor Beel 問及戴耀廷的計劃是否「一刀切地」無差別否決預算案,鍾錦麟答稱「我反而覺得你原先嘅講法一係為咗爭取五大訴求而去否決預算案,呢個係比較貼近實際嘅情況。」
鍾亦完成 3 日作供,共 10 名被告沒有作出盤問,而控方亦沒覆問。此外,法官批准控方為一名證人申請匿名令,該名證人將在屏風後作供。控方亦讀出黃碧雲、林卓廷及何桂藍的兩份修訂承認事實,其中何的版本新增她於 2020 年被 DQ 的經過。
5 May 2023法庭線#6405
47人案|鍾錦麟稱曾私下表達憂無差別否決預算案或致DQ 戴耀廷覆不會作出要求
The 53rd day of the trial in which 47 pro-democracy figures are charged with conspiracy to subvert state power began on Friday (the 5th). Under questioning by the prosecution, Chung Kam-lam said that after the first New Territories East coordination meeting in April 2020, he had “pulled Benny Tai aside” and privately expressed concern over rumours that indiscriminately vetoing the budget could result in everyone being disqualified from standing for election. Chung quoted Tai as saying at the time: “I won’t ask everyone to veto it indiscriminately ... I’ve made clear that it is a power under the Basic Law, so there shouldn’t be a problem, right?”
Chung also testified that at the end of May that year, Tai met him and other district council chairmen to discuss polling stations for the primary, and said during the meeting that “all the coordination for the primary had already been completed, and there was consensus.” Chung further testified that when Gwyneth Ho introduced herself as “Stance Sister” at a New Territories East meeting, Ho twice shouted “Definitely not!” from the dock.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周五(5 日)展開第 53 天審訊,鍾錦麟在控方主問下,提及曾於 2020 年 4 月新東首次協調會議後,「拉咗戴耀廷埋一邊」,私下對戴表示憂外面風聲說若無差別否決財政預算案,或致所有人遭取消參選資格。鍾並引述戴當時稱,「唔會要求大家去無差別咁否決…我講明係基本法嘅權力,就唔會有問題喇掛?」
鍾又供稱,同年 5 月尾,戴約見他和其他區議會主席討論初選票站,並指戴席上提及「所有嘅初選協調已經係完成咗,同埋係有共識喇」。此外,鍾供稱何桂藍在新東會議上自我介紹是「立場姐姐」時,何兩度在被告席大叫「肯定無!」
5 May 2023法庭線#6410
47人案|鍾錦麟稱曾私下表達憂無差別否決預算案或致DQ 戴耀廷覆不會作出要求
The 47 democrats’ case, in which they are charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power”, entered its 53rd day of trial on Friday (5th). Under questioning by the prosecution, Chung Kam-lam said that after the first New Territories East coordination meeting in April 2020, he had “pulled Benny Tai aside” and privately told Tai that he was worried by reports outside that indiscriminately vetoing the budget could result in everyone being disqualified from standing for election. Chung quoted Tai as saying at the time: “I won’t ask everyone to veto it indiscriminately … I’ve made clear that it is a power under the Basic Law, so there shouldn’t be a problem, right?”
Chung also testified that in late May of the same year, Tai met him and other district council chairpersons to discuss polling stations for the primary election, and said during the meeting that “all the coordination for the primary election has already been completed, and there is a consensus.” Chung further testified that when Gwyneth Ho introduced herself as “Stand News sister” at a New Territories East meeting, Ho twice shouted “Definitely not!” from the defendants’ dock.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周五(5 日)展開第 53 天審訊,鍾錦麟在控方主問下,提及曾於 2020 年 4 月新東首次協調會議後,「拉咗戴耀廷埋一邊」,私下對戴表示憂外面風聲說若無差別否決財政預算案,或致所有人遭取消參選資格。鍾並引述戴當時稱,「唔會要求大家去無差別咁否決…我講明係基本法嘅權力,就唔會有問題喇掛?」
鍾又供稱,同年 5 月尾,戴約見他和其他區議會主席討論初選票站,並指戴席上提及「所有嘅初選協調已經係完成咗,同埋係有共識喇」。此外,鍾供稱何桂藍在新東會議上自我介紹是「立場姐姐」時,何兩度在被告席大叫「肯定無!」
4 May 2023法庭線#6399
47人案|鍾錦麟開始作供 稱「民動」早於2020年2月與戴耀廷達共識協辦初選
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power entered its 52nd day on Thursday (4th), when the prosecution called its third witness, pleaded-guilty defendant and deputy convenor of Power for Democracy Chung Kam-lun. Chung appeared in court wearing a checked shirt, blazer and jeans.
Chung testified that Power for Democracy had planned in January and February 2020 to coordinate that year’s Legislative Council election, but that “in the end, Benny Tai took charge of the entire coordination process”. He also said Andrew Chiu had hoped the coordination would be handled by Power for Democracy, but “not many people paid him any attention”. Chung and Chiu met Tai in February of the same year and reached a consensus that Power for Democracy would assist with the primary election or coordination led by Tai.
Chiu earlier testified that Power for Democracy was invited by Tai and Au Nok-hin in early May 2020, and only agreed to undertake the primary election after mid-May. On Thursday, Judge asked Chung whether Power for Democracy had been formally appointed in May. Chung replied: “As for the judge’s description, I’m not very clear about it, so I have nothing else that I can assist the court with.” The case continues on Friday (5th).
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周四(4 日)展開第 52 天審訊,控方傳召第三名證人、認罪被告兼「民主動力」副召集人鍾錦麟作供。鍾身穿格子襯衫,外穿西裝外套、牛仔褲出庭。
鍾供稱,「民動」於 2020 年 1 、2 月曾計劃協調 2020 年的立法會換屆選舉,惟「最後係由戴耀廷去主導咗成個協調嘅程序」,又指趙家賢曾冀由「民動」協調,但「無乜人睬佢」。而鍾、趙同年 2 月與戴耀廷會面,並達成共識,「民動」會協助戴領導的初選或協調。
趙家賢早前供稱,「民動」於 2020 年 5 月初獲戴及區諾軒邀請,並於 5 月中後才同意承辦初選。法官周四問鍾,「民動」是否 5 月正式獲委任?鍾答稱,「對於法官呢個講法,我唔係太清楚,所以我無其他嘢可以協助到法庭。」案件周五(5 日)續。
25 Apr 2023法庭線#6356
47人案|控方稱近日破解鍾錦麟手機 法官關注或需重召證人作供
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 50th day on Tuesday (25th). Chiu Ka-yin completed his testimony. The prosecution said the next witness would be defendant Chung Kam-lun, who has pleaded guilty, but said police had only cracked his phone last Saturday (22nd) and obtained the data, and time was needed to determine whether the contents included material on which the prosecution could rely.
Judge Lee Yuntong said the situation was highly unsatisfactory, noting that it was already the 50th day of the trial and that the prosecution owed everyone an explanation. Lead prosecutor Jonathan Tak Ho Man explained that Chung had forgotten his passcode and that police had avoided attempting to crack the phone for fear that entering the wrong code would erase its data, succeeding only after technological improvements. The defence said it had received Chung’s data only at lunchtime, involving more than 2,400 messages.
The judge raised concern over whether Au Nok-hin and Chiu Ka-yin, who had completed their testimony, would need to be recalled to testify. He therefore ordered an immediate adjournment to allow the defence to review the material, with the parties to state their positions again on Wednesday. In addition, during cross-examination, Chiu said that when the constitutional reform proposal was put forward in 2010, he was a Democratic Party Central Committee member and supported voting to pass the government’s political reform proposal.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周二(25 日)展開第 50 天審訊。趙家賢完成作供,控方指下一證人為認罪被告鍾錦麟,但稱警方上周六(22 日)才破解到其手機取得資料,需時看有否控方可依賴內容等。
法官李運騰直言情況令人非常不滿意,指審訊已第 50 日,控方欠眾人解釋。主控萬德豪解釋指,鍾忘記密碼,警方為免撞錯密碼致手機資料清空,沒冒險破解,直至技術改良方成功。辯方稱,午膳才收到鍾的資料,涉逾 2,400 條訊息。
法官關注,會否需重召已完成作供的區諾軒、趙家賢作供,遂下令即時休庭,供辯方檢閱資料,周三再交代立場。另外,趙於盤問提及,2010 年政改方案時,他任民主黨中央委員,支持投票通過政府的政改方案。
24 Apr 2023法庭線#6350
47人案|上周否認記錯陳志全出席新東會議 趙家賢改口指助手認錯人
The 49th day of the trial in the case against 47 democrats charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” began on Monday (the 24th). Andrew Chiu Ka-yin, who last week denied misremembering that Chan Chi-chuen had attended the first New Territories East coordination meeting, voluntarily changed his account two days later, saying that “after recalling it several times”, he confirmed Chan had not attended the meeting. Chiu also said that Luke Lai King-fai, secretary-general of Power for Democracy, had mistaken someone for another person, resulting in errors in the meeting notes.
Chiu also voluntarily clarified that, after “thinking back”, he confirmed that the Civic Party had asked Power for Democracy to change its platform to a blank one after there was news that the National Security Law had been passed but before it was promulgated. He also recalled a Power for Democracy staff member saying, “What about the one in Stanley? There’s something in the platform that he wants to change.” He only remembered afterwards that this referred to Michael Cheuk Kei Pang.
The representative counsel for Owen Chow Ka-shing, Philip Sai Kit Chan, began cross-examination, saying that the first New Territories East meeting had not discussed veto power at all, and that Chow had not said that “using every means was to force the government to respond to the ‘five demands’”, among other things. Chiu disagreed. In response to questions from the judge, Chiu said that Chow and Winfield Chong Wing-fai of the Democratic Party had at one point “stood up” to discuss matters at the meeting.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周一(24 日)展開第 49 天審訊。上周否認記錯陳志全有出席新東首次協調會議的趙家賢,事隔兩日主動改口指經「多次回想後」,確認陳沒出席該次會議。趙又指,「民動」總幹事黎敬輝因認錯人致會議的筆記紀錄出錯。
趙另又主動澄清,「回想返」後確認公民黨在有消息指《國安法》通過但未頒布前,向「民動」要求改為留白政綱;亦記得有「民動」職員說「赤柱嗰個呢,個政綱有啲嘢想改」,他事後回想才記得為彭卓棋。
鄒家成的代表大狀陳世傑開始盤問,指新東首次會議根本沒討論否決權,而鄒沒說「用盡方法係去逼政府回應『五大訴求』」等。趙不同意。法官提問下,趙稱鄒與民主黨莊榮輝於會上,一度「企咗起身」討論。
21 Apr 2023法庭線#6342
47人案|趙家賢被何桂藍一方質疑 一度激動以英語回應 法官提醒非針對個人
The 47 pro-democracy figures’ case, in which they are charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power”, entered its 48th day of trial on Friday (the 21st). When Gwyneth Ho’s side challenged the credibility of Andrew Chiu’s testimony, saying that Chiu had put himself forward as politically moderate and so on, Chiu responded emotionally in English: “I’m not put(ting) myself forward! I just told the fact!” (I am merely stating the facts, not positioning myself.) The judge reminded Chiu that the defence was not targeting him personally. Chiu subsequently continued answering in English, saying, “I disagree.”
Ho’s side also said that Chiu had minimised his own participation and shifted responsibility to others in his testimony, questioning whether he was testifying in order to obtain a reduced sentence. Chiu denied this. In response to questions from the judge, he agreed that he knew a guilty plea could lead to a reduction and that acting as a prosecution witness might result in an additional reduction. Chiu also voluntarily mentioned that Ho had said at a meeting: “The Legislative Council has become a battleground for protest ... [I] hope to use the Legislative Council to break the deadlock in Hong Kong-mainland relations.”
Raymond Chan’s side played a clip from a live broadcast of Chan’s online programme, questioning whether Chiu had misremembered Chan’s attendance at a New Territories East meeting held at the same time. Chiu said he remembered Chan and his assistant being at the meeting venue and answered “No comment” to the defence’s questions.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周五(21 日)展開第 48 天審訊。何桂藍一方質疑趙家賢口供可信性時,指趙定位自己(put yourself forward)政見溫和等,趙激動以英語回應「I’m not put(ting) myself forward! I just told the fact!(我只是說出事實,不是定位自己)」。法官提醒趙,辯方並非針對;趙其後續以英語回答「I disagree」。
何一方又指出,趙作供時將其參與減至最低、卸責予他人等,質疑為減刑作供。趙否認,並在法官提問下同意,知道有認罪扣減,以及做控方證人或可獲額外扣減。另趙主動提及何曾於會議上說,「立法會係變咗一個抗爭陣地...希望將立法會係用作中港關係破局」。
陳志全一方則播放陳的網台節目直播片段,質疑趙記錯陳出席同一時間的新東會議,趙稱記得陳及助理身在會議場地,對辯方的提問「No comment」。
20 Apr 2023法庭線#6339
47人案|被何桂藍一方引FB帖文質疑可信性 趙家賢稱應是他人代發
The trial of 47 democrats charged with conspiracy to subvert state power entered its 47th day on Thursday (20th). Ho Kwun-lam’s side questioned Andrew Chiu’s credibility by showing, among other things, posts from his personal Facebook account. The judge expressed concern about the direction of the questioning, warning that it might have a “backfire effect” or broaden the scope of the co-conspirator principle. Ho’s side said the questioning concerned Chiu’s credibility.
Two posts shown in court included the phrases “#抗爭無退路” (“#ThereIsNoRetreatInTheProtests”), “#香港正式進入準戰爭狀態” (“#HongKongHasOfficiallyEnteredAQuasi-WarState”) and “#香港人反抗” (“#HongKongersResist”). After the defence questioned the apparently protest-oriented posts, the judge asked whether Chiu was not as moderate as he had pretended to be and directly asked whether he belonged to the local protest camp.
Chiu initially said he did not remember the relevant posts, and said he wondered in retrospect whether he had been emotional because of the turbulent political situation. He later said the posts should have been made by a Tai Koo Shing resident he had hired, as he had “absolutely no memory” of them. The hearing ended early in the afternoon because one of the defendants was unwell.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周四(20 日)展開第 47 天審訊。何桂藍一方展示趙家賢個人 Facebook 帖文等盤問,法官關注盤問方向,提醒或會引來「反效果」或擴闊共謀者原則的應用範圍。何一方則指,盤問是有關趙的可信性。
庭上展示的兩則帖文中,有「#抗爭無退路」、「#香港正式進入準戰爭狀態」及「#香港人反抗」等字眼。辯方質疑看似抗爭派的帖文,法官指辯方是問趙是否並非假裝的那樣溫和,又直接問趙是否屬本土抗爭派。
趙一度稱不記得有相關帖文,又指回想是否因政局躁動而人有情緒,其後又稱帖文應是由他聘請的太古城居民發出,因自己「完全無任何印象」。此外,因有被告身體不適,審訊下午提早結束
19 Apr 2023法庭線#6334
47人案|被何桂藍代表大狀屢質疑證供 趙家賢反問「辯方律師想我點答?」
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power entered its 46th day on Wednesday (the 19th). Trevor Beel, lead counsel for Gwyneth Ho, repeatedly challenged Andrew Chiu’s earlier testimony in court. Chiu twice asked, “How does defence counsel want me to answer?” and “Does defence counsel want to implant in my mind some perceptions that do not belong to me?” He eventually gave brief answers after questions from the judge.
Beel also cited Facebook posts about the Power for Democracy primary election crowdfunding campaign and asked Chiu three times about the phrase “resist tyranny” in the posts, including whether he supported it. Chiu denied this and said he would not use that phrase.
Chiu also said he would “absolutely not” regard Benny Tai as a close friend. He acknowledged feeling that Tai was a “troublemaker”, saying Tai’s ideas had made his work more difficult. He also admitted harbouring resentment towards Tai, which was why he had consistently referred to him as a “great thinker and great scholar”.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周三(19 日)展開第 46 天審訊。何桂藍代表大狀 Trevor Beel 展開盤問,數次質疑趙家賢早前庭上證供,趙兩度反問「辯方律師想我點答呀?」、「辯方大狀係咪想喺我個腦度,植入一啲唔屬於我嘅認知?」最後在法官提問下簡短回答。
Beel 亦引用「民主動力」初選眾籌 Facebook 帖文,3 度問趙對當中「對抗暴政」字眼的看法,包括是否支持;趙否認並指自己不會使用該字眼。
此外,趙指「絕對不會」視戴耀廷為密友,又承認有感戴為「搞事者」(troublemaker),指其想法令自己工作變得困難,亦承認對戴有怨恨(resentment),故一直稱對方為「大思想家、大學者」。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.