29 Aug 2024獨媒#3969
【立場案】陳國基指不存在限制新聞自由 視乎批評目的
The parent company of Stand News, its former editor-in-chief Chung Pui-kuen and former acting editor-in-chief Lam Siu-tong were found guilty by the District Court this afternoon of conspiracy to publish seditious publications, a verdict that was immediately widely reported by foreign media. After attending an event, Chief Secretary for Administration Eric Chan was asked about the verdict. He said the government greatly respected and valued press freedom in Hong Kong, and that there would be no restrictions on press freedom if journalists reported based on the facts. He said the media were not prohibited from criticising the government, noting that many reports continued to criticise the government every day, but that it depended on the purpose.
《立場新聞》母公司、前總編輯鍾沛權及前署任總編輯林紹桐被控「串謀發布煽動刊物」罪,區域法院今午被裁定罪名成立,迅間就被外國傳媒廣泛報導。政務司司長陳國基出席一個活動後被問到裁決一事,他指政府非常尊重和重視香港新聞自由,如果記者依事實報導,不會存在限制新聞自由。他表示傳媒並非不可以批評政府,每日仍有不少報導批評政府,惟需視乎目的。
29 Aug 2024獨媒#3972
【立場案】檢控涉案文章作者?李桂華:視乎是否具煽動意圖
Stand News was alleged to have published seditious articles. Former editor-in-chief Chung Pui-kuen and acting editor-in-chief Lam Siu-tong were found guilty today at the District Court of conspiracy to publish seditious publications. Asked whether police would investigate and take further action against the journalists and bloggers who wrote the articles, after the court found that the articles in question had seditious intent, National Security Department Chief Superintendent Li Guihua said it would depend on whether the articles had seditious intent: “As for the authors and those responsible for writing them, we will look at one thing: whether they had seditious intent in doing so. If they did, we will discuss with the Department of Justice whether prosecution is ultimately appropriate.”
《立場新聞》涉嫌發布煽動性文章,前總編輯鍾沛權及署任總編輯林紹桐今日在區域法院,被裁定串謀發布煽動刊物罪名成立。對於法庭已就涉案文章裁定具煽動意圖,警方會否就撰寫文章的記者、博客作調查及進一步行動。國安處總警司李桂華表示,會視乎文章是否有煽動意圖:「就作者,同埋嗰啲負責寫嘅人士,我哋會睇睇一樣嘢,佢哋有無煽動意圖做呢一樣嘢,如果有嘅話,我哋會同律政處商量,究極適唔適合檢控嘅情況。」
29 Aug 2024獨媒#3973
【立場案】記協:判決證香港新聞自由嚴重倒退
The two former chief editors of Stand News, Chung Pui-kuen and Lam Siu-tong, were found guilty today of conspiracy to publish seditious publications. In a statement, the Hong Kong Journalists Association said the case clearly reflected the decline of press freedom in Hong Kong. It said the Stand News case had already caused irreversible harm to Hong Kong’s journalism industry before the verdict.
《立場新聞》兩位前總編輯鍾沛權和林紹桐,今日被判串謀發布煽動刊物罪名成立。記協發聲明,指案件明確反映香港新聞自由衰落。在裁決前,立場案亦已對香港新聞業界造成不可逆轉的傷害。
8 Aug 2024法庭線#3891
《立場》案三度押後裁決 主審法官郭偉健屆退休之齡 政府延長其任期至2025年
The Stand News case, in which the news outlet is charged with conspiracy to publish seditious publications, has spanned more than two and a half years since the formal charges were brought in December 2021. After three postponements, the verdict will be delivered on the 29th of this month. Presiding District Court Judge Kwok Wai-kin reaches retirement age this year, but the District Court Ordinance provides that a judge may remain in office as necessary if a case is being heard.
According to the May 2024 Government Gazette, Chief Executive John Lee, acting under the District Court Ordinance and on the recommendation of the Judicial Officers Recommendation Commission, extended Kwok’s tenure by 18 months, from 15 May 2024 to 14 November 2025.
The Judiciary told The Witness that, generally speaking, during an extension of tenure, judges at all levels may continue to receive fringe benefits and allowances apart from their salaries, such as housing, medical and dental benefits, and children’s education allowances.
《立場新聞》被控「串謀發布煽動刊物」案,由 2021 年 12 月正式起訴至今橫跨逾 2 年半,經三度押後,將在本月 29 日裁決。主審的區院法官郭偉健今年屆退休之齡,惟《區域法院條例》訂明,如有案件正在審理,可按需要留任。
翻查 2024 年 5 月的政府憲報,特首李家超按《區域法院條例》及司法人員推薦委員會建議,延長郭的任期 18 個月,由 2024 年 5 月 15 日起至 2025 年 11 月 14 日止。
司法機構回覆《法庭線》指,一般來說各級法官在延任期間,可繼續享有除薪金外的附帶福利和津貼,例如房屋福利、醫療及牙科福利、子女教育津貼等。
24 Apr 2024法庭線#3417
《立場》被指煽動案原訂4.29裁決 第三度押後至8.30裁決
The prosecution and defence in the Stand News case, in which the outlet is charged with “conspiracy to publish seditious publications”, completed their closing submissions at the end of June 2023. The judgment was originally scheduled for October that year and was later rescheduled for November. At the defence’s request, the court was asked to consider an earlier Privy Council judgment concerning the sedition ordinance. Judge Kwok Wai-kin also wished to await the outcome of Tang Tak-chi’s sedition appeal, and the judgment was postponed to 29 April.
The Judiciary’s website now shows that the judgment has been postponed again to 2:30 p.m. on 30 August, and is expected to take 180 minutes. It is understood that both the prosecution and defence received notification from the court that Judge Kwok Wai-kin needs more time to consider the judgment.
The Stand News case, in which the outlet is charged with the offence of “conspiracy to publish seditious publications”, is the first trial since 1997 involving a media organisation charged with sedition. The trial began in October 2022 and has lasted 57 trial days; the period from the start of the trial to the latest scheduled judgment date spans nearly two years.
《立場新聞》被控「串謀發布煽動刊物」案,自控、辯雙方於 2023 年 6 月底完成結案陳詞,原定於同年 10 月裁決,其後改至 11 月裁決。因應辯方要求法庭考慮英國樞密院早前一份有關煽動條例的判詞,法官郭偉健另希望等候譚得志煽動上訴案結果,案件押後至 4 月 29 日裁決。
司法機構網頁最新顯示,案件再度押後至 8 月 30 日下午 2 時半裁決,預計需時 180 分鐘。據了解,控、辯收到法庭通知,法官郭偉健需要更多時間考慮裁決。
《立場新聞》被控「串謀發布煽動刊物罪」,為 1997 年後首宗傳媒被控煽動案的審訊,由 2022 年 10 月開審至今歷 57 日審訊,由案件開審至最新裁決日橫跨近 2 年。
28 Jun 2023法庭線#7877
《立場》被指煽動案|辯方結案:涉案文章非失實 質疑控方訂傳媒新守則 10.4裁決
The trial of Stand News, which is charged with conspiracy to publish seditious publications, entered its 56th day as both the prosecution and defence completed their closing submissions. Judge Kwok Wai-kin adjourned the case until Oct. 4 for judgment. The public gallery erupted on hearing the decision, while the two defendants were granted continued bail.
In her closing submission this afternoon, Senior Counsel Audrey Eu said the 17 articles in question were not false and did not pose any actual national security risk, stressing that Stand News had merely recorded the voice of the times. If the court accepted the defendants’ purpose, she argued, sedition would not be the only reasonable inference. Eu also questioned whether the prosecution had set out new rules for the media in its closing submission—for example, that information about “anti-China, destabilising-Hong Kong elements” could be reported but they could not be interviewed, and that relevant remarks could be quoted but not quoted in detail. She questioned the approach, saying, “I don’t even know [the rules], yet you say I breached them; it’s a bit like dying without closing one’s eyes.”
The prosecution’s closing submission also referred to Stand News’s article “Images of 100 Years of the Chinese Communist Party”, which mentioned historical events including the Great Famine. It described the content as “offending those above” and “reopening old wounds”. Eu said Stand News was criticised even for recording history, questioning whether the prosecution’s position was fair and saying the standards were difficult to apply.
《立場新聞》被控「串謀發布煽動刊物」案踏入第 56 日審訊,控辯雙方完成結案陳詞。法官郭偉健押後案件至 10 月 4 日裁決,旁聽席聞言嘩然,兩名被告續准保釋。
辯方資深大律師余若薇下午陳詞時指,涉案 17 篇文章並非失實,亦沒構成實際國安風險,強調《立場》只是記錄時代呼聲。若法庭接納被告的目的,煽動就不是唯一合理推論。余又質疑,控方在結案陳詞訂下傳媒新守則,例如「反中亂港分子」的資訊,可報道但不可訪問、相關言論可引述但不可詳盡引述,質疑「我都唔知(守則),你又話我犯咗,有啲死不閉目」。
另外,控方結案陳詞提到《立場》的「中共百年影像」文章,當中提及大饑荒等歷史事件,形容內容「以下犯上」、「揭瘡疤」。余認為,《立場》記錄歷史也被批評,質疑控方說法不公允、準則難以拿捏。
27 Jun 2023法庭線#7862
《立場》被指煽動案|控方否認雙重標準:「就算其他傳媒犯事,唔代表我唔可以告你」
The trial of Stand News, which is charged with “conspiracy to publish seditious publications”, entered its 55th day on Tuesday (the 27th). The prosecution completed its closing submissions, and the defence began its closing submissions. In response to the defence’s allegation of double standards in prosecution, arguing that Stand News had acted in the same way as other media outlets, the prosecution said that even for the same article, the publisher’s intent and the circumstances at the time had to be considered. It said: “Even if other media committed offences, that does not mean I cannot prosecute you.”
The prosecution also said that the conduct of Gwyneth Ho and people who had fled overseas harmed national security and “should not be a concern at all”. It said the government’s voice had long been in a disadvantaged position, and that opinions unfavourable to the government in the media could easily cause public misunderstanding. It cited as examples the police having given explanations regarding incidents including San Uk Ling, but said that “urban legends were passed around for a whole year, and continued even one or two years later”, while “the protesters still refused to accept it”.
In response to the defence’s claim that the prosecution had repeatedly changed the basis of the prosecution and the facts of the case, the prosecution said that as the defendants gave evidence, it could narrow or broaden the basis of the prosecution. It also said that national security risks should be assessed by the government and experts, stressing that the aim was not to prohibit political speech, but that it had to comply with the law.
《立場新聞》被控「串謀發布煽動刊物」案,周二(27 日)踏入第 55 日審訊。控方完成結案陳詞,並由辯方開始結案陳詞。就辯方質疑檢控「雙重標準」,認為《立場》與其他媒體做法相同,控方指即使是同一篇文章,都要考慮發布者意圖及當時背景等,稱「就算其他傳媒有犯事,唔代表我唔可以告你」。
控方又指,何桂藍及潛逃海外人士的行為有損國安,「根本唔應該關注」,而政府的聲音長期處於弱勢,媒對政府不利的意見容易令大眾誤會,舉例指警方曾就「新屋嶺」等事件交代,但「都市傳說傳咗整整一年,過咗一年兩年都有」、「示威者仍然係唔收貨」。
針對辯方稱控方不斷更改檢控基礎及案情,控方則認為隨被告作供,控方可以收窄或擴闊檢控基礎,又指國安風險應由政府及專家衡量,強調不是要禁制政治言論,但須符合法例。
27 Jun 2023法庭線#7867
《立場》被指煽動案|辯方結案同引「大公報案」 指須證被告煽動意圖
The trial of the case in which Stand News is charged with conspiracy to publish seditious publications entered its 55th day. After the prosecution completed its closing submissions, the defence made its submissions. Senior Counsel Audrey Eu said the “conspiracy” element of the charge was unclear, and that the conspiracy agreement between the defendants “was precisely the founding statement”. She said Stand News was fulfilling its responsibility as a news organisation, stressing that “running a newspaper does not equal committing a crime”. She also said that some people in society were emotionally unstable and “you cannot count that against us”, adding: “Do we also have to be psychologists, and stop people who are not mentally mature from reading? If you want to convict people at such a low standard, the media really cannot operate.”
On the prosecution’s reliance on the 1952 Ta Kung Pao case to argue that a sedition offence does not require proof of the defendant’s seditious intent, Eu cited the same case, saying that it specifically referred to the “state of mind of the defendant”. She argued that the prosecution had to prove the defendants’ seditious intent: “The articles themselves had no brain and no intent; if you are talking about intent, it must be the defendants’.” Eu also cited the Sheep Village case, heard by Judge Kwok Wai-kin, saying he had previously ruled that the prosecution had to prove the defendants’ intent, and that “you cannot say that because it is difficult to prove, it need not be proved.”
《立場新聞》被控「串謀發布煽動刊物」案踏入第 55 日審訊,控方完成結案陳詞,由辯方陳詞。資深大律師余若薇指,本案控罪的「串謀」元素並不清晰,又指被告之間的串謀協議「就係創刊辭」,《立場》是在履行傳媒責任,強調「辦報唔等於犯罪」。她又指,社會有人情緒不穩,不能「入我哋數」,「我哋係咪要做埋心理醫生,要心智未成熟嘅人唔好睇?你話要用咁低水平入罪嘅話,傳媒真係唔使做㗎啦」。
就控方援引 1952 年「大公報案」,指煽動罪毋須證被告有煽動意圖,余若薇引用同一案例,指當中正正提到「被告心態」,反駁指控方須證明被告煽動意圖,「文章係冇腦、冇意圖嘅,如果你講意圖,係一定講被告」。余又以法官郭偉健審理的「羊村案」為例,指他早前已裁定控方須證明被告意圖,「唔可以話好難證明就唔使證明」。
26 Jun 2023法庭線#7856
《立場》被指煽動案|控方結案引1952年大公報案 指煽動罪毋須證被告有煽動意圖
The trial of Stand News, which is accused of conspiracy to publish seditious publications, entered its 54th day. Closing submissions were originally scheduled for 19 June but were postponed until Monday (26th) after prosecution counsel Ng Suk-kuen tested positive for COVID-19. The prosecution cited several previous cases, including the 1952 Ta Kung Pao case, arguing that a sedition offence does not require proof that the defendant had seditious intent, but only that the articles in question possessed seditious intent.
The prosecution also cited an 1868 Irish case, saying that the media had influence and could cause seditious ideas to “spread like poison”. It added that, in present-day society, no medium was more effective than online media such as Stand News. She said the Hong Kong government’s proposed amendments to the sedition offence in 1996 did not mention that there had to be an intention to incite the public, reflecting the authorities’ view that it would be impossible for the prosecution to prove the defendants’ seditious intent; otherwise, it would become an offence that was “almost impossible to prosecute”. The prosecution also cited an Australian case, arguing that comments posted on social media were equivalent to being published by the media outlet.
《立場新聞》被控「串謀發布煽動刊物」案踏入第 54 日審訊,案件原定於 6 月 19 日結案陳詞,因控方伍淑娟確診新冠肺炎,押至周一(26 日)處理。控方援引多宗舊案例,包括 1952 年「大公報案」等,指煽動罪毋須證被告有煽動意圖,僅須證明涉案文章具煽動意圖。
控方另引 1868 年愛爾蘭案例指,傳媒具影響力,能令煽動想法「如毒藥般擴散」,又指放諸現今社會,沒有一個媒介比《立場新聞》這樣的網媒更有效。她提到港府於 1996 年擬修訂煽動罪,沒提及「必須有意煽動公眾」,反映當局認為控方不可能證明被告的煽動意圖,否則變成「幾乎不可檢控」罪行。另外,控方亦引用澳洲案例,指在社交媒體上的留言,等同由該傳媒發布。
23 Feb 2023法庭線#6092
《立場》被指煽動案|控方再新呈4篇《立場》文章 以推論鍾沛權意圖 辯方強烈反對
On the 14th day of the prosecution’s cross-examination of Chung Pui-kuen, questioning focused on Nathan Law’s blog article “Hong Kong – Beautiful Island”, which is part of the case. The prosecution questioned whether the article’s information was incomplete, making readers more likely to accept the author’s commentary and causing them to be misled by inaccurate information. Chung said commentaries were generally concise and polished, combining narrative and opinion. As the primary election case had not yet reached a final conclusion, the public could debate whether Law’s claims were factually grounded. In response to the prosecution’s assertion that the article’s wording clearly prompted hatred of the Central Government and Hong Kong’s judiciary, Chung said that freedom of expression should allow criticism directed at public authorities.
The prosecution also sought to introduce four more Stand News articles related to the National Security Law to infer Chung’s intention in publishing the articles. The defence objected twice, saying it had “already lost count of how many times new articles have been introduced”. Judge Kwok Wai-kin instructed Chung to read the articles after the court adjourned. The trial will continue on Friday (24th).
控方第 14 日盤問鍾沛權,圍繞涉案羅冠聰〈香港-美麗島〉的博客文章。控方質疑文章資料不全,會令人容易接受作者的評論,誤導失實。鍾沛權認為,評論文章大多簡潔精鍊,夾敘夾議,加上初選案尚未「蓋棺定論」,公眾可辯論羅的說法是否有事實根據。至於控方指文章用字明顯令人憎恨中央和本港司法,鍾沛權認為在言論自由下,應容許針對公權力的批評。
另外,控方欲新呈《立場》4 篇國安法相關文章,以推論鍾發布文章的意圖。辯方兩度反對稱「已經唔知係第幾次再入新文章」。法官郭偉健著鍾散庭後細閱文章。案件周五(24 日)續審。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.