HONG KONG · NEWS RECORDS

Search the archive

Explore news reporting in English and traditional Chinese.

Results JSON

Statistics

259matching records

of 7107 in this collection

Records over time

Monthly distribution

0
Feb 20
0
Mar 20
0
Apr 20
0
May 20
0
Jun 20
0
Jul 20
0
Aug 20
0
Sep 20
0
Oct 20
0
Nov 20
0
Dec 20
0
Jan 21
2
Feb 21
12
Mar 21
3
Apr 21
2
May 21
2
Jun 21
0
Jul 21
1
Aug 21
4
Sep 21
1
Oct 21
0
Nov 21
1
Dec 21
1
Jan 22
0
Feb 22
1
Mar 22
0
Apr 22
1
May 22
1
Jun 22
1
Jul 22
5
Aug 22
2
Sep 22
0
Oct 22
3
Nov 22
0
Dec 22
3
Jan 23
24
Feb 23
19
Mar 23
15
Apr 23
10
May 23
14
Jun 23
18
Jul 23
21
Aug 23
1
Sep 23
1
Oct 23
3
Nov 23
1
Dec 23
0
Jan 24
1
Feb 24
2
Mar 24
0
Apr 24
15
May 24
4
Jun 24
12
Jul 24
4
Aug 24
7
Sep 24
1
Oct 24
16
Nov 24
5
Dec 24
0
Jan 25
0
Feb 25
0
Mar 25
2
Apr 25
1
May 25
0
Jun 25
8
Jul 25
2
Aug 25
1
Sep 25
3
Oct 25
1
Nov 25
1
Dec 25
About this collection

14 Feb 2020 - 24 Dec 2025

English translations accompany the original Chinese records.

Results 259

47人案Clear all
Showing 11-20 of 259 recordsEN
26 Jul 2025法庭線#7099

47-Person Case Appeals: Defendants and Department of Justice Dispute Verdicts and Grounds for Excessive Sentences

47人案上訴口頭陳詞整合 被告方及律政司爭議裁決結果、刑罰過重理據為何?

In the democratic primary election case, the Court of Appeal heard, over four consecutive days in mid-July, appeals by 12 convicted defendants against their convictions and/or sentences, as well as the Department of Justice’s appeal against the acquittal of Lawrence Wai Chung Lau. The judges said they would hand down their judgment within nine months, no later than mid-April 2026. The Witness has summarised in bullet points the oral submissions concerning each defendant’s case, to make it easier for readers to understand the grounds on which the appellants argued that the trial judges had erred in their judgments, as well as the respondents’ replies. Some issues relied on written submissions and were not read out in court, and are therefore not covered. In addition to the circumstances of the individual cases, the defendants and the Department of Justice also made submissions on legal disputes, including how “unlawful means” in the provisions on the offence of subversion should be interpreted, and the circumstances in which the court should intervene in the exercise of powers by the legislature. See the reports on the first and second days of the hearing for details.

民主派初選案,上訴庭 7 月中一連四天處理罪成的 12 人就定罪及或刑罰提出上訴,以及律政司就劉偉聰無罪裁決提上訴的聆訊,法官指將在 9 個月內,即不遲於 2026 年 4 月中頒布判決。 《法庭線》以列點形式整理各被告案情相關的口頭陳詞,讓讀者容易理解上訴方指出原審法官判決錯誤的理據,以及答辯方的回應。部分議題因依賴書面陳詞,庭上未有讀出,故未有涵蓋。 除了個人案情,被告方與律政司亦分別就法律爭議陳詞,例如提出「顛覆罪」條文的「非法手段」應如何詮釋,以及法庭應在何種情況下才介入立法機關行使權力的事宜等,詳見聆訊第一日、第二日的報道。

17 Jul 2025法庭線#7054

47 Democrats Case Appeal | Defence Challenges Sentencing Tiers, Excessive Starting Points and Devastating Overall Terms; Judgment to Be Handed Down Within 9 Months

47人案上訴|被告方爭議刑罰分級、量刑起點過高、總刑期毀滅性 官9個月內頒判詞

The fourth day of the appeal hearing in the democrats’ primary election case began on Thursday (the 17th), with both sides completing their submissions on the sentencing appeals. Chief High Court Judge Poon Siu-chu said the judgment would be handed down within nine months. Chan Tsz-kit, who was released from prison earlier, attended the hearing. At the end of the hearing, Leung Kwok-hung and Lam Cheuk-ting waved to those in the public gallery, while Yeung Suet-ying smiled broadly. The defence challenged the sentencing tiers and the starting points, which it said were too high, arguing that Leung Kwok-hung, Lam Cheuk-ting and Wong Pik-wan should not have been classified as “active participants”. In particular, counsel Erik Ignatius Sze Man Shum argued forcefully that Lam and Wong had not publicly supported the plotting and had “remained almost silent”. The seven-year starting points imposed on them effectively treated their roles as equivalent to those of more radical defendants in the same case, which was an error by the trial court. The defence also challenged the mitigating factors, arguing that Chan Chi-chuen and Ho Kai-ming, who had held public office for many years, should have received greater reductions. Cheng Tat-hung’s side said his starting point should differ from that of fellow Civic Party member Jeremy Tam Man-ho. Chow Ka-shing and Prince Wong Ji-yuet were also involved in a separate riot case; their counsel said that the trial court’s ordering of the sentences to be served consecutively was a heavy blow and devastating for the two men.

民主派初選案周四(17 日)展開第四日上訴聆訊,雙方完成刑罰上訴陳詞。高院首席法官潘兆初稱將在 9 個月內頒下判決。早前出獄的岑子杰到庭旁聽;散庭時,梁國雄、林卓廷向旁聽揮手,楊雪盈則露齒笑。 被告方爭議刑罰分級、量刑起點過高,指梁國雄、林卓廷、黃碧雲不應被裁定為「積極參加者」,其中,大狀沈士文力陳,林、黃沒有公開支持謀劃、「幾乎保持沉默」,兩人面對的 7 年量刑起點,有如指他們的角色等同同案更激進的被告,原審實屬錯誤。 被告方又爭議減刑因素,如陳志全、何啟明任公職多年,應獲更多減刑;鄭達鴻一方指,其量刑起點應與同屬公民黨的譚文豪有別;鄒家成、黃子悅另涉暴動案,代表大狀指原審分期執行判刑,對兩人是沉重打擊、毀滅性。

16 Jul 2025法庭線#7051

47-person case appeal|Owen Chow and Yu Wai-ming say trial judge intervened excessively; Helena Wong and Lam Cheuk-ting say Wu Chi-wai’s remarks were wrongly applied

47人案上訴|鄒家成、余慧明指原審過度干預 黃碧雲、林卓廷指錯誤套用胡志偉言論

The third day of the appeal hearing in the democratic primary case began on Wednesday (the 16th), with the defence completing its submissions on the appeals against conviction. The legal teams for Helena Wong and Lam Cheuk-ting said the trial court had wrongly relied on remarks made by then Democratic Party chairman Wu Chi-wai at a Kowloon East forum to rule that Wong and Lam knew of the party’s position on vetoing and agreed to participate in planning. They also said there was no evidence that the Democratic Party had a unified position on vetoing. Counsel for Owen Chow and Yu Wai-ming respectively cited examples to argue that trial judge Andrew Hing Wai Chan had intervened excessively while the two gave evidence. These included publicly commenting that Chow’s testimony “had no logic” and preventing defence counsel and another judge, Chan Chung-hang, from asking Yu questions, leaving her unable to explain her views on the “five demands”. Their representatives said the defendants had the right to a fair trial. Ho Kwai-lam’s legal team said Legislative Council members had a duty to convey public opinion to the government and had also been given a mandate by the public. It asked rhetorically how a lawmaker’s conveying citizens’ legitimate demands could constitute subversion of state power. The Department of Justice made oral rebuttals to the submissions of the four defendants’ legal teams. The case will continue on Thursday, when the defence will continue making submissions on the appeals against sentence.

民主派初選案周三(16 日)展開第三日上訴聆訊,被告方已完成定罪上訴的陳詞。黃碧雲、林卓廷一方指,原審錯誤引用民主黨時任主席胡志偉在九東論壇的發言,裁斷黃碧雲、林卓廷對黨的否決立場知情,同意參與謀劃,又指沒證據顯示民主黨對否決有一致立場。 鄒家成、余慧明的代表大狀分別舉例指出,原審法官陳慶偉在兩人作供時過度干預,包括公開評論鄒的供詞「沒有邏輯」,亦阻止辯方大狀及另一法官陳仲衡擬對余提問,令她無法解釋對「五大訴求」看法。兩人代表指,被告有權獲得公平審訊。 何桂藍一方則稱,立會議員有責任向政府反映民意,亦獲民意授權,反問議員反映市民的正當訴求,何以構成顛覆政權?律政司一方則就 4 名被告方的陳詞,作口頭反駁。案件周四續,由被告方續就刑罰上訴陳詞。

15 Jul 2025法庭線#7046

47-person case appeal | Wong Pak-yu and Chan Po-ying appear in court; police cordon off media area, say it is inconvenient to let reporters “walk around”

47人案上訴|王百羽、陳寶瑩到庭 警方劃採訪區、稱不方便讓記者「行嚟行去」

In the pro-democracy primary election 47-person case, 13 convicted defendants have appealed against their convictions and sentences; the Department of Justice has also appealed against the acquittal of Lawrence Wai Chung Lau. The appeal hearing continued at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Tuesday morning (15th). At 7:30am, about 50 people were already outside the court queueing for public gallery seats. One spectator said they had previously volunteered for the League of Social Democrats and helped Lam Cheuk-ting’s election campaign, and hoped to show their support. Another spectator said they had voted in the primary, adding that if the defendants’ participation in the election was illegal, “we would also be accomplices, having authorised them to stand for election.” When reporters interviewed people in the queue, police required them to conduct the interviews in a media area marked off with orange tape and metal barriers. Reporters who subsequently entered the queue were also taken aside by police for a search of their belongings.

民主派初選 47 人案,13 名罪成被告提出定罪及刑罰上訴;在原審獲裁定無罪的劉偉聰,律政司亦提出上訴。上訴聆訊周二(15 日)早上在西九龍裁判法院續審,早上 7 時半,法院外已有約 50 人,排隊輪候公眾席。 有旁聽市民指自己曾為社民連義工,亦曾為林卓廷助選,希望可表達支持。亦有旁聽者直言自己有在初選投票,認為若被告參選違法,「我哋都係共犯、有份授權佢哋選。」記者採訪排隊人士時,被警員要求在警方以橙帶、鐵馬劃分的記者區,才可進行訪問。之後記者進入輪候隊伍,亦被警方帶到一旁搜查隨身物品。

15 Jul 2025法庭線#7047

47-defendant case appeal | DOJ: Limiting subversion to force would undermine legislative intent; defendants begin submissions on individual cases

47人案上訴|律政司:顛覆罪若僅限武力違立法目的 被告方開始就個人案情陳詞

The appeal hearing in the pro-democracy primary election case entered its second day on Tuesday (15th), with the Department of Justice responding to the defendants’ joint submissions and saying they were based on a “wrong premise”. The prosecution was not merely alleging that the defendants had failed to consider the contents of the budget, but that the entire process—from gaining control of a majority in the Legislative Council to bringing about the Chief Executive’s resignation—constituted an abuse of power. It also said the defendants’ arguments and examples were absurd. On the defendants’ argument that “unlawful means” in the offence of subversion should, under an analogous common-law principle, be limited to conduct related to the use of force and criminal acts, Deputy Director of Public Prosecutions Tianxing Zhou said the principle could not be applied. Tianxing Zhou also said the trial court’s ruling was correct, while the defendants’ interpretation was absurd, illogical and contrary to the legislative intent of the National Security Law. The hearing continued in the afternoon.

民主派初選案周二(15 日)展開第二日上訴聆訊,律政司一方回應被告方的聯合陳詞,指是「立足錯誤」,因控方不只是指控被告沒審議預算案的內容,而是由取得立法會大多數控制權至導致特首下台,整個過程才構成濫權,又指被告方的說法及舉例是荒謬。 對於被告方爭議,顛覆罪條文中的「非法手段」,在普通法的同類原則下應限於與使用武力相關及刑事行為。副刑事檢控專員周天行指,不能應用該原則,又指原審裁決正確,而被告方的詮釋是荒謬、不合邏輯、有違《國安法》立法目的。案件下午續審。

14 Jul 2025法庭線#7036

47-Person Case Appeal|Defence Says Trial Judgment Was Wrong: Lawmakers’ Rejection Was Not an Abuse of Power; Politics Should Be Decided by the Public, Not Judges

47人案上訴|被告方指原審裁決錯誤:議員否決非濫權 政治應由公眾而非法官決定

The first day of the appeal hearing in the pro-democracy primary election case began on Monday (14th), with Michael Cheuk Kei Pang confirming its withdrawal from the appeal. Regarding the acquittal of Lawrence Wai Chung Lau, the Department of Justice said the trial court had placed excessive weight on Liu’s failure to endorse “No Regrets Once the Ink Is Cast”. In his own defence, Liu reiterated that he had never advocated “five demands, not one less”, called for the Chief Executive to step down, or sought the indiscriminate rejection of budget bills. Counsel for the defendants also began making submissions, pointing to multiple errors in the trial judgment. On the phrase “unlawful means” in the offence of subversion, the defence said that the National Security Law was intended for Hong Kong citizens and ordinary people, and that “unlawful” should be limited to criminal conduct. They asked: “If ordinary people cannot understand what the provision means, how can that person regulate their own conduct?” The defence also disputed the trial court’s finding that rejecting budget bills constituted an abuse of power, saying that legislators’ powers were conferred by voters: “They exercise their powers according to their own wishes; this is not an abuse of power.” They further argued that the judiciary should not interfere with the Legislative Council’s operation or the exercise of its powers: “Politics should remain on the political stage and be decided by the public, not judges.”

民主派初選案周一(14 日)展開首日上訴聆訊,彭卓棋確認退出上訴。就劉偉聰獲裁無罪,律政司指原審過度考慮劉沒贊同〈墨落無悔〉一事。劉自辯時重申,不曾提倡「五大訴求,缺一不可」、要求特首下台,或者無差別否決預算案。 被告方各大狀亦開始陳詞,指出原審裁決多處錯誤。就顛覆罪條文的「非法手段」,被告方指《國安法》是為香港市民、普通人而設,當中「非法」應限於刑事行為,反問若一般人無法理解條文意思,「這個人又如何能夠規範自己的行為呢?」 被告方亦爭議,原審裁斷否決預算案是濫權屬錯誤,指立法會議員的權力是由選民賦予,「他們按照自己的意願行使權力,這並非濫權」;又力陳司法不應該干預立法會的運作和權力行使,「政治應留在政治舞台,由公眾決定,而非法官」。

30 May 2025法庭線#6842

47-case: Second batch of defendants released; Shum visits former district and has tea with friends; Lee and Wong noticeably slimmer

47人案|第二批被告出獄 岑子杰「落區」、偕友飲茶 李嘉達、王百羽清減

The second batch of four defendants in the 47-case—岑子杰, Roy Hoi Pong Tam, 王百羽 and 李嘉達—were released from prison on Friday (the 30th). They were driven away early in the morning in nine vehicles, all with their curtains drawn, while the police presence outside the prison was lighter than last time. Police officers stood guard near the defendants’ residences, with one officer reminding reporters not to enter private areas of the buildings. The media filmed 岑子杰 and 李嘉達 returning home, with both going upstairs alone. 岑 smiled when he got out of the car and told reporters, “Let me spend some time with my family.” About three hours later, he went out again and was interviewed downstairs. He said he had no plans to leave Hong Kong for the time being and that he had felt warmth from outside the prison walls during his imprisonment. He subsequently went to Lai Yuen, the district where he had previously been elected district councillor, to meet residents and have tea with members of the League of Social Democrats. 李嘉達 was noticeably slimmer. He wore a mask when returning home and replied “Thank you for your hard work” to reporters’ questions. 王百羽 uploaded a recent photograph to Facebook in the morning, showing that he was well-built and noticeably slimmer. As for Roy Hoi Pong Tam, he was also reportedly released and had returned to his family.

47 人案第二批 4 名被告岑子杰、譚凱邦、王百羽、李嘉達周五(30 日)出獄。他們清晨由車接載離開,共有 9 輛車,全部拉上窗簾,不過監獄外的警力較上次少。被告的住所附近有警員戒備,有警員提醒記者不要進入大廈私人地方。 傳媒拍到岑子杰、李嘉達回家的畫面,二人獨自上樓。岑下車時面露笑容,向記者稱「等我陪一陪我啲屋企人」,約 3 小時後再出門,在樓下受訪,稱暫時無意離港,繫獄時感受到牆外的溫暖。他隨後往曾當選區議員的選區瀝源,見街坊及與社民連成員飲茶。 李嘉達身型清瘦不少,回家時戴上口罩,對記者提問答「辛苦晒」。王百羽則在早上,在 Facebook 上載近照,身型健壯、清減不少。至於譚凱邦,據悉他亦已經出獄,回到家人身邊。

30 Apr 2025法庭線#6743

Court of Appeal Rules NSL Sentencing Tiers Apply to Conspiracy, Disagrees with Trial Court’s View in 47-Person Case; DOJ: No Sentence Review Sought

上訴庭裁國安法刑罰分級適用於串謀 不同意47人案原審觀點 律政司:沒提覆核

In April, the Court of Appeal dismissed the defendants’ application for leave to appeal against their sentences in the Hong Kong Independence Party case. It ruled that the sentencing tiers for offences under the National Security Law apply to conspiracy offences, and said it disagreed with the trial court’s view in the 47-person case. In the case, Au Nok-hin, Chiu Ka-yin and Chung Kam-lun were each found to be a “principal offender”. However, because the three had pleaded guilty and served as prosecution witnesses, among other factors, their sentences were reduced to between six and seven years’ imprisonment, below the 10-year minimum stipulated by the provision. The sentences of the other defendants were within the statutory minimum and maximum limits. The Court News asked the Department of Justice whether, in response to the Court of Appeal’s judgment, it had sought a review of the sentences imposed on Au Nok-hin and the other two defendants. The department replied on Monday (28th) that it had “not filed an application for sentence review”, adding that as the case had entered the appellate judicial process, it was inappropriate to comment on whether the sentences imposed were appropriate.

上訴庭 4 月駁回「香港獨立黨案」被告申請刑罰上訴許可,裁定《國安法》罪行的刑罰分級適用於串謀罪,又提及不同意 47 人案原審觀點。 該案中,區諾軒、趙家賢和鍾錦麟雖被裁定屬「首要分子」,但因 3 人認罪、出任控方證人等,獲減刑至判囚 6 至 7 年,低於條文的 10 年下限。其餘被告的刑期則在上下限之內。 《法庭線》向律政司查詢,有否因應上訴庭的判決,就區諾軒等 3 人的刑期提出覆核。律政司周一(28 日)回覆指,「沒有提出刑罰覆核申請」,又指由於案件已進入上訴司法程序,不宜就案件的判刑是否合適作任何評論。

29 Apr 2025集誌社#6741

47-person case | National security vehicles leave, preventing appearances; Correctional Services: arrangements made in response to inmates’ wishes | A review of public figures released from prison | National security case defendants and former senior officials walk out of prison

47人案.出獄|國安車走未能露面 懲教:因應在囚人意願 盤點公眾人物出獄 國安案被告、前高官自行步出監獄

At dawn on 29 April, as daylight was just breaking, multiple private cars belonging to the national security police left in three groups from Lo Wu Correctional Institution, Stanley Prison and Shek Pik Prison. Some vehicles had their curtains drawn, making it impossible to see inside. The vehicles were believed to be carrying Mao Meng-ching, Tam Man-ho, Kwok Ka-ki and Fan Kwok-wai, the first defendants in the pro-democracy primary election 47-person case to be released; police vehicles took them home one after another. The arrangements for their release differed from those for ordinary inmates. In response to an inquiry from The Collective, the Correctional Services Department said it had made appropriate arrangements taking into account factors including security and order, the inmates’ wishes, privacy and safety.

4 月 29 日清晨,剛剛天亮,多部國安警的私家車,已兵分三路,由羅湖懲教所、赤柱監獄、石壁監獄陸續駛出,部分車輛拉上了窗簾,看不見車內的情況。車內相信是民主派初選 47 人案,首批獲釋的被告毛孟靜、譚文豪、郭家麒、范國威,他們先後被警方的車輛接回家。有關的出獄安排,跟一般在囚人士有別。懲教署回覆《集誌社》查詢指,因應保安和秩序、在囚人士意願、私隱和安全等因素,作出適當安排。

19 Dec 2024法庭線#4375

47-person case | Defence appeal deadline expired Tuesday; court records and DOJ confirm 14 appeals filed by Thursday

47人案|辯方提上訴限期周二屆滿 截至周四高院紀錄、律政司確認共14人提出

In the primary-election case involving 47 pro-democracy figures, 45 defendants convicted of conspiracy to subvert state power were sentenced to between four years and two months and 10 years in prison. The deadline for the defence to appeal the convictions and sentences expired on Tuesday (the 17th). As of Thursday, High Court records showed that 14 defendants had lodged appeals. The 12 who had pleaded not guilty—鄒家成, 吳政亨, 何桂藍, 余慧明, 黃碧雲, 林卓廷, 楊雪盈, Michael Cheuk Kei Pang, 何啟明, 陳志全, 鄭達鴻 and 梁國雄—appealed against both their convictions and sentences. The two who had pleaded guilty—譚得志 and Prince Wong Ji-yuet—appealed against their sentences. The Department of Justice told The Witness on Thursday evening that it had received notices of applications for leave to appeal from the 14 defendants, concerning their convictions and/or sentences. The Judiciary’s website had not yet listed hearing dates for the appeals.

民主派初選 47 人案,45 名「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪成的被告被判囚 4 年 2 個月至 10 年。辯方提出定罪及刑罰上訴的限期,本周二(17 日)屆滿。 截至周四,高院資料顯示共 14 名被告提出上訴,包括不認罪 12 人鄒家成、吳政亨、何桂藍、余慧明、黃碧雲、林卓廷、楊雪盈、彭卓棋、何啟明、陳志全、鄭達鴻、梁國雄,他們提出定罪及刑罰上訴;以及認罪 2 人即譚得志、黃子悅,他們提出刑期上訴。 律政司周四傍晚回覆《法庭線》,確認收到上述 14 人的上訴許可申請通知書,分別就定罪及或刑罰提出上訴。司法機構網頁暫未顯示上訴的聆訊日期。

Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.