7 Oct 2022法庭線#2576
5.24 銅鑼灣|男子否認「私了」律師 辯方指警曾威脅利誘、虛構口頭招認 警全否認
During the 24 May 2020 Causeway Bay protest against the national anthem law, solicitor Tze Chin Chan was allegedly subjected to “street justice” while trying to stop protesters from damaging shops. Four men were subsequently accused of assaulting Chan. Three pleaded guilty, while the remaining man denied the charges and entered the fourth day of trial on Friday (7th). The defendant admitted in a video-recorded interview that he had assaulted Tze Chin Chan. The defence disputed that the statement was voluntary, and the court held a “trial within a trial” to determine whether the video was admissible.
When the defence cross-examined the police officer responsible for the defendant’s arrest and cautioning, it alleged that police had threatened him, saying, “Cooperate more, or we’ll arrest your girlfriend too.” It also alleged that the defendant had been strip-searched and insulted by officers. The police were said to have told the defendant, “Either I tell you the script, you admit it to me, and I’ll try talking to Sir to find a lighter charge to prosecute you with,” and to have fabricated an oral admission in the notebook.
2020 年 5 月 24 日銅鑼灣「反惡歌法大遊行」,事務律師陳子遷疑制止示威者破壞店舖時遭「私了」。事後 4 男被指襲擊陳,當中 3 人認罪,餘下一男否認控罪,周五(7 日)踏入第 4 日審訊。被告在錄影會面承認曾襲擊陳子遷。辯方爭議被告並非自願作供,法庭召開「案中案」審理影片呈堂性。
辯方盤問負責拘捕及警誡的警員時指出,警曾威脅被告「合作啲,否則拉埋你女朋友。」又指被告遭赤裸搜身,期間遭警員侮辱,而警曾告訴被告「一係咁我講個劇本畀你聽,你同我認咗佢,我試吓同阿 Sir 講,搵條再輕啲嘅控罪告你」,並在記事冊虛構口頭招認。
6 Oct 2022法庭線#2568
男子刀刺何君堯囚 9 年 官拒批上訴許可 沒致嚴重傷害不一定可減輕罪責
During the November 2019 District Council election, a man pretending to be a supporter presented flowers to pro-establishment Tuen Mun candidate Junius Ho while he was canvassing at a street booth, and stabbed him in the chest. Ho’s bodyguard was also injured. After being subdued, the man shouted, “The 721 Yuen Long attack was carried out by Junius Ho” and “Please find someone to carry on my cause and kill him.” The man earlier pleaded guilty to wounding with intent and wounding, and was sentenced to nine years in prison. He challenged the sentence on appeal, but a judge refused to grant leave to appeal.
2019 年 11 月區議會選舉,建制派屯門區候選人何君堯在街站拉票時,一名男子佯裝成支持者獻花並用刀刺何胸口,何的保鑣亦受傷。男子被制服後高叫「721 元朗襲擊係何君堯所為」、「唔該搵人繼承我嘅遺志殺咗佢」等。男子早前承認有意圖傷人罪及傷人罪,被判囚 9 年。他不服刑期申上訴,遭法官拒批上訴許可。
6 Oct 2022法庭線#2570
摩洛哥籍男子被控國慶日翌日北角侮辱國旗、區旗 准保釋至 12.1 再訊
The day after National Day this Sunday, 13 national flags and 12 regional flags were removed and thrown onto the road in North Point. Police subsequently arrested a 36-year-old Moroccan man and charged him with insulting the national flag, insulting the regional flag and criminal damage. The man appeared at Eastern Magistrates’ Courts for the first time on Thursday (6th).
本周日十一國慶翌日,北角有 13 支國旗、12 支區旗被人拆下及拋出馬路,警方事後拘捕 36 歲摩洛哥籍男子,起訴他侮辱國旗、區旗及刑事毁壞 3 罪,男子周四(6 日)在東區裁判法院首度提堂。
3 Oct 2022法庭線#2550
東涌二胡奏《願榮光》 六旬翁獲判無罪
In April 2022, a man in his sixties was accused of playing “Glory to Hong Kong” on an erhu on a Tung Chung footpath without a permit. He was charged with “playing a musical instrument without a permit”. After the magistrate earlier ruled that there was no case to answer, the decision was overturned on review. After trial, the defendant was acquitted at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Monday (the 3rd).
2022 年 4 月,六旬翁被指在東涌行人路,沒有許可用二胡演奏《願榮光歸香港》,遭票控「沒有許可證而奏玩樂器」。裁判官早前裁定他表證不成立後,自行覆核改裁成立。案件經審訊後,被告周一(3 日)於西九龍裁判法院獲判無罪。
3 Oct 2022獨媒#2553
13人槍械案 10人被控串謀謀殺警察及《反恐條例》等 所有被告正式交付高院
On the eve of the 8 December 2019 International Human Rights Day mass march, police seized firearms and weapons at guesthouses, warehouses and other locations. Thirteen people were subsequently charged, including the owner of the “3C Repair Workshop”, a “yellow shop”, and three of the “12 Hong Kong residents”. Some have been remanded in custody for nearly three years. Ten of them were charged with conspiracy to murder police officers, as well as the offence of prohibition against bombing prescribed targets under the United Nations (Anti-Terrorism Measures) Ordinance. This was the first time the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance had been used since its passage in 2002. The case came before Eastern Magistrates’ Court today (the 3rd) for its eighth hearing. Magistrate Loretta Suk Han Lau formally committed all the defendants to the High Court for further proceedings. None applied for bail, and they continued to be remanded in custody.
2019年12月8日「國際人權日大遊行」前夕,警方在民宿及貨倉等檢獲槍械武器,先後起訴13人,包括黃店「3C維修工作室」老闆及「12港人」的3人,部分人還柙近3年。其中10人遭控串謀謀殺警察,以及《聯合國(反恐怖主義措施)條例》下「對訂明標的的爆炸的禁制罪」,是次為《反恐條例》自2002年通過至今首次使用。案件今(3日)於東區裁判法院第8次提訊。裁判官劉淑嫻將所有被告正式交付到高等法院,以待處理。各人均沒有保釋申請,繼續還柙。
3 Oct 2022法庭線#2557
將軍澳景林邨法團 2021 年換屆選舉衝突 傷人罪成兩男提上訴 指事情非可合理預見
During the election for a new term of the incorporated owners of Tseung Kwan O’s King Lam Estate in July 2021, several people rushed onto the stage and a conflict broke out. Two men were accused of pushing a security guard, causing him to lose his balance and knock into firefighting equipment. His buttocks landed on glass shards on the floor, and his left buttock required two stitches. The two men were convicted of assault and on Monday (the 3rd) appealed against their convictions in the High Court.
將軍澳景林邨 2021 年 7 月舉行法團換屆選舉期間,多人衝上台起衝突。其中兩名男子被指推跌保安員,致其失平衡撞倒消防救火裝置,臀部着落地上玻璃碎,左臀需縫兩針。兩人被裁定傷人罪罪成,周一(3 日)在高等法院就定罪提上訴。
3 Oct 2022法庭線#2558
5.24 銅鑼灣|涉「私了」律師陳子遷 三男與控方達認罪協商 暴動改控非法集結
The defence said that, except for the first defendant, the other three had reached plea agreements with the prosecution. The charge of rioting was changed to unlawful assembly, and they admitted the charges of participating in an unlawful assembly and wounding with intent. After the second defendant, who had initially intended to plead not guilty, reached an agreement, the charge of possessing weapons was placed on the court file. The three men were allowed to remain on bail, and the case was adjourned to October 18 for a further hearing.
辯方指,除首被告外,其餘三人已與控方達成認罪協商,控罪由暴動改為非法集結,並承認參與非法集結及有意圖而傷人兩罪。當中原擬不認罪的次被告達協商後,其藏武罪獲存檔法庭。3 人獲准繼續保釋,押後 10 月 18 日再訊。
30 Sept 2022獨媒#2543
不滿政府推疫苗通行證 市民司法覆核許可遭拒再上訴
The Government introduced the Vaccine Pass on 24 February this year, requiring members of the public to be vaccinated against COVID-19 to enter specified premises such as shopping malls and markets. A member of the public who had not been vaccinated at the time, dissatisfied that the Government’s measures restricted his personal freedom, applied to the High Court in the same month for leave to seek judicial review and asked for the measures to be quashed. His application was dismissed, and he subsequently appealed. The appeal was heard remotely at the High Court today (30th). The applicant argued: “Give Hong Kong people back their freedom and justice, and let them decide whether to get vaccinated.” He also said whether a person had been vaccinated would affect the ease of employment, and that describing the consequence merely as causing a slight inconvenience was “an utter absurdity”. Appeal judges Au Hing-cheung and Lam Wan-ho said they would hand down their decision on a date to be fixed.
政府於今年2月24日起實施「疫苗通行證」,市民進入商場、街市等表列處所須接種新型冠狀病毒疫苗。一名當時未打疫苗的市民不滿政府措施限制其人身自由,於同月入稟高等法院申請司法覆核許可,要求撤銷措施。其申請遭駁回,他再提出上訴,今(30日)在高等法院進行遙距聆訊。申請人陳詞指:「畀返香港人一個自由同公道,決定打唔打針」,並認為有否打針會影響「就業方便程度」,若僅稱導致少許不便,是「荒天下之大謬」。上訴庭法官區慶祥及林雲浩指將會擇日裁決。
30 Sept 2022獨媒#2545
藏索帶罪成、已刑滿男生 引終院裁決上訴得直 官指脫罪純屬僥倖
On 11 November 2019, netizens launched the “three strikes”. A 17-year-old student was alleged to have possessed barbecue tongs, zip ties and other items outside the public toilet at Aldrich Bay Playground in Shau Kei Wan. In 2021, he was convicted of “possession of an instrument fit for an unlawful purpose with intent to use it for an un…”.
2019 年 11 月 11 日,網民發起「三罷」,17 歲男生被指在筲箕灣愛秩序灣遊樂場公廁外,藏有燒烤鉗、索帶等物品,2021 年被裁定「管有適合作非法用途的工具並意圖作非
29 Sept 2022法庭線#2533
兩男被指「連登」、YouTube 及 Discord 發圖 被控煽動、發布篡改國歌歌詞 還押候訊
Two men, aged 18 and 29, were accused of posting seditious statements, photographs and images on the LIHKG Discussion Forum, YouTube and Discord. They were charged separately with sedition and offences including insulting the national anthem and national flag. The two cases were heard at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Thursday (29th) before Chief Magistrate So Wai-tak.
The 18-year-old defendant was charged with one count of sedition and three other charges, including knowingly publishing altered lyrics of the national anthem. His bail application was refused and he was remanded until 4 November for further mention pending police investigation. The 29-year-old defendant was charged with one count of sedition. He made no bail application and was remanded until 27 October for further mention, also pending police investigation.
兩名 18 歲及 29 歲男子,被指在「連登討論區」、YouTube 及 Discord 平台,發布煽動陳述、相片及圖片,分別被控煽動、侮辱國歌國旗等罪,兩案周四(29 日)在西九裁判法院提堂,由總裁判官蘇惠德處理。
18 歲被告被控一項煽動罪,以及「故意發布經篡改的國歌歌詞」等另外 3 罪,申保釋被拒,還押 11 月 4 日再訊,候警調查。29 歲被告則被控一項煽動罪,沒保釋申請,還押 10 月 27 日再訊,同樣候警調查。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.