26 Aug 2022法庭線#2390
福利工作員涉轉發許智峯帖文 認煽惑投白票罪 判囚兩個月緩刑一年半
The former president of the Chinese University Students’ Union So Tsun-fung and a 58-year-old welfare worker were accused of reposting online in 2021 a post by former Legislative Council member Ted Hui advocating blank votes in that year’s Legislative Council general election. They had earlier been charged with violating the Elections (Corrupt and Illegal Conduct) Ordinance. The welfare worker pleaded guilty at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Friday (26).
中大學生會前會長蘇浚鋒及 58 歲福利工作員,被指 2021 年在網上轉載前立法會議員許智峯,倡於同年立法會換屆選舉投白票的帖文,早前被起訴違反《選舉(舞弊及非法行為)條例》。福利工作員周五(26 日)在西九龍裁判法院承認控罪。
26 Aug 2022法庭線#2391
被指用假「安心出行」入機舖 技術員獲准簽保守行為 警誡稱擔心被政府追蹤
A 35-year-old technician was accused of using a fake LeaveHomeSafe app in November 2021 to enter an arcade in Kwun Tong Plaza. He was charged with one count of wilfully supplying false information with intent to mislead a police officer. The case was mentioned again at Kwun Tong Magistrates’ Courts on Friday (26th).
The prosecution agreed to withdraw the charge and deal with the case by way of a bind-over order. Magistrate Lam Tsz-kan then ordered the defendant to enter a HK$2,000 recognisance to keep the peace and be of good behaviour for two years. According to the facts of the case, the defendant said under caution that he had used the fake app because he feared the government would track his personal data.
35 歲技術員被指 2021 年 11 月使用假「安心出行」應用程式,進入觀塘廣場的遊戲機中心,被控一項「有意圖而提供虛假資料企圖誤導警員罪」,案件周五( 26 日)在觀塘裁判法院再訊。
控方同意撤銷控罪,以簽保守行為方式處理本案。裁判官林子勤隨即下令,被告自簽 2000 元、守行為 2 年。根據案情,被告在警誡下解釋,因擔心被政府追蹤個人資料,才使用虛假的應用程式。
25 Aug 2022法庭線#2386
8.31 兩年|網媒「蛋蛋俱樂部」台長認阻差辦公等兩罪
On the second anniversary of the “8.31” incident at Prince Edward MTR station in 2021, the head of online media outlet Dan Dan Club was accused of shouting at police while livestreaming on a footpath outside the station. He was charged with obstructing a public officer and public nuisance. The case was originally scheduled to go to trial at West Kowloon Court on Thursday (the 25th). Before the trial began, the defendant changed his plea to guilty and made a personal mitigation plea, saying that he suffered from hyperthyroidism and other illnesses, had lost more than 50 pounds and was in poor health. He also said he wished to accompany his grandfather in his 80s, with whom he lived, and hoped to receive a non-custodial sentence.
2021 年港鐵太子站「8.31」事件兩周年,網媒「蛋蛋俱樂部」台長在太子站外行人路直播時,被指向警方叫囂,被控阻礙公職人員及公眾妨擾兩罪。案件原訂周四(25 日)在西九龍法院開審。被告於開審前改為認罪,並親自求情表示患甲狀腺亢進等病,消瘦超過 50 磅,健康惡劣,並欲陪伴同住八旬外公,望獲判非監禁式刑罰。
25 Aug 2022法庭線#2388
支聯會拒交資料案|控方擬再披露少於 20 項資料 官透露警曾擬要求 4 組織交資料
Chief Magistrate Lo Tak-chuen revealed that the relevant National Security Department application documents were intended for issuing notices to four organisations, including the Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China. The prosecution also confirmed that the National Security Department’s investigation report on the Alliance had not been given to the secretary and director, but said the application documents “to some extent summarised the report’s findings”. It also said it intended to disclose fewer than 20 further items of information to the defence. The case will continue next Monday (29th).
主任裁判官羅德泉透露,國安處相關申請文件是擬向支聯會等 4 個組織發出通知書。控方又確認,國安處針對支聯會的調查報告,並無交予局長和處長,但指申請文件「某程度上總結了報告結果」,又指擬進一步向辯方披露少於 20 項資料。案件下周一(29 日)續審。
24 Aug 2022法庭線#2383
岑子杰海外同性婚姻司法覆核上訴被駁回 上訴庭:若認可將違《基本法》立法原意
Jimmy Sham, a member of Rainbow Action and former convenor of the Civil Human Rights Front, lost a judicial review challenge over Hong Kong law’s non-recognition of same-sex marriages conducted overseas. Sham filed an appeal in July 2022, arguing that recognising only heterosexual marriages amounted to differential treatment, constituting discrimination and violating the right to equality. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal on Wednesday (24th), upholding the original ruling and ordering Sham to pay the legal costs.
「彩虹行動」成員、前民陣召集人岑子杰,就香港法律不承認海外同性婚姻提司法覆核敗訴。岑 2022 年 7 月提出上訴,質疑若法律只認可異性婚姻,屬於差別待遇,構成歧視、違反平等權。上訴庭周三(24 日)駁回,維持原判,並下令岑須支付訟費。
22 Aug 2022法庭線#2379
六旬翁二胡奏《願榮光》遭票控 表證不成立兼得訟費
In April 2022, a man in his sixties was accused of playing “Glory to Hong Kong” on an erhu on a footpath in Tung Chung. He was charged with “playing a musical instrument without a permit”. The case went to trial at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Monday (22nd). Acting Magistrate Tam Lap-fung ruled that there was no case to answer, and the defendant was awarded $500 in costs.
2022 年 4 月,六旬翁被指在東涌行人路,以二胡演奏《願榮光歸香港》,被票控「沒有許可證而奏玩樂器」,案件周一(22 日)在西九龍裁判法院開審。暫委裁判官談立豐裁定被告表證不成立,毋須答辯,兼得 500 元訟費。
19 Aug 2022法庭線#2372
47 人案|控方案情:被告參與四大戰線 涵議會、國際、街頭及工會
Forty-seven pro-democracy figures were charged with conspiracy to subvert state power over allegedly organising and participating in a primary election. After a year-long committal process at the High Court, Lo Tak-chuen, a judge designated under the National Security Law and the Chief Magistrate, lifted reporting restrictions on Thursday (18th), allowing the media to disclose details of the prosecution’s case.
47 名民主派人士涉組織及參與初選,被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪,歷經一年的高院交付程序,周四(18日)獲《國安法》指定法官、主任裁判官羅德泉解除報道限制,傳媒可披露控方案情。
19 Aug 2022法庭線#2373
消防員非法集結脫罪 律政司訟費上訴得直 法官禁穿「旁觀有罪」T 恤旁聽
During the “blossoming across eight districts” events on 10 November 2019, a firefighter was charged with unlawful assembly in Mong Kok and using a masked object. He was acquitted in 2021 and awarded costs. On Friday (the 19th), the Department of Justice appealed against the costs order. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal on the same day, but disagreed with part of the reasoning and will issue written reasons within six months.
Before adjourning, Court of Appeal Justice Pang Wai-cheong pointed out that a spectator was wearing a black T-shirt bearing the four Chinese characters “旁觀有罪” in white on the front. The spectator explained that they were the title of a song. Justice Pang said the court was not a platform for political propaganda, and all three judges considered “旁觀有罪” to have political implications and that it could be understood as satirising certain prosecutions. He said it was inappropriate to wear the T-shirt while attending a court hearing.
2019 年 11 月 10 日「八區開花」,一名消防員被控在旺角非法集結及使用蒙面物品兩罪, 2021 年被裁定罪名不成立,並獲批訟費。律政司周五(19 日)就訟費命令上訴,上訴庭即日裁定得直,惟不同意部分理據,將於 6 個月內頒布書面理由。
上訴庭法官彭偉昌於散庭前指出,一名旁聽人士身穿黑色、胸前有白色「旁觀有罪」4 字的 T 恤。該人解釋指是歌曲名稱。彭偉昌指法院不是政治宣傳的平台,而 3 名法官均認為「旁觀有罪」有政治含義,或可理解為對某類檢控作出諷刺,不適合在法庭旁聽時穿着。
18 Aug 2022獨媒#2368
李家超遲交選舉廣告同意書 法官批准豁免刑罰 須付逾6萬元訟費
Chief Executive John Lee filed an application with the High Court in June this year, admitting that during his candidacy he had, on three occasions, failed to submit on time three consent forms from relevant persons in election advertisements, as required by the statutory requirements of the Electoral Affairs Commission, and applied to be exempted from punishment. A hearing was held at the High Court this morning (18th), but Lee did not appear. Judge Au-Yeung Kwai-yue issued a written decision in the afternoon, saying the breaches arose from negligence and did not give rise to doubts about any improper intentions on the part of Lee or his campaign team. They also promptly submitted the forms late, with the delay lasting only two to three working days, which was relatively short, and Lee had gained no benefit from the matter. The judge further described Lee’s attitude as sincere and ultimately approved an exemption from the penalty for the breaches.
特首李家超今年6月入稟高等法院,承認在參選期間三度無按照選管會的法定要求,依時呈交三份選舉廣告中相關人士的支持同意書,並向法庭申請豁免刑罰。高院今早(18日)進行聆訊,惟李家超未有現身。法官歐陽桂如下午頒布書面決定,指是次違規乃源於疏忽,並未使人懷疑李及其競選團隊有不良企圖,他們亦迅速補交同意書,延誤時間僅2至3個工作天,相對較短,李並未有從中獲取任何利益。法官更形容李態度誠懇,最終批准豁免是次違規的刑罰。
18 Aug 2022獨媒#2369
【初選47人案】長達139頁案情曝光 指戴耀廷5人為「組織者」 趙家賢個別行為無另闢一節
Forty-seven people were charged with conspiracy to subvert state power for organising and participating in the pro-democracy primary election. Twenty-nine pleaded guilty and 18 pleaded not guilty. In the first conspiracy-to-subvert-state-power case, the prosecution’s case comprises 414 paragraphs and runs to 139 pages. It alleges that the defendants organised and took part in the primary to secure a majority of seats in the Legislative Council, and then veto the budget to paralyse the Hong Kong government’s operations, thereby implementing the “laam chau” plan advocated by Dai Yaoting. Dai Yaoting, Au Nok-hin, Chiu Ka-yin, Chung Kam-lun and Ng Ching-hang were identified as the five organisers of the primary, while the other 41 were participants. Power for Democracy provided a support platform. The case details revealed that the Hong Kong Public Opinion Research Institute, which provided technical support, was searched by police. After discussions among four people including Dai Yaoting, Power for Democracy deputy convenor Chung Kam-lun said the primary should proceed according to the original plan wherever feasible.
47人涉組織及參與民主派初選,被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪,29人認罪,18人不認罪。首宗串謀顛覆國家政權案,控方案情有414段,長139頁,指眾被告舉辦及參與初選以取得立法會過半議席,繼而否決財政預算案以癱瘓港府運作,實現戴耀廷提倡的「攬炒」計劃。當中戴耀廷、區諾軒、趙家賢、鍾錦麟和吳政亨5人被指為初選組織者,其餘41人則為參與者,「民主動力」提供支援平台。案情透露,提供技術支援的香港民意研究所被警方搜查,戴耀廷4人討論後,民主動力副召集人鍾錦麟曾指在可行情況下,初選都應按原定計劃進行。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.