18 Aug 2022法庭線#2370
47 人案|何桂藍等 4 人申解除報道限制 羅德泉下令解除 為國安法第二案獲解限制
The 47 pro-democracy figures were charged with conspiracy to subvert state power over organising and participating in a primary election. More than a year and a half has passed since they were charged, and the committal proceedings to the High Court were completed in July this year. Four defendants—Gwyneth Ho, Tiffany Yuen, Ventus Lau and Ng Ching-hang—had earlier applied to lift reporting restrictions on the committal proceedings. On Thursday (18th), Law Tak-chuen, a designated judge under the National Security Law and Chief Magistrate, ordered that the restrictions be lifted, with the order taking effect from the date of the case’s first mention. This is the second National Security Law case to have the relevant restrictions lifted, following the Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China case on Wednesday.
47 名民主派人士涉組織及參與初選,被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪,由檢控起計至今逾 1 年半,今年 7 月完成交付高院程序。4 名被告包括何桂藍、袁嘉蔚、劉頴匡及吳政亨,早前申請解除交付程序的報道限制,周四(18 日)獲《國安法》指定法官、主任裁判官羅德泉下令解除,時效由案件首次提訊日起計,是繼本周三支聯會案後,第二宗國安法案件獲解除有關限制。
17 Aug 2022獨媒#2365
官正式解除87A報導限制、下令鄒幸彤初級偵訊公開進行
Chow Hang-tung, former vice-chairwoman of the dissolved Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China, was refused an application to lift reporting restrictions in the case in which the Alliance is accused of inciting subversion of state power. She then successfully brought a judicial review in the High Court. The High Court overturned the decision of Law Tak-chuen, the national security law-designated judge and chief magistrate, and ordered him to lift the restrictions at the next hearing in accordance with the law. When the case was mentioned at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts today (17th), Law said that, under the High Court’s judgment, lifting the Section 87A restrictions was now a fait accompli. He ordered the reporting restrictions lifted, with effect from the date of the first hearing on 14 February.
已解散的支聯會被指煽動顛覆國家政權案,前副主席鄒幸彤申請解除報導限制遭拒,入稟高等法院提司法覆核勝訴。高院頒令推翻國安法指定法官、主任裁判官羅德泉的決定,要求他須在下次提訊按規定解除限制。案件今(17日)於西九龍法院提堂,羅德泉稱根據高院判決,87A限制要解除已成事實,下令解除報導限制,並由2月14日首次提訊當天生效。
17 Aug 2022獨媒#2366
初選47人案不設陪審團 律政司:絕無減損被告權益
It is understood that defendants in the pro-democracy camp primary election case have been notified one after another that the case will be tried without a jury. The reason is that the case involves “external factors” and the personal safety of jurors and their families must be protected. The case will be heard by three judges designated under the National Security Law. The Department of Justice said it would not comment on individual cases. The Secretary for Justice will, in accordance with the law and the circumstances of the case, consider whether to direct that the proceedings need not have a jury, stressing that the arrangement is to “ensure a fair trial” and “absolutely does not diminish any lawful rights of the defendants”.
據了解,民主派初選案的被告已陸續收到通知,初選案將不設陪審團審訊,原因是案件有「涉外因素」,需保障陪審員及其家人的人身安全,案件將由3名國安法指定法官審理。律政司回覆稱不評論個別案件,律政司司長會按法律和案件,考慮是否指示訴訟毋須設有陪審團,強調安排是「確保公平審訊」,「絕無減損被告人的任何合法權益」。
17 Aug 2022獨媒#2367
兩暴動案脫罪 律政司就13人提上訴 9人已離港
Eight people, including Chan Hung-sau, were acquitted of rioting in the 31 August 2019 Wan Chai riot case, while six people in a case involving protest items concealed in a short-term rental unit were acquitted of conspiracy to riot. The Department of Justice has appealed the acquittals of a total of 13 people in the two cases by way of case stated. It is understood that nine people in the two cases have left Hong Kong, meaning the Department of Justice was unable to serve the notices of appeal on the defendants. The High Court’s Court of Appeal heard the matter today (17th). Appeal judges Pang Wai-cheong, Poon Man-ki and Pang Po-kam directed the Department of Justice to seek the assistance of an amicus curiae to deal with the current situation. The matter will not be heard again until no earlier than four months later, during which written submissions must be prepared.
2019年8.31灣仔暴動案陳虹秀等8人,以及短租單位藏示威物品案6人,皆分別獲裁定暴動及串謀暴動罪不成立,律政司就兩案共13人的無罪裁決,以案件呈述方式提出上訴。據悉兩案合共9人已離港,故律政司未能把上訴通知書送達被告。高院上訴庭今(17日)進行聆訊,上訴庭法官彭偉昌、潘敏琦和彭寶琴指示律政司尋求「法庭之友」協助,以處理目前情況,將不早於4個月後再聆訊,期間須準備陳詞。
16 Aug 2022法庭線#2364
青年夥「健仔」失聯逾 1 年半被捕 涉違感化令 改判入戒毒所
In July 2022, police arrested four youths, including Tsang Chi-kin, in Sai Kung. All were defendants in an anti-extradition bill case and were suspected of hiding for more than a year and a half. Twenty-one-year-old Wong Hoi-ming had been sentenced to a 12-month probation order in another criminal damage case. He was accused of failing to contact his probation officer as required and using cannabis while in hiding, thereby breaching the probation order. He was brought to Eastern Magistrates’ Courts on Tuesday (16th) and sentenced to a drug rehabilitation centre.
2022 年 7 月,警方在西貢拘捕「健仔」曾志健等 4 名青年,同為反修例案被告,涉嫌匿藏逾一年半。其中 21 歲男生王愷銘,在另一刑事損壞案被判 12 個月感化令,被指匿藏期間沒依時聯絡感化官、吸食大麻,違反感化令,周二(16日)被押往東區裁判法院,改判入戒毒所。
15 Aug 2022獨媒#2358
「爆眼教師」楊子俊承認兩項非法集結 判囚9個月 官指受傷雖遺憾但非減刑理由
Former Diocesan Girls’ School liberal studies teacher Yeung Tze-chun was injured when a police bullet struck his right eye during the 12 June 2019 clashes, impairing his vision. Nearly three years later, he was charged with two counts of unlawful assembly and pleaded guilty at Eastern Magistrates’ Court this afternoon. In mitigation, the defence said Yeung Tze-chun had borne the consequences for three years: the incident caused him to lose his sight and teaching job. However, Yang did not give up and instead began running a publishing house, believing that education and writing could benefit the next generation, and helping others through his publishing work. In sentencing, Chief Magistrate Ada Shun Yee Yim said that although Yang’s efforts over the three years were acknowledged, the number of protesters that day and the length of his participation in the unlawful assembly were aggravating factors. The magistrate said “moving metal barricades” had “obviously encouraged others to commit violent acts”. The injury was regrettable but was not a valid mitigating factor, and Yang was sentenced to nine months’ imprisonment.
前拔萃女書院通識科教師楊子俊,於2019年6.12衝突中被警方子彈擊中右眼受傷,致視力受損。事隔近3年,他被起訴兩項非法集結罪,今午在東區裁判法院承認控罪。辯方求情指楊子俊三年間一直承受後果,當天事件導致他失明並失去教職,惟楊沒有放棄,轉為經營出版社,相信教育和文字造福下一代 ,以出版社工作幫助別人。主任裁判官嚴舜儀判刑則指,雖肯定楊三年間的努力,惟認為當天示威者人數多、楊參與非法參結的時間長,「搬鐵馬」是「顯然激發他人暴力行為」;又指他受傷雖令人遺憾,惟不是有效求情理由,判處他九個月監禁。
12 Aug 2022法庭線#2345
9.29 旺角|25 歲工程師認管鐳射筆判囚 140 日 官:保釋期間犯案須加刑
Magistrate Si Cho-yiu said in sentencing that, as the defendant had earlier been involved in another social movement-related case and was sentenced to five months’ imprisonment days ago, he decided to add 30 days after taking into account that the defendant committed the present offence while on bail in that case. The total sentence was 140 days. The magistrate exercised discretion to order part of the sentence to run concurrently, and the defendant ultimately received an additional 125 days in prison.
裁判官施祖堯判刑指,由於他早前牽涉另一宗社運案件,日前被判囚 5 個月,考慮到他在該案保釋期間干犯本案,決定加刑 30 天,總刑期為 140 日。裁判官酌情批准部分刑罰同期執行,被告最終加監 125 天。
12 Aug 2022獨媒#2346
運輸工稱遭警無理襲擊受傷 索償敗訴須付訟費 官:證供不可信
On 3 August 2019, netizens launched the “Mong Kok March Again”, and the protest developed into clashes in multiple districts. Police cleared Mong Kok that evening. A 50-year-old transport worker said he was unreasonably assaulted while on his way to eat at a restaurant, causing an injury to his left ankle. Three years ago, he filed a civil claim against the police in the District Court, seeking total compensation of HK$1.64 million. The parties made their closing submissions at the District Court today (the 12th). Judge Ko King-chiu dismissed the claim in a same-day ruling, finding the plaintiff’s testimony unreliable, and ordered him to pay the defendants’ legal costs.
2019年8月3日,網民發起「旺角再遊行」,示威演變成多區衝突事件。警方晚上在旺角清場,50歲運輸工稱前往餐廳用膳期間遭無理襲擊,導致左腳踝受傷,3年前入稟區域法院向警方提出民事索償,追討合共164萬賠償。雙方今(12日)於區院作結案陳詞,法官高勁修即日宣判,指原告人證供不可信,駁回他的申索,並下令他向被告支付訟費。
12 Aug 2022法庭線#2347
理大衝突|首人認「突圍而出」 20 歲女生認兩暴動罪 官促政府修例賦更大酌情權判刑
The judge also urged the government to amend the law to give courts greater discretion when sentencing defendants aged 16 to 20 facing riot charges. If the law were amended as suggested, courts would be able to impose imprisonment directly without requesting reports.
此外,法官促政府修例,讓法庭處理面對暴動罪的 16 至 20 歲被告時,在判刑有更大酌情權。若按其建議修例,法庭將可在不索取報告下,直接判監。
12 Aug 2022法庭線#2348
11.18 理大衝突|20 歲男生涉搶犯 認暴動判入教導所 官:案發猶如戰場
On November 18, 2019, police surrounded Hong Kong Polytechnic University, while members of the public gathered around the Hong Kong Science Museum in Tsim Sha Tsui to support protesters trapped inside the campus. The man, who was 18 at the time, was involved in “snatching a suspect” outside PolyU. He earlier pleaded guilty to one count of riot and was sentenced to a training centre at the District Court on Friday (the 12th).
2019 年 11 月 18 日,警方圍堵理工大學,巿民在尖沙咀科學館一帶,聲援被困校內的示威者。案發時 18 歲男生,涉於理大門外「搶犯」,早前承認一項暴動罪,周五(12 日)在區域法院被判入教導所。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.