5 Aug 2022獨媒#2297
彭卓棋申更改保釋條件 獲法官批准
Forty-seven pro-democracy figures who took part in the primary election were charged with conspiracy to subvert state power. One of the defendants, Michael Cheuk Kei Pang, was granted bail last March. More than a year later, Michael Cheuk Kei Pang applied to the High Court today (the 5th) to vary the bail conditions. The prosecution said it had no objection, and Andrew Hing Wai Chan, the National Security Law-designated judge, ultimately approved the application.
47名參與初選的民主派人士被控串謀顛覆國家政權罪,被告之一彭卓棋在去年3月獲准保釋外出。事隔逾一年,彭今(5日)向高等法院申請更改保釋條件,控方表示不反對下,《國安法》指定法官陳慶偉最終批准相關申請。
5 Aug 2022獨媒#2298
網媒「FreeHK」記者「姜牧師」阻差辦公罪不成立 官批兩警證供有矛盾分歧
On 1 July last year, after police rejected an application for a procession and maintained a security presence in Causeway Bay, “Keung Ka Wai” Keung Ka Wai, who described himself as a reporter for the online media outlet “FreeHK”, was arrested while livestreaming. He was subsequently charged with one count of obstructing a police officer in the execution of his duty. During the earlier trial, an inspector involved in the case said the defendant had held a selfie stick and obstructed a body search. Magistrate LEUNG Ka-kie ruled today (the 5th) that the two officers involved had only asked the defendant to stop filming and had never told him that the selfie stick constituted an obstruction. Their evidence also contained contradictions and discrepancies. The magistrate further said that footage showed the defendant had been cooperative at the time and had not deliberately intended to obstruct the officers, and found him not guilty.
去年7月1日警方拒絕遊行申請,並於銅鑼灣戒備,自稱為網媒「FreeHK」記者的「姜牧師」姜嘉偉當日直播時被捕,事後被控一項「阻差辦公」罪,早前審訊時涉案督察稱被告手持自拍棍妨礙搜身。裁判官梁嘉琪今(5日)裁決指,兩名涉案警員僅要求被告停止拍攝,從未向被告指出自拍棍構成妨礙,二人證供亦有矛盾分歧。梁官又指,片中可見被告案發時表現合作,沒有刻意阻礙的意圖,裁定他罪名不成立。
5 Aug 2022法庭線#2302
稱怕被人追蹤用假「安心出行」 18 歲男認企圖誤導警員 判 160 小時社服令
In December 2021, an 18-year-old man was accused of using a fake LeaveHomeSafe app at an arcade in Mong Kok. He said under caution that he was “afraid of being tracked”. After earlier pleading guilty to one count of attempting to mislead a police officer, he was sentenced to 160 hours of community service at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Friday (the 5th). Magistrate Veronica Shuk Han Heung said the defendant was still young and deserved to be given one chance.
2021 年 12 月,18 歲男子被指在旺角機舖使用假「安心出行」程式,警誡下稱「怕俾人追蹤」,早前承認一項企圖誤導警員罪,周五(5 日)在西九龍裁判法院被判 160 小時社會服務令。裁判官香淑嫻指,考慮被告年紀尚輕,值得給予一次機會。
3 Aug 2022獨媒#2294
馬俊文煽動罪囚5年9個月上訴 高院指原審官判刑過重 減刑9個月改判5年
Ma Chun-man, known as the “Second-generation Captain America”, was accused of repeatedly shouting slogans advocating Hong Kong independence in public two years ago. He denied the National Security Law charge of “inciting others to secede” but was convicted after a trial in the District Court and sentenced to five years and nine months in prison. He is currently serving his sentence. He earlier applied to the High Court to appeal against the term, in the first sentencing case under the National Security Law to be handled by the Court of Appeal. The High Court’s Court of Appeal ruled today (the 3rd) that his appeal was allowed, reducing his sentence by nine months to five years. The judges said the original trial judge, Chan Kwong-chi, had adopted an excessive six-year starting point for sentencing. Although the circumstances of the case were serious, the appellant’s culpability was relatively low and the sentence should be closer to the five-year minimum standard.
人稱「第二代美國隊長」的馬俊文被指前年多次在公眾場合叫喊港獨口號,他否認《國安法》的「煽動他人分裂國家」罪,於區域法院審訊後罪成,判監5年9個月,現正服刑。他早前向高等法院申請刑期上訴,為首宗上訴庭處理的《國安法》判刑案件。高院上訴庭今(3日)裁定他上訴得直,減刑9個月,改判5年。高院法官指原審法官陳廣池以6年為量刑起點過重,雖然本案情節嚴重,但上訴人刑責相對較輕,應貼近5年最低標準。
2 Aug 2022獨媒#2291
鄒幸彤司法覆核勝訴 高院頒令須解除支聯會案報導限制
In the case alleging that the dissolved Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China incited subversion of state power, former vice-chairwoman Chow Hang-tung had applied under Section 87A of the Magistrates Ordinance to lift reporting restrictions on the committal proceedings, but was refused by Chief Magistrate Victor So Wai-tak, a designated national security law judge. She filed for judicial review in the High Court in May, seeking an order quashing the decision and requiring So Wai-tak to lift the reporting restrictions.
已解散的支聯會被指煽動顛覆國家政權案,前副主席鄒幸彤曾按《裁判官條例》第87A條,申請解除交付程序報導限制,但遭《國安法》指定法官、主任裁判官羅德泉拒絕。她於5月入稟高等法院提司法覆核,要求法庭頒令推翻決定並要求羅德泉解除報導限制。
29 Jul 2022獨媒#2283
6人事隔近3年被控非法集結 兩男認罪還柙候判 杜汶澤創辦的「喱DAO女團」四強成員申請離港一個月被拒
On 29 September 2019, protesters gathered outside Mong Kok Police Station, where clashes between police and protesters occurred. Nearly three years later, four men and two women were charged with five offences, including unlawful assembly and assaulting police. The case was relisted at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts today (29th). Two male defendants pleaded guilty and were remanded until 12 August for sentencing. One of them is also involved in another protest case scheduled for sentencing on 10 August. Three others applied to adjourn their trial until 3 October so that the defendants could obtain medical reports and discuss the case with the prosecution. An application by 18-year-old female student Liu Lok-yee, who had originally been barred from leaving Hong Kong, to leave Hong Kong for one month was refused by Magistrate Sze Cho-yiu. Online information shows that the student is one of the four finalists of the “Lai DAO girl group” founded by Chapman To. According to the group’s website, the girl group will travel to South Korea for training.
2019年9月29日,有示威者在旺角警署外集結,發生警民衝突。事隔近3年,4男2女被控非法集結及襲警等5罪,案件今(29日)於西九龍法院再提堂。兩名男被告承認控罪,還柙至8月12日判刑,其中一人牽涉的另一宗示威案件將於同月10日判刑。另外3人申請押後至10月3日訊,以待被告索取醫療報告及與控方商討。原本不准離港的18歲女學生廖樂兒申請離港一個月,遭裁判官施祖堯拒絕。翻查網上資料,該女學生為杜汶澤創辦的「喱DAO女團」四強成員之一。據網頁顯示,女團將前往韓國受訓。
28 Jul 2022獨媒#2275
前沙田區議員李志宏擾亂秩序罪成 判囚7個月 申保釋候上訴遭拒
On 24 May the year before last, large numbers of people marched in Wan Chai and Causeway Bay on Hong Kong Island to protest the National Anthem Law and the National Security Law. Former Sha Tin district councillor Zhihong (1967) Li was subsequently charged with “creating a disturbance or disorderly conduct in a public place”. He was earlier convicted at the Eastern Magistrates’ Courts and was sentenced today (the 28th) to seven months’ imprisonment. Magistrate Lau Yee-wan said the case was serious. She said that several people dissatisfied with the police had already gathered at the scene, and considered that the defendant’s conduct would cause those present to “join in, shout and hurl abuse”. She also said the court had a duty to protect the police in carrying out their task of maintaining social order. The defence applied for bail pending an appeal, but the application was refused by Magistrate Lau, and Lee Sui was taken into custody immediately.
前年5月24日,大批市民在港島灣仔和銅鑼灣遊行,抗議《國歌法》及《國安法》,前沙田區議員李志宏事後被控「在公眾地方作出喧嘩或擾亂秩序的行為」罪。他早前在東區裁判法院被裁定罪成,今(28日)被判監7個月。裁判官劉綺雲指本案案情嚴重,案發時已有多名不滿警方人士聚集,認為被告的行為會使在場人士「附和、叫囂及咒罵」,並指法庭有責任保護警方執行維持社會秩序的任務。辯方替被告申請保釋以等候上訴,遭劉官拒絕,李須即時服刑。
28 Jul 2022法庭線#2279
補習老師扔國旗入垃圾桶 侮辱國旗罪成判囚 4 月
On July 1 last year, a 23-year-old part-time tutorial teacher was accused of pulling down three national flags erected by the roadside in Wong Tai Sin and throwing them into a rubbish bin. He was earlier convicted of one count of insulting the national flag and was sentenced to four months’ imprisonment at Kowloon City Magistrates’ Courts on Thursday (28th).
去年 7 月 1 日,23 歲兼職補習老師被指將豎立在黃大仙路旁的 3 幅國旗扯下,扔進垃圾桶。他早前被裁定一項侮辱國旗罪成,周四( 28 日)於九龍城裁判法院被判囚 4 個月。
26 Jul 2022獨媒#2268
裁判官吳重儀下令襲警教師還柙小欖 專責小組指「錯誤行使司法權力」惟投訴不成立
The Judiciary announced today (26th) the results of investigations into three public complaints against magistrates. A panel of specialist judges found that none of the three complaints was substantiated. One concerned magistrate Debbie Chung Yee Ng of Fanling Court and the handling of a case involving primary school teacher Yeung Pak-man, who had assaulted a police officer. The complaint alleged that, after finding the defendant guilty, the magistrate questioned his mental state, ordered a psychiatric report and remanded him to Siu Lam Psychiatric Centre. The panel said it “strongly disagreed” with the magistrate’s actions, which were clearly a “wrong exercise of judicial power”, placed considerable pressure on the defendant and fell short of the high standard she should have met when sentencing. It nevertheless found that the complaint was not substantiated.
司法機構今(26日)公布3宗公眾針對裁判官作出投訴的調查報告結果,專責法官小組裁定3宗投訴均不成立。其中一宗涉及粉嶺法院裁判官吳重儀處理小學教師楊博文襲警的案件,投訴指吳官裁定被告罪成後,質疑其心智,並下令索取其精神科報告及還柙小欖精神病治療中心。專責小組表示「極不認同」裁判官做法,顯然是「錯誤行使司法權力」,對被告構成沉重壓力,亦未能合乎她判刑時應達到的高水平,但最後裁定這項投訴不成立。
25 Jul 2022獨媒#2261
涉寄恐嚇信予律政司司長 41歲女子被控刑事恐嚇罪 留院中未能出庭
A 41-year-old woman allegedly mailed a threatening letter this month to the mail receiving and dispatch section of the Justice Place, reportedly threatening Secretary for Justice Paul Lam Ting-kwok. She was charged with one count of criminal intimidation and appeared at the Eastern Magistrates’ Court today (25th) for the first time. The prosecution said the defendant was currently hospitalised and unable to attend court, and applied for an adjournment. On the prosecution’s application, Chief Magistrate Ada Shun Yee Yim adjourned the case until 29 July, or until the defendant is discharged from hospital, for a further hearing. In the meantime, the defendant was placed in police custody.
41歲女子涉於本月郵寄恐嚇信到律政中心收發組,疑恐嚇律政司司長林定國。女子被控一項刑事恐嚇罪,今(25日)於東區裁判法院首次提堂。控方指被告目前正留院,未能到庭,因此申請押後。主任裁判官嚴舜儀應控方申請,押後至7月29日,或待被告出院後再訊,期間被告交由警方看管。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.