3 May 2022獨媒#1959
【初選47人案】黃子悅准保釋 官判詞指為保程序公正不能詳列理由
Prince Wong Ji-yuet, one of the defendants in the Primary Election 47 case, was granted bail after applying to the High Court on the winter solstice last year. More than four months later, national security law-designated judge Esther Toh issued written reasons today. The judgment cited the Department of Justice’s allegations that, during the primary election and after the postponement of the Legislative Council election, Prince Wong Ji-yuet continued to maintain a stance of resisting the authorities and to create unfounded fears about the National Security Law, such as suggesting that Hong Kong people’s freedoms would further disappear as if concentration camps had been established in Xinjiang. It also alleged that she made unreasonable accusations against Hong Kong law-enforcement agencies on Twitter, where she had 32,000 followers. Prince Wong Ji-yuet’s side stressed that she had never called for international sanctions or advocated Hong Kong independence, and that she had focused on completing her visual studies degree at Lingnan University, with the hope of becoming an art therapist in the future. Judge Esther Toh accepted that Wong would not continue to engage in conduct endangering national security and granted bail, but said she would not provide specific reasons in order to safeguard the fairness of the trial proceedings.
初選47人案被告之一的黃子悅,去年冬至向高等法院申請保釋獲批,國安法指定法官杜麗冰事隔逾4個月今頒下書面理由。判詞中詳引律政司指控,指黃子悅於初選期間和立法會選舉延期後,仍堅持反抗政權立場、製造對《國安法》無根據的恐懼,如指香港人的自由會如新疆設集中營般進一步消失,並在有3.2萬追隨者的Twitter進行對香港執法機構不合理的指控。黃子悅一方則強調,她從無要求國際制裁和提倡香港獨立,且把重心放在完成嶺南大學視覺研究學位,望日後成為一名藝術治療師。法官杜麗冰信納黃不會繼續進行危害國家安全的行為,遂批出保釋,惟指為保障審訊程序公正性,沒有提供具體理由。
30 Mar 2022獨媒#1893
10.1灣仔 事隔2年半13人被控暴動等罪 獲准保釋待轉介區院訊
On October 1, 2019, large numbers of protesters gathered in Wan Chai, where roads were blocked and fires were set in several locations. Police had earlier arrested 57 people, who were subsequently released unconditionally. Two and a half years later, police yesterday rearrested 13 of the men. Twelve were charged with rioting, while some faced additional charges including possession of ammunition without a licence and possession of offensive weapons. They were brought to Eastern Magistrates’ Court today (the 30th). At the prosecution’s request, the magistrate adjourned the two cases to June 21 and May 24 respectively, pending preparation of documents for transfer to the District Court. All defendants were granted bail of between HK$5,000 and HK$30,000 in cash, and were required to surrender their travel documents and not leave Hong Kong.
2019年10月1日,大批示威者於灣仔一帶聚集,期間多處有堵路及縱火等,警方早前拘捕57人,被捕人其後「踢保」。事隔兩年半,警方昨重新拘捕其中13名男子,其中12人被控暴動罪,部分人被加控無牌管有彈藥及管有攻擊性武器等罪,他們今(30日)被押解往東區裁判法院提堂。裁判官應控方申請,將兩案分別押後至6月21日及5月24日,以待準備轉介往區域法院的文件。所有被告獲准以現金5千至3萬元保釋,並須交出旅遊證件及不得離港。
29 Mar 2022獨媒#1889
無家者財物被當垃圾丟棄 小額庭判康文署敗訴 象徵式賠100元
During the winter solstice period in 2019, a group of homeless people sleeping on Tung Chau Street in Sham Shui Po were driven away by the Leisure and Cultural Services Department (LCSD), together with more than a dozen riot police officers, on the grounds of combating crime. The belongings of 70 homeless people were thrown away as rubbish. Fourteen of them sought justice and, the year before last, filed claims with the Small Claims Tribunal against the Government for between $2,000 and $13,000 each. After one year and nine months, the case was decided today. The tribunal ruled against the LCSD, but awarded symbolic compensation of $100 because the homeless claimants were unable to prove the value of their belongings. Of the 14 original claimants, two died before hearing that they had won and four could no longer be contacted. The homeless people who appeared in court said: “The amount of compensation is not the issue; we want justice.”
一批在深水埗通州街露宿的無家者,在2019年冬至期間,被康文署夥同十多名防暴警員以「滅罪」為由驅趕,70名無家者的家當被當垃圾丟棄。其中14名無家者希望討回公道,前年入稟小額錢債審裁處,向政府索償$2,000至$13,000元不等。歷時1年9個月,案件今日終有裁決,康文署被判敗訴,惟無家者因無法證明家當的金額,法庭判「象徵式賠償」100元。最初入稟的14人,2人未及聽到勝訴已經離世,4人失去聯絡,出庭的無家者直言「賠多少都唔係問題嘅,攞返個公道」。
29 Mar 2022獨媒#1891
梁國雄立法會搶文件 藐視罪成囚兩周 官斥侵犯官員財產及權利
Former Legislative Council member Leung Kwok-hung allegedly took documents from then Under Secretary for Development Shaw Hsiang Mar during a meeting discussing the Wang Chau project in 2016. A magistrate previously ruled that the Legislative Council (Powers and Privileges) Ordinance was unsuitable for prosecuting legislators, but the Department of Justice successfully appealed and the case was remitted for retrial. Leung was convicted of contempt at Eastern Magistrates’ Courts today (the 29th) and sentenced to two weeks’ imprisonment, to be served consecutively with the sentence in an earlier case. Chief Magistrate Ada Shun Yee Yim said the defendant knowingly took the documents without the official’s consent despite having no authority to do so, infringing the official’s property and rights, disrupting the order of the meeting and affecting participants’ performance of their constitutional functions. She also said his conduct fell outside the scope of the immunity under the Powers and Privileges Ordinance, and stressed that although the incident lasted only two minutes, meeting time was precious.
前立法會議員梁國雄涉2016年於討論橫洲項目會議期間,搶去時任發展局副局長馬紹祥文件,裁判官早前指《立法會(權力及特權)條例》不適合向議員檢控,惟律政司上訴得直,案件發還重審,梁今(29日)在東區法院被裁定藐視罪成立,判囚兩周,刑期與早前案件分期執行。主任裁判官嚴舜儀指,被告明知沒有權力,卻未經官員同意拿走文件,是侵犯官員財產及權利,擾亂會議秩序,影響與會者執行憲法功能,而其行為亦超出《特權條例》的豁免範圍。她又強調,雖然案發只有兩分鐘,但會議時間珍貴。
29 Mar 2022獨媒#1892
10.1灣仔 事隔2年半警方重新拘捕13人 其中12人被起訴暴動明提堂
On 1 October 2019, large numbers of protesters gathered around Gloucester Road, Hennessy Road, Johnston Road and Queen’s Road East in Wan Chai and Admiralty. During the incident, roads were blocked at multiple locations, fires were set and objects were thrown at police officers. Police had earlier arrested 57 people on suspicion of taking part in an unlawful assembly, and those arrested were subsequently “kicked bail”. Two and a half years later, police today (29th) rearrested 13 of the men, aged between 20 and 54. Twelve were charged with rioting, while another was charged with possession of an object with intent to destroy property. The case will be brought before the Eastern Magistrates’ Courts tomorrow morning (30th).
2019年10月1日,大批示威者於灣仔金鐘道、軒尼詩道、莊士敦道及皇后大道東一帶聚集,期間多處有堵路、縱火、有人向警員投擲雜物等,警方早前以涉嫌參與非法集結拘捕57人,被捕人其後「踢保」。事隔兩年半,警方今(29日)重新拘捕其中13名男子,年齡介乎20至54歲,當中12人被控暴動罪,另一人被控管有物品意圖摧毀財產罪。案件將於明日(30日)上午在東區裁判法院提堂。
16 Mar 2022獨媒#1872
7.27元朗遊行 鍾健平擬承認組織未經批准集結 還柙至4.11答辯
After the 21 July 2019 attack by men in white in Yuen Long, Max Chung Kin-ping applied to police to hold a “Reclaim Yuen Long” march on 27 July, but was not issued a letter of no objection, and large numbers of members of the public gathered in Yuen Long. More than two years later, Chung was charged with organising and knowingly participating in an unauthorized assembly and has been remanded in custody since appearing in court last August. The case was mentioned at the District Court today (16th). Chung did not appear because of the pandemic situation at the detention centre, but the defence said it had reached a plea agreement with the prosecution. Chung will plead guilty to the charge of organising an unauthorized assembly, while the charge of knowingly participating in an unauthorized assembly will be filed by the court. The case was adjourned until 11 April for plea, and Chung will remain in custody in the meantime.
2019年7.21元朗白衣人襲擊後,鍾健平向警方申請於7月27日舉辦「光復元朗」遊行,但未獲發不反通知書,大批市民前往元朗聚集。事隔逾2年,鍾被控組織及參與未經批准集結罪,去年8月提堂還柙至今。案件今(16日)於區域法院提訊,由於羈留所疫情關係,鍾今日未有出庭,但辯方透露已與控方達成認罪協商,鍾將承認「組織未經批准集結罪」,而「明知而參與未經批准集結罪」則由法庭存檔,押後至4月11日答辯,期間繼續還柙。
2 Mar 2022獨媒#1855
初選案辯方律師阻差辦公罪成囚7天 官指無悔意不宜判社服令
On the first night the 47 defendants in the primary election case appeared in court, police cordoned off the entrances to West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts. A defence solicitor tried to enter the court area to handle the case but refused to produce identification documents when requested by police. He had earlier been convicted of wilfully obstructing a police officer and was sentenced at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts today (the 2nd). Magistrate Cheung Nim-chi said the case was serious and that the defendant had knowingly broken the law, while there was no indication of genuine remorse. The magistrate ruled that a community service order was unsuitable and sentenced him to seven days’ imprisonment. The defendant was granted bail pending an appeal.
初選47人案提堂首晚,警方圍封西九龍裁判法院出入口,一名辯方事務律師嘗試進入法院範圍以處理案件,期間拒絕應警方要求出示身份證明文件,他早前遭裁定「故意阻撓警務人員」罪成,今(2日)於西九龍裁判法院判刑。裁判官鄭念慈指案情嚴重,被告知法犯法,且看不到他有真誠悔意,不適宜判處社會服務令,最終判監7日。被告獲准保釋以等候上訴。
21 Dec 2020立場新聞#1092
終院裁定禁蒙面法合憲 判詞指「示威者勒索司機金錢」被質疑 台事實核查中心曾證「迫交過路費」短片內容錯誤
The Court of Final Appeal ruled that the Hong Kong government’s use of the Emergency Regulations Ordinance to enact the Prohibition on Face Covering Regulation was constitutional, and that the regulation itself did not contravene the Basic Law. However, the judgment’s account of evidence that protesters had undermined public order was questioned as having originated from “fake news”.
終審法院裁定香港政府使用《緊急法》訂立《禁蒙面法》合憲,《禁蒙面法》內容亦無違憲。然而判詞中對示威者破壞治安的證據陳述,被質疑來自「假新聞」。
21 Dec 2020HKFP#1097
Top Hong Kong court backs gov’t use of colonial-era emergency law to ban face masks at demos
The Court of Final Appeal rules that the Hong Kong government’s use of the emergency law to enact an anti-mask regulation is legal and proportionate.
CFA rules HK gov's use of emergency law to enact anti-mask regulation to be legal & proportionate.
3 Nov 2020獨媒#885
網上發帖稱「全民包圍新屋嶺」地盤工煽惑非法集結罪成 判160小時社服令
A 38-year-old construction worker using the online name “Kim Jong-un” was accused of posting four messages last year in a public Facebook group, including “everyone surround San Uk Ling” and “rescuing the righteous is of the utmost importance”. He was charged with inciting unlawful assembly and, in the alternative, inciting an unauthorised assembly. After being convicted earlier of inciting unlawful assembly, he was sentenced to 160 hours’ community service at Eastern Magistrates’ Courts today (the 3rd). The case was the first since the anti-extradition movement involving online speech in which a defendant was convicted at trial of an incitement offence. In sentencing, the magistrate said the defendant claimed online that someone had died at San Uk Ling. He did not know whether this was true, but nevertheless said someone had died to “cheat likes”; he also fabricated having a classmate who was a “black cop” to make the claim more persuasive. The court took into account that although some people “liked” the posts, others questioned them; the messages were exaggerated and untrue, the call to assemble had limited effect, and no violence ultimately occurred.
網名「金正恩」的38歲地盤工,被指去年在社交平台facebook一個公開群組發布4則帖文,稱「全民包圍新屋嶺」、「救出義士是重中之重」,被控煽惑非法集結,以及屬交替性質的煽惑未經批准集結罪。被告早前被裁定煽惑非法集結罪成,今(3日)在東區裁判法院被判160小時社會服務令。本案為「反送中」以來首宗涉及網上言論而經審訊被裁定「煽惑」罪成的案件。裁判官判刑時指被告於網上聲稱有人在新屋嶺死亡,他不知是否真有其事,但仍說有人死而藉此「呃like」;他又虛構有一名黑警同學以加強說服力。惟法庭考慮到即使有人「like」貼文,但亦有人對貼文抱質疑態度,他發佈的消息誇張失實,號召集會的效用低,最後沒有引發暴力事件。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.