19 Sept 2024法庭線#4060
23條|首宗新煽動罪定罪 27歲男認6.12穿「光時」衫遊蕩 判囚14個月
On June 12 this year, a 27-year-old man was accused of loitering at Shek Mun MTR Station while wearing clothing bearing the words “Liberate Hong Kong, Revolution of Our Times” and a yellow “F.D.N.O.L” mask, and of refusing to produce his identity card. He was charged with three offences, including the new sedition offence under the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance. He pleaded guilty to the sedition charge and was sentenced to 14 months’ imprisonment at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Thursday (19th).
今年 6 月 12 日,27 歲男子被指穿著印有「光復香港 時代革命」衣物、戴黃色「F.D.N.O.L 」口罩,在石門港鐵站遊蕩及拒出示身份證,被起訴《維護國家安全條例》下「新煽動罪」等 3 罪。他承認煽動罪,周四(19 日)在西九龍裁判法院被判囚 14 個月。
總裁判官蘇惠德指判刑須考慮立法原意,指當局藉更嚴峻的刑罰強化預防性,消除危害國安的風險。官指,被告在 6 月 12 日,即示威者視為標誌性的日子,伺機宣場危害國安訊息,斥其「藉一個象徵啟動的日子…企圖令動亂的思想死灰復燃。」
官又指,若法律不及早介入,會令社會再陷亂象,認為判刑的阻嚇不單為防止無知之人仿傚,亦要阻嚇「已經持有或認同被告人主張的人,從事散播危害國家安全思想的活動。」官以 18 個月監禁為量刑起點,因被告曾有類同案底,官斥不知悔改須加刑儆效尤。
19 Sept 2024法庭線#4061
23條|男子涉巴士椅背寫煽動字句 承認3項煽動罪囚10月
The National Security Department of the police earlier charged a 29-year-old man with three new sedition offences under the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance and two counts of destroying or damaging property. The defendant pleaded guilty to the three sedition offences at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Thursday (19th) and was sentenced to 10 months’ imprisonment.
The case stated that the defendant had written phrases including “Hong Kong independence” and “Liberate Hong Kong” on buses on separate occasions. After his arrest, he said he was expressing that he had freedom of speech. In mitigation, the defence said the defendant had wanted to prove that Hong Kong still had freedom of speech, but that his “social experiment was doomed to fail”. It also said that although the maximum sentence for the new sedition offence had increased from two years to seven years, the maximum sentence applied only to the most serious cases and “does not mean that all sentences have to be increased three and a half times”. The defence said the defendant hoped to turn over a new leaf after serving his sentence and “not get involved in social testing again”.
In sentencing, Chief Magistrate So Wai-tak said the defendant knew that the relevant phrases were illegal but had nevertheless repeatedly committed the offences. He also said the defendant had targeted buses to spread messages advocating Hong Kong independence and endangering national security. If intervention had not been made at an early stage, the “ripple effect” would have caused society to fall into chaos again.
警方國安處早前落案控告一名 29 歲男子,控以 3 項《維護國家安全條例》下新煽動罪,以及兩項摧毀或損壞財產罪。被告周四(19 日)在西九龍裁判法院承認 3 項煽動罪,被判囚 10 個月。
案情指,被告先後在巴士上寫上「香港獨立」、「光復香港」等字句,被捕後稱以此表達自己有言論自由。辯方求情指被告欲證本港仍有言論自由,但其「社會實驗注定失敗」,又指新煽動罪最高刑期由2年上升至7年,但最高刑期只適用於最嚴重者,「唔係所有都要增加3倍半」。辯方指,被告期望服刑後重新做人,「唔再牽涉喺社會測試上」。
總裁判官蘇惠德判刑時指,被告明知有關字句違法,仍一而再、再而三犯案,又指他以巴士為目標,達致宣揚香港獨立和危害國安的訊息。若不及早介入,在疊加效應的影響下,「會導致社會再次陷入亂象」。
22 Aug 2024法庭線#3929
23條|男子涉巴士椅背寫煽動字句 辯方稱正與控方商討控罪 押後9.19再訊
The police National Security Department earlier charged a 29-year-old man with three counts of the new offence of sedition under the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance, and two counts of destroying or damaging property. The case was mentioned again at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Thursday (22nd).
The defence applied to adjourn the case to Sept 19 for another mention, pending discussions with the prosecution over the charges. The application was granted, with the defence saying it was "confident that the final outcome would not require a trial". The defendant did not apply for bail and was remanded in custody pending the next hearing.
警方國安處早前落案控告一名 29 歲男子,控以 3 項《維護國家安全條例》下新煽動罪,以及兩項摧毀或損壞財產罪,案件周四(22日)在西九龍裁判法院再訊。
辯方申請將本案押後至 9 月 19 日再訊獲准,以待與控方商討控罪,並指「有信心最後嘅結果並不需要審訊」。另被告沒有保釋申請,還押候訊。
7 Aug 2024法庭線#3886
23條|涉6.12穿「光時」衫、戴黃口罩 27歲男擬認「新煽動罪」9.16答辯
On June 12 this year, a 27-year-old man was accused of wearing clothing bearing the words “Liberate Hong Kong; Revolution of Our Times” and a yellow “FDNOL” mask, loitering at Shek Mun MTR station and refusing to produce his identity card. He was charged with three offences, including the “new sedition offence” under the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance, and appeared again at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Wednesday (the 7th).
The defence said the defendant intended to plead guilty to the new sedition offence. He was further remanded until Sept 16 for plea. The prosecution was represented by Senior Prosecutor Ting Wai Lee, and the defence by barrister Steven Kwan. The case was handled by Chief Magistrate Su Wai-tak. The defence also said that the charge of refusing to produce an identity card was brought under the Public Order Ordinance, but stressed that the defendant had not intentionally refused to produce his identity card. If the prosecution amended the charge to failing to produce an identity card under the Immigration Ordinance, the defendant would plead guilty.
The case was adjourned to Sept 16 for plea, pending discussions between the prosecution and defence.
今年 6 月 12 日,27 歲男子被指穿著印有「光復香港 時代革命」衣物、戴黃色「FDNOL」口罩,在石門港鐵站遊蕩及拒出示身份證,被起訴《維護國家安全條例》下「新煽動罪」等 3 罪,周三(7 日)在西九龍裁判法院再訊。
辯方透露,被告擬認新煽動罪,續還押至 9 月 16 日答辯。控方由高級檢控官李庭偉代表,辯方由大律師關文渭代表,案件由總裁判官蘇惠德處理。辯方指,被告打算承認「新煽動罪」。另外,辯方指本案的拒出示身份證罪,屬於《公安條例》下的控罪,但強調被告非故意不出示身份證,若控方改控《入境條例》下的沒出示身份證罪,被告將會認罪。
案件押至 9 月 16 日答辯,候控辯雙方商討。
7 Aug 2024法庭線#3888
23條|涉網上提「革命無罪」男子被控「新煽動罪」 辯方稱將爭議控罪合憲性
A 58-year-old man was accused of posting seditious statements or photographs on online platforms including YouTube between March and June this year. The wording allegedly involved included “revolution is not a crime; rebellion is justified”. He was charged under the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance with knowingly publishing a publication with a seditious intention, and appeared again at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Wednesday (the 7th). The defence said the new sedition offence does not require proof of an intention to incite violence and violates the freedom of expression guaranteed by the Basic Law, and will challenge the constitutionality of the charge. Chief Magistrate So Wai-tak noted that the Tam Tak-chi case would address the same issue and asked whether the proceedings should await the Court of Final Appeal’s judgment. The defence said the two sedition offences were not completely the same and that the ruling was “not 100 per cent applicable to this case”. The prosecution and defence will make submissions on the issue on 20 September. The defendant was remanded in custody. The prosecution was represented by Senior Public Prosecutor Ting Wai Lee, and the defence by barristers Steven Kwan, Yvonne Lai Kwok Leung and Sze To Tsz-long. The case was handled by Chief Magistrate So Wai-tak.
今年 3 月至 6 月期間,58 歲男子被指在 YouTube 等網上平台,發布煽動陳述或相片,據悉涉案字眼包括「革命無罪造反有理」,被控《維護國家安全條例》下的「明知而發布具煽動意圖的刊物」罪,周三(7 日)在西九龍裁判法院再訊。
辯方表示,新煽動罪毋須證明煽暴意圖,違反《基本法》賦予的言論自由,爭議控罪合憲性。總裁判官蘇惠德關注,「譚得志案」將處理同一爭議,應否等候終院判決,辯方則稱兩項煽動罪不完全相同,「唔係百分之百可以適用於本案」。
控辯雙方訂於 9 月 20 日就此陳詞,被告續還押。控方由高級檢控官李庭偉代表,辯方由大律師關文渭、梁麗幗及司徒子朗代表,案件由總裁判官蘇惠德處理。
5 Aug 2024獨媒#3879
【國安法四年.數據分析】至今逾300人被捕 定罪率首跌破100% 23條下至少7人未能提早獲釋
In June 2020, the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress passed the Hong Kong National Security Law, ushering Hong Kong into a “new era”. The authorities have repeatedly used the National Security Law and sedition charges to make arrests and bring prosecutions. Before four years had passed, the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance, enacted under Article 23 of the Basic Law and referred to as Article 23, also formally came into effect in March this year. Together with the National Security Law, it has become what the authorities call the “two laws” that effectively safeguard national security, protect Hong Kong’s system, and target only an extremely small minority.
2020年6月,全國人大常委會通過《港區國安法》,香港進入「新時代」,當局屢次動用國安法和煽動罪名作拘捕檢控。不足四年,按《基本法》第23條制定的《維護國家安全條例》(下稱23條),今年3月亦正式生效,與《國安法》一同成為當局口中,有效維護國安、保障香港制度、只針對極少數人的「雙法」。
25 Jun 2024法庭線#3729
23條|警方首就新煽動罪檢控發稿公布 29歲男涉巴士椅背寫煽動字句 還押8.22再訊
The government issued a press release at noon on Tuesday (25th), saying that the Police National Security Department had charged a 29-year-old man with three counts of the new sedition offence under the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance and two counts of destroying or damaging property. The case is also the first prosecution under the new sedition offence announced by police in a press release since Article 23 came into force. In the two previous prosecutions recorded by the media, police did not issue news announcements.
The case was brought before the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Tuesday afternoon. The prosecution applied to adjourn the case for further police investigation, including examination of the defendant’s phone and computer and investigation into whether he was involved in other cases. The prosecution opposed bail, while the defence did not make a bail application. The defendant was remanded until Aug 22 for mention.
政府周二(25 日)中午發稿,指警方國安處落案控告一名 29 歲男子,控以 3 項《維護國家安全條例》下新煽動罪,以及兩項摧毀或損壞財產罪。此案亦是「23 條」生效後,首宗警方發稿公布的新煽動罪檢控,之前傳媒有紀錄的兩宗檢控,警方均未發新聞公告。
案件周二下午在西九龍裁判法院提堂,控方申請押後案件,待警方進一步調查,檢查被告的電話、電腦,以及調查被告是否涉及其他案件。控方反對被告保釋,辯方則沒有擔保申請,還押至 8 月 22 日再訊。
24 Jun 2024法庭線#3726
23條首宗司法覆核|馬俊文指行為良好不獲提早釋放 入稟要求即時獲釋兼索償
Ma Chun-man, nicknamed the “Second-generation Captain America”, was convicted of “inciting secession” and sentenced to five years in prison after allegedly repeatedly shouting slogans advocating Hong Kong independence and displaying Hong Kong independence placards. Ma had been due to receive early release in March this year for good conduct, but under a new arrangement introduced by the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance, commonly known as “Article 23”, he was not granted early release and will remain in prison until his sentence expires, at the latest, in November 2025.
Ma filed an application for judicial review in the High Court on Friday (the 21st), arguing that the new arrangement under Article 23 is unlawful, retrospective and beyond the authorities’ powers, and infringes rights including personal liberty protected by human rights law, amounting to unlawful detention. He said the arrangement had caused him extreme distress and depression and subjected him to “malicious and cruel” treatment. He is seeking declarations that the new arrangement is unlawful, a reinterpretation of the relevant provisions, his immediate release, and damages from the Correctional Services Department.
The application revealed that the Correctional Services Department notified Ma in February this year that he could be released early, when Article 23 had not yet come into force. However, two days before his scheduled release, the department said it had reversed its decision and that he would have to wait another year at the earliest to be released. The department subsequently provided a memorandum prepared by the Review Committee for Inmates Convicted of Offences Endangering National Security, stating that, as there was no information showing that Ma’s early release “would not be prejudicial to” national security, it had refused to release him.
綽號「第二代美國隊長」的馬俊文,被指多次叫喊港獨口號、展示港獨標語,「煽動分裂國家」罪成判囚 5 年。馬原定今年 3 月在行為良好減刑下提早獲釋,惟在《維護國安條例》(下稱「23 條」)新安排下,他未能提早釋放,最遲延至 2025 年 11 月刑滿。
馬俊文周五(21 日)入稟高等法院申請司法覆核,質疑「23 條」的新安排不合法、有追溯力、越權,侵害人權法保障的人身自由等權利,變相非法拘禁,令他感到極度痛苦和沮喪,遭受「具惡意、殘忍」的對待,要求法庭宣告新安排不合法,重新詮釋有關安排及即時釋放他,並向懲教署索償。
入稟狀透露,懲教署今年 2 月通知馬可提早獲釋,當時「23 條」尚未生效。惟在原定獲釋日前兩天,署方稱已推翻決定,他最快要在 1 年後獲釋。其後署方提供由「犯危害國家安全罪行的在囚人士評審委員會」撰寫的便箋,指基於無資料顯示,提早釋放馬「不會不利於」國安,因此拒絕釋放他。
21 Jun 2024法庭線#3715
23條|涉YouTube等發布陳述及照片 58歲男被控新發布煽動刊物罪 還押候訊
Another prosecution has been brought under Article 23. A 58-year-old man was charged with knowingly publishing publications with a seditious intention after allegedly posting seditious statements or photographs on three online platforms, including YouTube, between March 23—the day the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance took effect—and June 19 this year. The wording allegedly involved included “Revolution is not a crime; rebellion is justified”. He made his first appearance at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Friday (21st).
The defendant was not required to enter a plea at this stage. At the prosecution’s request, the National Security Law designated judge and Chief Magistrate Don Man Lung So adjourned the case to August 7 so police could examine two phones, a desktop computer and three laptops seized from his home. Senior Public Prosecutor Ting Wai Lee, representing the prosecution, said the defendant had not applied for bail, which defence lawyer Yik Kan Chan confirmed. The defendant was remanded in custody.
According to a tally by The Witness, before Article 23 took effect, cases involving seditious statements online were prosecuted by the Department of Justice as the offence of doing an act with a seditious intention, while the offence of publishing seditious publications mainly concerned physical or media publications. In this Article 23 prosecution, online speech has also been classified as the offence of publishing seditious publications.
「23 條」檢控再錄一案。58 歲男子被控在《維護國家安全條例》生效當日,即今年 3 月 23 日,至 6 月 19 日期間,在 YouTube 等三個網上平台,發布煽動陳述或相片,據悉涉案字眼包括「革命無罪造反有理」,被控「明知而發布具煽動意圖的刊物」罪,周五(21 日)在西九龍裁判法院首度提堂。
被告暫時毋須答辯,《國安法》指定法官、主任裁判官蘇文隆應控方要求,押後至 8 月 7 日再訊,以候警方檢查其家中搜出的兩部電話、桌上電腦,以及 3 部手提電腦。控方代表、高級檢控官李庭偉指,被告沒保釋申請,辯方代表、律師陳奕勤確認。被告須還押。
按《法庭線》統計,在「23 條」生效前,涉及網上煽動言論的案件,律政司均起訴「煽動作為」罪,而「煽動刊物」罪則主要涉實體或傳媒刊物。是次「23 條」檢控,網上言論亦歸類為「煽動刊物」罪。
21 Jun 2024集誌社#3717
反修例五年|《集誌社》還原國安「雙法」數據 23 條最少拘控 11人 兩宗無公布
The 2019 anti-extradition bill protests brought the Fugitive Offenders Ordinance amendment bill to an end. However, halting one law led to the creation of two others. The Hong Kong National Security Law, passed by the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress in Beijing, took effect on 30 June 2020, while the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance, enacted locally under Article 23, formally took effect on 23 March this year.
Over the past nearly four years, at least 301 people have been arrested for allegedly engaging in acts or activities that endanger national security. This figure includes arrests under the two national security laws as well as other criminal offences. The Security Bureau has refused to provide a breakdown of arrests by offence under the Hong Kong National Security Law and Article 23, citing the need to avoid affecting operational deployments.
The Collective compiled the data in an attempt to reconstruct the number of people arrested under the two laws. It found that, as of 21 June, at least 157 people had been arrested for allegedly violating the two national security laws, including 146 under the Hong Kong National Security Law. Article 23 had been in effect for less than three months, but had already resulted in at least 11 people being arrested or charged.
2019年的反修例運動,令《逃犯條例》修訂草案「壽終正寢」。不過,煞停一法,催生「雙法」。在北京由全國人大常委會通過的《香港國安法》,2020 年 6 月 30 日生效,在本地立法的《維護國家安全條例》(23條)也在今年 3 月 23 日正式生效。
近四年來,最少已有 301人,被指涉從事危害國安行為、活動被捕。這數字,包括兩條國安相關法例,及其他刑事罪行。保安局以「影響行動部署」為由,拒絕提供以《國安法》和 23條的拘捕罪行分類數字。
《集誌社》記者整理資料,嘗試還原因「雙法」被捕人數,發現截至 6 月 21 日,至少有 157 人涉違上述兩國安例被捕,其中 146 人涉《香港國安法》。而 23條生效未夠三個月,已引至少 11 人被拘捕或起訴。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.