3 Apr 2025Channel C#6650
司法機構稱過去一年新接獲約80宗反修例或國安案 認多宗案件矚目「審期超出預計」
The Legislative Council Finance Committee will hold a special meeting next week. In a document submitted to the committee yesterday (2nd), the Judiciary disclosed that the courts at all levels had received about 2,350 anti-extradition law amendment cases and more than 230 national security-related cases by the end of February this year. About 50 anti-extradition law amendment cases and 30 national security cases were newly received last year, equivalent to about four additional anti-extradition law amendment cases and 2.5 national security cases per month. The Judiciary said it would give priority to the two categories of cases, acknowledging that “the trial dates for many high-profile anti-extradition law amendment cases and national security cases have exceeded expectations”, while most of the remaining cases will be tried this year.
立法會財務委員會將於下周舉行特別會議,司法機構昨日(2日)向財委會提交文件,披露各級法院截至今年2月底接獲約2,350宗反修例案件、230多宗國家安全相關案件,即去年新增反修例案件約為50宗,國安案件則約30宗,相當於每月多接獲約4宗反修例案和2.5宗國安案。司法機構表示會優先處理這兩類案件,承認「多宗備受矚目的反修例案件及國安案件的審期超出預計」,而餘下案件大部分將在今年審訊。
3 Apr 2025集誌社#6651
維權運動員|轉會被「雪藏」索償勝訴 前空手道精英運動員:望運動界唔係保住一班人利益輸送
After training for years in the sport he loved and hoping to compete for good results, former elite karate athlete Lo Chin-pang was forced to stop because of an ultra vires policy adopted by a sports association. In 2015, he was expelled from his dojo because of a dispute between his instructors. After changing dojos, he was “frozen out” by the Hong Kong Karate Federation for four months on the grounds of a “transfer”, causing him to lose his status and funding as an elite athlete at the Hong Kong Sports Institute. He subsequently changed careers and became a fitness trainer. Two other athletes, Lo Sum-man and Shu Ching, experienced the same situation. The three filed a claim for compensation against the federation. High Court judge Herbert Ho Wing Au-Yeung ruled yesterday (the 2nd) that the three had won, saying the “cooling-off period” policy was ultra vires and served only to protect decision-makers in the karate associations to which the dojos belonged. The judge ordered the federation to pay the three a total of more than $1.57 million in compensation.
Lo Chin-pang, Lo Sum-man and her mother held a press conference today in response. Lo Chin-pang said he had faced considerable pressure over the past decade, and the competition opportunities he had lost could no longer be pursued. He hoped the case would serve as a warning to the sports sector, prompting relevant sports organisations to avoid similar situations when handling comparable incidents in future. He also hoped organisations would “not be about protecting a group’s interests and funnelling benefits”. Lo Sum-man’s mother said most of the federation’s funding came from public money, and it should shoulder social responsibility and be accountable to the public.
為心愛的運動訓練多年,望出賽爭取好成績,卻因體育總會一個越權政策而被逼停止。前空手道精英運動員羅展鵬,2015 年因師傅間的恩怨而被逐出道場,轉換道場後被香港空手道總會以「轉會」為由,「雪藏」4 個月,致失去體院精英運動員資格及資助,為生計轉行成為健身教練。另兩名運動員羅心汶及舒晴有同樣遭遇,三人入稟向總會索償,高院法官歐陽浩榮昨(2日)裁定三人勝訴,指該「冷凍期」政策越權,僅保護道場所屬空手道協會的決策人,下令總會須向三人賠償共逾 157 萬元。
羅展鵬、羅心汶及其母親今開記者會回應,羅展鵬指過去十年面對很多壓力,所失去的比賽機會亦已無法追究,望今次案例可作為運動界的一個警惕,令相關運動機構遇同類事件時,避免類似情況再發生,亦望機構「唔係保住一班人利益輸送」。羅心汶母親亦指總會資金大部分來自公帑,應負社會責任和向市民交代。
2 Apr 2025法庭線#6647
空手道精英運動員轉道場後失資格 索償勝訴 官斥總會完全無視運動員利益
Karate elite athlete Lo Chin-pang had his membership terminated by the Karate Federation in 2015 after switching dojos, and consequently lost his elite athlete status at the Hong Kong Sports Institute, as well as training and funding. Lo filed a claim against the federation for about $2.3 million. Two other athletes in the same situation separately filed claims for about $300,000 and $150,000. All three won their cases.
High Court judge Herbert Ho Wing Au-Yeung handed down a judgment on Wednesday (2nd), ruling that the federation must pay the three athletes more than $1.57 million in total, with Lo awarded more than $1.3 million. The judge said the true purpose of the “freeze period” policy was to restrict better athletes from transferring, thereby protecting the decision-makers of the karate associations to which the dojos belonged.
The judge also said the policy had created a “cruel reality”: regardless of the reason for transferring, athletes faced a four-month “freeze period”. In Lo’s case, this meant losing full-time employment for at least four months. The other two part-time athletes were also unable to receive the Hong Kong Sports Institute’s professional training and support, causing a major impact on their professional development.
空手道精英運動員羅展鵬於 2015 年因轉換道場,被空手道總會終止其會籍,其體院精英運動員資格亦被取消,失去訓練及資助。羅入稟向總會索償約 230 萬元,另有兩名運動員遭遇相同情況,分別向總會入稟索償約 30 萬元及 15 萬元,3 人均勝訴。
高院法官歐陽浩榮周三(2 日)頒下判詞,裁定總會須向 3 人賠償共逾 157 萬元,其中羅獲判償逾 130 萬元。官指,「冷凍期」政策的真正目的是限制更優秀的運動員轉會,以保護道場所屬空手道協會的決策人。
官又指,該政策創造的「殘酷現實」,是 無論運動員因任何原因轉會都有 4 個月的「冷凍期」,以羅為例,會失去全職工作至少 4 個月,另外兩名非全職運動員,亦無法獲得體院的專業訓練及支持,對其專業發展構成重大影響。
2 Apr 2025集誌社#6649
去年遭食環檢走大批月餅 「膳心小館」提訴要求法庭頒令撤銷
In August last year, 40 Food and Environmental Hygiene Department staff inspected the warehouse of social enterprise Agape Garden, saying they had received a complaint that the mooncakes were of unknown origin, and sealed them. In December that year, the department removed the batch of expired mooncakes. Agape Garden challenged the action in court, seeking an order requiring the department to revoke its decision and compensation. The case was heard at the Kwun Tong Magistrates’ Courts today. Acting Principal Magistrate LEUNG Ka-kie said proceedings had not yet formally commenced and adjourned the case to May 16 for mention.
去年 8 月,食環署 40 名職員往社企膳心小館倉庫巡查,稱收到投訴指月餅「來歷不明」作查封,同年 12 月檢走該批過期月餅。膳心小館不服有關行動,向法庭提出申訴,要求法庭頒令食環署撤銷有關決定及要求賠償,案件今在觀塘裁判法院處理。署理主任裁判官梁嘉琪指案件仍未正式展開程序,押後至 5 月 16 日再訊。
1 Apr 2025獨媒#6639
嶺大學生會賴卓賢等人要求法庭頒令親建制人士交出學聯會址 侯叔祺:只要「愛國愛港」學生便隨時可使用會址
The HKFS and Student Activities Fund Limited, which holds the title to two HKFS premises, currently has a board majority made up of pro-establishment figures. Two years ago, it filed a claim in the District Court seeking an order for four former HKFS members to return the two premises, but later withdrew the proceedings. Last Friday (March 28), Lingnan University Students’ Union President Hon Cheuk-yin and Vice-President (External) Lai Cheuk-yin filed proceedings in the High Court, seeking an order requiring the HKFS and Student Activities Fund Limited to hand over the properties and transfer the rights and interests in both properties to a company jointly owned by Hon and Lai.
持有學聯兩個會址物業的「學聯及學生活動基金有限公司」,現時由親建制人士佔董事局大多數,前年曾經入稟區院,要求法庭下令4名前學聯成員歸還兩個會址,其後撤回訴訟。直至上周五(3月28日),現任嶺南大學學生會會長韓焯彥和外務副會長賴卓賢入稟高院,要求法庭頒令「學聯及學生活動基金有限公司」交出物業,並且將兩個物業權利和利益,歸於韓和賴聯名持有的公司所擁有。
1 Apr 2025法庭線#6640
23條|男子認行人天橋升降機門寫「台獨」等囚10月 官指需嚴懲免仿效
A 53-year-old man was accused of writing “Xi Winnie is the Murder King of ‘End China’”, “the communist bandit dogs’ masturbation song is rubbish”, “the communist bandits have collapsed” and “Taiwan independence” on the doors of pedestrian footbridge lifts in the Wan Chai area in 2024. He was charged with eight counts of criminal damage and one count of the “new sedition offence”. On Tuesday (1 April), he pleaded guilty at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts to five offences, including the “new sedition offence”, and was sentenced to 10 months’ imprisonment.
The facts of the case stated that the defendant admitted the offences under caution. He had vented his dissatisfaction with the verdicts in the “47-person case” and the “721 case”, and believed that Hong Kong currently had no democracy or freedom. He did not want Taiwan to become like Hong Kong. Chief Magistrate Suen Hui-der said the words involved the country’s leaders, cursed the central regime and denigrated the national anthem, which represents national dignity. To prevent conduct endangering national security, a severe sentence was necessary to deter others from imitating him and to prevent undercurrents from emerging in a society that was becoming more peaceful.
53 歲男子被指 2024 年,在灣仔一帶行人天橋升降機門,寫上「習維尼係終國殺人王」、「共匪狗手淫曲係垃圾」、「共匪冧檔」、「台獨」等字眼,被控 8 項刑事損壞罪及 1 項「新煽動罪」,周二(4 月 1 日)在西九龍裁判法院承認包括「新煽動罪」在內的 5 罪,判囚 10 月。
案情提到,被告警誡下承認犯案,宣洩對「47 人案」、「721 案」判決不滿,又認為香港現時沒有民主、自由,不想台灣像香港一樣。總裁判官蘇惠德指,涉案字眼與國家領導人有關,又咒罵中央政權、貶低代表民族尊嚴的國歌,為了防範危害國安行為,要在刑罰上從嚴,避免他人仿效、為轉趨平和的社會帶來暗湧。
1 Apr 2025法庭線#6641
反恐第二案|專家證人被質疑缺乏化學知識、稱經驗來自「實戰」 控方完成舉證
In early 2020, explosives were found at Caritas Medical Centre and in a Lo Wu MTR train carriage. The Telegram channel “Ninety-Two Lots” subsequently claimed responsibility. Seven people were charged with offences under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, while one other person was charged with “attempting to make explosives”. All eight pleaded not guilty, and the trial at the High Court entered its 80th day on Tuesday (April 1).\n\nA senior bomb disposal officer from the Explosive Ordnance Disposal Bureau continued to face questioning by the defence. He was challenged over his lack of relevant chemistry knowledge in providing expert opinions on chemicals. The witness said his expert opinion was based on “my personal 18 years of experience handling explosives”, stressing that handling homemade explosives required practical experience and training, “not a chemistry degree”. He also agreed that explaining chemical reactions was not within his area of expertise.\n\nAll prosecution witnesses have finished giving evidence. The prosecution has completed its case after 80 days. The court will deal with the parties’ legal arguments in the absence of the jury, which is not required to return until next Tuesday.
2020 年初,明愛醫院、羅湖港鐵車廂被發現有爆炸品,Telegram 頻道「九十二籤」事後承認責任。7人被控《反恐條例》罪名,餘下 1 人被控以「企圖製造炸藥」罪。8 人不認罪,周二(4 月 1 日)於高院踏入第 80 天審訊。
爆炸品處理課高級炸彈處理主任續接受辯方盤問時,被質疑缺乏相關化學知識,提供化學品的專家意見。證人稱其專家意見源自「我個人 18 年嘅處理爆炸品經驗」,強調處理自製爆炸品需要實戰經驗和訓練,「並不是一個化學學位」;但他亦同意解釋化學反應,並非其專業範疇。
控方所有證人作供完畢,控方完成歷時 80 天的控方案情,法庭將在陪審團避席下,處理雙方的法律爭議,陪審團下周二才需再出庭。
1 Apr 2025法庭線#6642
林卓廷披露游乃強受查案 終院3比2裁定律政司得直 官就條文詮釋現明顯分歧
Lam Cheuk-ting was charged with disclosing the identity of police superintendent Yau Nai-keung, who led the search of Nam Pin Wai on 21 July and was under investigation by the ICAC. On Tuesday (1 April), the five judges of the Court of Final Appeal ruled 3-2 in favour of the Department of Justice, restoring Lam’s conviction for “disclosing the identity of a person under investigation” and the sentence of four months’ imprisonment. Lam, who is serving a sentence in another case, will have additional time added to his imprisonment; without any remission for good behaviour, he may not be released until as late as 2031.
The five judges showed a clear division over how to interpret the provision under which he was charged. Chief Justice Andrew Cheung Kui-nung and Permanent Judge Li Yee considered that the legislative intent of safeguarding the confidentiality of ICAC investigations should be given greater weight, meaning that disclosing any ongoing ICAC investigation constitutes an offence. Permanent Judges Fok Siu-kong and Lam Man-hon disagreed, holding that the wording of the provision was limited to corruption investigations and could not support extending it to all ICAC investigations.
After reading the judgments of the four judges, overseas non-permanent judge Au Chung-leut agreed with Cheung Kui-nung and Li Yee, saying their interpretation established rather than weakened the offence provision. The Witness asked the ICAC for its response to the ruling and an update on its investigation into Yau Nai-keung. The ICAC replied: “The ICAC respects the court’s judgment. The ICAC has no further comment on the investigation mentioned in the case.”
林卓廷被控披露 721 帶隊搜查南邊圍的警司游乃強,受廉署調查一案,終審法院 5 名法官周二(4 月 1 日)以 3 比 2 裁定律政司得直,恢復林「披露受查人身分」的定罪及 4 個月監禁的判刑。正就另案服刑的林再被加監,若沒有獄中減刑,他最遲或至 2031 年才獲釋。
5 名法官就控罪條文的詮釋方法,出現明顯分歧。首席法官張舉能、常任法官李義認為,應該側重維護廉署調查保密的立法原意,即披露任何廉署進行中的調查都屬犯禁。常任法官霍兆剛、林文瀚不同意,認為條文用語只限於貪污調查,沒法支持引伸至廉署的所有調查。
海外非常任法官歐頌律閱讀 4 名法官的判詞後,認同張舉能、李義的看法,指二人的詮釋能確立而不是削弱控罪條文。《法庭線》向廉署查詢對裁決的回應,以及對游乃強的調查進度,獲回覆指「廉署尊重法庭的裁決。對案中提及的調查,廉署沒有補充。」
1 Apr 2025法庭線#6643
11.12中環|兩人暴動罪成提上訴被駁回 質疑控方盤問突提新指控 官反駁指有基礎
At the “Lunch with You” event in Central on 12 November 2019, two defendants were charged with rioting. After trial, they were convicted and sentenced to four years’ and three years and three months’ imprisonment respectively. They appealed against their convictions, with the appeals heard in the High Court on Tuesday (1st). After hearing submissions, the appellate judge dismissed the appeals the same day and said the written judgment would be handed down within six months.
The appellants argued that, during the prosecution’s cross-examination of the defendants at trial, it “suddenly” played footage alleging that the defendants were at the scene, even though it had never previously been said that the footage was relevant, and questioned whether this amounted to a new allegation. The judge held that the footage formed part of the admitted facts and that the prosecution had a basis for referring to it. The appellants also said the footage showed that the defendants had not accepted any supplies. The judge queried: “That doesn’t mean he wasn’t at the core of the riot or wasn’t participating, does it?” The judge said this could not weaken the cumulative effect of the other evidence.
2019 年 11 月 12 日中環「和你 lunch」,兩人被控暴動,經審訊後被裁定罪成,分別判囚 4 年及 3 年 3 個月。兩人不服定罪提上訴,周二(1 日)在高等法院審理。上訴庭法官聽畢陳詞,即日駁回上訴,6 個月內頒判詞。
上訴方爭議,控方原審盤問被告時,「無端端」播放指控被告在現場的片段,但之前從未指片段相關,質疑屬新指控。官則認為,片段為承認事實,控方有基礎引用。上訴方又指,片段顯示被告無接受物資,官質疑「唔等於佢冇喺暴動核心、唔係參與呀嘛」,指未能削弱其他證據的疊加效應。
31 Mar 2025法庭線#6632
患自閉症男生侮辱國旗罪成、提上訴被駁回 官指原審已考慮精神狀況
On 1 October 2022, a 19-year-old male student with autism was alleged to have damaged five flagpoles for national and regional flags in Sham Shui Po, while the flags themselves were not damaged. He was convicted of three offences, including insulting the national flag, and sentenced to a rehabilitation centre. He appealed against the convictions. Acting Judge Yiu Fan-chi dismissed the appeal at the High Court on Monday (31st).
The judge said the appellant had confirmed at trial that he was not relying on autism as a defence, and said the trial magistrate had considered his mental condition. The judge also cited a medical report stating that “the likelihood of the appellant being affected by psychiatric [factors] and medication was relatively low”. The appeal also questioned why the trial court had not slowed down when asking questions. The judge said there was no evidence that the defendant did not understand the trial process and the questions.
The judge further said footage showed the defendant walking directly towards and bending the flagpoles, resulting in the national flags being unable to stand upright. This was “clearly done intentionally and with an intention to insult”, the judge said.
2022 年 10 月 1 日,19 歲自閉症男學生被指在深水埗,損毀 5 支國旗及區旗旗桿,旗幟則沒受損。男生被裁定「侮辱國旗」等 3 罪成,判入更生中心,不服定罪提上訴。暫委法官姚勳智周一(31 日)在高等法院駁回上訴。
法官指,上訴人在原審確認,不依賴自閉症作為抗辯理由,又指原審裁判官已考慮其精神狀況。法官另引述醫療報告,指「相信上訴人給精神同藥物影響的機會較微」。上訴方又質疑,原審提問時沒放慢速度,法官則指,沒證據顯示被告不明白審訊過程和提問。
法官又表示,片段顯示被告直接步向、屈曲旗桿,導致國旗不能豎立,「明顯是故意而行,且具侮辱意圖」。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.