12 Dec 2022法庭線#5817
10.1尖沙咀|9人暴動、管武等罪成 判囚4年7個月至5年
Road blockades and clashes between police and members of the public occurred in multiple districts on October 1, 2019. Nine people had earlier been found guilty of all charges, including rioting and possession of weapons. On Monday (the 12th), Judge Kit Yee (1971) Cheung sentenced eight of them to between 4 years 7 months and 5 years in prison at the District Court, which was relocated to the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts.
2019 年 10 月 1 日多區發生堵路及警民衝突,9 人早前被裁定暴動等全部罪成。法官張潔宜周一(12 日)於區域法院(移師西九龍裁判法院)判當中 8 人監禁 4 年 7 個月至 5 年。
12 Dec 2022法庭線#5818
11.11大三罷|救護員涉襲內地男 認暴動囚2年4個月 官:施襲與志向相違背
During the “Operation Dawn” three-strike action on 11 November 2019, protesters and police clashed in multiple districts. A 28-year-old paramedic was accused of assaulting a mainland man in Mong Kok. He earlier admitted a charge of rioting, while a charge of wounding with intent was left on the court file. Acting Judge LEUNG Ka-kie sentenced the defendant to 2 years and 4 months’ imprisonment at the District Court, which had moved to the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, on Monday (12th).
2019 年 11 月 11 日的「黎明行動」大三罷,示威者與警方在多區爆發衝突。28 歲救護員被指在旺角襲擊內地男子。他早前承認暴動罪,有意圖而傷人罪則存檔法庭。暫委法官梁嘉琪周一(12 日)在區域法院(移師西九龍裁判法院)判被告監禁2 年 4 個月。
10 Dec 2022獨媒#5811
涉隱瞞壹傳媒大樓違契 黎智英判監5年9月 取消管理層資格8年 官批利用傳媒形象作「保護罩」
Next Media founder Jimmy Lai and former administrative director Wong Wai-keung were accused of using the Next Media building in Tseung Kwan O Industrial Estate to operate a Dico Consultants consultancy company while concealing breaches of the lease terms. The two denied the fraud charges and were earlier convicted. They were sentenced this morning (10th) at the District Court. Judge Chen Guangchi criticised them for abusing government-leased low-rent land to enable the lessee to benefit personally. He also said Lai had abused his media image as a “protective shield” and, even after being convicted, continued to insist that he had done nothing wrong. The two charges together resulted in a sentence of 5 years and 9 months’ imprisonment. Wong was sentenced to 21 months after the judge took into account that he had acted on Lai’s instructions and had received no personal benefit. After the hearing, a spectator said to Lai, “Mr Lai, happy birthday!” Lai’s daughter wept outside the court.
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英及前行政總監黃偉強,被指使用將軍澳工業邨壹傳媒大樓經營力高顧問公司,隱瞞違反租契條款,二人否認欺詐罪,早前被裁定罪成,押後至今早(10日)於區域法院判刑。法官陳廣池批評二人濫用政府所批出的廉租土地,使承租人「自肥」,更指黎智英濫用傳媒形象為「保護罩」,被定罪後仍堅持沒有做錯,兩罪合共判監5年9個月。至於黃偉強,陳官考慮他聽命於黎、沒獲得個人利益,判監21個月。散庭後,有旁聽人士向黎智英道:「黎生,生日快樂!」黎的女兒在庭外落淚。
7 Dec 2022法庭線#5806
11.18 理大衝突|羅健熙非法集結罪不成立 律政司上訴 羅被帶到高院、官准保釋
On 18 November 2019, members of the public went to Tsim Sha Tsui to “rescue” protesters inside PolyU, and many people were arrested. Democratic Party chairman Lo Kin-hei was found not guilty of unlawful assembly after trial last Wednesday (30 November). District Court Judge Eddie Yip said Lo had gone to the scene “to raise his profile and accumulate political capital, hoping to create an image of standing on the same side as the protesters”, and that he had brought suspicion upon himself, but ruled that the prosecution evidence was insufficient for a conviction.
The Department of Justice lodged an appeal by way of case stated on Monday (5 December). On Wednesday (7 December), police took Lo to the High Court, where the Department of Justice applied to impose bail conditions. High Court Judge Pang Min-chi approved the application, including cash bail of $5,000, a prohibition on leaving Hong Kong, surrender of his travel documents, and reporting to a police station once a week.
2019 年 11 月 18 日,市民發起到尖沙咀「營救」理大內示威者,多人被捕。民主黨主席羅健熙上周三(11 月 30 日)經審訊後,被裁定非法集結罪不成立,區院法官練錦鴻指他到現場,「為了提高知名度及囤積政治本錢,希望塑造一個與示威者站在同一陣線的形象」,又指他自招嫌疑,惟認為控方證供不足以定罪。
律政司周一(5 日)以案件呈述方式提上訴,警方周三(7 日)將羅帶往高等法院,律政司申請向他施加保釋條件,獲法官潘敏琦批准,包括以 5,000 元現金保釋、期間不准離港、交出旅行證件,以及每周一次向警署報到。
7 Dec 2022法庭線#5807
採訪 7.21 襲擊查車牌罪成 蔡玉玲申上訴至終院 終院 1.17 處理上訴許可申請
Former producer of RTHK news programme “Hong Kong Connection” Choy Yuk Ling, Bao was accused of falsely stating to the Transport Department that she was checking vehicle registration details to follow up on reports about the 2019 Yuen Long 7.21 incident. She was convicted in 2021 on two counts of making false statements and fined HK$6,000.
Choy, dissatisfied with the conviction, lodged an appeal. After the High Court dismissed it on the 7th of last month, she applied for leave to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal. The Judiciary’s website says the Court of Final Appeal is scheduled to deal with her application for leave to appeal on 17 January next year. The application will be handled by Permanent Judges Frank Stock, Joseph Fok and Patrick Lam.
港台新聞節目《鏗鏘集》前編導蔡玉玲,被指為跟進 2019 年元朗 721 事件後續報道,向運輸署虛報車牌查冊用途,2021 年被裁定 2 項作出虛假陳述罪成,罰款 6,000元。
蔡不服定罪提出上訴,上月 7 日被高等法院駁回後,再申請上訴至終審法院。司法機構網頁顯示,終院排期於明年 1 月 17 日處理她的上訴許可申請,由常任法官李義、 霍兆剛及林文瀚處理。
7 Dec 2022法庭線#5808
七一刺警|梁健輝死因研訊 陪審團裁定死於自殺
A uniformed police officer was attacked and stabbed outside SOGO in Causeway Bay on July 1, 2021. Leung Kin-fai allegedly stabbed the officer and then stabbed himself in the chest; he was certified dead after being taken to hospital. The inquest into his death entered its fifth day at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Wednesday (the 7th). After summarising the evidence, Coroner Ko Wai-hung gave the jury two options: death by suicide or an open verdict. The jury of three women and two men retired to deliberate and, after about an hour this morning, unanimously ruled that Leung died by suicide. It made no recommendations, and the coroner added nothing further.
一名軍裝警於 2021 年 7 月 1 日在銅鑼灣崇光百貨外遇襲中刀,男子梁健輝涉刺傷警員後自刺胸口,送院後證實不治。死因研訊周三(7 日)在西九龍裁判法院踏入第五日。死因裁判官高偉雄總結證供後,為陪審團提供「死於自殺」及「死因存疑」兩個選項。3 女 2 男陪審團退庭商議今早約一小時後,一致裁定梁死於自殺,沒有提供建議,死因裁判官亦沒有補充。
6 Dec 2022法庭線#5799
10.1 沙田|情侶暴動罪成判囚 4 年半 官:兩人戴防火手套 非吶喊助威
On Oct. 1, 2019, clashes broke out in multiple districts. A young couple, aged 21 and 20 respectively, were arrested after fleeing hand in hand during a police dispersal. The pair were charged with rioting and were sentenced to four and a half years in prison at the District Court on Tuesday (the 6th).
2019 年 10 月 1 日,多區爆發衝突,一對分別 21 及 20 歲的年輕情侶,在警方驅散時手牽手逃跑,最終被捕。兩人被控暴動罪,周二(6 日)在區域法院被判監禁 4 年半。
6 Dec 2022法庭線#5800
涉致謝梁健輝被控宣揚恐怖主義 4 港大生擬不認罪 排期 2023 年 9 月開審
Four University of Hong Kong students were accused of moving and supporting a motion at the student union council in 2021 concerning Leung Kin-fai, the suspect in the July 1 police-stabbing case. They were charged with one count of “advocating terrorism” under the National Security Law. The case was heard again at the District Court on Tuesday (the 6th).
4 名港大生被指於 2021 年學生會評議會上,動議及支持七一刺警案疑兇梁健輝的議案,被控一項《國安法》下的「宣揚恐怖主義」罪,案件周二(6 日)在區域法院再訊。
辯方表示 4 人擬不認罪,將爭議被告的行為是否構成違法及其犯罪意圖。區域法院法官王詩麗排期案件於 2023 年 9 月 11 日開審,預計審期 8 日,將由《國安法》指定法官審理,被告期間續准以原有條件保釋。
6 Dec 2022法庭線#5801
支聯會被指煽動顛覆案|李卓人高院申保釋被拒 呈張炳良石禮謙信件證「和理非」
In the case in which the Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China, its former chair and vice-chair Lee Cheuk-yan, Albert Ho Chun-yan and Chow Hang-tung are accused of “inciting subversion of state power”, Lee, who has been remanded for more than a year, applied for bail at the High Court on Tuesday (the 6th). The defence submitted letters from several political figures, including former Secretary for Transport and Housing Cheung Bing-leung and Abraham Razack, a former pro-establishment Legislative Council member, to demonstrate that Lee is a representative figure of the labour sector, is “peaceful, rational and non-violent”, and keeps his word and would certainly comply with the bail conditions.
After hearing submissions from both the prosecution and defence, Judge Andrew Hing Wai Chan considered that the Alliance had operated for a long time and that, after the National Security Law took effect, Lee continued to act in the name of the Alliance. The judge also considered that whether the slogan “end one-party dictatorship” in the Alliance’s five-point programme was subversive remained a matter for interpretation, and that the case against Lee was quite strong. If convicted, he would receive a substantial prison sentence. Lee’s application was ultimately refused and he must remain in custody.
支聯會、前正、副主席李卓人、何俊仁及鄒幸彤被指「煽動顛覆國家政權」案,還押逾一年的李卓人周二(6 日)向高等法院申請保釋。辯方呈上多封政界人物的信件,如前運輸及房屋局局長張炳良、建制派前立法會議員石禮謙等,指李卓人是勞工界代表人物,力證他是「和理非」、為人信守承諾,定必遵守保釋條件。
法官陳慶偉聽畢控辯雙方陳詞,認為支聯會運作已久,《國安法》生效後,李卓人仍以支聯會名義行事,而支聯會五大綱領中「結束一黨專政」口號是否具顛覆性有待詮釋,認為針對李卓人的指控相當強,一旦罪成會判處不短刑期,最終拒絕李的申請,他須繼續還押。
5 Dec 2022法庭線#5797
8.5 將軍澳|24 歲男認警署外暴動囚 32 月 求情指因病完全切除大腸 獲酌情減刑
Judge Yiu Fan-chi said the violence in the case was serious, the police station had been targeted and the incident was large in scale, warranting a deterrent sentence, with a starting point of four and a half years. The defence said the defendant had undergone total colectomy at just two weeks old due to illness, had since needed to use the toilet frequently, and had never slept for more than two hours in his life. Taking the defendant’s physical condition and guilty plea into account, the judge ultimately imposed a sentence of two years and eight months after a discretionary reduction.
法官姚勳智指,本案使用的暴力程度高,並以警署為目標,規模較大,須判處阻嚇性刑罰,應以 4 年半為量刑起點。辯方求情指被告出生僅 2 周已因病完全切除大腸,自此需經常去洗手間,一生未曾試過睡多過 2 小時。法官最終因應被告的身體狀況和認罪,酌情扣減後判囚 2 年 8 個月。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.