Union fears opinions may be treated as criticism, leading civil servants to cross red lines; employees delete social media posts for safety
工會擔心「意見」被當「批評」誤觸紅線 公務員刪社交媒體保平安
The government yesterday launched a consultation document on a revised Civil Service Code. It retained the term “political neutrality” but added substantially more prerequisites, including a requirement to pledge allegiance to the country and the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. The Code also requires civil servants not to criticise the government in their capacity as civil servants, while imposing various rules on expressing views in a personal capacity. Secretary for the Civil Service Ingrid Yeung Ho Poi-yan said on radio this morning that private-sector organisations likewise do not allow employees to criticise their companies. She said that in future, even if civil servants state that they are speaking in a “personal capacity”, this would not be a licence to “say whatever they want”; in particular, if their remarks undermined the rule of law, she “strongly advised colleagues not to say it”. Tang Lai-ngo, chairwoman of the Federation of Civil Service Unions, said the Code contained grey areas over “when something is criticism and when it is an opinion”. She believed more civil servants would delete their social media accounts or posts to avoid crossing the government’s “red lines”, thinking, “Don’t bother; it’s better if they can’t see me.”
政府昨日推出新版《公務員守則》的諮詢文件,保留「政治中立」字眼,但大幅增加前設,例如必須效忠國家和香港特區;《守則》亦要求不得用公務員身份對政府作出批評,個人身份發表意見時亦有多項規範。公務員事務局局長楊何蓓茵今早在電台表示,私人機構工作也不容許員工批評公司,日後即使公務員申明「私人身份講」,也不是「講乜都得」的牌照,尤其若言論衝擊法治,她「強烈建議同事唔好講」。公務員工會聯合會主席唐麗娥認為《守則》存在灰色地帶,「幾時係批評,幾時係意見」,相信更多公務員會為了避免踩中政府「紅線」而刪除社交媒體,「唔好煩,睇唔到我仲好」。
