13 Nov 2025法庭線#7532
19歲女認煽惑鼓勵投票成立「香港議會」囚12月 官稱接納受前男友影響或操控
The police National Security Department issued a statement this year describing “Hong Kong Parliament” as a subversive organisation. A 19-year-old woman was accused of filming videos in Canada and elsewhere between March and May this year with the intention of inciting and encouraging Hong Kong residents to establish the organisation through voting. She pleaded guilty last month to a sedition offence under “Article 23” and was sentenced at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Thursday (13th).
So Wai-tak, a national security law designated judge and Chief Magistrate, said “Hong Kong Parliament” inherited the objectives of the “Hong Kong Parliament Preparatory Committee”, allegedly involving inciting Hong Kong residents to overthrow the Chinese Communist Party and claiming that the Chinese Communist Party was a “transnational criminal organisation”. He said the organisation challenged national sovereignty and threatened national security, while the defendant’s ideology was consistent with that of the organisation. The judge said he accepted that the defendant had committed the offence under the influence or control of her ex-boyfriend and would take this into account in sentencing. However, the sentence had to be increased because of the overseas elements, and apart from her guilty plea there were no other mitigating factors.
「香港議會」今年被警方國安處發稿,定性為顛覆組織。一名 19 歲女子被指今年 3 月至 5 月在加拿大等地拍片,意圖煽惑和鼓勵香港居民藉投票成立該組織。她上月承認「23 條」下的煽動罪,周四(13 日)在西九龍裁判法院判刑。
《國安法》指定法官、總裁判官蘇惠德指,「香港議會」繼承「香港議會籌備委員會」宗旨,涉煽動香港居民推翻中共、又宣稱中共為「跨國犯罪組織」,挑戰國家主權、威脅國安等,而被告意識形態,與此等組織一致。官稱接納被告受前男友影響或操控犯案,指會列入量刑考慮,但因涉及境外因素需加刑,另除認罪外沒其他減刑因素。
20 Sept 2024集誌社#4063
新煽動罪|網上發「共產黨下台」等訊息判囚14個月 法官:66 個讚好「非完全沒網民注意」
The new sedition offence under Article 23 came into force in March and carries a maximum sentence of seven years’ imprisonment. Following the sentencing yesterday (19th) in the first two cases involving a “seditious intention” offence, the court today (20th) heard another case involving knowingly publishing publications with a seditious intention. A 58-year-old man was charged with posting messages on social media including “Down with the Communist Party, peace will prevail” and “If people do not oppose communism, they cut themselves off from heaven and earth”. More than 200 posts were involved, including reposted content. The defendant pleaded guilty at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts and was sentenced to 14 months’ imprisonment.
The defence submitted that the defendant’s four social media accounts had only 20 followers and that his posts received no response. However, when sentencing, the judge said the more than 200 messages posted by the defendant had attracted 66 likes and that it was “not that no netizens noticed”. The judge also said the content was repetitive and rather monotonous, “but because it was repeated incessantly, it created a brainwashing effect and made it easy to implant ideas in other people’s minds.”
23 條下的新煽動罪,今年三月生效,罪成最高可判處七年監禁;較昨日(19日)法庭就首兩宗涉「煽動意圖」罪案件判刑,法庭今(20)再審理一宗「明知而發布具煽動意圖的刊物」案件。一名 58 歲男士被控在社交平台發佈「共產黨下台,天下太平」、「人不反共,自絕天地」等字句,涉逾 200 則帖文,當中包含轉發內容。被告在西九龍裁判法院認罪,被判囚 14 個月。
辯方陳詞指被告的四個社交媒體帳戶,只有 20 名追隨者、其帖文沒有迴響。惟法官判刑時指,被告發布的 200 多段訊息吸引了 66 個「讚好」,「並非完全沒有網民注意」;又指有關內容重重複複,頗為單調,「但因不停重複,形成洗腦式的效果,容易把思想植入別人的腦海中。」
20 Sept 2024法庭線#4064
23條|新煽動罪第三案判刑 男子網上提「革命無罪」認罪判囚14個月
About six months after Article 23 took effect, records by The Witness show that there have been three prosecution cases under the new sedition offence. In one of them, a 58-year-old man was accused of posting statements or photographs, including “Revolution is guiltless; rebellion is justified”, on YouTube and other online platforms between March and June this year. He pleaded guilty on Friday (the 20th) and was sentenced to 14 months in prison, making this the third sentencing under the new offence.
Defence counsel Steven Kwan had initially intended to challenge the constitutionality of the charge, but said the defendant changed his plea to guilty after leave to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal on the same issue was refused in the Tam Tak-chi case. The defence maintained that an increase in the maximum penalty for the new sedition offence did not mean the sentence should rise accordingly. It also argued that the new sedition offence was not a preventive offence and that the court must consider the actual outcome of the incitement when determining the sentence.
Chief Magistrate So Wai-tak, who is handling all three cases under the new sedition offence, maintained his view that the more severe penalty strengthened its preventive effect, setting 18 months’ imprisonment as the sentencing starting point. A comparison by The Witness found that this sentencing level was the same as in the Tam Tak-chi case under the former offence.
23 條生效約半年,按《法庭線》紀錄現有 3 宗新煽動罪的起訴個案。其中,58 歲男子涉在今年 3 月 至 6 月在 YouTube 等網上平台發布包括「革命無罪造反有理」等陳述或相片,他周五(20 日)認罪,被判囚 14 個月,是新罪第三宗判刑。
辯方大狀關文渭原擬爭議控罪合憲性,但稱因「譚得志案」就同一議題被拒批終極上訴許可,本案被告因而改為認罪,同時續主張新煽動罪最高刑罰調高,不等於要量刑隨之而增加,另又提出新煽動罪非預防性罪行,法庭須看實際煽惑結果考慮判刑。
同時負責新煽動罪 3 案的總裁判官蘇惠德維持看法,即更嚴峻的刑罰強化了預防性,以判囚 18 個月為量刑起點。《法庭線》比較發現,該量刑水平與舊罪譚得志案一樣。
20 Sept 2024法庭線#4065
新煽動罪3案審結 兩案量刑起點與舊罪譚得志案一致 官:立法藉嚴刑除危國安風險
The first three cases under the Article 23 “new sedition offence” were concluded this week, marking the first time that courts have imposed sentences under the new law, which raises the maximum penalty. The sentencing starting points have attracted considerable attention. In two cases, the defendants had previous convictions for the old sedition offence, and the magistrate set imprisonment of 18 months as the starting point in both cases—the same level as in the Tam Tak-chi case under the old offence. In the remaining case, the starting point was 12 months’ imprisonment.
All three cases were handled by Chief Magistrate So Wai-tak, and all three defendants were represented by barrister Steven Kwan. Citing a Court of Appeal case, the defence argued that raising the maximum sentence did not mean that the penalty should consequently be increased. So cited another case in response, saying that the legal principle in the case relied on was wrong, and that the increase in penalties reflected the legislature’s intention to eliminate through harsher punishment the risks of endangering national security and disrupting social order, which the court had to take into account.
23 條「新煽動罪」的首 3 宗案件本周審結,是法庭首次按提升最高刑罰的新法例判處刑罰,量刑起點備受關注。其中,有舊煽動罪案底的兩名被告,裁判官皆以囚 18 個月為量刑起點,水平與舊罪的譚得志案一樣。餘下一案,官則以囚 12 個月為量刑起點。
3 案均由總裁判官蘇惠德處理,3 被告同樣由大狀關文渭代表。關引上訴庭案例,指調高最高刑期也不等於刑罰要隨之調高;蘇則引另一案例反駁,指關引的案例法律原則有錯,又指調高刑罰反映立法機關藉嚴刑消除危害國安、破壞社會秩序的風險,法庭必須考慮。
19 Sept 2024法庭線#4060
23條|首宗新煽動罪定罪 27歲男認6.12穿「光時」衫遊蕩 判囚14個月
On June 12 this year, a 27-year-old man was accused of loitering at Shek Mun MTR Station while wearing clothing bearing the words “Liberate Hong Kong, Revolution of Our Times” and a yellow “F.D.N.O.L” mask, and of refusing to produce his identity card. He was charged with three offences, including the new sedition offence under the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance. He pleaded guilty to the sedition charge and was sentenced to 14 months’ imprisonment at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Thursday (19th).
今年 6 月 12 日,27 歲男子被指穿著印有「光復香港 時代革命」衣物、戴黃色「F.D.N.O.L 」口罩,在石門港鐵站遊蕩及拒出示身份證,被起訴《維護國家安全條例》下「新煽動罪」等 3 罪。他承認煽動罪,周四(19 日)在西九龍裁判法院被判囚 14 個月。
總裁判官蘇惠德指判刑須考慮立法原意,指當局藉更嚴峻的刑罰強化預防性,消除危害國安的風險。官指,被告在 6 月 12 日,即示威者視為標誌性的日子,伺機宣場危害國安訊息,斥其「藉一個象徵啟動的日子…企圖令動亂的思想死灰復燃。」
官又指,若法律不及早介入,會令社會再陷亂象,認為判刑的阻嚇不單為防止無知之人仿傚,亦要阻嚇「已經持有或認同被告人主張的人,從事散播危害國家安全思想的活動。」官以 18 個月監禁為量刑起點,因被告曾有類同案底,官斥不知悔改須加刑儆效尤。
19 Sept 2024法庭線#4061
23條|男子涉巴士椅背寫煽動字句 承認3項煽動罪囚10月
The National Security Department of the police earlier charged a 29-year-old man with three new sedition offences under the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance and two counts of destroying or damaging property. The defendant pleaded guilty to the three sedition offences at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Thursday (19th) and was sentenced to 10 months’ imprisonment.
The case stated that the defendant had written phrases including “Hong Kong independence” and “Liberate Hong Kong” on buses on separate occasions. After his arrest, he said he was expressing that he had freedom of speech. In mitigation, the defence said the defendant had wanted to prove that Hong Kong still had freedom of speech, but that his “social experiment was doomed to fail”. It also said that although the maximum sentence for the new sedition offence had increased from two years to seven years, the maximum sentence applied only to the most serious cases and “does not mean that all sentences have to be increased three and a half times”. The defence said the defendant hoped to turn over a new leaf after serving his sentence and “not get involved in social testing again”.
In sentencing, Chief Magistrate So Wai-tak said the defendant knew that the relevant phrases were illegal but had nevertheless repeatedly committed the offences. He also said the defendant had targeted buses to spread messages advocating Hong Kong independence and endangering national security. If intervention had not been made at an early stage, the “ripple effect” would have caused society to fall into chaos again.
警方國安處早前落案控告一名 29 歲男子,控以 3 項《維護國家安全條例》下新煽動罪,以及兩項摧毀或損壞財產罪。被告周四(19 日)在西九龍裁判法院承認 3 項煽動罪,被判囚 10 個月。
案情指,被告先後在巴士上寫上「香港獨立」、「光復香港」等字句,被捕後稱以此表達自己有言論自由。辯方求情指被告欲證本港仍有言論自由,但其「社會實驗注定失敗」,又指新煽動罪最高刑期由2年上升至7年,但最高刑期只適用於最嚴重者,「唔係所有都要增加3倍半」。辯方指,被告期望服刑後重新做人,「唔再牽涉喺社會測試上」。
總裁判官蘇惠德判刑時指,被告明知有關字句違法,仍一而再、再而三犯案,又指他以巴士為目標,達致宣揚香港獨立和危害國安的訊息。若不及早介入,在疊加效應的影響下,「會導致社會再次陷入亂象」。
31 Aug 2024獨媒#3994
【城大教授自殺】消息指國安拘2人指涉發布虛假遺言、放悼念燈箱煽動憎恨
As of yesterday (30th), the Police National Security Department arrested a man and a woman in Kowloon and the New Territories. The woman was suspected of publishing false “last words of the deceased” in connection with the above incident, while the man was suspected of repeatedly placing memorial light boxes at multiple locations to incite hatred against the central authorities and the Hong Kong government. The two, aged 41 and 28 respectively, were suspected of violating Section 24 of the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance, the offence of “doing one or more acts with seditious intention.”
至昨日(30日),警方國安處在九龍及新界拘捕一男一女,指女子涉就上述事件發布虛假的「死者遺言」,男子則涉嫌持續在多個地點放置悼念燈箱,煽動憎恨中央及港府。兩人年齡分別為41和28歲,涉嫌違反《維護國家安全條例》第24條「出於煽動意圖作出一項或多項具煽動意圖的作為」罪。
25 Jun 2024法庭線#3729
23條|警方首就新煽動罪檢控發稿公布 29歲男涉巴士椅背寫煽動字句 還押8.22再訊
The government issued a press release at noon on Tuesday (25th), saying that the Police National Security Department had charged a 29-year-old man with three counts of the new sedition offence under the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance and two counts of destroying or damaging property. The case is also the first prosecution under the new sedition offence announced by police in a press release since Article 23 came into force. In the two previous prosecutions recorded by the media, police did not issue news announcements.
The case was brought before the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Tuesday afternoon. The prosecution applied to adjourn the case for further police investigation, including examination of the defendant’s phone and computer and investigation into whether he was involved in other cases. The prosecution opposed bail, while the defence did not make a bail application. The defendant was remanded until Aug 22 for mention.
政府周二(25 日)中午發稿,指警方國安處落案控告一名 29 歲男子,控以 3 項《維護國家安全條例》下新煽動罪,以及兩項摧毀或損壞財產罪。此案亦是「23 條」生效後,首宗警方發稿公布的新煽動罪檢控,之前傳媒有紀錄的兩宗檢控,警方均未發新聞公告。
案件周二下午在西九龍裁判法院提堂,控方申請押後案件,待警方進一步調查,檢查被告的電話、電腦,以及調查被告是否涉及其他案件。控方反對被告保釋,辯方則沒有擔保申請,還押至 8 月 22 日再訊。
31 May 2024法庭線#3606
鄒幸彤等7人被指違新煽動罪准保釋 警指一人亦涉資助羅冠聰違《國安法》
The Police National Security Department arrested a total of six women and one man from Tuesday onwards, including Chow Hang-tung, former vice-chairwoman of the Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China. Police alleged that they had published seditious posts on the Facebook page “Siu Tung Kwan Chau Club” before “a certain sensitive date”, suspected of violating the offence of having a seditious intention under the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance.
Police said on Friday (the 31st) that six people had been granted bail while one woman remained in custody. They also alleged that the woman arrested on Wednesday had, through an online subscription platform, “provided financial assistance to fugitive Nathan Law and other people”, amounting to about $140,000, suspected of violating the National Security Law offence of “providing financial or other property assistance to others to secede”.
Apart from Chow Hang-tung, the other six arrested people were Chow’s mother Lau Wah-chun; former district councillor Kim Kam Chan; dentist Ying Chi (Med) Lee; former standing committee members of the Hong Kong Alliance Ka Yee (1980) Lau and Kwan Chun-bong; and Kwan’s wife, Poon Yau-chui, who was arrested on Wednesday. The 47-person case was ruled on at West Kowloon Court on Thursday, and Kim Kam Chan and Ying Chi (Med) Lee both attended the hearing.
警方國安處周二起拘捕一共 6 女 1 男,包括支聯會前副主席鄒幸彤,指他們於「某個敏感日子」前於Facebook 專頁「小彤群抽會」發布煽動帖文,涉嫌違反《維護國安條例》下的煽動意圖罪。
警方周五(31 日)指,6 人已獲准保釋,而一名女子繼續還押;又指周三被捕的女子,於網上訂閱平台「以金錢資助逃犯羅冠聰及其他人士」,金額約為 14 萬元,涉嫌違反《國安法》下的「以金錢或其他財物資助他人分裂國家」罪。
除鄒幸彤外,其餘 6 名被捕人為鄒母劉華珍、前區議員陳劍琴、牙醫李盈姿、前支聯會常委劉家儀和關振邦,以及關妻潘幼翠,而潘於周三被捕。47 人案周四於西九龍法院裁決,陳劍琴、李盈姿都有到場。
31 May 2024獨媒#3611
「敏感日子」煽動案 國安處稱一人涉資助逃犯羅冠聰等
Six people, including former vice-chairwoman of the Hong Kong Alliance Chow Hang-tung, were arrested on May 28 for allegedly continuing to post messages on the eve of “sensitive dates”, in violation of the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance. Police arrested a seventh person the following day, May 29. Apart from Chow, who is in custody, the other six were released on bail. In a press release today, the Police National Security Department said the seventh person allegedly funded fugitive Nathan Law and others through an online subscription platform, involving approximately HK$140,000. Police said she was suspected of violating Article 24 of the National Security Law, the offence of “providing financial or other property assistance to others to secede the country”.
前支聯會副主席鄒幸彤等6人,日前(5月28日)被指涉嫌在「敏感日子」前夕持續發帖,違反《維護國家安全條例》被捕。警方在翌日(5月29日)再拘捕第7人,除在囚的鄒幸彤外,其餘6人皆獲保釋。警方國安處今日發新聞稿補充,稱第7名被拘捕的人士涉透過網上訂閱平台,資助逃犯羅冠聰等人士,金額約14萬元,警方指她涉違反《國安法》24條「以金錢或其他財物資助他人分裂國家」罪。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.