Stand News case: Prosecution opening submissions repeatedly use phrases such as “purpose is self-evident” and “purpose is apparent without being stated”
《立場新聞》案 控方開案陳詞多次用上「目的不言而喻」、「目的不宣自告」等字眼
In the case involving the alleged conspiracy to publish seditious publications by Stand News, former editor-in-chief Chung Pui-kuen testified yesterday that the prosecution frequently used expressions such as “self-evident” in its opening submissions, conducting a criminal prosecution through associations and speculation. He said this had resulted in people being remanded in custody and the media organisation being forced to close, and questioned whether the chilling effect and suppression of freedom of expression were disproportionate. The prosecution responded that the prosecution was based on the evidence, and that “self-evident” referred to something obvious and known without needing to be stated.
《立場新聞》涉串謀發布煽動刊物案,被告前總編輯鍾沛權昨日作供時指出,控方的開案陳詞經常用「不言而喻」這些說法,透過一些聯想和猜測來進行刑事檢控,因而令人還押,因而令傳媒機構關閉,質疑這對言論自由的寒蟬效應和打壓大得不成比例。控方回應說,檢控是根據證據,而「不言而喻」是指顯而而見,不用說也知道的事。
