25 May 2023法庭線#6494
光城者案|被指策劃炸彈襲擊 21歲男判囚5年8月 3人被判入教導所
Six men and women, some of them members of Returning Valiant, were accused of planning to place bombs at various locations in Hong Kong. They were charged under the National Security Law with conspiracy to commit terrorist activities, with the alternative charge of conspiracy to cause an explosion likely to endanger life or property. Five were secondary school students aged 15 to 19 when charged and had earlier pleaded guilty to the alternative charge. The other defendant, an alleged mastermind who was 17 at the time, pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit terrorist activities.
National Security Law-designated judge Wilson Li sentenced a 21-year-old man to 5 years and 8 months in prison at the High Court on Friday (25th). Three other defendants aged under 21 were sent to a training centre. The remaining two applied to adjourn sentencing and will return to court on September 27; they remain remanded in custody in the meantime.
The judge said Hong Kong society had been unstable at the time of the offences, with many people resorting to violence to express political demands. The defendants had targeted courts, which symbolise the rule of law in Hong Kong, seriously undermining the dignity of the judiciary. He also said information about making explosives was readily available online and the materials could easily be obtained, so the sentences had to be deterrent. The 21-year-old had rented a guesthouse and was more culpable than the other three, receiving a sentence of 5 years and 8 months. The other three had lesser roles and were sent to a training centre.
6 名男女,部分為「光城者」成員,被指計劃在香港不同地方放置炸彈,被控《國安法》的「串謀恐怖活動罪」,及交替控罪「串謀導致相當可能危害生命或財產的爆炸罪」。其中 5 人被起訴時為 15 至 19 歲的中學生,早前承認交替控罪,另一名被指為主腦、案發時 17 歲男生則承認「串謀恐怖活動罪」。
《國安法》指定法官李運騰周五(25 日)在高等法院,判現年 21 歲青年監禁 5 年 8 個月,另外 3 名未滿 21 歲青年則判入教導所。另外兩人申請押後判刑,將於 9 月 27 日再訊,期間繼續還押。
法官指,案發時香港社會氣氛不穩,不少人訴諸暴力以表達政治訴求。被告以象徵香港法治的法院作為目標,嚴重削弱司法尊嚴。法官又指,網上有關製作爆炸品的資訊隨處可見,亦容易取得相關物料,判刑必須具阻嚇性。其中 21 歲青年曾租用賓館,罪責較另外 3 人重,判囚 5 年 8 個月。另外 3 人角色較次要,判入教導所。
20 Apr 2023獨媒#6338
光城者7人涉串謀恐怖活動 再多一人被起訴 23歲男學生被拒保釋 還柙至5.12訊
Returning Valiant was accused of planning terrorist activities at public facilities. Seven men and women were charged in three cases with one count of conspiracy to commit terrorism, with one count of conspiracy to cause an explosion likely to endanger life or property as an alternative charge. Another person was charged two years later, bringing the total number involved in the case to eight. The 23-year-old male student was brought to West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on the 20th. NSL-designated judge and Chief Magistrate So Wai-tak adjourned the case to May 12 for a mention to begin committal proceedings to the High Court. The defendant’s bail application was refused and he was remanded in custody.
「光城者」被指策劃在公共設施發動恐怖活動,7男女分3案被起訴一項「串謀恐怖活動」罪,及一項「串謀導致相當可能危害生命或財產的爆炸」罪為交替控罪。事隔兩年再多一人被起訴,至今案件共牽涉8人。23歲男學生今(20日)被押解往西九龍裁判法院提堂。《國安法》指定法官、總裁判官蘇惠德將案押後至5月12日作提訊日,以進行將案件交付高等法院的程序。被告申請保釋被拒須還柙。
9 Feb 2023法庭線#6033
光城者案|兩男認「串謀煽動顛覆政權」囚60至63月 官裁情節嚴重、認罪扣減6月
Seven members of “Light City” were accused of setting up street booths to advocate overthrowing the regime by force. The seven earlier admitted the charge of “conspiracy to incite subversion of state power”, in the first case in which a minor was convicted under the National Security Law. Five secondary school students were sentenced to training centres last year, while sentencing for the remaining two adult defendants was adjourned until Thursday (9th). National Security Law-designated judge Kwok Wai-kin sentenced the two men to between five years and five years and three months in prison.
「光城者」7 名成員被指擺街站提倡以武力推翻政權,7 人早前承認「串謀煽動顛覆政權」罪,屬首宗有未成年人因《國安法》定罪的案件。其中 5 名中學生去年被判入教導所,餘下兩名成年被告則押後至周四(9 日)判刑。《國安法》指定法官郭偉健判二人監禁 5 年至 5 年 3 個月。
16 Dec 2022法庭線#5839
光城者涉串謀恐怖活動案 15歲男生高院申保釋被拒 6被告明年3月答辯
A boy who was 15 when charged applied for bail in the High Court on Friday (16th). After hearing submissions, National Security Law designated judge Lee Wan-tang dismissed the application, and the boy remains in custody. The Judiciary’s website shows that the boy and the other five defendants in the case will formally enter pleas and be sentenced on 28 March 2023.
一名被起訴時 15 歲的男生周五(16 日)於高等法院申請保釋,《國安法》指定法官李運騰聽畢陳詞後駁回其申請,男生繼續還押。司法機構網頁顯示,男生與本案另外 5 名被告,將於 2023 年 3 月 28 日正式答辯及判刑。
11 Nov 2022法庭線#5702
光城者涉串謀恐怖活動 18 歲女學生首向高院申保釋遭拒
The organisation ‘Light City’ was accused of planning to place bombs at various locations in Hong Kong. Seven men and women aged 15 to 24 were charged under the National Security Law with conspiracy to commit terrorism. Six of them remain on remand, now for more than a year. Among them, 18-year-old student So Wing-ching made her first bail application to the High Court on Friday (11th) without legal representation. The prosecution opposed the application.
Li Wan-tang, a judge designated under the National Security Law, rejected the bail application after considering submissions from both sides. The Judiciary’s website shows that she and five other defendants in the same case are scheduled to enter pleas and be sentenced on 28 March 2023.
組織「光城者」被指計劃在香港不同地方放置炸彈,7 名 15 至 24 歲的男女被控《國安法》的「串謀恐怖活動罪」,當中 6 人仍在還押、至今超過一年。其中 18 歲女學生蘇穎貞,周五(11 日)在沒有律師代表下,首度向高等法院申請保釋,被控方代表反對。
《國安法》指定法官李運騰考慮雙方陳詞後,拒絕批出擔保。司法機構網頁顯示,她和同案 5 名被告獲排期在 2023 年 3 月 28 日答辯及判刑。
9 Nov 2022法庭線#5695
光城者涉串謀恐怖活動 6 人明年 3.28 答辯判刑 其中 1 人 11.11 申保釋
The organisation Radiant City was accused of planning to place bombs at various locations in Hong Kong. Seven men and women aged between 15 and 24 were charged under the National Security Law with conspiracy to commit terrorist activities, and the alternative charge of conspiracy to cause an explosion likely to endanger life or property. They have been remanded in custody for more than a year.
組織「光城者」被指計劃在香港不同地方放置炸彈,7 名 15 至 24 歲的男女被控《國安法》的「串謀恐怖活動罪」及交替控罪「串謀導致相當可能危害生命或財產的爆炸罪」,還押至今超過一年。
28 Oct 2022法庭線#5628
光城者涉串謀恐怖活動案 男司機高院申保釋獲批 控方不反對 官指取態合理
The organisation “Radiant City” was accused of planning to place bombs at various locations in Hong Kong. Seven men and women aged 15 to 24 were charged under the National Security Law with conspiracy to commit terrorist activities, with the alternative charge of conspiracy to cause explosions likely to endanger life or property. The seven have been remanded for more than a year. A 24-year-old male driver applied for bail at the High Court on Friday (the 28th); the prosecution did not object. The judge said the prosecution’s position was reasonable.
組織「光城者」被指計劃在香港不同地方放置炸彈,7 名 15 至 24 歲的男女被控《國安法》的「串謀恐怖活動罪」及交替控罪「串謀導致相當可能危害生命或財產的爆炸罪」。7 人至今還押超過一年,當中一名 24 歲男司機周五(28 日)在高等法院申請保釋;控方不反對。
25 Oct 2022獨媒#5607
警方國安處拘7人 其中一人涉「參與實施恐怖活動」罪 據悉曾資助「光城者」
National security police arrested seven people yesterday (the 24th). One of them, a 22-year-old man arrested in Yuen Long, is suspected of committing the offence of “participating in terrorist activities” under the National Security Law, as well as arson, conspiracy to commit arson, conspiracy to defraud and money laundering. Police said the man was linked to several local criminal organisations. He reportedly provided financial support to the organisation “Gwong Sing Ze”. Police also said the arrested man was suspected of participating last year in the burning of government testing stations.
警方國安處昨(24日)拘捕7人,其中一名於元朗區被捕的22歲男子,涉嫌干犯《港區國安法》中「參與實施恐怖活動」,另涉縱火、串謀縱火、串謀詐騙及洗黑錢罪。警方指該男子與數個本土犯罪組織有關。據悉他曾向組織「光城者」提供金錢資助。另外警方指被捕男子亦涉去年參與燒毁政府檢測站。
8 Oct 2022獨媒#2578
【光城者案】7人承認串謀煽動顛覆政權罪 5人判入教導所 兩人押後判刑
Seven members of the political organisation Gwong Sing Ze, aged 16 to 26, were charged under the National Security Law with conspiracy to incite subversion of state power after setting up street booths to call for an “armed uprising”. Six of them had been remanded for nearly a year. All seven defendants previously pleaded guilty. In the first case in which a minor was convicted of a National Security Law offence, five defendants under the age of 21 were sentenced to training centres at the District Court today (8th), while sentencing for the other two was adjourned. National Security Law designated judge Kwok Wai-kin said the defendants had regarded the Central Government and the Hong Kong Government as totalitarian governments when they committed the offences. Although they had received a good education, they had been influenced by the social atmosphere and held mistaken perceptions of Hong Kong and the country. Judge Kwok said the case involved serious circumstances, but reduced it to the less serious category because the defendants had committed the offences when they were young and immature.
7名16至26歲的政治組織「光城者」成員,因擺街站呼籲「武裝起義」,遭控《國安法》的「串謀煽動顛覆國家政權」罪,其中6人已還柙近一年。案中7人早前全數認罪,為首次有未成年者被裁定《國安法》罪成,其中5名未滿21歲被告今(8日)在區域法院被判入教導所。《國安法》指定法官郭偉健指,各人犯案時認為中央政府及香港政府是極權政府,他們雖然接受良好教育,但受社會氛圍影響,對香港及國家有錯誤觀感。郭官指本案為情節嚴重,但考慮到他們年輕不成熟而犯案,因此降低至情節較輕。
8 Oct 2022獨媒#2579
官指組織籲寫信予在囚手足為建抗爭網絡 讚被告求情信引《中國的民主》白皮書
National Security Law-designated judge Kwok Wai-kin said the organisation had urged people to write to jailed comrades in order to establish a network and plan a long-term struggle. Although there was no evidence that anyone had been incited to revolution, he said social stability would be endangered if even a small group of people were incited. After sentencing, Judge Kwok praised the defendant for citing content from the China’s Democracy white paper in the mitigation letter to recognise the facts. He continued: “Whether you like this place or not, historically and legally this really is a place of China,” and suggested that people could pay attention to “what the Chinese government has done, what it has done well and what it has not done well.”
《國安法》指定法官郭偉健指,組織呼籲寫信予在囚手足,從而建立網絡,並計劃長遠抗爭。另外雖無證據顯示有人被煽動革命,但只要一小撮人受煽動,社會穩定將受危害。郭官在判刑後稱讚被告在求情信引用《中國的民主》白皮書的內容,以認清事實。他續指:「不論你鍾唔鍾意呢個地方,歷史上、法律上呢度真係中國嘅地方」,並建議可留意「中國政府做咗咩,做得好、做得唔好」。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.