Sheep Village case defendants remanded for a year before verdict; defence says vague law will have a chilling effect
羊村案被告未判先還押一年 辯方:模糊法律會帶來寒蟬效應
Five members of the executive committee of the Hong Kong Speech Therapists’ General Union were charged with conspiracy to print, publish, distribute, display or reproduce seditious publications over the publication of the Sheep Village series of picture books. They have been remanded in custody for a year, and the case has been adjourned to July 30 for closing submissions to continue. The maximum sentence for a first conviction of the offence is two years’ imprisonment. At a hearing earlier this month, the defence said that a further postponement would be unfair to the defendants, saying that by then, “whatever sentence is handed down, the time will already have passed.” The defence also submitted that terms such as “hatred” and “disaffection” in the sedition offence lacked legal certainty. It said vague laws would have a chilling effect, causing people to fear that they could be arrested and denied bail for putting forward narratives other than official ones, as had happened to the defendants in this case.
香港言語治療師總工會5名理事因出版羊村系列繪本,被控「串謀刊印、發布、分發、展示或複製煽動刊物」罪,至今已還押一年,案件將押後至7月30日繼續結案陳詞。該控罪的首次定罪最高刑罰為監禁兩年,辯方在本月初的聆訊中曾提到案件再延後會對被告造成不公,認為屆時「無論判乜嘢都已過咗」。 辯方 另在陳詞中提到煽動罪「憎恨」、「離叛」等字眼欠缺法律確定性,模糊的法律會帶來寒蟬效應,令人們害怕若提出官方以外的論述便會被捕及不准保釋,情況與本案被告相若。
