Lai Chee-ying’s application for leave to challenge National Security Committee’s recommendation to refuse Tim Owen a visa dismissed; ordered to pay costs
指國安委越權建議拒Tim Owen簽證 黎智英申司法覆核許可被駁回 被頒令付訟費
Next Digital founder Lai Chee-ying was charged with “conspiracy to collude with a foreign country” and was granted permission by the court to hire British King’s Counsel Tim Owen to come to Hong Kong to defend him. The Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress subsequently issued an interpretation of Articles 14 and 47 of the National Security Law at the Hong Kong Government’s request, stating that a certificate issued by the Chief Executive should first be obtained before an overseas lawyer may be hired in a case endangering national security. Lai earlier separately filed proceedings in the High Court and applied for leave for judicial review, asking the Secretary for Justice to declare that the NPCSC interpretation did not affect the court’s earlier decision approving Tim Owen’s coming to Hong Kong to defend him. He also argued that the Committee for Safeguarding National Security had exceeded its powers under the National Security Law by recommending that the Immigration Department refuse to issue Owen a visa. In May this year, Chief Judge of the High Court Jeremy Poon dismissed both the application for leave for judicial review and Lai’s summons application. In a judgment on costs handed down on Thursday (the 3rd), Justice Jeremy Poon said Lai’s judicial review application was “wholly unmeritorious” and had no prospect of success. The National Security Law expressly states that the Committee’s decisions are not subject to challenge, and Hong Kong courts had no jurisdiction to supervise it. The application should not have been brought, the judge said, ordering Lai to pay costs on an indemnity basis.
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」,獲法庭批准,聘用英國御用大狀 Tim Owen 來港抗辯。全國人大常委會其後應港府提請,就《國安法》第 14 及 47 條釋法,指在危害國安案件批准聘任海外律師前,應先取得特首發出的證明書。 黎智英早前分別入稟高院及提司法覆核,要求律政司宣布,人大釋法不影響法院早前批准 Tim Owen 來港為其抗辯的決定,又指國安委建議入境處拒絕向他批出簽證,僭越《國安法》權力。高等法院首席法官潘兆初今年 5 月,一併駁回司法覆核許可申請及黎的傳票入稟。 法官潘兆初周四(3 日)就訟費頒下判詞,指黎智英的司法覆核申請完全沒有勝訴機會(wholly unmeritorious),《國安法》已列明國安委的決定不受挑戰,本港法院無權監督,不應提出申請,下令黎以彌償基準支付訟費。
