4 Aug 2023光傳媒#8146
陳慶偉以為Fb「專頁」為「專業」 法官行為指引:對社交媒體缺乏認識或予人脫節觀感
In the case involving 47 pro-democracy primary election defendants, when defendant Chan Chi-chuen referred to a Facebook page, the court interpreter rendered 專頁 as “page”. Judge Andrew Hing Wai Chan corrected this to “professional”, meaning 專業. Chan Chi-chuen clarified that he meant “page” as in a page of a book, not “professional”. Judge Chan’s unfamiliarity with Facebook pages sparked heated online discussion. The Judicial Conduct Guide, updated last year, states that a lack of basic understanding of social media may give the impression that a judge is out of touch with modern society.
民主派47人初選案中,被告陳志全提到Facebook專頁時,法庭傳譯員將「專頁」譯作「page」,法官陳慶偉就糾正是「professional,專業」,陳志全澄清是「一頁書的『頁』」,而非「專業」。陳官不識Facebook專頁引起網上熱議,翻查去年更新的《法官行為指引》,註明對社交媒體缺乏基本認識,或會予人法官與現代社會脫節的觀感。
3 Aug 2023法庭線#8137
47人案|控方質疑曾稱願望是達成35+、沒提不可行 陳志全:希望與相信沒衝突
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power entered its 98th day on Thursday (the 3rd), with Chan Chi-chuen completing three days of testimony. Chan had earlier testified that he had serious doubts about whether “35+” could be achieved. On Thursday, prosecutor Tianxing Zhou referred to remarks Chan made at a street booth in Tseung Kwan O, in which he said his wish was to achieve “35+”, and questioned why he had not mentioned that it was unfeasible.
In response, Chan asked, “When you make a birthday wish for world peace, do you think world peace can be achieved?” He later said he believed that “hope and belief” did not conflict, adding, “Winning more than others is certainly a good thing; that’s what a wish is.”
Chan was also said to have mentioned at the street booth that “Carrie Lam is a puppet” and “not let them [the establishment camp] have an easy time”. Chan denied that the former remark meant bringing down Lam was useless and that the Chinese Communist Party had to be brought down. He said the latter referred to doing his utmost to speak in the legislature, forcing the establishment camp to continue holding meetings, so that “even if they wanted to go to the racecourse to watch horse racing, they couldn’t.”
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周四(3 日)展開第 98 天審訊,陳志全完成共 3 日作供。陳早前供稱對於「35+」能否實現有很大懷疑,主控周天行周四引陳於將軍澳街站發言提及願望是達成「35+」,質疑沒提及不可行。
陳回答時反問,「當你生日許願嘅時候係世界和平嘅時候,你覺得世界和平可唔可以達到呀?」後再稱,認為「希望同埋相信」兩者沒衝突,「贏到多過人地緊係好事嚟㗎,咁係個願望嚟之嘛」。
陳另被指在街站亦提及「林鄭月娥係傀儡」、「唔畀佢(建制派)有好日子過」等,陳否認前者是指打倒林鄭無用,要打倒中共,又稱後者是指在議會盡力發言,令建制派需繼續開會,「想去馬場跑馬呢都去唔到」。
2 Aug 2023法庭線#8131
47人案|陳志全:沒大殺傷力憲制武器概念、始終不認同35+目的在否決預算案
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 97th day on Wednesday (the 2nd), with Chan Chi-chuen giving evidence for a second day. During cross-examination, the prosecution asked whether Chan knew that the purpose of the “35+” plan was to obtain a constitutional weapon. Chan said he knew the purpose of the primary election was “to enable the pan-democrats to win the most seats”, but he had no concept of a “constitutional weapon of mass destruction”.
Under further questioning, Chan said he had never agreed that the purpose of the primary election was to veto the budget. He said many people might have thought that vetoing the budget was the strongest power for compelling the Chief Executive to respond to the “five demands”, but this was not the case “at the operational level”. If the pan-democrats achieved “35+”, he said, the pro-establishment camp would not have enough members to form a quorum, and would not even be able to conduct the first and second readings of the budget at the Legislative Council.
Chan also testified that he had not seen the coordination agreement document for New Territories East. He said the document proposed fielding seven candidate lists, which carried considerable risk and might even have resulted in the loss of six seats. If he had seen the document at the time, he said, “I definitely would have spoken out!”
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周三(2 日)展開第 97 天審訊,陳志全第二日作供。控方盤問時,問陳知否「35+」計劃目的,就是取得憲制武器?陳供稱,知道初選的目的「就係要令到民主派攞到最多嘅議席」,但他沒有「大殺傷力憲制武器」的概念。
陳並在追問下稱,由始至終不認同初選目的是否決預算案,又指可能很多人以為否決預算案是最強權力逼使特首回應「五大訴求」,但「操作層面上」並非如此,因民主派若達成「35+」,建制派將不夠召開會議的法定人數「連個財政預算案嚟立法會首讀、二讀,都讀唔到」。
陳又供稱,沒看過新東的協調協議文件,指文件上提及派出 7 張名單參選,風險很大,甚至保不住 6 個議席,稱若當時看到該文件,「我一定會出聲囉!」
1 Aug 2023法庭線#8115
47人案|陳志全認為35+非實贏 關鍵在於一致行動 稱任議員間民主派出席率低感無力
The 47 democrats’ case of conspiracy to subvert state power entered its 96th day of trial on Tuesday (1st), when another defendant, Chan Chi-chuen, who stood in New Territories East, began giving evidence. Chan said People’s Power was formed out of dissatisfaction with the traditional pan-democrats. It had previously cooperated and coordinated little with the pan-democrats, and was labelled the “Establishment camp’s B team” and “People’s Renminbi Power” because it ran against them.
Chan also said he had always believed the pan-democrats needed a common code of conduct for action. This did not refer to supporting or opposing bills or funding, but to whether legislators responsibly attended meetings and joined different committees. Referring to legislators’ past attendance records, he said: “Of the 10 with the lowest attendance rates, seven were actually pan-democrats,” adding, “So how many seats you have is one matter; whether you actively attend meetings is another.”
Chan also said he had serious doubts in 2020 about whether “35+” could be achieved, and believed there was little chance of the pan-democrats securing 30 seats. However, he continued promoting “35+” in campaign videos and at street booths because society was permeated by a sense of helplessness in 2019 and 2020 — “as if nothing you did was useful”. Chan therefore hoped to “encourage voters to come out and vote, to confront this sense of helplessness” and “tell them that 35+ would provide ABCD choices and the ability [to choose], in the hope that voters would feel the legislature was useful and that voting was useful.” The case will continue on Wednesday, pending a review by Chan’s counsel of whether any other questions were missed; otherwise, the defence case will conclude.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周二(1 日)展開第 96 天審訊,參選新東區的另一被告陳志全開始作供。陳提到,人民力量成立源於對傳統民主派不滿,過往較少與民主派合作、沒協調,亦因與民主派對選,被稱為「建制派 B 隊」、「人民幣力量」。
陳又指,一直認為民主派需有一致的行動守則,不是指贊成或否決法例或撥款,而是指議員有否盡責開會、加入不同的委員會,提到過往議員開會「最低出席率嗰 10 個,有 7 個竟然係民主派」,「所以你有幾多席係一回事,係咪積極開會係另一回事」。
陳另提到,在 2020 年對能否實現「35+」抱很大懷疑,認為民主派取得 30 席機會很微。但他選擇在宣傳片和街站繼續宣傳「35+」,因 2019 及 2020 年社會彌漫著無力感,「好似做乜都無用」,故陳希望以此「鼓勵選民出嚟投票,要對峙呢個無力感」、「話畀佢聽 35+ 就有 ABCD 嘅選擇同能力,希望選民覺得議會有用、投票有用。」案件周三續,以待陳代表律師審視有否遺漏其他提問,否則將完結辯方案情。
2 Nov 2021立場新聞#1668
【47 人案】法官解釋准陳志全保釋原因 稱考慮其過往立會表現 相信不再危害國安
The High Court handed down its judgment explaining the reasons for granting bail to defendant Chan Chi-chuen in the “47-person case”, saying it had considered his past conduct in the Legislative Council and believed he would no longer endanger national security.
高等法院就「47人案」被告陳志全保釋原因頒下判詞,稱考慮其過往立會表現,相信不再危害國安。
16 Sept 2021立場新聞#1574
【47 人案】還押逾半年 陳志全高院申保釋獲批
Chan Chi-chuen was granted bail in the 47-person case.
47人案陳志全獲准保釋。
2 May 2021立場新聞#1367
【47 人案】陳志全發聲明退出人民力量 不再參與選舉、遊行集會或示威
People Power chairman Chan Chi-chuen, who remains remanded in custody in connection with the 47-person case, issued a statement through his family announcing that he was leaving the party and resigning as party chairman. He will no longer take part in any elections, electioneering activities, assemblies, marches or demonstrations.
因47人案目仍然還押的人民力量主席陳志全,透過家人發表聲明宣布退黨及辭任黨主席,日後不會再參與任何選舉、助選活動、集會、遊行或示威。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.