17 May 2024法庭線#3547
黎智英案第78日審訊|國安警講述替陳梓華錄口供過程 另頒令禁披露證人保護計劃細節
Next Digital founder Jimmy Lai and three companies related to Apple Daily have been charged with “conspiracy to collude with a foreign country or with external elements” and other offences. The case entered its 78th day of trial on Friday (17th) at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, temporarily exercising the jurisdiction of the High Court. Under questioning by the defence, a national security police officer described the process of taking Chan Tsz-wah’s statement at a detention centre.
The court also issued an order prohibiting anyone, including the media and the public, from disclosing by any means the identity or whereabouts of a witness under the witness protection programme, or any information that could endanger the person’s safety, to avoid compromising the administration of justice. Breach of the order may constitute contempt of court. The case was adjourned until next Monday (20th).
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英與《蘋果日報》3 間相關公司,被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」等罪,案件周五(17 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)展開第 78 日審訊,國安警在辯方盤問下,講述到羈押中心替陳梓華錄取口供的過程。
另外,法庭頒下命令,指任何人包括媒體及公眾,不得以任何方式披露證人保護計劃下的證人身分、身處位置,或危害此人安全的資料,以免損害司法公義;違反命令可被控藐視法庭。案件押後至下周一(20 日)續審。
6 May 2024法庭線#3491
黎智英案第70日審訊|陳梓華:決定任控方證人後如實交代 「唔想受到良心責難」
The trial of Next Digital founder Jimmy Lai Chee-ying and three companies associated with Apple Daily, who are charged with offences including conspiracy to collude with a foreign country or external elements, entered its 70th day at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, temporarily acting as the High Court, on Monday (6th). Chan Tsz-wah, the fifth accomplice witness, gave evidence for his 12th day.
Under re-examination by the prosecution, Chan confirmed that the statements he made during recorded interviews after his first arrest in October 2020 were false, while statements he made after being charged with a national security offence in April 2021 and deciding to become a prosecution witness were true. Asked to explain, Chan said: “The statement I gave at the beginning wasn’t the truth. Later, I hoped to tell the truth, because I didn’t want to be blamed any more… I didn’t want to be condemned by my conscience.”
The prosecution is expected to call Chow Tat-kwun, chief operating officer of the Next Digital group and its acting chief financial officer at the time, to give evidence after Chan completes his testimony on Tuesday (7th).
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英與《蘋果日報》3 間相關公司,被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」等罪,案件周一(6 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)展開第 70 日審訊,第五位從犯證人陳梓華第 12 天作供。
陳在控方覆問下確認,於 2020 年 10 月首被捕後的錄影會面供詞虛假,及後於 2021 年 4 月以《國安罪》被起訴、及決定成為控方證人後的供詞則屬實。陳在提問下解釋,「我一開始畀嘅口供唔係事實,後來我希望將個事實講返出嚟,因為我唔想再受到責難⋯我唔想受到良心嘅責難」。
控方預計周二(7 日)陳梓華完成作供後,將傳召壹傳媒集團營運總裁兼時任財務總裁周達權作供。
3 May 2024法庭線#3485
黎智英案第69日審訊|陳梓華否認庭上捏造供詞以獲減刑 認首錄口供作假為撇清關係
Jimmy Lai, founder of Next Digital, and three companies linked to Apple Daily are charged with, among other offences, conspiracy to collude with a foreign country or with external elements. The case entered its 69th day of trial on Friday (the 3rd) at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, sitting as the High Court, with Chan Tsz-wah, the fifth accomplice witness, giving evidence for an 11th day.
During cross-examination, the defence pointed out that parts of Chan’s testimony in court differed from his recorded video interviews and written statements. Chan denied fabricating his testimony in court to obtain a reduced sentence, saying: “Precisely because I hate [lies], I wanted to tell the truth.” Regarding his earlier agreement that the contents of his first recorded statement were false, Chan explained during re-examination by the prosecution: “At the time, I still had a mentality of taking a chance,” believing he could distance himself from Jimmy Lai, Mark Simon and others. The trial will resume next Monday (the 6th).
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英與《蘋果日報》3 間相關公司,被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」等罪,案件周五(3 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)展開第 69 日審訊,第五位從犯證人陳梓華第 11 天作供。
辯方盤問時指出,陳庭上多處證供與錄影會面及書面供詞不一。陳否認庭上捏造供詞以獲減刑,「正正就係因為我討厭(謊言),所以我想將個事實講返出嚟」。至於陳早前同意首次錄口供內容虛假,他在控方覆問下解釋,「當時我仲有一個僥倖嘅心態」,以為可以與黎、Mark Simon 等人撇清關係。案件下周一(6 日)續審。
29 Apr 2024法庭線#3456
黎智英案第68日審訊|還押錄口供後與警會面65次 陳梓華稱「講吓生活嘢」否認談及證供
Next Digital founder Lai Chee-ying and three companies related to Apple Daily are charged with offences including “conspiracy to collude with foreign forces”. The case entered its 68th day of trial at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, sitting as the High Court, on Monday (29th). Chan Tsz-wah, the fifth accomplice witness, gave evidence for his 10th day and was cross-examined by the defence for the third day.
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英與《蘋果日報》3 間相關公司,被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」等罪,案件周一(29 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)展開第 68 日審訊,第五位從犯證人陳梓華第十天作供,由辯方第三天盤問。
辯方指,陳還押期間錄取供詞後,曾與警方會面 65 次。陳否認過程談及證供,指他與警方商討其身體情況、還押生活以及「抱怨」,形容自己還押初期「情緒好崩潰」,「去到後來,我會講吓啲生活嘢,因為我喺裡面係睇唔到太陽嘅,所以,真係講吓生活啲嘢,想知多啲。」
另外,陳在辯方盤問下確認,曾為李宇軒安排安全屋及協助他離港,但否認自己曾說過要成為流亡政府領袖及組軍隊。
26 Apr 2024法庭線#3437
黎智英案第67日審訊|陳梓華認於錄影會面說謊 想與SWHK撇清關係、為李宇軒脫罪
The trial of Next Digital founder Jimmy Lai and three companies linked to Apple Daily, who are charged with offences including conspiracy to collude with a foreign country or external forces, entered its 67th day on Friday (26th) at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, temporarily exercising the jurisdiction of the High Court. Chan Tsz-wah, the fifth accomplice witness, began his ninth day of testimony.
The defence questioned Chan about six meetings between Lai and Chan from October 2019 to June 2020. It put to Chan that Lai had never said he wanted to lead the militant faction, nor had he mentioned “China collapse”; that claim had been made by Lau Cho-dik. The defence also put to Chan that Lai had never said he wanted to bring about “China collapse” through sanctions, or that he wanted to combine street, parliamentary and international forces to “push the government to collapse”. Chan disagreed with all of these suggestions.
The defence also questioned Chan about the contents of video-recorded interviews conducted before he became a prosecution witness. Chan repeatedly admitted in court that the contents were false. In one interview, Chan described SWHK (Team Reignite) as having several leaders, saying it was “not as if Li Yu-hsuan was the only one”. Chan told the court that he had wanted the police to believe that “it had nothing to do with Li Yu-hsuan”, and admitted that he wanted to exonerate Li. Chan also said in the interview that he had made negative comments about SWHK; he admitted in court that he had lied because he wanted to distance himself from SWHK.
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英與《蘋果日報》3 間相關公司,被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」等罪,案件周五(26 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)展開第 67 日審訊,第五位從犯證人陳梓華第九天作供。
辯方針對黎與陳於 2019 年 10 月至 2020 年 6 月期間六次會面情況提問,指黎沒說過欲領導勇武派,亦沒說過「支爆」,此說法是由劉祖廸提出。辯方又指,黎沒稱要透過制裁達「支爆」,亦沒指要結合街頭、議會及國際力量「推爆政府」,陳一概不同意。
另外,辯方引述陳在成為控方證人前的錄影會面內容提問,陳多次庭上承認內容虛假。當中陳於錄影會面形容 SWHK(重光團隊)有數名領導,「唔似係得李宇軒一個」,陳庭上稱「想畀警察覺得,唔關李宇軒事」,承認想為李脫罪;而陳在會面稱對 SWHK 有負面評論,他亦在庭上承認,是想與 SWHK 撇清關係而說謊。
25 Apr 2024法庭線#3426
黎智英案第66日審訊|陳梓華:《國安法》後考慮續推制裁 因黎無畏無懼、以身作則
Jimmy Lai, founder of Next Digital, and three companies associated with Apple Daily are charged with “conspiracy to collude with foreign forces” and other offences. The case entered its 66th day of trial at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, sitting as the High Court, on Thursday (25th), with Chan Tsz-wah, the fifth accomplice witness, giving evidence for his eighth day and beginning cross-examination by the defence.
Under questioning, Chan said that after the National Security Law came into effect, he believed sanctions should continue to be pursued. He said: “Because even someone of Jimmy Lai’s stature can be so fearless, or even set an example, I felt that there were things that needed to be done. But how far to go was something I was still considering at the time.”
The defence also said Chan did not subscribe to “mutual destruction” and frequently mocked people who supported it, which Chan initially disputed. The defence later presented a transcript of a video interview conducted after Chan’s first arrest, in which he was shown to have said: “I myself don’t buy ‘mutual destruction’ ... I often laugh at them.” Chan explained in court: “I did laugh at the concept of ‘mutual destruction’ because I had brought mutual destruction upon myself.” Judge Li Yun-teng asked whether Chan had mocked people who supported “mutual destruction” at the time. Chan said he had not. The trial will resume on Friday (26th).
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英與《蘋果日報》3 間相關公司,被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」等罪,案件周四(25 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)展開第 66 日審訊,第五位從犯證人陳梓華第八天作供,開始接受辯方盤問。
陳在盤問下表示,《國安法》生效後,認為需要繼續推動制裁,「因為連黎智英呢啲咁樣級數嘅人物,都可以無畏無懼,甚或乎係以身作則,所以我覺得應該有啲嘢係要去做,但做到邊一步,當時我仲思考緊」。
另外,辯方指陳不接受「攬炒」、經常嘲笑支持「攬炒」的人,陳一度不同意。辯方其後展示陳首次被捕後的錄影會面謄本,顯示他曾稱「我本人都係唔 buy(攬炒)⋯我成日笑佢哋」。陳庭上解釋,「我有笑『攬炒』呢個概念,因為我自己攬炒咗自己」。法官李運騰追問,即陳當時有否嘲笑支持「攬炒」的人?陳稱當時沒有。案件周五(26 日)續審。
24 Apr 2024法庭線#3413
黎智英案第65日審訊|陳梓華:被捕後Mark Simon稱會與黎協助安排「後路」
The trial of Next Digital founder Jimmy Lai and three companies associated with Apple Daily, who are charged with “conspiracy to collude with a foreign country or external forces” and other offences, entered its 65th day at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts (temporarily acting as the High Court) on Wednesday (24th). The fifth accomplice witness, Chen Tsz-wah, continued giving evidence for a seventh day.
Chen testified that in August 2020, SWHK believed that the organisation would face risks if Lee Yuet-shun were arrested and considered that he should leave Hong Kong. Chen would take over Lee’s connections, but Lee was “very stubborn” and wanted to remain in Hong Kong. After Lee and Lai were arrested that month, Lai’s assistant Mark Simon told Chen that both he and Lai believed Lai’s arrest “was a good thing” because it could attract attention and boost Apple Daily’s sales.
In October of the same year, Chen was arrested for assisting an offender. A few days after his release, he called Mark Simon, who said that he and Lai would arrange legal and other support for him, and “would also arrange a way out for you in the United States”. He also quoted Mark Simon as saying that he “didn’t need to do anything”, but should be psychologically prepared to be arrested again on a charge under the National Security Law, and should not worry. Mark told Chen to continue international lobbying to promote sanctions. The trial continues on Thursday (25th).
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英與《蘋果日報》3 間相關公司,被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」等罪,案件周三(24 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)展開第 65 日審訊,第五位從犯證人陳梓華第七天作供。
陳供稱,2020 年 8 月,SWHK(重光團隊)覺得若李宇軒被捕,會令組織有風險,認為他應離港,由陳接手李的人脈關係,惟李「好頑固」想留港。同月李及黎被捕後,黎的助手 Mark Simon 向陳稱,他與黎智英均認為,黎被捕「係一件好事」,可引起關注,提升《蘋果》銷量。
同年 10 月,陳因協助罪犯被捕,獲釋後幾天致電 Mark Simon,對方指與黎會為他安排法律等支援,「亦都會喺美國安排埋後路畀你」。他又引述 Mark Simon 指「乜都唔使做,但就叫我有心理準備,我會再次被拘捕,罪名係《國安法》,叫我唔使擔心」,著陳應繼續做國際遊說,以推動制裁。案件周四(25 日)續審。
23 Apr 2024法庭線#3411
黎智英案第64日審訊|陳梓華確認黎曾稱不擔心個人安全 「準備好戰鬥到最後」
Jimmy Lai, founder of Next Digital, and three companies related to Apple Daily are charged with “conspiracy to collude with a foreign country or external elements” and other offences. The case entered its 64th day of trial at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, sitting as the High Court, on Tuesday (23rd), with Chan Tsz-wah, the fifth accomplice witness, giving evidence for a sixth day.
The prosecution showed messages exchanged between Chan and Lai in May 2020, in which they discussed the National People’s Congress’s impending announcement of the “Hong Kong version of the National Security Law”. Lai said he was “prepared to fight to the end”, while Chan replied: “If you all fall, I will be the one left until the end.” Chan explained in court that “if the National Security Law was going to arrest people, the first would be Jimmy Lai”. He also said everyone should be sent away before the National Security Law came into effect, and that he should be the last to leave, “because they had done a lot, but I had never achieved as much as they had”.
The court also heard that Chan messaged Lai in July that year to thank him for everything he had done for the primary election. Chan testified that Lai had originally conceived the primary election, but not everyone agreed to the mechanism when it was held. Lai had “done a lot of work behind the scenes”, using extensive personal connections and media resources, and ultimately brought about the primary election. The trial continues on Wednesday (24th).
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英與《蘋果日報》3 間相關公司,被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」等罪,案件周二(23 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)展開第 64 日審訊,第五位從犯證人陳梓華第六天作供。
控方庭上顯示陳與黎於 2020 年 5 月的訊息,兩人討論人大將公布「港版國安法」,黎稱「準備好戰鬥到最後」,陳則回應「如果你們都倒下了,我將是留到最後的人」。陳庭上解釋,「《國安法》若然要拉人的話,第一個就係黎智英」,又指應在《國安法》生效前,將所有人送走,「而我應該係最後尾一個走,因為佢哋做咗好多嘢,但係我一直冇好似佢哋咁有建樹」。
庭上另顯示,陳於同年 7 月向黎發訊息,感謝黎在初選所做的一切。陳供稱,初選當初由黎構思,但當舉辦初選時,並非所有人同意此機制,黎在背後「做好多功夫」,動用了大量人脈及媒體資源,終促成初選。案件周三(24 日)續審。
19 Apr 2024法庭線#3391
黎智英案第63日審訊|陳梓華:黎提國際遊說 稱他「呢代人」未必實現推翻中共
Jimmy Lai, founder of Next Digital, and three companies linked to Apple Daily are charged with, among other offences, conspiracy to collude with foreign forces. The case entered its 63rd day of trial on Friday (19th) at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, temporarily acting as the High Court, with Chan Tsz-wah, the fifth accomplice witness, giving evidence for the fifth day. Chan testified that he, Lau Cho-dik and others met Lai in Taipei in early 2020. Lai proposed seeking international recognition and applying pressure through foreign embargoes and sanctions, saying that different sectors would need to unite with civil forces to achieve the “collapse of the CCP”. Lai also mentioned steps for international lobbying, including getting to know “behind-the-scenes figures” such as foreign political advisers. Chan recalled that Lai said, “People of his generation may not be able to achieve this. He hoped that the ‘burn-it-all-down’ team led by Lau Cho-dik, together with these young people, could take over.” Chan and Lau also met Shih Ming-teh, who said that mass movements had to consider three points, including legitimacy. Shih also said that if Lau were arrested, public support could be sought, and encouraged them to “hold high the spirit of sacrifice”. The trial will continue next Tuesday (23rd).
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英與《蘋果日報》3 間相關公司,被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」等罪,案件周五(19 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)展開第 63 日審訊,第五位從犯證人陳梓華第五天作供。
陳供稱,與劉祖廸等人於 2020 年初在台北和黎會面,黎提出應爭取國際認同,由外國禁運、制裁以施壓,並需團結不同板塊,加上民間力量,才可以達到「支爆」,黎並提及國際遊說的步驟,包括要認識外國政治顧問等「枱底人」。陳又憶述,當時黎稱「佢呢一代人,未必可以實現呢件事,佢希望劉祖廸牽頭嘅攬炒團隊,同呢班年輕人可以接棒」。
另外,陳與劉亦與施明德見面,施稱群眾運動須考慮認受性等 3 點,又稱若劉被捕可爭取群眾支持,勉勵「要高舉犧牲精神」。案件下周二(23 日)續審。
17 Apr 2024法庭線#3368
黎智英案第62日審訊|陳梓華確認在黎智英要求下 協調黎與劉祖廸會面
Jimmy Lai, founder of Next Digital, and three companies related to Apple Daily are charged with offences including conspiracy to collude with foreign forces. The case entered its 62nd day of trial at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, sitting as the High Court, on Wednesday (17th), with Chan Tsz-wah, the fifth accomplice witness, giving evidence for a fourth day.
Chan testified that after the November 2019 District Council elections, Lai’s assistant Mark Simon said the “yellow camp” victories were the prevailing trend and that he and his boss had “started studying the primary election” in the hope of extending this momentum and securing a major victory in the Legislative Council election. Chan met Lai the following month. Lai said the primary election could attract young voters, and that if political novices lost, “their votes could flow to the old pan-democratic camp” in the general election, ultimately consolidating pan-democratic seats.
Chan also said Lai wanted to combine street, legislative and international forces in taking action, and proposed meeting Lau Yu-dit, known as “Lamlash Ba”, for discussions. Chan met Lau in the United Kingdom, where Lau appeared hesitant, and the parties eventually met in Taipei after coordination. Chan also said that Lai “wanted to lead the entire international front”. The trial will continue on Friday.
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英與《蘋果日報》3 間相關公司,被控「串謀勾結外國勢力」等罪,案件周三(17 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)展開第 62 日審訊,第五位從犯證人陳梓華第四天作供。
陳供稱,2019 年 11 月區議會選舉後,黎智英助手 Mark Simon 曾稱,「黃絲」勝選屬大勢所趨,他與老闆「開始研究緊初選,就希望延續呢股氣勢」,以在立法會選舉取得大勝。陳翌月與黎見面,黎指初選可吸納年青人票,而若素人落敗,正選時「佢嗰啲票可以流落老泛民」,最後可鞏固泛民議席。
陳又指,黎欲結合街頭、議會及國際力量行動,提出與「攬炒巴」劉祖廸見面商討。陳到英國與劉見面,對方感猶豫,而最終經協調下,眾人於台北會面。陳又提及,黎「想主導成條國際線」。案件周五續審。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.