Woman with Two-Way Permit accused of photographing Court of Final Appeal clerk has courtroom photography charge withdrawn; prosecution says law covers only “special persons”
涉終院內拍攝文書人員 持雙程證婦獲撤法庭內攝影罪 控方指條例僅涉「特別人士」
In October 2024, a 52-year-old woman was accused of photographing a clerk at the Court of Final Appeal’s registry and charged with one count of “prohibition on taking photographs, etc., in court”. When the case was mentioned again at Eastern Magistrates’ Courts on Friday (the 3rd), the prosecution’s application to withdraw the charge was granted. Chief Magistrate Don Man Lung So had asked at one point, “Why not continue with the prosecution?” The prosecution said the legislation concerned only “special persons” and did not include the person involved. A review of the legislation found that the offence concerns photographing or drawing judges, jurors and witnesses in court, and does not mention clerical staff.
2024 年 10 月,52 歲女子被指在終審法院登記處拍攝文書人員,被控一項「禁止在法庭內攝影等」,周五(3 日)在東區裁判法院再訊,控方申請撤控獲批。主任裁判官蘇文隆一度關注「點解唔繼續告?」,控方指條例僅涉「特別人士」,不包括涉案人士。 翻查條例,控罪牽涉法庭內拍攝或繪畫法官、陪審員及證人,未有提及文書人員。
