18 Dec 2023法庭線#2688
古思堯涉置物阻逃生路徑罪成 庭上質疑選擇性檢控 官:佢拎咩案上嚟,我就要審咩
In April 2023, social activist veteran Ko Sze-yiu, now 77, was accused of placing miscellaneous items on the rear staircase of an industrial building in Lai Chi Kok. He was summoned on two charges: failing to comply with the requirements of a Fire Services Department notice to abate fire hazards, and obstructing an escape route. Ko pleaded not guilty, and the trial began at Kowloon City Magistrates’ Courts on Monday (18th).
On the charge of obstructing an escape route, Ko said that some items in the building belonged to the management company and cleaners, and that the Fire Services Department had said they could remain if nobody complained. “Only I am not allowed to put even a toothpick in a public place,” he said, questioning whether he had been selectively prosecuted. Acting Magistrate Yau Kwok-sun said he was “not too concerned” about this, adding that magistrates were “very passive”: “Whatever case they bring before me, I have to hear it.”
In delivering his verdict, the magistrate said Ko’s admissions under caution were clear and that the Fire Services Department witness was honest and reliable. He found Ko guilty and fined him HK$6,000. Ko condemned the Fire Services Department for selective and targeted prosecution, saying he would very likely appeal. He also disclosed that he was filing proceedings to pursue the department over “maladministration”.
2023 年 4 月,現 77 歲的社運老將古思堯被指在荔枝角工廈後樓梯擺放雜物,遭票控沒遵從消防處發出「消除火警危險通知書」的規定、阻塞逃生途徑兩罪,古不認罪,周一(18 日)在九龍城裁判法院開審。
就阻塞逃生途徑罪,古思堯指大廈內有雜物屬於管理公司、清潔工,消防處曾指沒人投訴的話可繼續擺放,「唯獨是我,喺公眾地方放一支牙籤都唔得」,質疑選擇性檢控;暫委裁判官丘國新稱對此「唔太關注」,又形容裁判官「好被動」,「佢拎咩案上嚟,我就要審咩」。
官裁決時指,古於警誡下的招認清晰,消防處證人誠實可靠,裁定罪名成立,罰款 6,000 元。古則提出,譴責消防處選擇性及針對性檢控,指很大可能上訴,另透露正入稟追討消防處的「行政失當」。
7 Dec 2023法庭線#8779
工廈後樓梯物品遭清走 古思堯入稟指消防處行政失當 追討5萬9千元
Veteran social activist Koo Sze-yiu filed a claim with the Small Claims Tribunal, alleging that Fire Services Department personnel cleared items he had placed on the rear staircase of an industrial building while he was in hospital. The items included his tools for earning a living and $9,000 in cash inside a toolbox. He is seeking $59,000 from the Fire Services Department. The case received a brief mention at the West Kowloon Courts on Thursday (the 7th) and was adjourned until 24 April 2024 for a further hearing.
Koo Sze-yiu was separately accused of placing miscellaneous items on the rear staircase of an industrial building in Lai Chi Kok. He was charged with two offences: failing to comply with the requirements of a “Notice to Remove Fire Hazard” issued by the Fire Services Department, and obstructing an escape route. He denied the charges, and the case is scheduled for trial on 18 December.
社運老將古思堯入稟小額錢債審裁處,指消防處人員在他住院期間清理他放置於工廈後樓梯的物品,包括其謀生工具及工具箱內的九千元現金,遂向消防處追討 5 萬 9 千元,案件周四(7 日)在西九龍法院作簡短提訊,押後至 2024 年 4 月 24 日再訊。
古思堯另被指在荔枝角工廈後樓梯擺放雜物,遭票控沒遵從消防處發出「消除火警危險通知書」的規定、阻塞逃生途徑兩罪,他否認控罪,該案排期 12 月 18 日開審。
28 Jan 2021獨立媒體#1208
古思堯第十度侮辱國旗罪成 入獄4個月 庭上稱:若時機允許會故意違《國安法》
Social activist Koo Sze-yiu was convicted of insulting the national flag last July and immediately sentenced to four months in prison.
社運人士古思堯被判去年7月侮辱國旗罪成,即時入獄4個月。
21 Jan 2021獨立媒體#1188
古思堯第十度被控侮辱國旗 自辯批中共獨裁專制 「繼續坐監,繼續公民抗命」
Social activist Koo Sze-yiu allegedly held up an upside-down Chinese national flag bearing the words “White Terror” and “Fascist Terror” outside the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts building last July. He earlier pleaded not guilty to one count of insulting the national flag, and the case opened at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts. The magistrate ruled that a prima facie case had been established and adjourned the case until tomorrow morning for a verdict.
社運人士古思堯去年7月涉於西九龍裁判法院大樓外,舉起一面倒掛並寫有「白色恐怖」、「法西斯恐怖」等字眼的中國國旗。他早前否認一項侮辱國旗罪,案件於西九龍裁判法院開審。裁判官裁定表面證供成立,案件押後至明早裁決。
16 Jul 2020獨媒#7771
昨倒掛塗污國旗 患癌古思堯被控侮辱國旗 申保釋遭拒
Social activist Koo Sze-yiu was arrested outside the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts yesterday while holding an upside-down Chinese national flag bearing words including “Fascist terror” in support of 15 pro-democracy figures charged with inciting an unauthorised assembly. He was charged with one count of insulting the national flag. His application for bail was denied, and he was remanded in custody until August 27 for a further hearing.
社運人士古思堯昨日在西九龍裁判法院外手持一枝倒掛及寫上「法西斯恐怖」等字眼的中國國旗,聲援15名被控煽惑未經批准集結的民主派人士時,被當場拘捕。他被控一項侮辱國旗罪,庭上申請保釋被拒,還押至8月27日再訊。
16 Jul 2020獨媒#7775
昨倒掛塗污國旗 患癌古思堯被控侮辱國旗 申保釋遭拒
Yesterday, 15 pro-democracy figures appeared at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts in connection with four cases involving incitement to participate in unauthorised assemblies. Before the hearing, social activist Koo Sze-yiu was arrested outside the court building after waving a national flag that was upside down and had been defaced with words including “White Terror”. Today (the 16th), he was charged with one count of insulting the national flag. He was originally scheduled to appear at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, but was taken to the Kowloon City Magistrates’ Courts because another case involving him had to be dealt with there. Koo declined legal representation and applied for bail in person, but the magistrate refused the application. He was remanded in custody until August 27 for a further hearing.
昨日15名民主派人士就4宗煽惑未經批准集結案到西九龍裁判法院應訊,開庭前社運人士古思堯在法院大樓外揮動一面上下倒轉,兼寫上「白色恐怖」等字的國旗,被警方當場拘捕。他今(16日)被控一項侮辱國旗罪,原訂於西九龍裁判法院提堂,惟因古在九龍城裁判法院有另一案需處理,故轉往該法院提堂。古拒絕由律師代表,庭上親自申請保釋,但遭裁判官拒絕,須還柙至8月27日再訊。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.