Magistrate Debbie Chung Yee Ng orders teacher convicted of assaulting police remanded to Siu Lam; panel says “wrong exercise of judicial power” but complaint unsubstantiated
裁判官吳重儀下令襲警教師還柙小欖 專責小組指「錯誤行使司法權力」惟投訴不成立
The Judiciary announced today (26th) the results of investigations into three public complaints against magistrates. A panel of specialist judges found that none of the three complaints was substantiated. One concerned magistrate Debbie Chung Yee Ng of Fanling Court and the handling of a case involving primary school teacher Yeung Pak-man, who had assaulted a police officer. The complaint alleged that, after finding the defendant guilty, the magistrate questioned his mental state, ordered a psychiatric report and remanded him to Siu Lam Psychiatric Centre. The panel said it “strongly disagreed” with the magistrate’s actions, which were clearly a “wrong exercise of judicial power”, placed considerable pressure on the defendant and fell short of the high standard she should have met when sentencing. It nevertheless found that the complaint was not substantiated.
司法機構今(26日)公布3宗公眾針對裁判官作出投訴的調查報告結果,專責法官小組裁定3宗投訴均不成立。其中一宗涉及粉嶺法院裁判官吳重儀處理小學教師楊博文襲警的案件,投訴指吳官裁定被告罪成後,質疑其心智,並下令索取其精神科報告及還柙小欖精神病治療中心。專責小組表示「極不認同」裁判官做法,顯然是「錯誤行使司法權力」,對被告構成沉重壓力,亦未能合乎她判刑時應達到的高水平,但最後裁定這項投訴不成立。
