Lesbian loses final appeal after legal aid withdrawn; top court says lawyers must report information on misuse known before appointment
女同志被撤法援終極敗訴 終院指律師有責舉報獲委派前知悉的涉濫用資料
MK, a lesbian who sought a judicial review several years ago over the rights to same-sex marriage and civil unions, had her legal aid withdrawn and lost her final appeal at the Court of Final Appeal on Friday (22nd). MK had been anonymously reported as operating a pet-shop business, and the Legal Aid Department revoked her assistance after making inquiries, based on information provided by two barristers from their meetings with MK. The dispute concerned whether information from MK’s meetings with her lawyers was protected by legal professional privilege (LPP). The Court of Final Appeal ruled that, under the Legal Aid Regulations, solicitors and barristers have a duty to report to the department information relating to the misuse of legal aid that they know before being assigned to represent a recipient, and that such information is not protected by LPP. All five judges unanimously ruled against MK.
數年前就同性婚姻及民事結合權利,提司法覆核的女同志 MK,被撤銷法援;MK 上訴至終審法院,周五(22 日)被裁定終極敗訴。事件中,MK 被匿名舉報擁寵物店業務,而法援署經查詢後,基於兩名大律師提供與 MK 會面時的資料,而撤銷其援助。 案件爭議 MK 與律師會面的相關資料,是否受「法律專業保密特權」(LPP)保障。終院裁定,在《法援規例》下,律師和大律師有責任向署方舉報,獲委派代表受助人之前所知悉的涉濫用法援資料,而相關資料不受 LPP 保障。5 名法官一致裁定 MK 一方敗訴。
