Jimmy Lai Fraud Case: Lai and Former Senior Executive Wong Wai-keung Appeal; Prosecution Says Any Company Occupying Tenant’s Premises Must Be Licensed, Judgment Reserved
黎智英欺詐案|黎與前高層黃偉強提上訴 律政司:承租人任何公司佔用處所都須領牌 官押後裁決
Next Digital founder Jimmy Lai and group executive Wong Wai-keung were accused of concealing from the Hong Kong Science and Technology Parks Corporation that they had breached the lease for the Tseung Kwan O Industrial Estate. They were sentenced in 2022 to 5 years and 9 months’ imprisonment and 1 year and 9 months’ imprisonment respectively. Both appealed against their convictions, with the hearing continuing at the High Court on Wednesday (15th). The prosecution’s representative, Director of Public Prosecutions Mi Ki Yeung, said that any company occupying the premises as a tenant must apply for a licence. The defendants had a duty to disclose this but concealed the existence of “Dico Consultants”. She also said the tenant had been allowed by the Hong Kong Science and Technology Parks Corporation to lease the land at a concessionary rent, making it a “special lease”. The judge, however, noted that the tenant had invested a substantial amount and that the project also promoted Hong Kong’s economic development, questioning whether it benefited only the tenant. Mi Ki Yeung also said Lai was “the person who gave instructions and made decisions” and had used Apple Daily Printing to commit the offence. The judge questioned whether, under the prosecution’s argument, Lai and Apple Daily Printing should be regarded as “joint offenders”, even though the latter had not been charged. Yang said Lai controlled the company behind the scenes, citing the money-laundering case in which the company involved would likewise not be prosecuted. After hearing submissions from both sides, the Court of Appeal will deliver its written judgment within six months.
壹傳媒創辦人黎智英與集團行政總監黃偉強,被指向科技園公司隱瞞違反將軍澳工業邨租契,2022 年分別被判監禁 5 年 9 個月及 1 年 9 個月。兩人不服定罪提上訴,周三(15 日)在高等法院續審。 律政司代表、刑事檢控專員楊美琪指,承租人的任何公司佔用處所都須要申請牌照,被告有披露責任,卻隱瞞「力高」存在。她又指,承租人獲科技園公司批准以優惠地價租地,因此屬「特殊租契」。惟法官指承租人投資金額巨大,計劃同時促進香港經濟發展,質疑非僅對承租人有利。 楊美琪又指,黎是「作出指示及決定的人」,利用「蘋果印刷」犯案。法官關注,按律政司此說法,黎與「蘋果印刷」應屬「共同犯罪」,但後者沒被控。楊指,黎幕後控制涉案公司,舉例在洗黑錢案,涉事公司也不會被起訴。上訴庭聽畢雙方陳詞,將於 6 個月內頒布書面判詞。
