Man convicted of insulting national anthem at Women’s Volleyball Nations League; magistrate says patriots can also insult anthem
男子世界女排聯賽侮辱國歌罪成 官:即使愛國都可做出侮辱國歌行為
A 21-year-old man was accused of booing, giving a thumbs-down gesture and singing “Do You Hear The People Sing” while China’s national anthem was played at the Women’s Volleyball Nations League at the Hong Kong Coliseum in June 2023. The defendant was convicted of insulting the national anthem at Kowloon City Magistrates’ Courts on Friday (19th). He was released on bail under the existing conditions pending mitigation and sentencing. Magistrate Chee Hong Lam said the defendant’s claim that he had been provoked by “Disney people” was sophistry. The magistrate stressed that the focus of the trial was not to determine whether the defendant was patriotic, and said that even patriotic people could engage in conduct insulting the national anthem. The magistrate also said that although the defendant had autism and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, his conduct that day was entirely voluntary and constituted an open and deliberate insult to the national anthem. The magistrate further said the defence’s argument that some of the lyrics of “Do You Hear The People Sing” were similar to those of China’s national anthem was self-deception and disregarded the anthem’s meaning and importance. The magistrate considered that a national anthem must carry profound meaning and an underlying message for its citizens, and rejected the defence’s argument.
21 歲青年涉在 2023 年 6 月,於紅館觀看世界女排聯賽,在播放中國國歌時發出噓聲,倒竪拇指及唱出《Do You Hear The People Sing》,被控侮辱國歌罪。被告周五(19 日)在九龍城裁判法院被裁定罪成,准以原有條件保釋,候處理求情及判刑。 裁判官林子康認為,被告稱因受到「迪士尼人」的刺激一說屬於狡辯,又強調審訊重點不是判斷被告是否愛國,認為即使是愛國人士也可以做出侮辱國歌的行為。官又指,被告雖然患有自閉症及過度活躍症,但當日的行為全屬自主,是公開故意侮辱國歌。 官續指,辯方主張《Do》的歌詞中有與中國國歌相似的部分,是自欺欺人,罔顧國歌的意義及重要性,又認為國歌必定是對國民有深厚的意義和背後訊息,不接納辯方說法。
