Viet Spa prostitution case: 4 men and women acquitted of managing a vice establishment; judge says all witnesses, including Chin Pang Tsoi, were honest and reliable
Viet Spa涉賣淫案 4男女涉管理色情場所脫罪 官指全部證人包括蔡展鵬誠實可靠
Magistrate Jason Siu Ming Wan said the threshold for convicting someone of managing or operating a vice establishment was proof that the premises were mainly used for prostitution. He accepted the evidence of two undercover police officers that, during five undercover operations over six months, female technicians had offered to provide sexual services on each occasion. However, the defence called evidence from, among others, the then head of the Police National Security Department, Chin Pang Tsoi, who testified that during his four or five previous visits to Viet Spa, no one had offered sexual services. As the prosecution had not strongly challenged Choi’s evidence, the magistrate said he “could not see any reason not to accept Choi’s evidence”. He ultimately ruled that the prosecution had failed to prove that Viet Spa was “mainly used” as a vice establishment, but only “occasionally” used for prostitution, and acquitted all the defendants.
裁判官溫紹明指,「管理或經營賣淫場所罪」的定罪門檻,須證處所主要(mainly)用作賣淫場所。他接納兩名喬裝警員指,二人半年間共 5 次放蛇,均獲女技師提出可提供性服務。但考慮辯方證人、時任警務處國家安全處長蔡展鵬供稱,過往 4 至 5 次光顧 Viet Spa ,均沒有人提出有性服務。而控方亦不太挑戰蔡的證供,因此「看不到不接納蔡證供的原因」,最終裁定控方未能證明 Viet Spa 「主要用作」賣淫場所,只是「偶作」(ocassionally)賣淫場所,全部被告無罪。
