Challenging the Gender Marker on His Identity Card, Transgender Man Wins Court Battle; Mr Q: “I Only Want the Same Rights as Everyone Else”
挑戰改身份證性別 跨仔法庭勝一仗 Q先生:都係想爭取同其他人一樣嘅權利
Few people may pay particular attention to the gender field on an identity card. But for transgender people, under current government policy, the field can seem like a window that lays them bare. No matter how much they change their appearance to become the person they feel themselves to be, when others see the gender on their identity card, they can feel as though they are completely naked, exposed to people’s scrutiny. Seeking to change the “F” in this field to “M”, Mr Q embarked on a judicial review that lasted ten years. He suffered two defeats during the process. On 6 February 2023, however, the Court of Final Appeal handed down its judgment, ruling that requiring transgender men to undergo full sex-reassignment surgery before changing the gender on their identity cards violated the Bill of Rights. The five judges unanimously ruled in favour of the transgender applicant, bringing his final victory.
身份證上性別一欄,或沒多少人會特別留意。但對跨性別人士而言,在現行政府政策下,這一欄彷彿變成一面透視鏡,即使在外型上如何改變成為心目中的那個自己,當別人看到身份證上的性別,自己猶如全身赤裸,任由旁人目光掃視全身。 為了爭取把這一欄的「F」改為「M」,Q 先生展開了司法覆核之路,一行就十年。期間曾經歷兩次敗訴,至 2023 年 2 月 6 日,終審法院頒下判詞,指局方要求跨性別男子必須接受完整性別重置手術,才能更改身份證性別,違反《人權法》。5 名法官一致裁定跨性別人士終極勝訴。
