1 Oct 2024獨媒#4102
鄧炳強去信《明報》 指吳靄儀專欄「英雄化」鍾沛權
Former Legislative Council member Margaret Ng published an article titled “Supporting Kuen” in Ming Pao’s supplement yesterday, discussing former Stand News editor-in-chief Chung Pui-kuen, who was sentenced to 21 months in prison for conspiracy to publish seditious publications. She said Chung had refused to plead guilty in exchange for a reduced sentence and had instead chosen to make clear his beliefs about journalism. Secretary for Security Tang Ping-keung wrote to Ming Pao that evening, describing the article as “discussing the Stand News case in a roundabout manner, using indirect insinuations” and “heroising” Chung Pui-kuen.
前立法會議員吳靄儀昨日在《明報》副刊刊出題為《權撐住》文章,談及因「串謀發布煽動刊物」被判監21個月的前《立場新聞》總編輯鍾沛權,指對方不肯認罪以換取減刑,而選擇說清楚新聞工作的信念。保安局局長鄧炳強即晚去信《明報》,形容其為「以拐彎抹角、指桑罵槐的方式談論《立場新聞》案」,並「英雄化」鍾沛權。
5 Sept 2024獨媒#4025
【立場案】鄧炳強去信《明報》 指陳景祥文章誤導
The Stand News case was decided last week, with all defendants found guilty of conspiracy to publish and/or reproduce seditious publications. Chan King-sang, former editor-in-chief of the Hong Kong Economic Journal, wrote an article in Ming Pao titled “What red lines did the sedition offence draw?”, saying that the sedition offence had placed considerable pressure on the news industry. Chris Tang, Secretary for Security and “the Response and Rebuttal Team Captain”, wrote to Ming Pao that evening, saying Chan’s views were incorrect. Ming Pao today published the full text of Tang’s response, as well as an article by Francis Lee Lap-fung, a professor at the Chinese University of Hong Kong’s School of Journalism and Communication. Lee said that many parts concerning the media in the judgment in the Stand News case differed from journalists’ understanding, and believed they could cause unnecessary harm to the industry.
《立場新聞》案上周裁決,所有被告「串謀發布/或複製煽動刊物」罪罪成。《信報》前總編輯陳景祥在《明報》以《煽動罪劃出了什麼紅線?》為題撰文,指煽動罪對新聞界造成相當大的壓力。「反駁隊隊長」、保安局局長鄧炳強即晚去信《明報》,指陳文觀點錯誤。《明報》今日刊出鄧炳強的回應全文,同時亦刊出了中大新聞與傳播學院教授李立峯的文章,李文指《立場新聞》案的判詞中不少就媒體的部分,與新聞工作者理解不一樣,認為或對行業帶來不必要的損害。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.