9 Jan 2025獨媒#4408
《獨媒》向關愛隊索全年報告不果 民政:未有不達標情況、統整表現資料後向市民提供
“What have the Care Teams done?” has become a topic of public discussion recently. InMedia attempted to obtain from the Home Affairs Department the contents of the work reports of all 452 Care Teams across Hong Kong, but was not provided with them. InMedia subsequently contacted each Care Team by email and WhatsApp to enquire about details including activity expenditure. As of press time, six Care Teams had replied to the reporter, all saying that media enquiries were handled by the relevant District Office. The Home Affairs Department said on Wednesday (8th) that it was providing a unified response on behalf of all Care Teams, stating that all Care Teams were currently carrying out their work according to their KPIs and that there were no cases of failing to meet the standards. The department is currently consolidating all information on the performance of the Care Teams and will provide it to the public in an appropriate form once completed.
This year’s Policy Address announced that funding for the operation of the Care Teams would be regularised and that the subsidy would be increased by 50%. However, University Line reported last week that the Tsuen Wan District Office had refused to disclose the work reports of Care Teams in the district, and had filmed what appeared to be members of the public “pretending to be volunteers” at an activity, prompting public concern. The Under Secretary for Culture, Sports and Youth Clarence Wang Ching Leung subsequently criticised the report, saying it “may have painted with too broad a brush”, and added: “If there are any enquiries, everyone is welcome to approach the Home Affairs Department directly; we can provide the relevant information.”
「關愛隊做咗乜」成為近期社會熱話,《獨媒》嘗試向民政事務總署索取全港合共452隊的工作報告內容,惟未獲提供。《獨媒》及後以電郵及WhatsApp逐一聯絡各「關愛隊」,查詢活動開支詳情等。至截稿前,共有6隊「關愛隊」回覆記者,均表示傳媒查詢交由民政處負責。民政事務總署周三(8日)稱代所有「關愛隊」統一回覆,指目前各支「關愛隊」皆按KPI進行工作,沒有不達標的情況。署方現正全面統整所有有關「關愛隊」表現的資料,完成後會以適當形式向市民提供資料。
今年《施政報告》宣布,將恆常化撥款「關愛隊」運作及增加五成資助額。不過《大學線》上周報道,荃灣民政處拒絕公開區內關愛隊的工作報告,又拍攝到疑有市民在活動中「扮義工」,引起社會關注。民青局副局長梁宏正事後批評,報道「可能有些以偏概全」,又指「如有任何查詢,歡迎大家直接找民政總署,我們可以提供有關資料。」
8 Jan 2025光傳媒#4399
「警察勁揪」群組發起聯署投訴《大學線》報道 稱指導老師及該系教授「煽動學生反政府」
A recent report by Varsity, the student media outlet of The Chinese University of Hong Kong’s School of Journalism and Communication, about the Care Teams has sparked heated discussion. An official said the report “painted with a broad brush”. Less than a week after the controversy began, a pro-establishment group today (the 8th) launched a joint petition to complain to CUHK, alleging that the report’s adviser, Shum Wan-wah, and professor Li Lap-fung of the school had committed “professional misconduct”, “incited students against the government” and “poisoned the minds of the younger generation with false information”.
Someone launched the petition in the social media group “Police Are Awesome, the Brave Fear Nothing”. Letters were sent to former CUHK president Rocky S. Tuan, CUHK president Dennis Lo Yuk-ming and the dean of the School of Journalism and Communication, Anthony Ying Him Fung, complaining about CUHK part-time lecturer Shum Wan-wah, who supervised Varsity’s report “It’s None of Our ‘Care’ Business”, and School of Journalism and Communication professor Li Lap-fung. The petition alleged that the two had committed “professional misconduct”, called them “Hong Kong independence lecturers”, and accused them of unfairly blaming the government over the effectiveness of the Care Teams.
中文大學新聞與傳播學院學生媒體《大學線》近日一則有關「關愛隊」的報道引起熱議,有官員指報道「以偏概全」,事件發酵不足一周,今(8日)有建制群組發起聯署向中大投訴,指該報道的指導老師岑蘊華及該系教授李立峯「專業失德」,「煽動學生反政府」、「以虛假信息荼毒年輕一代嘅思想」。
有人在社交媒體群組「警察勁揪,勇者無懼」發起聯署,向中文大學校長段崇智(按:應為前校長)、中文大學校長盧煜明、新聞與傳播學院院長馮應謙(按:應為社會科學院院長)致函,投訴指導《大學線》「事不『關』己」報道的中大兼任講師岑蘊華,以及新傳學院教授李立峯「專業失德」,指二人為「港獨講師」,「老屈政府關受(按:愛)隊成效」。
6 Jan 2025獨媒#4393
《大學線》追訪關愛隊引熱議 中大新傳講師:傳媒係應該做呢啲工作
A report by CUHK student media The University Line following up on the Care Teams has become a hot topic in recent days. Some internet users praised the students’ work, while some officials criticised the report, saying it “may generalise from a partial view.” Shum Wan-wah, an adjunct lecturer at CUHK’s School of Journalism and Communication and a veteran media professional, said the students’ interviews were reasoned and evidence-based, and that she did not consider the subject of the report sensitive. Although some internet users commented, “Are these things reportable?”, she said, “The media should be doing this kind of work.”
中大新傳學生媒體《大學線》追訪關愛隊的報道是近日熱話,有網民讚賞學生做得好,但亦有官員批評報道「可能有些以偏概全」。中大新傳學院兼任講師、資深傳媒人岑蘊華認為,學生進行訪問時有理有據,自己亦不覺得報道題材敏感,雖然有網民留言「呢啲報唔報得㗎」,但「傳媒係應該做呢啲工作」。
5 Jan 2025獨媒#4388
《大學線》揭關愛隊邀市民穿背心充撐場面 梁宏正:報道有些以偏概全
A report by “University Line”, a student media outlet run by CUHK journalism and communication students, about the Care Teams has recently sparked discussion online. The report revealed that some Care Team members distributed vests for participants to wear before taking group photos at activities to “pad out the scene”. It also said that the outlet had repeatedly applied to the District Offices for Care Team work reports but was refused. Clarence Wang Ching Leung, Under Secretary for Home and Youth Affairs, said that Care Team services required the help of volunteers, and that the report “may have painted with too broad a brush, or may not have been comprehensive”. Clarence Wang Ching Leung also said: “If anyone has any enquiries, they are welcome to contact the Home Affairs Department directly; we can provide the relevant information.”
中大新傳學生媒體《大學線》一則關於關愛隊的報道近日在網上引起迴響。報道中,記者揭發有關愛隊成員在拍攝活動大合照前,派發背心予參加者穿上「充撐場面」,又多番向民政處申請索取關愛隊工作報告,但被拒絕。民青局副局長梁宏正回應指,關愛隊的服務是需要找義工幫忙,報道「可能有些以偏概全,或者未必是全面」,又指「如有任何查詢,歡迎大家直接找民政總署,我們可以提供有關資料」。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.