5 Nov 2024獨媒#4202
霍啟剛批杜琪峯「無靈魂論」非常自私 將個人創作低潮歸咎香港政治氣候
Hong Kong director Johnnie To said in a recent interview with BBC Chinese that he had produced fewer works in recent years because he was at the lowest point of his life. He said he and Hong Kong had “lost their souls”, prompting responses from various sectors. Kenneth Fok, a Legislative Council member representing the sports, performing arts, culture and publishing sectors, also posted a response that evening without naming To. Fok said the remarks blamed Hong Kong’s current political climate for the speaker’s personal “creative low” and described the claim that “I and Hong Kong have both lost our souls” as extremely selfish. He also said that people with a certain standing should be even more careful with their words.
香港導演杜琪峯在近日《BBC中文網》的專訪中,指近年減產是因為正處於人生最低潮,認為自己與香港「無咗靈魂」,言論引起各界回應。體育、演藝、文化及出版界立法會議員霍啟剛晚上亦發文不點名回應,指言論將個人「處於創作低潮」歸咎於香港當前政治氣候,並聲言自己「和香港都失去靈魂」是非常自私,又認為對方具有一定地位就更需要謹言慎行。
5 Nov 2024獨媒#4203
杜琪峯稱香港無靈魂 何敬康不同意:應尊重內地電檢原則調整
Hong Kong director Johnnie To recently told BBC Chinese in an interview that he was in the lowest point of his life in recent years, explaining the decline in his output and saying that he and Hong Kong had “lost their souls”. The remarks sparked widespread reaction. Andrew Wai Kwong Fung, a former government news coordinator, wrote that To was nostalgic for Hong Kong in the past and urged him to “look forward”. Adrian Pedro King Hong Ho, a New People's Party legislator, also wrote today that they disagreed with To’s comments, stressing that Hong Kong and mainland China have different film censorship systems. They said the mainland’s socialist and film censorship principles should be respected, and that those seeking to enter the mainland market should “make some adjustments” or consider developing markets in other regions and reducing filming costs, rather than merely making unreasonable accusations that there is “no freedom of speech” and that Hong Kong has “lost its soul”.
香港導演杜琪峯近日接受《BBC中文網》專訪,剖白近年產量減少的原因,指近年正處於人生最低潮,認為自己與香港「無咗靈魂」。言論一出即引起廣泛迴響,前政府新聞統籌專員馮煒光發文,指杜琪峯眷戀往昔香港,呼籲他「向前看」。新民黨立法會議員何敬康今日亦發文,表示不同意杜琪峯的言論,強調香港與內地有不同電檢制度,應尊重內地的社會主義與電檢原則,如要打入內地市場便應「做些調整」或考慮開拓其他地區市場及降低拍攝成本,而非只是無理指責「沒有言論自由」和「失去靈魂」。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.