Tai Po Wang Fuk Court Level Five Fire|Is Bamboo Scaffolding Being Made a Scapegoat? Veteran Master Defends It as High-Standard Craft and an Art Form
宏福苑五級火|竹棚成代罪羊? 資深師傅平反:竹棚工藝規格高,係藝術品
Following the Level Five fire at Wang Fuk Court in Tai Po, the government has revived the proposal to replace bamboo scaffolding with metal scaffolding, while overseas media have focused on the risks of bamboo scaffolding. Ka Chun (SAB) Lee, a scaffolding master with more than 30 years in the trade, defended bamboo scaffolding, saying it originated in Guangdong and has a history of more than a century. He said bamboo contains moisture and has a certain degree of fire resistance, and ultimately believed the incident was related to negligence in project management. Master Lee said scaffolding collapses had occurred repeatedly in recent years, and the government had proposed several times replacing bamboo scaffolding with metal scaffolding. He also said the mainland had in recent months begun preventing raw materials from being transported to Hong Kong: “Fir timber can no longer come to Hong Kong, forcing me recently to use steel tubes to make up for the shortfall when building opera stages, which has made the entire stage lose its authenticity; it seems that later even bamboo may not be allowed to be transported to Hong Kong. If that is true, there will not even be bamboo scaffolding.” He said about 70% of Hong Kong’s construction sites used bamboo scaffolding, so it would be difficult to switch entirely to metal scaffolding at once. Metal scaffolding required less craftsmanship but involved greater physical exertion, and he believed the industry’s thousands of bamboo-scaffolding workers would find it difficult to retrain, with some potentially being eliminated and facing unemployment. He stressed that Hong Kong had inherited bamboo-scaffolding craftsmanship with high standards, and that bamboo scaffolding was regarded as an art form and “worth continuing.”
大埔宏福苑發生五級火,政府重提以金屬棚架取代竹棚架,外媒則關注竹棚風險。入行超過 30 年的搭棚師傅李家俊為竹棚「平反」,指竹棚沿自廣東省,歷史過百年,竹材内含有水份,有一定礙燃性,歸根究柢,他認為是與工程管理疏忽有關。 李師傅指,近年屢有棚架倒塌意外,政府已多次提出以金屬架取代竹棚,又提到內地近月更開始不讓原材料運港:「杉木已不可以嚟香港,害我最近搭戲棚要用鋼通來補救不足,變成整個戲棚失咗真;好似遲啲連竹也不准運來香港,如果屬實,就連竹棚都無喇。」他提到,香港約七成地盤都用竹棚,要一時間全部轉用金屬棚架會較困難;而金屬棚手藝含量低、體力消耗大,相信業内數千名竹棚師傅轉型不易,最終或遭淘汰,面臨失業。他強調香港傳承了竹棚工藝,規格水平高,竹棚被視作藝術品、「係值得做落去」。
