Former CUHK student union president admits inciting blank votes; appeal over restriction on freedom of expression dismissed — judge: restrictions ensure fairness
前中大學生會長認煽惑投白票 提上訴爭議限制言論自由被駁回 官:設限制為保公平
Former Chinese University of Hong Kong student union president So Tsun-fung was accused of reposting online in 2021 a post by former Legislative Council member Hui Chi-fung advocating casting blank ballots in elections. The Independent Commission Against Corruption charged So Tsun-fung with violating the Elections (Corrupt and Illegal Conduct) Ordinance. The defence challenged the constitutionality of the charge, but after the magistrate ruled that it was constitutional, So Tsun-fung changed the plea to guilty and was sentenced to two months’ imprisonment, suspended for 18 months. So Tsun-fung lodged an appeal by way of case stated, arguing that the charge imposed an unreasonable restriction on freedom of expression. In earlier submissions, So Tsun-fung’s side said the case involved freedom of expression and that any restriction had to serve a legitimate purpose, but there was no evidence that calling on others not to vote or to cast blank ballots would interfere with elections. Acting Judge Yao Huen-chi handed down his judgment at the High Court on Monday (the 3rd), ruling that the restriction served the legitimate purpose of ensuring that elections were fair and open, and agreeing that the restriction imposed was necessary. The judge also said that inciting people to vote against a candidate would not only render the electoral process ineffective, but would also affect the smooth transition of popular representation in the legislature. He ruled that the trial magistrate had not erred in finding that the relevant provisions did not infringe the appellant’s freedom of expression or right to equality before the law, and dismissed the appeal.
前中大學生會會長蘇浚鋒,被指 2021 年在網上轉載前立法會議員許智峯倡選舉投白票帖文,被廉署起訴違反《選舉(舞弊及非法行為)條例》。辯方爭議控罪合憲性,而裁判官裁定合憲後,蘇改為認罪,判囚兩個月、緩刑 18 個月。 蘇以案件呈述方式提上訴,爭議控罪不合理限制言論自由。蘇一方早前陳詞時指,本案涉及言論自由,如要設限必須有合理目的,惟沒有證據證明,呼籲他人不投票或投白票會干擾選舉。 暫委法官姚勳智周一(3 日)於高院頒下判詞,指限制設有合法目的,以確保選舉公平公開,並同意所施加的限制是必要的。官又指,煽動投反對票,不但令選舉過程變得無作用,也會影響議會民意代表順利過渡,指原審裁判官裁定相關條文並無侵犯上訴人的言論自由,及法律面前的平等權利,沒有出錯,駁回上訴。
