Long waits for High Court criminal proceedings; Judiciary says three-judge national security trials put further strain on resources
高院刑事程序候時長 司法機構:國安案須三官審 令資源「更受壓」
Long waiting times for court trials have long drawn criticism from the public. In a paper submitted to the Legislative Council, the Judiciary outlined the latest waiting times at different levels of court. The average waiting time for criminal proceedings in the High Court’s Court of First Instance remains relatively long. The Judiciary said the main reason was that national security cases must be heard by three criminal judges, putting resources under “greater pressure”. As anti-extradition bill cases and national security cases must be given priority, the scheduling of other criminal cases has been “unavoidably affected”. The Judiciary expects waiting times to improve significantly “in about two years” as many national security cases are concluded and newly recruited judges begin to be appointed from the second half of the year. The Judiciary submitted the paper to the Legislative Council Panel on Administration of Justice and Legal Services. It handled about 527,000 cases in total last year, 9% and 4% more than in 2022 and 2019 respectively. The Judiciary said that, apart from “certain categories of criminal cases” in the High Court’s Court of First Instance, the average waiting times for most criminal proceedings had improved significantly, while the average waiting times for most civil cases at all levels of court had “generally met the targets”.
法庭審訊的等候時間冗長,一直被社會詬病,司法機構向立法會提交文件闡述各級法院最新輪候狀況,高等法院原訟庭的刑事程序平均輪候時間仍然較長,司法機構表示主因是國安案件須由3名刑事法官審理,令司法資源「更為受壓」,而由於反修例案件和國安案件需優先處理,其他刑事案的排期「無可避免受到影響」。司法機構預期「大約兩年後」,隨著眾多國安案件陸續結案,加上新聘法官在下半年起開始任命,輪候時間將有明顯改善。 司法機構向立法會「司法及法律事務委員會」提交文件,去年已處理案件的總數約為52.7萬宗,較2022年及2019年高9%及4%。司法機構指,除了高院原訟庭「若干類別刑事案件」,多數刑事法律程序的平均輪候時間均有顯著改善,各級法院大部分民事案件平均輪候時間更是「大致達標」。
