[Article 23 legislation] Did Li Wenliang’s exposure of the epidemic violate the “disclosure” principle? Security Bureau: “reasonable steps” must first be taken
【23條立法】李文亮揭疫情違「披露」原則?保安局:須先採取「合理步驟」
Several legislators expressed concern about the definition of “state secrets” under Article 23 of the Basic Law and how it would be applied. New People’s Party chairwoman Regina Ip said the media were concerned about whether “the public interest” could serve as a defence, but said she understood that whistleblowers must first take practical and feasible measures before making a disclosure. Citing Wuhan doctor Li Wenliang as an example, she said before Li exposed the COVID-19 outbreak: “Did he speak to his superiors? Or did he just go out and say it? After discussing it and feeling that it was very serious, wouldn’t failing to tell the public mean that … at the very least, all these things must be done before there can be a defence? It’s not enough just to casually claim that it is in the public interest, is it?”
多名議員關注《基本法》23條中「國家秘密」定義及如何應用。新民黨主席葉劉淑儀指,傳媒關注「公眾利益」是否能成為辯解理由,但自己理解是吹哨人在作出披露前,要先採取切實可行的措施。她以武漢醫生李文亮為例,指李爆出新冠肺炎疫情前:「佢有冇同上司講呢?抑或佢就咁出去講?傾咗覺得好嚴重喎,唔話比市民知就會⋯⋯起碼做晒呢啲嘢,先可以有辯解,唔係隨便求其講有公眾利益就得?」
