Lui Sai Yu granted certificate to appeal to CFA after one-third sentence reduction denied for admitting National Security Law offence
認違國安法不獲三分一減刑 呂世瑜獲批上訴至終院 上訴庭指涉重大法律觀點
A male Polytechnic University student, Lui Sai Yu, was accused of using a TG channel in 2020 to incite Hong Kong independence and sell weapons to incite violence. In April 2022, he pleaded guilty to the offence of “inciting others to secede from the country”. The court originally reduced his sentence from five and a half years’ imprisonment to three years and eight months. However, the prosecution argued that sentencing was subject to the minimum terms for offences under the National Security Law, under which a serious case must carry “five years or more”. Judge Amanda Jane Woodcock subsequently resentenced him to five years’ imprisonment. Lui Sai Yu previously appealed against the sentence, but the appeal was dismissed by the Court of Appeal. The Chief Justice, Poon Siu-chu, and Court of Appeal Justices Pang Wei-cheung and Pang Pui-ching handed down their judgment on Thursday (27th), granting Lui Sai Yu a certificate to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal. They said the case involved a point of law of great and general importance. According to the Court of Final Appeal website, the hearing of Lui Sai Yu’s application for leave to appeal has yet to be scheduled. Lui Sai Yu, who is serving his sentence, appeared in court today wearing a checked sweater and black-rimmed glasses and appeared to be in good spirits.
理大男生呂世瑜被指 2020 年在 TG 頻道煽動港獨及售武煽暴,2022 年 4 月承認「煽動他人分裂國家」罪,原獲法庭由判囚 5 年半減刑至 3 年 8 個月。惟控方指,判刑受《國安法》罪行的最低刑期所限,情節嚴重者須「處 5 年以上」,法官胡雅文改判被告監禁 5 年。 呂世瑜早前不服刑罰提上訴,被上訴庭駁回。呂向上訴庭申請上訴至終院的證明書,首席法官潘兆初、上訴庭法官彭偉昌及彭寶琴周四(27 日)頒下判詞,指涉及重大而廣泛重要性的法律觀點,批出證明書。 根據終院網站,呂世瑜申上訴許可的聆訊,尚待排期處理。服刑中的呂世瑜今出庭時身穿格仔冷衫,戴黑框眼鏡,精神不俗。根據終院網站,呂世瑜申上訴許可的聆訊,尚待排期處理。
