“Lunch Gor” wins appeal against IFC conviction for organising a prohibited group gathering; judge says he was merely responding by participating
IFC「組織受禁群組聚集」罪成「Lunch 哥」上訴得直 官:充其量只是響應參與
Li Kwok-wing, known online as “Lunch Gor”, was accused of organising a protest at the International Finance Centre mall (IFC) in Central in September 2020, in breach of the then two-person gathering restriction. He denied the summons charge of “organising a prohibited group gathering”, but was convicted after trial and sentenced to a 15-month probation order. Li appealed against his conviction. High Court deputy judge Anthony Kai On Kwok handed down judgment on Monday (26th), allowing the appeal. On the trial court’s finding that the appellant was an organiser of the group gathering, the judge said the appellant had gone up an escalator to the second floor after being stopped by mall security and continued shouting slogans. This was “in essence different” from planning or directing a procession route. The judge also cited the Court of Appeal’s ruling on the “818 assembly”, which held that an organiser must bear a certain degree of responsibility or have actively participated in planning and arranging the event; merely being present and participating, “even in a prominent position, is not sufficient”. The judge ruled that there was no evidence that the appellant was the initiator or organiser of the “和你 lunch” activity. Even if he knew about the activity, his conduct “at most amounted to responding by participating, and did not necessarily make him an organiser”.
被網民稱為「Lunch 哥」的李國永,被指於 2020 年 9 月,在中環國際金融中心商場(IFC )組織示威,違反當時的「二人限聚令」。他否認傳票控罪「組織受禁群組聚集」,受審後被裁定罪成,判處 15 個月感化令。李不服定罪提上訴,高院暫委法官郭啟安周一(26 日)頒下判詞,裁定李上訴得直。 對於原審裁定上訴人為群組聚集的組織者,官指上訴人的行為是因受商場保安阻止,遂乘扶手電梯至二樓,繼續叫口號,情況與計劃或指導遊行路線「在本質上亦有所不同」。官又引述「818 集會」的上訴庭裁決,指上訴庭認為,組織者必須負起某程度的責任,或有積極參與計劃、安排等,純粹在現場出現,有份參與,「即使在顯眼的位置並不足夠」。 官裁定,沒證據指上訴人是「『和你 lunch』活動的發起人或組織者」,即使他知道該活動,其行為「充其量只是響應參與,而不一定是組織者」。
